Evaluating stereotactic accuracy with patient-specific MRI distortion corrections for frame-based radiosurgery.

PURPOSE: This study examines how MRI distortions affect frame-based SRS treatments and assesses the need for clinical distortion corrections. METHODS: The study included 18 patients with 80 total brain targets treated using frame-based radiosurgery. Distortion within patients' MRIs were corrected using Cranial Distortion Correction (CDC) software, which utilizes the patient's CT to alter planning MRIs to reduce inherent intra-cranial distortion. Distortion was evaluated by comparing the original planning target volumes (PTVORIG) to targets contoured on corrected MRIs (PTVCORR). To provide an internal control, targets were also re-contoured on uncorrected (PTVRECON) MRIs. Additional analysis was done to assess if 1 mm expansions to PTVORIG targets would compensate for patient-specific distortions. Changes in target volumes, DICE and JACCARD similarity coefficients, minimum PTV dose (Dmin), dose to 95% of the PTV (D95%), and normal tissue receiving 12 Gy (V12Gy), 10 Gy (V10Gy), and 5 Gy (V5Gy) were calculated and evaluated. Student's t-tests were used to determine if changes in PTVCORR were significantly different than intra-contouring variability quantified by PTVRECON. RESULTS: PTVRECON and PTVCORR relative changes in volume were 6.19% ± 10.95% and 1.48% ± 32.92%. PTVRECON and PTVCORR similarity coefficients were 0.90 ± 0.08 and 0.73 ± 0.16 for DICE and 0.82 ± 0.12 and 0.60 ± 0.18 for JACCARD. PTVRECON and PTVCORR changes in Dmin were -0.88% ± 8.77% and -12.9 ± 17.3%. PTVRECON and PTVCORR changes in D95% were -0.34% ± 5.89 and -8.68% ± 13.21%. The 1 mm expanded PTVORIG targets did not entirely cover 14 of the 80 PTVCORR targets. Normal tissue changes (V12Gy, V10Gy, V5Gy) calculated with PTVRECON were (-0.09% ± 7.39%, -0.38% ± 5.67%, -0.08% ± 2.04%) and PTVCORR were (-2.14% ± 7.34%, -1.42% ± 5.45%, -0.61% ± 1.93%). Except for V10Gy, all PTVCORR changes were significantly different (p < 0.05) than PTVRECON. CONCLUSION: MRIs used for SRS target delineation exhibit notable geometric distortions that may compromise optimal dosimetric accuracy. A uniform 1 mm expansion may result in geometric misses; however, the CDC algorithm provides a feasible solution for rectifying distortions, thereby enhancing treatment precision.

Commissioning and validation of a Monte Carlo algorithm for spine stereotactic radiosurgery.

PURPOSE: A 6FFF Monte Carlo (MC) dose calculation algorithm was commissioned for spine stereotactic radiosurgery (SRS). Model generation, validation, and ensuing model tuning are presented. METHODS: The model was generated using in-air and in-water commissioning measurements of field sizes between 10 and 400 mm2 . Commissioning measurements were compared to simulated water tank MC calculations to validate output factors, percent depth doses (PDDs), profile sizes and penumbras. Previously treated Spine SRS patients were re-optimized with the MC model to achieve clinically acceptable plans. Resulting plans were calculated on the StereoPHAN phantom and subsequently delivered to the microDiamond and SRSMapcheck to verify calculated dose accuracy. Model tuning was performed by adjusting the model's light field offset (LO) distance between physical and radiological positions of the MLCs, to improve field size and StereoPHAN calculation accuracy. Following tuning, plans were generated and delivered to an anthropomorphic 3D-printed spine phantom featuring realistic bone anatomy, to validate heterogeneity corrections. Finally, plans were validated using polymer gel (VIPAR based formulation) measurements. RESULTS: Compared to open field measurements, MC calculated output factors and PDDs were within 2%, profile penumbra widths were within 1 mm, and field sizes were within 0.5 mm. Calculated point dose measurements in the StereoPHAN were within 0.26% ± 0.93% and -0.10% ± 1.37% for targets and spinal canals, respectively. Average SRSMapcheck per-plan pass rates using a 2%/2 mm/10% threshold relative gamma analysis was 99.1% ± 0.89%. Adjusting LOs improved open field and patient-specific dosimetric agreement. Anthropomorphic phantom measurements were within -1.29% ± 1.00% and 0.27% ± 1.36% of MC calculated for the vertebral body (target) and spinal canal, respectively. VIPAR gel measurements confirmed good dosimetric agreement near the target-spine junction. CONCLUSION: Validation of a MC algorithm for simple fields and complex SRS spine deliveries in homogeneous and heterogeneous phantoms has been performed. The MC algorithm has been released for clinical use.

Commissioning cranial single-isocenter multi-target radiosurgery for the Versa HD.

PURPOSE: Brainlab's Elements Multiple Brain Mets SRS (MBMS) is a dedicated treatment planning system for single-isocenter multi-target (SIMT) cranial stereotactic radiosurgery (SRS) treatments. The purpose of this study is to present the commissioning experience of MBMS on an Elekta Versa HD. METHODS: MBMS was commissioned for 6 X, 6 FFF, and 10 FFF. Beam data collected included: output factors, percent depth doses (PDDs), diagonal profiles, collimator transmission, and penumbra. Beam data were processed by Brainlab and resulting parameters were entered into the planning system to generate the beam model. Beam model accuracy was verified for simple fields. MBMS plans were created on previously treated cranial SRS patient data sets. Plans were evaluated using Paddick inverse conformity (ICI), gradient indices (GI), and cumulative volume of brain receiving 12 Gy. Dosimetric accuracy of the MBMS plans was verified using microDiamond, Gafchromic film, and SRS Mapcheck measurements of absolute dose and dose profiles for individual targets. Finally, an end-to-end (E2E) test was performed with a MR-CT compatible phantom to validate the accuracy of the simulation-to-delivery process. RESULTS: For square fields, calculated scatter factors were within 1.0% of measured, PDDs were within 0.5% past dmax, and diagonal profiles were within 0.5% for clinically relevant off-axis distances (<10 cm). MBMS produced plans with ICIs < 1.5 and GIs < 5.0 for targets > 10 mm. Average point doses of the MBMS plans, measured by microDiamond, were within 0.31% of calculated (max 2.84%). Average per-field planar pass rates were 98.0% (95.5% minimum) using a 2%/1 mm/10% threshold relative gamma analysis. E2E point dose measurements were within 1.5% of calculated and Gafchromic film pass rates were 99.6% using a 5%/1 mm/10% threshold gamma analysis. CONCLUSION: The experience presented can be used to aid the commissioning of the Versa HD in the Brainlab MBMS treatment planning system, to produce safe and accurate SIMT cranial SRS treatments.

Dosimetric Effects of Dynamic Jaw Tracking and Collimator Angle Optimization in Non-Coplanar Cranial Arc Radiotherapy.

The stereotactic treatment of single cranial targets using noncoplanar volumetric modulated arc therapy (VMAT) allows for effective dose delivery to the target, while sparing normal brain tissue. In this study, the dosimetric effect of adding dynamic jaw tracking and automatic collimator angle selection in the optimization of single target cranial VMAT plans was investigated. Twenty-two cranial targets, previously treated with VMAT without dynamic jaw tracking and automatic collimator angle optimization (CAO) were chosen for replanning. Target volumes ranged from 0.441cc to 25.863cc with doses between 18Gy and 30Gy delivered in 1 to 5 fractions. Original plans were reoptimized with automatic CAO, keeping all other objectives the same (CAO plans). Next, original plans were reoptimized with both dynamic jaw tracking and CAO (DJT plans). Original, CAO, and DJT target doses were compared using the Paddick gradient index (GI) and the Paddick inverse conformity index (ICI), while normal tissue dose was compared using the volume of the normal brain receiving 5Gy, 10Gy, and 12Gy. The normal tissue volume was normalized to target size to allow cross comparison between plans. A one-sided t-test was performed to determine whether the changes in the plan metrics were statistically significant. CAO plans had improved GIs compared to the originals (p = 0.03) with insignificant changes in other plan metrics (p > 0.20). The addition of dynamic jaw tracking in DJT plans greatly improved ICIs and normal brain metrics (p < 0.01) compared to the CAO plans with minor improvement in ICIs (p = 0.07). The combined effect of adding dynamic jaw tracking and collimator optimization led to improvements in all metrics of the DJT plans when compared to the original (p < 0.02). The addition of dynamic jaw tracking and CAO led to improvements in both target and normal tissue dose metrics for single-target noncoplanar cranial VMAT plans.

Simultaneous Optimization of Radiation-Imaging Coincidence for a Multi-Energy Linac.

INTRODUCTION: Medical physics guidelines stress the importance of radiation-imaging coincidence, especially for stereotactic treatments. However, multi-energy linear accelerators may only allow a single imaging isocenter. A procedure was developed to simultaneously optimize radiation-imaging isocenter coincidence for all linac photon energies on a Versa HD. MATERIALS AND METHODS: First, the radiation beam center of each energy was adjusted to match the collimator rotation axis using a novel method that combined ion chamber measurements with a modified Winston-Lutz (WL) test using images only at gantry, couch, and collimator angles of 0°. With all energies properly steered, an 8-field WL test was performed to determine average linac isocenter position across all energies, gantry, and collimator angles. Lasers and the kV imaging isocenter were calibrated to the average linac isocenter of all photon energies. Finally, A 12-field WL test consisting of gantry, couch, and collimator rotations was used to adjust the couch rotation axis to the average linac isocenter, thereby minimizing overall radiation-imaging isocentricity of the system. RESULTS: Using this method, the beam centers were calibrated within 0.10 mm of collimator rotation axis, and linac isocenter coincidence was within 0.20 mm for all energies. Couch isocenter coincidence was adjusted within 0.20 mm of average linac isocenter. Average radiation-imaging isocentricity for all energies was 0.89 mm (0.80-0.98 mm) for a single imaging isocenter. CONCLUSION: This work provides a method to adjust radiation-imaging coincidence within 1.0 mm for all energies on Elekta's Versa HD.

Determination of age from pubic symphysis: an autopsy study.

The present study was conducted on three hundred and thirty-six cases brought for autopsy to the Department of Forensic Medicine, Government Medical College, Amritsar, Punjab, India, during the period 2000-2002. Pubic bones of either sex were analysed according to Todd's method (1920; 1921a,b,c) as modified by McKern and Stewart (1957) to assess and compare the known age of the corpses. Cases belonged to both sexes, i.e. 79.46% males and 20.54% females. All the cases were above the age of 17 years. No difference was noted in the scoring of right and left pubic bones. The age estimation from different components in males and females up to the total score of 10 (23-28 years) was +/- 6, whereas above a score of 10 the estimated age was +/- 12 in males and +/- 9 in females. The age range given for scores of 14 and 15, which were 29+ and 36+ respectively, did not account for variability of age after 40 years. Therefore, the age assessment from pubic bones in the fourth decade age group and beyond is not reliable which is in variance to the study by McKern and Stewart (1957).

External beam pulsed low dose radiotherapy using volumetric modulated arc therapy: planning and delivery.

PURPOSE: To evaluate the feasibility of planning and delivering pulsed low dose radiotherapy (PLRT) using volumetric modulated arc therapy (VMAT) on Elektalinacs. METHODS: Ten patients previously treated for glioblastomamultiforme (GBM) were replanned using PLRT VMAT to deliver ten 0.2 Gy pulses separated by 3 min intervals with an effective dose rate of 0.067 Gy∕min. VMAT parameters such as leaf speed and arc length were investigated to deliver 2 Gy∕fraction to a total of 60 Gy to the target volume in ten subfractions or pulses. Plan quality was assessed using conformity and homogeneity indices. Absolute dose distribution for individual pulses was measured using ArcCHECK diode array. Individual pulses were analyzed for reproducibility and stability using machine log files. Machine characteristics at low monitor units and low dose rate were also investigated. RESULTS: An optimal arc length of 140°-160° and a leaf speed of 0.18-0.25 cm∕° were sufficient to provide equivalent plan coverage and stable delivery. The average time and dose rate required to deliver a single 0.2 Gy pulse was 39.5 ± 2.3 s and 49 ± 32.3 cGy∕min. Average reductions in MUs for the VMAT PLRT plan compared to IMRT for PTV was 16% (Range: -5.5%-36.1%) and 10.9% (Range: -18.4%-32.3%) for the initial and boost plan. A significant improvement was seen in maximum doses to all sensitive structures when planned with VMAT PLRT. The average absolute dose gamma passing rate for the 10 pulses combined and 2 Gy plan were 91.6 ± 2.5% and 97.3 ± 1.2%, respectively. Cumulative monitor units, dose rate, gantry angles, and leaf positions evaluated using machine log files were within 2% for all pulses. CONCLUSIONS: Elekta linacs are capable of delivering reproducible and stable PLRT plans. A prospective clinical study employing PLRT is currently in development.