An avoidable death in police custody?

An obviously inebriated 36-year-old man was found in a helpless condition on a pavement. When he was brought to a police station, a doctor certified the individual to be fit to be held in custody. He was unresponsive when the officers tried to wake him the next morning but was allowed to sleep on until he was found dead in his cell at mid day. An autopsy revealed as cause of death an epidural hematoma and cerebral contusion with fracture of the calvarium. The expert report stressed the point that the monitoring of the state of consciousness had been objectively insufficient throughout the entire time period, both in terms of frequency as well as in terms of the monitoring methods. However, neither the police officers involved nor the doctor, was subjected to prosecution mainly because of the high burden of proof required by German criminal law. The article will discuss conclusions for the avoidance of such deaths (such as training of police officers, legal regulations on monitoring procedures, etc).

New autopsy signs in violent death.

In forensic medicine subtle observation has often resulted in the detection of single findings which are of great significance regarding the mechanisms of development of the incidence or its vitality. Thus, empiricism is an accepted method to gain new insights. Nevertheless the value and the significance of empirically gained insights have to be proven either by retrospective or prospective analysis of important case series or by experiments. It is often a long and difficult way from observation to proof. But without a detailed and evidence-based scientific argumentation the level of empirical methods could not be exceeded.

Diagnosis and presentation of fatal myocarditis.

The clinical presentation of myocarditis is highly variable, and histopathology is thus considered to be the cornerstone of diagnosis. We studied how accurately myocarditis was diagnosed in a series of routine autopsies and how fatal myocarditis presents clinically. All death certificates with myocarditis recorded as the underlying cause of death in Finland in 1970 to 1998 were collected retrospectively (N = 639). All cases with cardiac autopsy samples and clinical data available (n = 142; median age, 51 years) were included in this study. The cardiac samples were reexamined for the presence of myocarditis by 3 experienced independent pathologists using the Dallas criteria. The clinical data were evaluated for the presenting signs and symptoms of myocarditis. Histopathologic reanalysis showed that only 32% of the 142 subjects met the Dallas criteria for myocarditis (75% of pediatric and 28% of adult patients, P = .001). Clinicians had suspected myocarditis in only one third of the hospitalized Dallas-positive patients. Dallas-positive patients presented more often with features of myocardial infarction (26% versus 9%, P = .026) or heart failure (35% versus 10%, P = .001) than Dallas-negative subjects. The signs and symptoms of infectious disease were also more common in Dallas-positive patients (61% versus 23%, P < .001). In contrast, Dallas-negative subjects died suddenly or were found dead more frequently (68% versus 39%, P = .004). The most evident cause of death in the Dallas-negative subjects was ischemic heart disease (n = 78, 55% of all cases). Our study provides evidence that myocarditis is overdiagnosed on routine autopsies, particularly in patients who have died suddenly or are found dead. Fatal myocarditis appears to present equally often as heart failure, sudden death, or mimicking myocardial infarction.

Apoptotic cardiomyocyte death in fatal myocarditis.

Acute myocarditis is often a self-limited process with a good outcome. Experimental animal studies have found that cardiomyocyte apoptosis occurs in severe forms of myocarditis. We studied whether cardiomyocyte apoptosis plays a role in the development of fatal acute human myocarditis. Myocardial autopsy samples from subjects who died of acute myocarditis in Finland between 1970 and 1998 were studied. Thirty-three of these cases(16 men and 17 women; 45 +/- 6 years old) were randomly selected for this study. All cases fulfilled the histopathologic Dallas criteria for myocarditis. Eight subjects who had died accidentally served as controls. Apoptotic DNA fragmentation (terminal transferase-mediated DNA nick end labeling) and activation of caspase-3 (immunohistochemistry) were detected. The mode of death was determined retrospectively from all available clinical data. In fatal myocarditis, large amounts of cardiomyocytes showed apoptotic DNA fragmentation or contained active caspase-3 (2.0 +/- 0.3% and 2.8 +/- 0.4%, respectively). In the controls, few apoptotic cardiomyocytes were found (0.008 +/- 0.003% by terminal transferase-mediated DNA nick end labeling and 0.009 +/- 0.003% by detection of active caspase-3, p <0.001 vs myocarditis). The amount of apoptosis did not correlate with the age or gender of the cases, recognized viral etiology, histologic features, or duration of disease. However, more apoptotic cardiomyocytes were detected in the subjects who had myocarditis and had died of heart failure (n = 18) than in those who had myocarditis and died suddenly of cardiac arrest (n = 15; 2.6 +/- 0.4% vs 1.1 +/- 0.2%, p <0.001). In conclusion, cardiomyocyte apoptosis is a common mechanism of myocardial damage in severe acute human myocarditis. Moreover, higher rates of cardiomyocyte apoptosis are associated with the development of fatal heart failure in acute myocarditis.