Is Dissociation of HCl in DMSO Clusters Bistable?

Dissociation of HCl embedded in dimethyl sulfoxide (DMSO) clusters was investigated by projecting the solvent electric field along the HCl bond using B3LYP-D3/6-31+G(d) and MP2/6-31+G(d,p) levels of theory. A large number of distinct structures (about 1500) consisting of up to five DMSO molecules were considered in the present work for statistical reliability. The B3LYP-D3 calculations reveal that the dissociation of HCl embedded in DMSO clusters requires a critical electric field of 138 MV cm-1 along the H-Cl bond. However, a large number of exceptions wherein the electric field values much higher than the critical electric field of 138 MV cm-1 did not result in dissociation of HCl were observed, in addition to several cases wherein the HCl dissociates with an electric field less than the critical electric field. On the other hand, the MP2 level calculations reveal that the critical electric field for HCl dissociation is about 181 MV cm-1 with almost no exceptions. A comparison of calculations carried out using the MP2 and the B3LYP-D3 levels suggests that the dissociation of HCl embedded in DMSO clusters is bistable at the B3LYP-D3 level, which is an artifact, suggesting that care must be exercised in interpreting the processes of proton transfer. The answer to the question raised as the title of this paper is NO.

Bend-to-Break: Curvilinear Proton Transfer in Phenol-Ammonia Clusters.

The electric field experienced by the OH group of phenol embedded in the cluster of ammonia molecules depends on the relative orientation of the ammonia molecules, and a critical field of 236 MV cm-1 is essential for the transfer of a proton from phenol to the surrounding ammonia cluster. However, exceptions to this rule were observed, which indicates that the projection of the solvent electric field over the O-H bond is not a definite descriptor of the proton transfer reaction. Therefore, a critical electric field is necessary, but it is not a sufficient condition for the proton abstraction. This, in combination with an adequate solvation of the acceptor ammonia molecule in a triple donor motif that energetically favors the proton transfer process, constitutes necessary and sufficient conditions for the spontaneous proton abstraction. The proton transfer process in phenol-(ammonia)n clusters is statistically favored to occur away from the plane of the phenyl ring and follows a curvilinear path which includes the O-H bond elongation and out-of-plane movement of the proton. Colloquially, this proton transfer can be referred to as a "bend-to-break" process.