Tuberculosis case detection in Nigeria, the unfinished agenda.

OBJECTIVE: Underdetection of TB is a major problem in sub-Saharan Africa. WHO recommends countries should have at least 1 laboratory per 100,000 population. However, this recommendation is not evidence based. METHODS: We analysed surveillance data of the Nigerian National TB Control Programme (2008-2012) to describe TB case detection rates, their geographical distribution and their association with the density of diagnostic laboratories and HIV prevalence. RESULTS: The median CDR was 17.7 (range 4.7-75.8%) in 2008, increasing to 28.6% (range 10.6-72.4%) in 2012 (P < 0.01). The CDR2012 was associated with the 2008 baseline; however, states with CDR2008 < 30% had larger increases than states with CDR2008 > 30. There were 990 laboratories in 2008 and 1453 in 2012 (46.7% increase, range by state -3% to +118). The state CDR2012 could be predicted by the laboratory density (P < 0.001), but was not associated with HIV prevalence or the proportion of smear-positive cases. CDR2012 and laboratory density were correlated among states having < and > than 1 laboratory per 100,000 population. CONCLUSION: There are large variations in laboratory density and CDR across the Nigerian states. The CDR is associated with the laboratory density. A much larger number of diagnostic centres are needed. It is likely that a laboratory density above the recommended WHO guideline would result in even higher case detection, and this ratio should be considered a minimum threshold.

The yield of chest X-ray based versus symptom-based screening among patients with diabetes mellitus in public health facilities in Addis Ababa, Ethiopia.

Background: Patients with diabetes mellitus (DM) are at increased risk of developing TB, but the best screening algorithm for early detection and treatment of TB remains unknown. Our objective was to determine if combining routine chest X-ray screening could have a better yield compared with symptom-based screening alone. Methods: We conducted this cross-sectional study between September 2020 and September 2021 in 26 public health facilities in Addis Ababa, Ethiopia. All DM patients attending the clinics during the study period were offered chest X-ray and symptom screening simultaneously followed by confirmatory Xpert testing. We analyzed the number and proportion of patients with TB by the diagnostic algorithm category and performed binary logistic regression analysis to identify predictors of TB diagnosis. Results: Of 7394 patients screened, 54.6 % were female, and their median age was 53 years. Type-2 diabetes accounted for 89.6 % of all participants of the patients. Of 172 symptomatic patients, chest X-ray suggested TB in 19, and 11 of these were confirmed to have TB (8 bacterilogicially confirmed and 3 clinically diagnosed). Only 2 of the 152 asymptomatic patients without X-ray findings had TB (both bacteriologically confirmed). X-ray was not done for one patient. On the other hand, 28 of 7222 symptom-negative patients had X-ray findings suggestive of TB, and 7 of these were subsequently confirmed with TB (6 clinically diagnosed). When combined with 8 patients who were on treatment for TB at the time of the screening, the overall point prevalence of TB was 380 per 100,000. The direct cost associated with the X-ray-based screening was 42-times higher. Conclusion: Chest X-ray led to detection of about a third of TB patients which otherwise would have been missed but the algorithm is more expensive. Its full cost implication needs further economic evaluation.

Plantar ulcer occurrence among leprosy patients in Northern Nigeria: A study of contributing factors.

Background: The study was conducted in three major leprosy referral hospitals in Northern Nigeria, which are NKST Rehabilitation Hospital, Benue State, Yadakunya Leprosy Hospital, Kano, and National Tuberculosis/Leprosy Training Hospital, Zaria. The main objective of the study was to investigate factors responsible for the occurrence of ulcers among leprosy patients reporting to the leprosy referral hospitals. Materials and Methods: An analytic study of case-control design was used, with patients having plantar ulcers as cases and those without as control. Semi-structured was administered to all cases and controls. Results: A total of 242 patients were studied; 124 patients (51.2%) had plantar ulcers whereas 118 (48.8%) had no ulcers (controls). A Chi-square test was used in the analysis to compare cases and controls. The study found differences between cases and controls with respect to patients release from treatment (RFT), gender, availability and utilization of footwear, age, occupation, and educational status. Footwears were provided to most patients, i.e. 60.8% late (i.e., after developing plantar ulcers); however, there was very good utilization of the footwears among those who had the footwears, 65.3%. Knowledge of self-care was higher among 64.5% of cases compared to only 28.1% of the controls. Conclusion: Ulcer still remains a major problem among leprosy patients, especially RFT (76.6%) and most cases are provided with footwear late. Self-care knowledge is higher among cases than controls.

RésuméContexte: L'étude a été menée dans trois hôpitaux majeurs de référence pour la lèpre dans le nord du Nigéria, qui sont l'hôpital de réadaptation NKST, l'État de Benue, l'hôpital de la lèpre de Yadakunya, Kano et l'hôpital national de la tuberculose et de la lèpre, Zaria. L'objectif principal de l'étude était d'étudier les facteurs responsables de l'apparition d'ulcères chez les patients atteints de lèpre signalant des hôpitaux de référence pour la lèpre. Matériaux et méthodes: une étude analytique de la conception cas-témoins a été utilisée, les patients ayant des ulcères plantaires comme cas et ceux qui n'ont pas le contrôle. Semi-structuré a été administré à tous les cas et contrôles. sRésultats: Au total, 242 patients ont été étudiés; 124 patients (51,2%) avaient des ulcères plantaires tandis que 118 (48,8%) n'avaient pas d'ulcères (témoins). Un test du Chi-carré a été utilisé dans l'analyse pour comparer les cas et les témoins. L'étude a révélé des différences entre les cas et les contrôles par rapport aux patients libérés du traitement (RFT), le sexe, la disponibilité et l'utilisation de la chaussure, l'âge, la profession et le statut scolaire. Les chaussures ont été fournies à la plupart des patients, soit 60,8% en retard (c'est-à -dire après développement d'ulcères plantaires); cependant, il y avait une très bonne utilisation des chaussures parmi ceux qui avaient les chaussures, soit 65,3%. La connaissance de l'autosoins était plus élevée chez 64,5% des cas que dans seulement 28,1% des témoins. Conclusion: L'ulcère reste un problème majeur chez les patients atteints de lèpre, en particulier les TF (76,6%) et la plupart des cas sont munis de chaussures en retard. La connaissance des soins personnels est plus élevée parmi les cas que les témoins.

'Sustaining the DOTS': stakeholders' experience of a social protection intervention for TB in Nigeria.

Background: Social protection for TB patients can lower patient costs and improve adherence. The aim of this study was to explore patients' and health workers' experiences of a social protection intervention for TB in order to inform a more patient-centred approach for the Nigeria National TB Programme strategy. Methods: This was a qualitative study consisting of 103 in-depth interviews and two focus group discussions with patients who received the intervention, and 10 key informant interviews with health workers. A thematic content analysis of the interviews was performed. Results: Of those who completed the interviews, 53 (51.5%) were male, and 69 (67.0%) were below 40 years. Most of the participants received care and support from their families but delayed access to TB services due to lack of funds for transportation, nutritional supplementation and non-TB drugs. The intervention had a high level of acceptability and uptake; particularly clear benefits emerged for most patients who used the social protection funds to purchase food and supplements, other drugs, transportation and additional personal necessities. Some patients assert that the financial incentive package increased their awareness of timing of their follow-up visits. In addition, health workers observed increased enthusiasm to treatment and improvement in adherence among participants. Conclusions: Patients and health workers reported positive experiences with the financial incentives provided for TB treatment.

Leprosy Elimination: Progress and Challenges in Nigeria; Kaduna State TB and Leprosy Control Programme as a Case Study.

The study aims at describing the achievements and challenges of Leprosy control in Kaduna State using appropriate indicators. The study was a five year (2004-2008) retrospective review of the Leprosy records and annual reports of all the twenty three LGAs in Kaduna State. Various Leprosy indicators were calculated and presented in different graphic presentations. Focus group discussions were organised with the aim of identifying current challenges of Leprosy control in the State. There was a decline in the new Leprosy cases detected annually from 226 cases in 2004 to 140 cases in 2008. The prevalence rate ranged between 0.3-0.4 per 10,000 population within the five year period. The proportion of children among new cases dropped from 12% in 2004 to 5% in 2007 and increased to 9% in 2008. Grade 2 disability among new cases was very high (between 21%-27%) within the same period. Leprosy elimination target has been achieved in Kaduna State, but new cases with high proportion of children and WHO grade 2 disability were still been reported.