Detection of ac4C in human mRNA is preserved upon data reassessment.

We recently reported the distribution of N4-acetylcytidine (ac4C) in HeLa mRNA at base resolution through chemical reduction and the induction of C:T mismatches in sequencing (RedaC:T-seq). Our results contradicted an earlier report from Schwartz and colleagues utilizing a similar method termed ac4C-seq. Here, we revisit both datasets and reaffirm our findings. Through RedaC:T-seq reanalysis, we establish a low basal error rate at unmodified nucleotides that is not skewed to any specific mismatch type and a prominent increase in C:T substitutions as the dominant mismatch type in both treated wild-type replicates, with a high degree of reproducibility across replicates. In contrast, through ac4C-seq reanalysis, we uncover significant data quality issues including insufficient depth, with one wild-type replicate yielding 2.7 million reads, inconsistencies in reduction efficiencies between replicates, and an overall increase in mismatches involving thymine that could obscure ac4C detection. These analyses bolster the detection of ac4C in HeLa mRNA through RedaC:T-seq.

Direct epitranscriptomic regulation of mammalian translation initiation through N4-acetylcytidine.

mRNA function is influenced by modifications that modulate canonical nucleobase behavior. We show that a single modification mediates distinct impacts on mRNA translation in a position-dependent manner. Although cytidine acetylation (ac4C) within protein-coding sequences stimulates translation, ac4C within 5' UTRs impacts protein synthesis at the level of initiation. 5' UTR acetylation promotes initiation at upstream sequences, competitively inhibiting annotated start codons. Acetylation further directly impedes initiation at optimal AUG contexts: ac4C within AUG-flanking Kozak sequences reduced initiation in base-resolved transcriptome-wide HeLa results and in vitro utilizing substrates with site-specific ac4C incorporation. Cryo-EM of mammalian 80S initiation complexes revealed that ac4C in the -1 position adjacent to an AUG start codon disrupts an interaction between C and hypermodified t6A at nucleotide 37 of the initiator tRNA. These findings demonstrate the impact of RNA modifications on nucleobase function at a molecular level and introduce mRNA acetylation as a factor regulating translation in a location-specific manner.

ac4C: a fragile modification with stabilizing functions in RNA metabolism.

In recent years, concerted efforts to map and understand epitranscriptomic modifications in mRNA have unveiled new complexities in the regulation of gene expression. These studies cumulatively point to diverse functions in mRNA metabolism, spanning pre-mRNA processing, mRNA degradation, and translation. However, this emerging landscape is not without its intricacies and sources of discrepancies. Disparities in detection methodologies, divergent interpretations of functional outcomes, and the complex nature of biological systems across different cell types pose significant challenges. With a focus of N4-acetylcytidine (ac4C), this review endeavors to unravel conflicting narratives by examining the technological, biological, and methodological factors that have contributed to discrepancies and thwarted research progress. Our goal is to mitigate detection inconsistencies and establish a unified model to elucidate the contribution of ac4C to mRNA metabolism and cellular equilibrium.

Enhanced ac4C detection in RNA via chemical reduction and cDNA synthesis with modified dNTPs.

The functional analysis of epitranscriptomic modifications in RNA is constrained by a lack of methods that accurately capture their locations and levels. We previously demonstrated that the RNA modification N4-acetylcytidine (ac4C) can be mapped at base resolution through sodium borohydride reduction to tetrahydroacetylcytidine (tetrahydro-ac4C), followed by cDNA synthesis to misincorporate adenosine opposite reduced ac4C sites, culminating in C:T mismatches at acetylated cytidines (RedaC:T). However, this process is relatively inefficient, resulting in <20% C:T mismatches at a fully modified ac4C site in 18S rRNA. Considering that ac4C locations in other substrates including mRNA are unlikely to reach full penetrance, this method is not ideal for comprehensive mapping. Here, we introduce "RetraC:T" (reduction to tetrahydro-ac4C and reverse transcription with amino-dATP to induce C:T mismatches) as a method with enhanced ability to detect ac4C in cellular RNA. In brief, RNA is reduced through NaBH4 or the closely related reagent sodium cyanoborohydride (NaCNBH3) followed by cDNA synthesis in the presence of a modified DNA nucleotide, 2-amino-dATP, that preferentially binds to tetrahydro-ac4C. Incorporation of the modified dNTP substantially improved C:T mismatch rates, reaching stoichiometric detection of ac4C in 18S rRNA. Importantly, 2-amino-dATP did not result in truncated cDNA products nor increase mismatches at other locations. Thus, modified dNTPs are introduced as a new addition to the toolbox for detecting ac4C at base resolution.

Active turnover of genomic methylcytosine in pluripotent cells.

Epigenetic plasticity underpins cell potency, but the extent to which active turnover of DNA methylation contributes to such plasticity is not known, and the underlying pathways are poorly understood. Here we use metabolic labeling with stable isotopes and mass spectrometry to quantitatively address the global turnover of genomic 5-methyl-2'-deoxycytidine (mdC), 5-hydroxymethyl-2'-deoxycytidine (hmdC) and 5-formyl-2'-deoxycytidine (fdC) across mouse pluripotent cell states. High rates of mdC/hmdC oxidation and fdC turnover characterize a formative-like pluripotent state. In primed pluripotent cells, the global mdC turnover rate is about 3-6% faster than can be explained by passive dilution through DNA synthesis. While this active component is largely dependent on ten-eleven translocation (Tet)-mediated mdC oxidation, we unveil additional oxidation-independent mdC turnover, possibly through DNA repair. This process accelerates upon acquisition of primed pluripotency and returns to low levels in lineage-committed cells. Thus, in pluripotent cells, active mdC turnover involves both mdC oxidation-dependent and oxidation-independent processes.

Chromatin-dependent allosteric regulation of DNMT3A activity by MeCP2.

Despite their central importance in mammalian development, the mechanisms that regulate the DNA methylation machinery and thereby the generation of genomic methylation patterns are still poorly understood. Here, we identify the 5mC-binding protein MeCP2 as a direct and strong interactor of DNA methyltransferase 3 (DNMT3) proteins. We mapped the interaction interface to the transcriptional repression domain of MeCP2 and the ADD domain of DNMT3A and find that binding of MeCP2 strongly inhibits the activity of DNMT3A in vitro. This effect was reinforced by cellular studies where a global reduction of DNA methylation levels was observed after overexpression of MeCP2 in human cells. By engineering conformationally locked DNMT3A variants as novel tools to study the allosteric regulation of this enzyme, we show that MeCP2 stabilizes the closed, autoinhibitory conformation of DNMT3A. Interestingly, the interaction with MeCP2 and its resulting inhibition were relieved by the binding of K4 unmodified histone H3 N-terminal tail to the DNMT3A-ADD domain. Taken together, our data indicate that the localization and activity of DNMT3A are under the combined control of MeCP2 and H3 tail modifications where, depending on the modification status of the H3 tail at the binding sites, MeCP2 can act as either a repressor or activator of DNA methylation.

Analysis of an Active Deformylation Mechanism of 5-Formyl-deoxycytidine (fdC) in Stem Cells.

The removal of 5-methyl-deoxycytidine (mdC) from promoter elements is associated with reactivation of the silenced corresponding genes. It takes place through an active demethylation process involving the oxidation of mdC to 5-hydroxymethyl-deoxycytidine (hmdC) and further on to 5-formyl-deoxycytidine (fdC) and 5-carboxy-deoxycytidine (cadC) with the help of α-ketoglutarate-dependent Tet oxygenases. The next step can occur through the action of a glycosylase (TDG), which cleaves fdC out of the genome for replacement by dC. A second pathway is proposed to involve C-C bond cleavage that converts fdC directly into dC. A 6-aza-5-formyl-deoxycytidine (a-fdC) probe molecule was synthesized and fed to various somatic cell lines and induced mouse embryonic stem cells, together with a 2'-fluorinated fdC analogue (F-fdC). While deformylation of F-fdC was clearly observed in vivo, it did not occur with a-fdC, thus suggesting that the C-C bond-cleaving deformylation is initiated by nucleophilic activation.

Influencing Epigenetic Information with a Hydrolytically Stable Carbocyclic 5-Aza-2'-deoxycytidine.

5-Aza-2'-deoxycytidine (AzadC) is an antimetabolite in clinical use, which reduces the level of the epigenetic modification 5-methyl-2'-deoxycytidine (mdC). AzadC is incorporated into the genome of proliferating cells, where it inhibits DNA methyltransferases (DNMTs), leading to a reduction of mdC. The loss of mdC, which is a transcriptional silencer in the promoter region found upstream of genes, leads to the reactivation of the corresponding gene, including tumor-suppressor genes, which elicits a beneficial effect. The problem associated with AzadC is that the compound is hydrolytically unstable. It decomposes during treatment to a variety of poorly characterized hydrolysis products. After its incorporation into the genome, this hydrolytic instability generates abasic sites. It is consequently difficult to dissect whether the activity of the compound is caused by DNMT inhibition or more generally by DNA lesion formation. We now discovered that a disarmed version of AzadC, in which the ribose oxygen was replaced by a CH2 group, is surprisingly stable under a variety of pH values while keeping activity against the DNMTs.

Quantitative LC-MS Provides No Evidence for m6 dA or m4 dC in the Genome of Mouse Embryonic Stem Cells and Tissues.

Until recently, it was believed that the genomes of higher organisms contain, in addition to the four canonical DNA bases, only 5-methyl-dC (m5 dC) as a modified base to control epigenetic processes. In recent years, this view has changed dramatically with the discovery of 5-hydroxymethyl-dC (hmdC), 5-formyl-dC (fdC), and 5-carboxy-dC (cadC) in DNA from stem cells and brain tissue. N6 -methyldeoxyadenosine (m6 dA) is the most recent base reported to be present in the genome of various eukaryotic organisms. This base, together with N4 -methyldeoxycytidine (m4 dC), was first reported to be a component of bacterial genomes. In this work, we investigated the levels and distribution of these potentially epigenetically relevant DNA bases by using a novel ultrasensitive UHPLC-MS method. We further report quantitative data for m5 dC, hmdC, fdC, and cadC, but we were unable to detect either m4 dC or m6 dA in DNA isolated from mouse embryonic stem cells or brain and liver tissue, which calls into question their epigenetic relevance.

Quantification of DNA Methylation and Its Oxidized Derivatives Using LC-MS.

The amount of 5-methyl-2'-deoxycytidine (m5dC) and its oxidized derivatives 5-hydroxymethyl-dC (hm5dC), 5-formyl-dC (f5dC), and 5-carboxy-dC (ca5dC) inside mammalian cells provides valuable information concerning cellular state and fate. LC-MS methods enable reliable quantification of these noncanonical DNA modifications in the low femtomolar range. Here, we describe a broadly applicable protocol to quantify m5dC, hm5dC, f5dC, and ca5dC in vertebrate-derived cells using ultra-HPLC triple quadrupole MS (UHPLC-QQQ-MS).

Isotope-dilution mass spectrometry for exact quantification of noncanonical DNA nucleosides.

DNA contains not only canonical nucleotides but also a variety of modifications of the bases. In particular, cytosine and adenine are frequently modified. Determination of the exact quantity of these noncanonical bases can contribute to the characterization of the state of a biological system, e.g., determination of disease or developmental processes, and is therefore extremely important. Here, we present a workflow that includes detailed description of critical sample preparation steps and important aspects of mass spectrometry analysis and validation. In this protocol, extraction and digestion of DNA by an optimized spin-column and enzyme-based method are described. Isotopically labeled standards are added in the course of DNA digestion, which allows exact quantification by isotope dilution mass spectrometry. To overcome the major bottleneck of such analyses, we developed a short (~14-min-per-sample) ultra-HPLC (UHPLC) and triple quadrupole mass spectrometric (QQQ-MS) method. Easy calculation of the modification abundance in the genome is possible with the provided evaluation sheets. Compared to alternative methods, the quantification procedure presented here allows rapid, ultrasensitive (low femtomole range) and highly reproducible quantification of different nucleosides in parallel. Including sample preparation and evaluation, quantification of DNA modifications can be achieved in less than a week.