RNA-catalyzed evolution of catalytic RNA.

An RNA polymerase ribozyme that was obtained by directed evolution can propagate a functional RNA through repeated rounds of replication and selection, thereby enabling Darwinian evolution. Earlier versions of the polymerase did not have sufficient copying fidelity to propagate functional information, but a new variant with improved fidelity can replicate the hammerhead ribozyme through reciprocal synthesis of both the hammerhead and its complement, with the products then being selected for RNA-cleavage activity. Two evolutionary lineages were carried out in parallel, using either the prior low-fidelity or the newer high-fidelity polymerase. The former lineage quickly lost hammerhead functionality as the population diverged toward random sequences, whereas the latter evolved new hammerhead variants with improved fitness compared to the starting RNA. The increase in fitness was attributable to specific mutations that improved the replicability of the hammerhead, counterbalanced by a small decrease in hammerhead activity. Deep sequencing analysis was used to follow the course of evolution, revealing the emergence of a succession of variants that progressively diverged from the starting hammerhead as fitness increased. This study demonstrates the critical importance of replication fidelity for maintaining heritable information in an RNA-based evolving system, such as is thought to have existed during the early history of life on Earth. Attempts to recreate RNA-based life in the laboratory must achieve further improvements in replication fidelity to enable the fully autonomous Darwinian evolution of RNA enzymes as complex as the polymerase itself.

Discovery of small molecules that target a tertiary-structured RNA.

There is growing interest in therapeutic intervention that targets disease-relevant RNAs using small molecules. While there have been some successes in RNA-targeted small-molecule discovery, a deeper understanding of structure-activity relationships in pursuing these targets has remained elusive. One of the best-studied tertiary-structured RNAs is the theophylline aptamer, which binds theophylline with high affinity and selectivity. Although not a drug target, this aptamer has had many applications, especially pertaining to genetic control circuits. Heretofore, no compound has been shown to bind the theophylline aptamer with greater affinity than theophylline itself. However, by carrying out a high-throughput screen of low-molecular-weight compounds, several unique hits were identified that are chemically distinct from theophylline and bind with up to 340-fold greater affinity. Multiple atomic-resolution X-ray crystal structures were determined to investigate the binding mode of theophylline and four of the best hits. These structures reveal both the rigidity of the theophylline aptamer binding pocket and the opportunity for other ligands to bind more tightly in this pocket by forming additional hydrogen-bonding interactions. These results give encouragement that the same approaches to drug discovery that have been applied so successfully to proteins can also be applied to RNAs.

RNA Polymerase Ribozyme That Recognizes the Template-Primer Complex through Tertiary Interactions.

RNA enzymes (ribozymes) often rely on specific base-pairing interactions to engage RNA substrates, which limits the substrate sequence generality of these enzymes. An RNA polymerase ribozyme that was previously optimized by directed evolution to operate in a more efficient and sequence-general manner can now recognize the RNA template, RNA primer, and incoming nucleoside 5'-triphosphate (NTP) entirely through tertiary interactions. As with proteinaceous polymerases, these tertiary interactions are largely agnostic to the sequence of the template, which is an essential property for the unconstrained transmission of genetic information. The polymerase ribozyme exhibits Michaelis-Menten saturation kinetics, with a catalytic rate of 0.1-1 min-1 and a Km of 0.1-1 µM. Earlier forms of the polymerase did not exhibit a saturable substrate binding site, but this property emerged over the course of directed evolution as the ribozyme underwent a structural rearrangement of its catalytic center. The optimized polymerase makes tertiary contacts with both the template and primer, including a critical interaction at the C2' position of the template nucleotide that opposes the 3'-terminal nucleotide of the primer. UV cross-linking studies paint a picture of how several portions of the ribozyme, including regions that were remodeled by directed evolution, come together to position the template, primer, and NTP within the active site for RNA polymerization.

An RNA polymerase ribozyme that synthesizes its own ancestor.

The RNA-based organisms from which modern life is thought to have descended would have depended on an RNA polymerase ribozyme to copy functional RNA molecules, including copying the polymerase itself. Such a polymerase must have been capable of copying structured RNAs with high efficiency and high fidelity to maintain genetic information across successive generations. Here the class I RNA polymerase ribozyme was evolved in vitro for the ability to synthesize functional ribozymes, resulting in the markedly improved ability to synthesize complex RNAs using nucleoside 5'-triphosphate (NTP) substrates. The polymerase is descended from the class I ligase, which contains the same catalytic core as the polymerase. The class I ligase can be synthesized by the improved polymerase as three separate RNA strands that assemble to form a functional ligase. The polymerase also can synthesize the complement of each of these three strands. Despite this remarkable level of activity, only a very small fraction of the assembled ligases retain catalytic activity due to the presence of disabling mutations. Thus, the fidelity of RNA polymerization should be considered a major impediment to the construction of a self-sustained, RNA-based evolving system. The propagation of heritable information requires both efficient and accurate synthesis of genetic molecules, a requirement relevant to both laboratory systems and the early history of life on Earth.

Kinetic Effects of ß,γ-Modified Deoxynucleoside 5'-Triphosphate Analogues on RNA-Catalyzed Polymerization of DNA.

A recently described DNA polymerase ribozyme, obtained by in vitro evolution, provides the opportunity to investigate mechanistic features of RNA catalysis using methods that previously had only been applied to DNA polymerase proteins. Insight can be gained into the transition state of the DNA polymerization reaction by studying the behavior of various ß,γ-bridging substituted methylene (CXY; X, Y = H, halo, methyl) or imido (NH) dNTP analogues that differ with regard to the pKa4 of the bisphosphonate or imidodiphosphate leaving group. The apparent rate constant (kpol) of the polymerase ribozyme was determined for analogues of dGTP and dCTP that span a broad range of acidities for the leaving group, ranging from 7.8 for the CF2-bisphosphonate to 11.6 for the CHCH3-bisphosphonate. A Brønsted plot of log(kpol) versus pKa4 of the leaving group demonstrates linear free energy relationships (LFERs) for dihalo-, monohalo-, and non-halogen-substituted analogues of the dNTPs, with negative slopes, as has been observed for DNA polymerase proteins. The unsubstituted dNTPs have a faster catalytic rate than would be predicted from consideration of the linear free energy relationship alone, presumably due to a relatively more favorable interaction of the ß,γ-bridging oxygen within the active site. Although the DNA polymerase ribozyme is considerably slower than DNA polymerase proteins, it exhibits a similar LFER fingerprint, suggesting mechanistic commonality pertaining to the buildup of negative charge in the transition state, despite the very different chemical compositions of the two catalysts.

Cross-Chiral, RNA-Catalyzed Exponential Amplification of RNA.

Informational macromolecules in biology are composed of subunits of a single handedness, d-nucleotides in nucleic acids and l-amino acids in proteins. Although this chiral uniformity may be expedient, it is not a chemical necessity, as demonstrated by the recent example of an RNA enzyme that catalyzes the RNA-templated polymerization of RNA molecules of the opposite handedness. This reaction, when carried out iteratively, can provide the basis for exponential amplification of RNA molecules and the information they contain. By carrying out thermal cycling, analogous to the polymerase chain reaction, and supplying oligonucleotide building blocks that comprise both the functional strand of RNA and its complement, cross-chiral exponential amplification was achieved. This process was used to amplify the l-RNA form of the hammerhead ribozyme, catalyzed by the d-RNA form of the polymerase. The resulting l-hammerhead exhibits the expected activity in cleaving a corresponding l-RNA substrate. Exponential amplification was also carried out within individual droplets of a water-in-oil emulsion. The ability to amplify enantio-RNAs, both in bulk solution and within compartments, provides a means to evolve cross-chiral RNA polymerases based on the function of the RNAs they produce.

RNA-Catalyzed Cross-Chiral Polymerization of RNA.

Biology relies almost exclusively on homochiral building blocks to drive the processes of life. Yet cross-chiral interactions can occur between macromolecules of the opposite handedness, including a previously described polymerase ribozyme that catalyzes the template-directed synthesis of enantio-RNA. The present study sought to optimize and generalize this activity, employing in vitro evolution to select cross-chiral polymerases that use either mono- or trinucleotide substrates that are activated as the 5'-triphosphate. There was only modest improvement of the former activity, but dramatic improvement of the latter, which enables the trinucleotide polymerase to react 102-103-fold faster than its ancestor and to accept substrates with all possible sequence combinations. The evolved ribozyme can assemble long RNAs from a mixture of trinucleotide building blocks, including a two-fragment form of the ancestral polymerase ribozyme. Further improvement of this activity could enable the generalized cross-chiral replication of RNA, which would establish a new paradigm for the chemical basis of Darwinian evolution.

Thermal Habitat for RNA Amplification and Accumulation.

The RNA world scenario posits replication by RNA polymerases. On early Earth, a geophysical setting is required to separate hybridized strands after their replication and to localize them against diffusion. We present a pointed heat source that drives exponential, RNA-catalyzed amplification of short RNA with high efficiency in a confined chamber. While shorter strands were periodically melted by laminar convection, the temperature gradient caused aggregated polymerase molecules to accumulate, protecting them from degradation in hot regions of the chamber. These findings demonstrate a size-selective pathway for autonomous RNA-based replication in natural nonequilibrium conditions.

A cross-chiral RNA polymerase ribozyme.

Thirty years ago it was shown that the non-enzymatic, template-directed polymerization of activated mononucleotides proceeds readily in a homochiral system, but is severely inhibited by the presence of the opposing enantiomer. This finding poses a severe challenge for the spontaneous emergence of RNA-based life, and has led to the suggestion that either RNA was preceded by some other genetic polymer that is not subject to chiral inhibition or chiral symmetry was broken through chemical processes before the origin of RNA-based life. Once an RNA enzyme arose that could catalyse the polymerization of RNA, it would have been possible to distinguish among the two enantiomers, enabling RNA replication and RNA-based evolution to occur. It is commonly thought that the earliest RNA polymerase and its substrates would have been of the same handedness, but this is not necessarily the case. Replicating D- and L-RNA molecules may have emerged together, based on the ability of structured RNAs of one handedness to catalyse the templated polymerization of activated mononucleotides of the opposite handedness. Here we develop such a cross-chiral RNA polymerase, using in vitro evolution starting from a population of random-sequence RNAs. The D-RNA enzyme, consisting of 83 nucleotides, catalyses the joining of L-mono- or oligonucleotide substrates on a complementary L-RNA template, and similar behaviour occurs for the L-enzyme with D-substrates and a D-template. Chiral inhibition is avoided because the 10(6)-fold rate acceleration of the enzyme only pertains to cross-chiral substrates. The enzyme's activity is sufficient to generate full-length copies of its enantiomer through the templated joining of 11 component oligonucleotides.

3'-End labeling of nucleic acids by a polymerase ribozyme.

A polymerase ribozyme can be used to label the 3' end of RNA or DNA molecules by incorporating a variety of functionalized nucleotide analogs. Guided by a complementary template, the ribozyme adds a single nucleotide that may contain a fluorophore, biotin, azide or alkyne moiety, thus enabling the detection and/or capture of selectively labeled materials. Employing a variety of commercially available nucleotide analogs, efficient labeling was demonstrated for model RNAs and DNAs, human microRNAs and natural tRNA.

Mapping a Systematic Ribozyme Fitness Landscape Reveals a Frustrated Evolutionary Network for Self-Aminoacylating RNA.

Molecular evolution can be conceptualized as a walk over a "fitness landscape", or the function of fitness (e.g., catalytic activity) over the space of all possible sequences. Understanding evolution requires knowing the structure of the fitness landscape and identifying the viable evolutionary pathways through the landscape. However, the fitness landscape for any catalytic biomolecule is largely unknown. The evolution of catalytic RNA is of special interest because RNA is believed to have been foundational to early life. In particular, an essential activity leading to the genetic code would be the reaction of ribozymes with activated amino acids, such as 5(4 H)-oxazolones, to form aminoacyl-RNA. Here we combine in vitro selection with a massively parallel kinetic assay to map a fitness landscape for self-aminoacylating RNA, with nearly complete coverage of sequence space in a central 21-nucleotide region. The method (SCAPE: sequencing to measure catalytic activity paired with in vitro evolution) shows that the landscape contains three major ribozyme families (landscape peaks). An analysis of evolutionary pathways shows that, while local optimization within a ribozyme family would be possible, optimization of activity over the entire landscape would be frustrated by large valleys of low activity. The sequence motifs associated with each peak represent different solutions to the problem of catalysis, so the inability to traverse the landscape globally corresponds to an inability to restructure the ribozyme without losing activity. The frustrated nature of the evolutionary network suggests that chance emergence of a ribozyme motif would be more important than optimization by natural selection.

Amplification of RNA by an RNA polymerase ribozyme.

In all extant life, genetic information is stored in nucleic acids that are replicated by polymerase proteins. In the hypothesized RNA world, before the evolution of genetically encoded proteins, ancestral organisms contained RNA genes that were replicated by an RNA polymerase ribozyme. In an effort toward reconstructing RNA-based life in the laboratory, in vitro evolution was used to improve dramatically the activity and generality of an RNA polymerase ribozyme by selecting variants that can synthesize functional RNA molecules from an RNA template. The improved polymerase ribozyme is able to synthesize a variety of complex structured RNAs, including aptamers, ribozymes, and, in low yield, even tRNA. Furthermore, the polymerase can replicate nucleic acids, amplifying short RNA templates by more than 10,000-fold in an RNA-catalyzed form of the PCR. Thus, the two prerequisites of Darwinian life-the replication of genetic information and its conversion into functional molecules-can now be accomplished with RNA in the complete absence of proteins.

Real-Time Detection of a Self-Replicating RNA Enzyme.

A system was developed to detect the self-replication of an RNA enzyme in real time. The enzyme is an RNA ligase that undergoes exponential amplification at a constant temperature and can be made to operate in a ligand-dependent manner. The real-time system is based on a fluorimetric readout that directly couples the ligation event to an increase in florescence signal that can be monitored using standard instrumentation. The real-time system can also operate entirely with l-RNA, which is not susceptible to degradation by ribonucleases that are present in biological samples. The system is analogous to real-time PCR, but with the potential to detect small molecules, proteins, and other targets that can be recognized by a suitable aptamer. The ligand-dependent self-replication of RNA has potential applications in molecular diagnostics and biosensing that benefit from the rapid, precise, and real-time detection of various target molecules.

Specific Inhibition of MicroRNA Processing Using L-RNA Aptamers.

In vitro selection was used to obtain l-RNA aptamers that bind the distal stem-loop of various precursor microRNAs (pre-miRs). These l-aptamers, termed "aptamiRs", bind their corresponding pre-miR target through highly specific tertiary interactions rather than Watson-Crick pairing. Formation of a pre-miR-aptamiR complex inhibits Dicer-mediated processing of the pre-miR, which is required to form the mature functional microRNA. One of the aptamiRs, which was selected to bind oncogenic pre-miR-155, inhibits Dicer processing under simulated physiological conditions, with an IC50 of 87 nM. Given that l-RNAs are intrinsically resistant to nuclease degradation, these results suggest that aptamiRs might be pursued as a new class of miR inhibitors.

Bit by bit: the Darwinian basis of life.

All known examples of life belong to the same biology, but there is increasing enthusiasm among astronomers, astrobiologists, and synthetic biologists that other forms of life may soon be discovered or synthesized. This enthusiasm should be tempered by the fact that the probability for life to originate is not known. As a guiding principle in parsing potential examples of alternative life, one should ask: How many heritable "bits" of information are involved, and where did they come from? A genetic system that contains more bits than the number that were required to initiate its operation might reasonably be considered a new form of life.

Limits of neutral drift: lessons from the in vitro evolution of two ribozymes.

The relative contributions of adaptive selection and neutral drift to genetic change are unknown but likely depend on the inherent abundance of functional genotypes in sequence space and how accessible those genotypes are to one another. To better understand the relative roles of selection and drift in evolution, local fitness landscapes for two different RNA ligase ribozymes were examined using a continuous in vitro evolution system under conditions that foster the capacity for neutral drift to mediate genetic change. The exploration of sequence space was accelerated by increasing the mutation rate using mutagenic nucleotide analogs. Drift was encouraged by carrying out evolution within millions of separate compartments to exploit the founder effect. Deep sequencing of individuals from the evolved populations revealed that the distribution of genotypes did not escape the starting local fitness peak, remaining clustered around the sequence used to initiate evolution. This is consistent with a fitness landscape where high-fitness genotypes are sparse and well isolated, and suggests, at least in this context, that neutral drift alone is not a primary driver of genetic change. Neutral drift does, however, provide a repository of genetic variation upon which adaptive selection can act.

Kinetic properties of an RNA enzyme that undergoes self-sustained exponential amplification.

A special class of biochemical reactions involves a set of enzymes that generate additional copies of themselves and transfer heritable information from parent to progeny molecules, thus providing the basis for genetics and Darwinian evolution. Such a process has been realized with a pair of self-replicating RNA enzymes that undergo exponential amplification at a constant temperature. Exponential growth requires that the rate of production of new enzymes be directly proportional to the existing concentration of enzymes, which is the case for this system and provides a doubling time of ~20 min. However, the catalytic rate of the underlying enzymes is ~100-fold faster than the observed rate of replication. As in biological replication, other aspects of the system limit the generation time, chiefly the propensity of the substrate molecules to form nonproductive complexes that limit their availability for replication. An analysis of this and other kinetic properties of the self-replicating RNA enzymes reveals how exponential amplification is achieved and how the rate of amplification might be increased.

Binding of a structured D-RNA molecule by an L-RNA aptamer.

An L-RNA aptamer was developed that binds the natural D-form of the HIV-1 trans-activation responsive (TAR) RNA. The aptamer initially was obtained as a D-aptamer against L-TAR RNA through in vitro selection. Then the corresponding L-aptamer was prepared by chemical synthesis and used to bind the desired target. The L-aptamer binds D-TAR RNA with a Kd of 100 nM. It binds D-TAR exclusively at the six-nucleotide distal loop, but does so through tertiary interactions rather than simple Watson-Crick pairing. This complex is the first example of two nucleic acids molecules of opposing chirality that interact through a mode of binding other than primary structure. Binding of the L-aptamer to D-TAR RNA inhibits formation of the Tat-TAR ribonucleoprotein complex that is essential for TAR function. This suggests that L-aptamers, which are intrinsically resistant to degradation by ribonucleases, might be pursued as an alternative to antisense oligonucleotides to target structured RNAs of biological or therapeutic interest.

Ligand-dependent exponential amplification of a self-replicating L-RNA enzyme.

A nuclease-resistant RNA enzyme, constructed entirely from L-ribonucleotides, was shown to undergo ligand-dependent, self-sustained replication with exponential growth. The catalytic motif is based on a previously described RNA ligase that can undergo either self- or cross-replication but had been limited in its application to ligand sensing due to its susceptibility to degradation by ribonucleases. The self-replicating RNA enzyme and its RNA substrates were prepared synthetically from either D- or L-nucleoside phosphoramidites. The D and L reaction systems undergo isothermal, ligand-dependent exponential amplification in the same manner, but only the l system is impervious to ribonucleases and can operate, for example, in the presence of human serum. This system has potential for the quantitative detection of various ligands that are present within biological or environmental samples. In addition, this work provides the first demonstration of the self-sustained exponential amplification of nonbiological molecules.