The XIIIth Banff Conference on Allograft Pathology: The Banff 2015 Heart Meeting Report: Improving Antibody-Mediated Rejection Diagnostics: Strengths, Unmet Needs, and Future Directions.

The 13th Banff Conference on Allograft Pathology was held in Vancouver, British Columbia, Canada from October 5 to 10, 2015. The cardiac session was devoted to current diagnostic issues in heart transplantation with a focus on antibody-mediated rejection (AMR) and small vessel arteriopathy. Specific topics included the strengths and limitations of the current rejection grading system, the central role of microvascular injury in AMR and approaches to semiquantitative assessment of histopathologic and immunophenotypic indicators, the role of AMR in the development of cardiac allograft vasculopathy, the important role of serologic antibody detection in the management of transplant recipients, and the potential application of new molecular approaches to the elucidation of the pathophysiology of AMR and potential for improving the current diagnostic system. Herein we summarize the key points from the presentations, the comprehensive, open and wide-ranging multidisciplinary discussion that was generated, and considerations for future endeavors.

Assessment of Tocilizumab (Anti-Interleukin-6 Receptor Monoclonal) as a Potential Treatment for Chronic Antibody-Mediated Rejection and Transplant Glomerulopathy in HLA-Sensitized Renal Allograft Recipients.

Extending the functional integrity of renal allografts is the primary goal of transplant medicine. The development of donor-specific antibodies (DSAs) posttransplantation leads to chronic active antibody-mediated rejection (cAMR) and transplant glomerulopathy (TG), resulting in the majority of graft losses that occur in the United States. This reduces the quality and length of life for patients and increases cost. There are no approved treatments for cAMR. Evidence suggests the proinflammatory cytokine interleukin 6 (IL-6) may play an important role in DSA generation and cAMR. We identified 36 renal transplant patients with cAMR plus DSAs and TG who failed standard of care treatment with IVIg plus rituximab with or without plasma exchange. Patients were offered rescue therapy with the anti-IL-6 receptor monoclonal tocilizumab with monthly infusions and monitored for DSAs and long-term outcomes. Tocilizumab-treated patients demonstrated graft survival and patient survival rates of 80% and 91% at 6 years, respectively. Significant reductions in DSAs and stabilization of renal function were seen at 2 years. No significant adverse events or severe adverse events were seen. Tocilizumab provides good long-term outcomes for patients with cAMR and TG, especially compared with historical published treatments. Inhibition of the IL-6-IL-6 receptor pathway may represent a novel approach to stabilize allograft function and extend patient lives.

Report from a forum on US heart allocation policy.

Since the latest revision in US heart allocation policy (2006), the landscape and volume of transplant waitlists have changed considerably. Advances in mechanical circulatory support (MCS) prolong survival, but Status 1A mortality remains high. Several patient subgroups may be disadvantaged by current listing criteria and geographical disparity remains in waitlist time. This forum on US heart allocation policy was organized to discuss these issues and highlight concepts for consideration in the policy development process. A 25-question survey on heart allocation policy was conducted. Among attendees/respondents were 84 participants with clinical/published experience in heart transplant representing 51 US transplant centers, and OPTN/UNOS and SRTR representatives. The survey results and forum discussions demonstrated very strong interest in change to a further-tiered system, accounting for disadvantaged subgroups and lowering use of exceptions. However, a heart allocation score is not yet viable due to the long-term viability of variables (used in the score) in an ever-developing field. There is strong interest in more refined prioritization of patients with MCS complications, highly sensitized patients and those with severe arrhythmias or restrictive physiology. There is also strong interest in distribution by geographic boundaries modified according to population. Differences of opinion exist between small and large centers.

Calculated PRA: initial results show benefits for sensitized patients and a reduction in positive crossmatches.

The calculated panel reactive antibody (CPRA), which is based upon unacceptable HLA antigens listed on the waitlist form for renal transplant candidates, replaced PRA as the measure of sensitization among US renal transplant candidates on October 1, 2009. An analysis of the impact of this change 6 months after its implementation shows an 83% reduction in the number of kidney offers declined nationwide because of a positive crossmatch. The increasing acceptance and utilization of unacceptable HLA antigens to avoid offers of predictably crossmatch-positive donor kidneys has increased the efficiency of kidney allocation, resulting in a significant increase in the percentage of transplants to broadly sensitized (80+% PRA/CPRA) patients from 7.3% during the period 07/01/2001-6/30/2002 to 15.8% of transplants between 10/1/09-3/31/10. The transplant rates per 1000 active patient-years on the waitlist also increased significantly for broadly sensitized patients after October 1, 2009. These preliminary results suggest that 'virtual' positive crossmatch prediction based on contemporary tools for identifying antibodies directed against HLA antigens is effective, increases allocation efficiency and improves access to transplants for sensitized patients awaiting kidney transplantation.

Complexity of the HLA-D region studied by primed-lymphocyte test.

The results obtained by mixed lymphocyte culture (MLC), HLA-D and -DR typing, and primed lymphocyte test (PLT) in the F. family give some indication of the complexity of the HLA-D region in man. Two siblings identical for HLA-A, -B, -C, -D, and -DR by typing are mutually MLC-stimulatory. PLT studies indicate that one of these siblings expresses D-region determinants of both of the mother's haplo-types, suggesting an intra-D recombinant. These results suggest that the D region contains genes for a number of different determinants.

A new era for T-cell immune function assays in transplantation.

Cellular assays have been used to assess the pre- and post-transplant immune status of recipients throughout the history of clinical transplantation. Initially, bulk culture assays were used; however, more recent refinements in the techniques allow for assaying multiple functions simultaneously including cell subset functional analysis and the response at the single cell level. The intracellular ATP synthesis assay is being incorporated routinely into the clinical testing strategy. Both donor-specific and non-specific testing strategies are being used to evaluate the immune status of recipients allowing for potential points of intervention aimed at decreasing the adverse impact of clinical complications. This review focuses on the current use of cellular testing in clinical transplantation.

Incidence of humoral sensitization in HLA partially mismatched hematopoietic stem cell transplantation.

As part of the 15th International Histocompatibility and Immunogenetics Workshop (IHIWS), seven centers participated in a collaborative project to determine whether any significant humoral sensitization occurred post-transplant among recipients of HLA partially mismatched hematopoietic cell transplants (HCTs). A total of 140 donor/recipient pairs were enrolled with a total of 367 pre-and post-transplant sera analyzed. The majority of the samples (69.1%) were obtained within 30-90 days post-HCT. HLA-specific antibodies were defined using single antigen bead assays on a Luminex platform with a positive cutoff value of 1000 normalized median fluorescence intensity (MFI). There was an overall incidence of post-HCT sensitization toward donor HLA mismatches of 5.7%; however, all cases were among recipients of one HLA haplotype-mismatched grafts under nonmyeloablative, pre-transplant conditioning. Among the one haplotype-mismatched recipients, 15.7% (8/51) developed donor HLA-specific antibodies and 29.4% also had antibodies directed toward third party HLA antigens. Among the donor-specific antibodies, 9.8% were directed toward HLA class I antigens; 7.8% were against class II antigens; and 2.0% had both class I and II specificity. The relative strength of post-transplant antibodies was low with no significant difference in the mean maximum MFI values between third party and donor-specific antibodies. Because only a small number (10.2%) of the post-transplant samples were obtained 180 days or more post-HCT, longer term study is needed to evaluate any clinical relevance of these low-to-moderate levels of donor-specific antibody in one haplotype-mismatched recipients, as well as to determine whether any other antibodies occur at later times.

Analysis of subcutaneous (SQ) alemtuzumab induction therapy in highly sensitized patients desensitized with IVIG and rituximab.

Here we report on our experience with subcutaneous (SQ) Alemtuzumab in an uncontrolled study in highly HLA-sensitized patients (HS). From 3/05-4/07, 54 HS patients received Alemtuzumab 30 mg SQ as induction. Patient and graft survival, AR episodes, serum creatinines, absolute lymphocyte counts, monthly PCR monitoring for viruses, AE/SAEs and infectious complications were monitored. No patient to date has developed acute injection-related reactions after SQ Alemtuzumab; however, bone marrow suppression was occasionally seen requiring reduction or elimination of mycophenolate mofetil approximately 1-2 months posttransplant. Patient and graft survival at 12 M was 98%/96%, respectively. AR episodes occurred in 35% with 20% being C4d+ AMR. Mean SCrs at 12 M were 1.4 +/- 0.3 mg/dL. The nadir ALC was 0.17 +/- 0.19 within 24 h and sustained up to 365 days posttransplant. Infections occurred in eight patients (five with polyoma BK viremia [PBK], one CMV/PBK and two CMV viremia). SQ Alemtuzumab was well tolerated and resulted in prolonged lymphocyte depletion. Compared to our previous experience with daclizumab and rabbit ATG induction in HS patients, single-dose SQ Alemtuzumab was more cost effective, showed similar infection rates and did not reduce the AMR rates posttransplant. Although uncontrolled, these observations suggest that induction therapy with Alemtuzumab appears feasible and indeed promising, but awaits more definitive study.

Linkage analysis between the major histocompatibility system and insulin-dependent diabetes in families with patients in two consecutive generations.

We have histocompatibility (HLA) genotyped 28 families with insulin-dependent diabetics in two or more consecutive generations, usually parent and child. This strategy of ascertainment was used to maximize the likelihood of obtaining a homogeneous type of disease within a family, and an autosomal dominant mode of inheritance. 76 diabetics and 169 nondiabetics were studied in these families. The frequencies of the antigens Dw3 and Dw4, and the genotype Dw3/Dw4 among the diabetics are 59, 68, and 30%, respectively, as compared with 15, 12, and 2% in normal controls, and 43, 41, and 10% in the nondiabetic relatives of the diabetics. Dw2 is present in only one diabetic (4%), as compared with 18% in normal controls and 17% in nondiabetic relatives.HLA haplotype concordance was analyzed for sib pairs in relation to the haplotype shared by the affected parent/child pair, and for the diabetic sib pairs within each sibship. The results failed to reveal deviations in the expected HLA haplotype assortment. Assuming an autosomal dominant mode and several penetrance levels, linkage analysis between the HLA and diabetes was performed. The total lod score is 0.37 for a recombination fraction of 0.29 at 50% penetrance. Although the linkage and concordance analysis results are inconclusive, they seem to be different from those reported by us for families with normal parents and two or more diabetic sibs. Because ascertainment biases may have influenced these results in an unquantifiable manner, it is not certain whether the two types of families are genetically different. However, the marked difference in the lod scores for the 50% penetrant autosomal recessive model between the two types of families is compatible with a genetic dissimilarity between them. The high frequency of the Dw3 and Dw4 antigens, the Dw3/Dw4 genotype, and the decreased frequency of Dw2, however, indicate the existence of two or more important diabetic genetic factors associated with the D region of the HLA in these families.

Antigens associated with acute leukemia detected in the primed lymphocyte test.

Mixed lymphocyte culture (MLC) studies of families with several leukemia patients, all potential bone marrow transplant recipients, demonstrated that cells from acute myelogenous leukemia patients (5 of 5) and acute undifferentiated leukemia patients (1 of 4) in relapse stimulated autologous lymphocytes as well as lymphocytes from siblings known to be identical at the major histocompatibility linkage group. In the patients studied, the blast transformation induced by leukemia cells was not detectable when the patient was in remission. Stimulation by leukemia cells also elicited increased responses of the lymphocytes from normal haploidentical siblings, parents, and unrelated individuals as compared to stimulation by normal allogeneic cells or leukemia cells of patients with leukemia in remission. The primed lymphocyte test (PLT) was used successfully to establish HLA-D identity of the leukemia patients and their respective HLA-identical siblings, despite high percentages of circulatory blasts. Utilizing lymphocytes from normal siblings primed against the leukocytes from an HLA-identical sibling with leukemia, we also presented results of PLT's which suggested that the stimulation induced by leukemia cells in MLC was produced by leukemia-associated antigens.

Peripheral blood allogeneic microchimerism in lung and cardiac allograft recipients.

We have been investigating two parameters, donor antigen-specific hyporeactivity and peripheral blood allogeneic microchimerism, to determine whether these parameters will predict a chronic rejection-free state and which recipients may be candidates for steroid withdrawal. We have identified donor antigen-specific hyporeactivity for 33% (16/48) of lung and 23% (11/47) of heart recipients. For both organ groups, the hyporeactive subgroup experienced a lower incidence of chronic rejection. The probability of donor antigen-specific hyporeactivity predicting a chronic rejection-free state is 100% for lung and 91% for heart recipients. We have identified peripheral blood allogeneic microchimerism for 77% (20/26) of lung and 36% (9/25) of heart recipients tested at 12-18 months posttransplant. Donor antigen-specific hyporeactivity correlates with a critical level of donor cells in lung recipients; the probability of high peripheral blood allogeneic microchimerism levels predicting a chronic rejection-free state in lung recipients is 100%. The results in heart recipients are not as clear with a short-, but not long-term, trend of higher chimerism levels correlating with the development of donor antigen-specific hyporeactivity. These results illustrate the usefulness of immmune parameters to predict long-term graft outcome in an organ-specific manner.

Evidence that improved late renal transplant outcome correlates with the development of in vitro donor antigen-specific hyporeactivity.

Previous studies suggest stable renal transplant recipients can have either prednisone (P) or cyclosporine withdrawn; however, 30% of these patients undergo rejection requiring reinstitution of P or CsA. Some patients return to baseline creatinine levels, while others either stabilize at a higher creatinine level or lose their graft. It would be ideal to establish immunologically based criteria for selecting patients who can be successfully withdrawn or tapered from immunosuppression. We have investigated the development of donor antigen-specific hyporeactivity by using donor cells and/or homozygous typing cells defining the HLA-Dw specificities of the donor cells as stimulator cells in the mixed lymphocyte culture (MLC) and comparing the pre- and posttransplant responses of peripheral blood mononuclear cells from 199 kidney transplant recipients. Of these, 27% of the haploidentical living-related donor and 25% of the cadaver recipients developed in vitro donor antigen-specific hyporeactivity. The LRD recipients who did so have lower mean creatinine levels at 6, 12, and 24 months posttransplant (1.3, 1.3, and 1.2, respectively) than those who remained responsive to the donor antigens (1.6, 1.7, and 1.8) (P < 0.05). However, no differences in the mean creatinine levels were observed between CAD recipients who developed donor antigen-specific hyporeactivity and those who remained responsive. Rejection episodes were common in all groups in the first 3 months posttransplant; however, recipients who developed donor antigen-specific hyporeactivity tended to experience fewer rejection episodes after 3 months posttransplant. The percentage of recipients who remained rejection-free after 3 months post-transplant was 95% for CAD recipients who developed donor antigen-specific hyporeactivity vs. 83% for those who remained responsive. Only 1 hyporesponsive recipient (0/15 LRD; 1/20 CAD) developed chronic rejection vs. 12 (5/41, LRD; 7/60, CAD) recipients who remained responsive. For those with graft function at 3 months (when hyporesponsiveness was first determined), the actuarial 36-month graft survival was higher in the hyporesponsive (92%, LRD; 94%, CAD) than in responsive groups (LRD, 76%; CAD, 91%). No differences in the degree of HLA-DR mismatching (MM) were observed for the LRD hyporesponsive (1.20 DR MM) vs. reactive (0.98 DR MM) groups or for the CAD hyporesponsive (1.35 DR MM) vs. reactive (1.30 DR MM) groups. Donor antigen-specific hyporeactivity could not be determined (UND) for 30 of the LRD recipients and 33 of the CAD recipients due to lack of mismatching for DR antigens (0.03 DR MM and 0.25 DR MM, respectively).(ABSTRACT TRUNCATED AT 400 WORDS)

Impact of transfusions and acute rejection on posttransplantation donor antigen-specific responses in two study populations. Cooperative Clinical Trial in Transplantation Research Group.

BACKGROUND: We participated in a protocol supported by the National Institutes of Allergy and Infectious Disease, Cooperative Clinical Trial in Transplantation (CCTT), which was designed to investigate the effect of peritransplant donor-specific transfusion in non-HLA-identical living donor kidney recipients. METHODS: We determined the donor antigen-specific responses at 1 year after transplantation for the 79 CCTT donor-recipient combinations in this study. A lower rate of donor antigen-specific hyporeactivity was seen in the CCTT recipients (6 of 79=8%) versus our recipients at the University of Minnesota who underwent transplantation in the same period (9 of 55=16%, P=0.16) and versus our combined historical data (33 of 131=25%, P=0.002). Therefore, we studied the differences in the two recipient populations to determine why hyporeactivity was lower in the CCTT group than at our center. RESULTS: Significant differences were seen in the acute rejection rates and the frequency of pretransplantation random transfusion. Overall and early (<3 month) acute rejection rates were higher in CCTT versus Minnesota recipients (overall: 51% vs. 20%, P=0.001) (early: 43% vs. 16%, P=0.001). The frequency of pretransplantation random transfusion was 40% for CCTT recipients (34%) versus 80% for Minnesota recipients (75%) (P=0.0004). CONCLUSIONS: These results provide provocative, although not conclusive, evidence for the importance of pretransplantation transfusion and acute rejection episodes in the development of donor antigen-specific hyporeactivity. Pre-, peri-, and posttransplantation clinical events undoubtedly have an impact on posttransplantation immune parameters.

A new in vitro approach to determine acquired tolerance in long-term kidney allograft recipients.

Previous studies indicate some kidney allograft recipients treated with total lymphoid irradiation, cyclosporine, or conventional immunosuppressive therapy demonstrate specific proliferative unresponsiveness in mixed lymphocyte culture (MLC) to donor cells at various times posttransplant. To investigate possible donor-specific hyporeactivity, we have studied 3 patients treated with TLI whose grafts have survived longer than 10 years; 2 patients given the same immunosuppressive protocol but without TLI whose grafts have survived longer than 10 years; and 27 CsA-treated living-related donor and cadaver-allograft recipients 1 year posttransplant. We confirmed previous observations of hyporeactivity of some patients' cells to stimulation by donor cells. In addition, we identified hyporeactivity to stimulation by homozygous typing cells (HTCs) defining the HLA-Dw specificities of the donor cells for all 3 of the 3 TLI patients, 1 of the 2 non-TLI patients, and 9 of the 27 patients 1 year posttransplant. The LRD recipients with donor-specific hyporeactivity as defined by the HTC analysis demonstrated fewer rejection episodes (25% vs. 57%) and lower mean creatinine levels (1.18 vs 1.78 mg/dL) than patients without donor-specific hyporeactivity. These studies demonstrate the feasibility of monitoring the immune status of allograft recipients posttransplant by means of HTC analysis, eliminating the need for pretransplant specimens. This approach provides a possible means to assess which patients may have acquired donor-specific hyporeactivity to their kidney allograft and thus may require less immunosuppression.

Differentiation of class I- and class II-directed donor-specific alloreactivity in bronchoalveolar lavage lymphocytes from lung transplant recipients.

Previous studies have demonstrated that donor antigen-specific primed-lymphocyte-test (PLT) reactivity of bronchoalveolar lavage lymphocytes is strongly associated with acute pulmonary rejection and with obliterative bronchiolitis (OB); however, a systematic analysis of PLT reactivity as being class I-or II-directed has not been performed. To assess reactivity directed against individual class I or II antigens, we tested a total of 67 BAL-derived lymphocyte samples from 26 recipients for alloreactivity in the PLT, using a pool of allogeneic cells and selected homozygous typing cells (HTCs) representing the HLA class I and II antigens expressed by the recipient and donor cells. The results obtained by PLT were correlated with the clinical status of the recipient with regard to rejection, infection, and OB. In 9 of 10 cases where transbronchial biopsy results were consistent with rejection, donor antigen-specific allogeneic PLT reactivity was observed and, more specifically, could be determined to be directed toward donor class II antigen in 8 of these cases. For 3 of 4 recipients tested chronologically, positive donor antigen-specific PLT reactivity was observed at the time of and 2-3 1/2 months prior to the diagnosis of rejection by transbronchial biopsy. During periods of acute infection, donor antigen-specific PLT reactivity was not observed; instead, non-specific PLT reactivity of BAL-derived cells (i.e., reactivity that did not correlate with any defined HLA antigens) was observed as well as reactivity associated with the self-antigens expressed by the recipients' cells. The PLT reactivity of BAL-derived cells from a recipient diagnosed with OB correlated specifically with one of the disparate donor class I antigens (HLA-B44). In 23 cases, BAL cells were propagated in the presence of autologous cells and rIL-2, thereby allowing for sufficient numbers of cells to test with a panel of 29 HTCs and to analyze for cell surface phenotype. The cultured BAL cells from 4 recipients undergoing a rejection episode demonstrated a predominant CD4+ phenotype consistent with the class II-directed reactivity observed in PLT. However, these results did not demonstrate a phenotype distinctive from the 7 BAL results obtained from 4 quiescent recipients. In marked contrast, the cultured BAL cells obtained from 4 recipients diagnosed with OB demonstrated a predominant CD8+ phenotype, with 60-92% of the cultured cells being CD8+. These results are consistent with the class I-directed reactivity observed in PLT.(ABSTRACT TRUNCATED AT 400 WORDS)

Are multiple immunopathogenetic events occurring during the development of obliterative bronchiolitis and acute rejection?

The primed lymphocyte test (PLT) has been used to detect donor antigen-specific reactivity of bronchoalveolar lavage (BAL) lymphocytes associated with acute lung rejection and obliterative bronchiolitis (OB). To identify more precisely the immunopathogenetic events related to these processes, we have determined the PLT alloreactivity of 162 BAL specimens from 40 recipients as being directed against individual class I or class II antigens. We used selected homozygous typing cells representing the specific HLA class I and II antigens expressed by the recipient and donor cells. Our previous studies demonstrated a predominant CD8+ cell population mediating class I donor antigen-specific reactivity, correlating with OB in 3 out of 3 recipients tested, and a predominant CD4+ cell population mediating class II donor antigen-specific reactivity, correlating with acute rejection episodes in 13 out of 15 recipients tested. The obstructive airway disease OB, which is frequently fatal, is identified histologically by the presence of small airway inflammation and fibrosis of the lamina propria and lumen, and is characterized clinically by rapidly progressive airflow obstruction. However, a subgroup of patients with histologically proven OB demonstrates stabilization or only minimal progression of airflow limitation after augmentation of their immunosuppressive regimen, usually with high-dose methylprednisolone. To further characterize this subgroup, we tested the BAL-derived lymphocytes from 4 of these patients and observed PLT reactivity that correlated with the class II antigens of the donor, in contrast to the predominant donor class I antigen-specific PLT reactivity of patients with progressive OB. The distinct patterns of PLT reactivity observed for the BAL-derived lymphocytes from patients with the progressive versus the less progressive form of OB suggest that more than one immune process or perhaps different cell targets are involved. Alternatively, these clinical and in vitro findings may represent different stages of the same disease process. Taken together, these results suggest that distinct immunopathogenetic events may be occurring during acute lung rejection and OB.

Sequential measurement of peripheral blood allogeneic microchimerism levels and association with pulmonary function.

We have shown in lung recipients that high levels of peripheral blood allogeneic microchimerism at 12 to 18 months posttransplant correlated with donor antigen-specific hyporeactivity (i.e., decreased proliferative response to donor antigen in MLC while response to 3rd-party cells remains unchanged); both parameters correlated with an obliterative bronchiolitis (OB)-free state. We have expanded these studies to determine any association of sequential microchimerism levels with concomitant clinical events. In this preliminary study of 7 lung recipients, we used limiting-dilution PCR to quantify peripheral blood microchimerism at serial timepoints ranging from 3 to >48 months posttransplant. These levels were compared with a variety of immunologic and clinical parameters: acute rejection, CMV infection, OB, donor antigen-specific hyporeactivity, and pulmonary function. Pulmonary function was measured per the International Society of Heart and Lung Transplantation: "current FEV1/ baseline FEV1" (FEV1: forced expiratory volume in 1 second). Of the clinical parameters, the association between microchimerism and pulmonary function was the most striking. We observed dynamic patterns of peripheral microchimerism, which reflected the general rise and fall of FEV1. In all 7 recipients, chimerism and FEV1 were high very early posttransplant, then dropped at various rates and to various degrees. After its initial decline, microchimerism increased with FEV1 for the 1 hyporesponsive recipient; for the other 6 recipients, both values declined. These results illustrate, for the first time, that the fluctuation of peripheral blood microchimerism levels is associated with the recipient's clinical condition.

The impact of the quality of initial graft function on cadaver kidney transplants.

Living unrelated donor (LURD) transplants have immunologic barriers similar to cadaver transplants, yet the outcome is better (1-year graft survival = 96%). One advantage of LURD transplants is that, with the extremely short preservation time, the kidney functions immediately. We studied whether the quality of initial renal function affects the outcome of primary cadaver transplants. We divided 301 non-6-antigen-matched recipients transplanted between 1/1/86 and 8/1/92--who had no graft loss due to hyperacute rejection, primary nonfunction, or technical reasons--into 5 groups based on the quality of initial renal function (serum creatinine level in the first week). We determined patient and graft survival rates for each group. We found that the quality of initial function had a significant effect on patient and graft survival rates. Recipients whose serum creatinine level was < 3 mg/dl on posttransplant day 5 (groups 1 and 2) had better patient and graft survival than either those whose serum creatinine level was > 3 mg/dl on day 7 (group 4) or those who required dialysis (group 5). Because some early dysfunction may be immunologic, we reanalyzed the data excluding patients with percent reactive antibody > or = 15; the quality of initial function in this group had a significant impact on outcome. Similarly, when patients with graft loss due to "death with function" were excluded, the quality of initial function had a significant impact on survival rates. We conclude that the quality of early posttransplant function is an important predictor of long-term outcome. Cadaver recipients with immediate good function have outcomes similar to living donor recipients. Our data suggest that increased effort should be made to improve immediate posttransplant function.

Beyond hyperacute rejection. Accelerated rejection in a discordant xenograft model by adoptive transfer of specific cell subsets.

If hyperacute rejection is prevented in the guineapig (GP)-to-Lewis rat (Lew) cardiac xenograft (CXg) model, an accelerated rejection involving cellular infiltration occurs in 3 to 4 days. In previous work using an adoptive transfer model, we found that this accelerated rejection was facilitated by either sensitized splenocytes or sensitized serum. In the current study, in an attempt to determine which splenocyte subset(s) facilitated this process, sensitized splenocytes, with or without subset depletion were injected, into complement- and natural antibody-depleted Lew recipients of GP CXgs. Graft survival was 4.18 +/- 0.75 days with no injection (n = 11), 4.13 +/- 0.99 days with naive splenocytes (n = 8), 1.80 +/- 0.45 days with sensitized splenocytes (n = 5), 2.67 +/- 1.03 days with CD4(W3/25+) depletion of the sensitized splenocytes (n = 6), 3.13 +/- 0.84 days with CD8(OX8+) cell depletion (n = 8), 4.70 +/- 0.68 days with macrophage depletion (n = 10), and 4.22 +/- 0.41 days with B cell depletion (n = 9). Cellular infiltrates, hemorrhage, myocyte necrosis, and endothelial deposition of IgG, IgM, and fibrin were seen in rejected grafts. In most groups, infiltrating cells consisted of CD4 (W3/25+), CD8 (OX8+), IL2R+ cells, macrophages, and natural killer (NK) cells. However, in the macrophages-depleted group, activated (ED2+) macrophages and NK cells were significantly reduced. Total IgM, anti-GP IgM, and anti-GP IgG rebounded in all groups over several days but were not consistent at the time of rejection. Lewis rats rejecting GP CXgs early had lower final titers than those rejecting later. Total IgG titers rebounded to baseline by posttransplant day 1 and were therefore similar in all groups at the time of rejection. These findings suggest that this accelerated rejection requires interaction between macrophages and B cells, since depletion of either significantly alters the rejection tempo. A possible explanation is that xenoreactive IgG antibodies, synthesized by sensitized B cells, bind their target antigens--but also bind sensitized macrophages through their Fc region, thus causing rejection by antibody-dependent cell-mediated cytotoxicity.