Mapping low-affinity/high-specificity peptide-protein interactions using ligand-footprinting mass spectrometry.

Short linear peptide motifs that are intracellular ligands of folded proteins are a modular, incompletely understood molecular interaction language in signaling systems. Such motifs, which frequently occur in intrinsically disordered protein regions, often bind partner proteins with modest affinity and are difficult to study with conventional structural biology methods. We developed LiF-MS (ligand-footprinting mass spectrometry), a method to map peptide binding sites on folded protein domains that allows consideration of their dynamic disorder, and used it to analyze a set of D-motif peptide-mitogen-activated protein kinase (MAPK) associations to validate the approach and define unknown binding structures. LiF-MS peptide ligands carry a short-lived, indiscriminately reactive cleavable crosslinker that marks contacts close to ligand binding sites with high specificity. Each marked amino acid provides an independent constraint for a set of directed peptide-protein docking simulations, which are analyzed by agglomerative hierarchical clustering. We found that LiF-MS provides accurate ab initio identification of ligand binding surfaces and a view of potential binding ensembles of a set of D-motif peptide-MAPK associations. Our analysis provides an MKK4-JNK1 structural model, which has thus far been crystallographically unattainable, a potential alternate binding mode for part of the NFAT4-JNK interaction, and evidence of bidirectional association of MKK4 peptide with ERK2. Overall, we find that LiF-MS is an effective noncrystallographic way to understand how short linear motifs associate with specific sites on folded protein domains at the level of individual amino acids.

Discovery of covalent enzyme inhibitors using virtual docking of covalent fragments.

Here we present a virtual docking screen of 1648 commercially available covalent fragments, and identified covalent inhibitors of cysteine protease cathepsin L. These inhibitors did not inhibit closely related protease cathepsin B. Thus, we have established virtual docking of covalent fragments as an approach to discover covalent enzyme inhibitors.

UbMES and UbFluor: Novel probes for ring-between-ring (RBR) E3 ubiquitin ligase PARKIN.

Ring-between-ring (RBR) E3 ligases have been implicated in autoimmune disorders and neurodegenerative diseases. The functions of many RBR E3s are poorly defined, and their regulation is complex, involving post-translational modifications and allosteric regulation with other protein partners. The functional complexity of RBRs, coupled with the complexity of the native ubiquitination reaction that requires ATP and E1 and E2 enzymes, makes it difficult to study these ligases for basic research and therapeutic purposes. To address this challenge, we developed novel chemical probes, ubiquitin C-terminal fluorescein thioesters UbMES and UbFluor, to qualitatively and quantitatively assess the activity of the RBR E3 ligase PARKIN in a simple experimental setup and in real time using fluorescence polarization. First, we confirmed that PARKIN does not require an E2 enzyme for substrate ubiquitination, lysine selection, and polyubiquitin chain formation. Second, we confirmed that UbFluor quantitatively detects naturally occurring activation states of PARKIN caused by Ser65 phosphorylation (pPARKIN) and phosphorylated ubiquitin (pUb). Third, we showed that both pUb and the ubiquitin-accepting substrate contribute to maximal pPARKIN ubiquitin conjugation turnover. pUb enhances the transthiolation step, whereas the substrate clears the pPARKIN∼Ub thioester intermediate. Finally, we established that UbFluor can quantify activation or inhibition of PARKIN by structural mutations. These results demonstrate the feasibility of using UbFluor for quantitative studies of the biochemistry of RBR E3s and for high-throughput screening of small-molecule activators or inhibitors of PARKIN and other RBR E3 ligases.

Catalytically Important Residues of E6AP Ubiquitin Ligase Identified Using Acid-Cleavable Photo-Cross-Linkers.

Inactivation of the E6AP E3 ubiquitin ligase (UBE3A gene) causes Angelman syndrome, while aberrant degradation of p53 by E6AP is implicated in cervical cancers. Herein, we describe the development of photo-cross-linkers to discover catalytic residues of E6AP. Using these cross-linkers, we identified covalent modifications of the E6AP catalytic cysteine and two lysines: Lys(847) and Lys(799). Lys(847) is required for the formation of Lys(48)-linked polyubiquitin chains, while the K799A E6AP mutant was more active at producing Lys(48)-linked polyubiquitin chains. Thus, opposing roles of Lys(799) and Lys(847) pave the path forward to pharmacological inhibitors or activators of E6AP for therapeutic purposes.

A Small Molecule That Switches a Ubiquitin Ligase From a Processive to a Distributive Enzymatic Mechanism.

E3 ligases are genetically implicated in many human diseases, yet E3 enzyme mechanisms are not fully understood, and there is a strong need for pharmacological probes of E3s. We report the discovery that the HECT E3 Nedd4-1 is a processive enzyme and that disruption of its processivity by biochemical mutations or small molecules switches Nedd4-1 from a processive to a distributive mechanism of polyubiquitin chain synthesis. Furthermore, we discovered and structurally characterized the first covalent inhibitor of Nedd4-1, which switches Nedd4-1 from a processive to a distributive mechanism. To visualize the binding mode of the Nedd4-1 inhibitor, we used X-ray crystallography and solved the first structure of a Nedd4-1 family ligase bound to an inhibitor. Importantly, our study shows that processive Nedd4-1, but not the distributive Nedd4-1:inhibitor complex, is able to synthesize polyubiquitin chains on the substrate in the presence of the deubiquitinating enzyme USP8. Therefore, inhibition of E3 ligase processivity is a viable strategy to design E3 inhibitors. Our study provides fundamental insights into the HECT E3 mechanism and uncovers a novel class of HECT E3 inhibitors.

Identification of non-peptidic cysteine reactive fragments as inhibitors of cysteine protease rhodesain.

Rhodesain, the major cathepsin L-like cysteine protease in the protozoan Trypanosoma brucei rhodesiense, the causative agent of African sleeping sickness, is a well-validated drug target. In this work, we used a fragment-based approach to identify inhibitors of this cysteine protease, and identified inhibitors of T. brucei. To discover inhibitors active against rhodesain and T. brucei, we screened a library of covalent fragments against rhodesain and conducted preliminary SAR studies. We envision that in vitro enzymatic assays will further expand the use of the covalent tethering method, a simple fragment-based drug discovery technique to discover covalent drug leads.

Development of a PROTAC Targeting Chk1.

A series of Chk1 degraders were designed and synthesized. The degraders were developed through the conjugation of a promiscuous kinase binder and thalidomide. One of the degraders PROTAC-2 was able to decrease Chk1 levels in a concentration-dependent manner in A375 cells. The developed probes can be useful for the development of selective and more potent Chk1 degraders.

Development of activity-based probes for ubiquitin and ubiquitin-like protein signaling pathways.

Ubiquitin and ubiquitin-like (UBL) proteins regulate a vast variety of cellular functions. Some UBL proteins are present in all cell types, while others are expressed only in certain cells or under certain environmental conditions. This highlights the central role of UBL systems in regulation of ubiquitous as well as specific cellular functions. UBL proteins share little amino acid sequence identity to each other, yet they share similar 3D shapes, which is exemplified by the ß-grasp fold. Central to UBL protein signaling pathways are UBL protein-activating E1 enzymes that activate the C-terminus of UBL proteins for subsequent conjugation to the protein substrates. Due to their critical roles in biology, E1 enzymes have been recognized as emerging drug targets to treat human diseases. In spite of their biological significance, however, methods to discover UBL proteins and to monitor the intracellular activity of E1 enzymes are lacking. Thus, there is a critical need for methods to evaluate the intracellular mechanisms of action of E1 enzyme inhibitors. Here we describe the development of a mechanism-based small-molecule probe, ABP1, that can be used to discover and to detect active UBL proteins, and to monitor the intracellular activity of E1 enzymes inside intact cells. The developed probe can also be used to profile the selectivity of E1 enzyme-targeting drugs in vitro and inside intact cells.

The development of a one pot, regiocontrolled, three-component reaction for the synthesis of thieno[2,3-c]pyrroles.

A three-component reaction has been developed that allows the regioselective synthesis of thieno[2,3-c]pyrroles. The reaction is based on the ability of 2-acetyl-3-thiophenecarboxaldehyde to react with amine and thiol nucleophiles to produce the corresponding tri-substituted thieno[2,3-c]pyrroles, with water as the only by-product. The developed reaction expands the range of synthetically accessible, tri-substituted thieno[2,3-c]pyrroles.

Selective Smurf1 E3 ligase inhibitors that prevent transthiolation.

Smurf1 is a HECT E3 ligase that is genetically micro-duplicated in human patients and is associated with osteoporosis. Smurf1 -/- mice on the other hand show an increase in bone density as they age, while being viable and fertile. Therefore, Smurf1 is a promising drug target to treat osteoporosis. This paper reports the discovery, synthesis, and biochemical characterization of highly selective Smurf1 inhibitors. We show that these compounds inhibit the catalytic HECT domain of Smurf1 with 500 nM IC 50 , but they do not inhibit closely related Smurf2 ligase, which is 80% identical to Smurf1. We show that Smurf1 inhibitors act by preventing the trans-thiolation reaction between Smurf1 and E2∼Ub thioesters. Our preliminary studies show that the C-lobe of Smurf1 alone does not contribute to the observed high selectivity of Smurf1 inhibitors.

Inhibiting protein synthesis to treat malaria.

Covalent prodrugs inhibit protein synthesis targets killing parasites but not human cells.

Covalent-Fragment Screening of BRD4 Identifies a Ligandable Site Orthogonal to the Acetyl-Lysine Binding Sites.

BRD4, a member of the bromodomain and extraterminal domain (BET) family, has emerged as a promising epigenetic target in cancer and inflammatory disorders. All reported BET family ligands bind within the bromodomain acetyl-lysine binding sites and competitively inhibit BET protein interaction with acetylated chromatin. Alternative chemical probes that act orthogonally to the highly conserved acetyl-lysine binding sites may exhibit selectivity within the BET family and avoid recently reported toxicity in clinical trials of BET bromodomain inhibitors. Here, we report the first identification of a ligandable site on a bromodomain outside the acetyl-lysine binding site. Inspired by our computational prediction of hotspots adjacent to nonhomologous cysteine residues within the C-terminal BRD4 bromodomain (BRD4-BD2), we performed a midthroughput mass spectrometry screen to identify cysteine-reactive fragments that covalently and selectively modify BRD4. Subsequent mass spectrometry, NMR, and computational docking analyses of electrophilic fragment hits revealed a novel ligandable site near Cys356 that is unique to BRD4 among human bromodomains. This site is orthogonal to the BRD4-BD2 acetyl-lysine binding site as Cys356 modification did not impact binding of the pan-BET bromodomain inhibitor JQ1 in fluorescence polarization assays nor an acetylated histone peptide in AlphaScreen assays. Finally, we tethered our top-performing covalent fragment to JQ1 and performed NanoBRET assays to provide proof of principle that this orthogonal site can be covalently targeted in intact human cells. Overall, we demonstrate the potential of targeting sites orthogonal to bromodomain acetyl-lysine binding sites to develop bivalent and covalent inhibitors that displace BRD4 from chromatin.

Methodology for Identification of Cysteine-Reactive Covalent Inhibitors.

Covalent fragments are an emerging technology to discover covalent ligands in target-based or phenotypic screens. Here we describe screening of cysteine-reactive covalent fragments against a protein of interest using mass spectrometry or enzymatic methods.

Monitoring PARKIN RBR Ubiquitin Ligase Activation States with UbFluor.

PARKIN is a RING-Between-RING (RBR) E3 ligase, which ubiquitinates mitochondrial proteins in response to mitochondrial damage. Ser65 of PARKIN is phosphorylated by kinase PINK1 (pPARKIN), which causes partial PARKIN activation. PINK1 also phosphorylates Ser65 of ubiquitin (pUb), which further activates pPARKIN. Due to the lack of precise and quantitative assays to quantify the activity of PARKIN, there were many conflicting reports on the role of pUb as a PARKIN activator, whether S65E PARKIN is a true phosphomimetic of pPARKIN, and the effect of substrate of PARKIN turnover was also not known. This protocol provides a step-by-step guide on the use of the UbFluor probe to precisely quantitate changes in the activity of PARKIN in response to phosphorylation, allosteric activation by pUb, protein substrates, and activating structural mutations. These results pave the way to discover PARKIN activators and to precisely quantify the activity of other RBR E3s. © 2018 by John Wiley & Sons, Inc.

Structural Basis of Substrate Recognition and Covalent Inhibition of Cdu1 from Chlamydia trachomatis.

Based on the similarity between the active sites of the deubiquitylating and deneddylating enzyme ChlaDub1 (Cdu1) and the evolutionarily related protease adenain, a target-hopping screening approach on a focused set of adenain inhibitors was investigated. The cyanopyrimidine-based inhibitors identified represent the first active-site-directed small-molecule inhibitors of Cdu1. High-resolution crystal structures of Cdu1 in complex with two covalently bound cyanopyrimidines, as well as with its substrate ubiquitin, were obtained. These structural data were complemented by enzymatic assays and covalent docking studies to provide insight into the substrate recognition of Cdu1, active-site pocket flexibility and potential hotspots for ligand interaction. Combined, these data provide a strong basis for future structure-guided medicinal chemistry optimization of this cyanopyrimidine scaffold into more potent and selective Cdu1 inhibitors.

Dynamic recruitment of ubiquitin to mutant huntingtin inclusion bodies.

Many neurodegenerative diseases, such as Huntington's disease, are hallmarked by the formation of intracellular inclusion bodies (IBs) that are decorated with ubiquitin, proteasomes and chaperones. The apparent enrichment of ubiquitin and components involved in protein quality control at IBs suggests local ubiquitin-dependent enzymatic activity. In this study, we examine recruitment of ubiquitin to IBs of polyglutamine-expanded huntingtin fragments (mHtt) by using synthesized TAMRA-labeled ubiquitin moieties. We show that intracellular TAMRA-ubiquitin is dynamic at mHtt IBs and is incorporated into poly-ubiquitin chains of intracellular substrates, such as mHtt, in a conjugation-dependent manner. Furthermore, we report that mHtt IBs recruit catalytically active enzymes involved in (de)-ubiquitination processes based on novel activity-based probes. However, we also find that the overexpression of the GFP-ubiquitin reporter, unlike the endogenous ubiquitin and TAMRA-ubiquitin, becomes irreversibly sequestered as a ring-like structure around the mHtt IBs, suggesting a methodical disadvantage of GFP-tagged ubiquitin. Our data provide supportive evidence for dynamic recruitment of ubiquitin and ubiquitin (de)-conjugating activity at mHtt initiated IBs.

UbFluor: A Fluorescent Thioester to Monitor HECT E3 Ligase Catalysis.

HECT E3 ubiquitin ligases (∼28 are known) are associated with many phenotypes in eukaryotes and are important drug targets. However, assays used to screen for small molecule inhibitors of HECT E3s are complex and require ATP, Ub, E1, E2, and HECT E3 enzymes, producing three covalent thioester enzyme intermediates E1∼Ub, E2∼Ub, and HECT E3∼Ub (where ∼ indicates a thioester bond), and mixtures of polyubiquitin chains. To reduce the complexity of the assay, we developed a novel class of fluorescent probes, UbFluor, that act as mechanistically relevant pseudosubstrates of HECT E3s. These probes undergo a direct transthiolation reaction with the catalytic cysteine of HECT E3s, producing the catalytically active HECT E3∼Ub thioester accompanied by fluorophore release. Thus, a fluorescence polarization assay can continuously monitor UbFluor consumption by HECT E3s, and changes in UbFluor consumption rendered by biochemical point mutations or small molecule modulation of HECT E3 activity. © 2017 by John Wiley & Sons, Inc.

High-Throughput Screening of HECT E3 Ubiquitin Ligases Using UbFluor.

HECT E3 ubiquitin ligases are responsible for many human disease phenotypes and are promising drug targets; however, screening assays for HECT E3 inhibitors are inherently complex, requiring upstream E1 and E2 enzymes as well as ubiquitin, ATP, and detection reagents. Intermediate ubiquitin thioesters and a complex mixture of polyubiquitin products provide further opportunities for off-target inhibition and increase the complexity of the assay. UbFluor is a novel ubiquitin thioester that bypasses the E1 and E2 enzymes and undergoes direct transthiolation with HECT E3 ligases. The release of fluorophore upon transthiolation allows fluorescence polarization detection of HECT E3 activity. In the presence of inhibitors, HECT E3 activity is ablated, and thus no reaction and no change in FP are observed. This assay has been adapted for high-throughput screening of small molecules against HECT E3 ligases, and its utility has been proven in the discovery of HECT E3 ligase inhibitors. © 2017 by John Wiley & Sons, Inc.

Dissecting the Specificity of Adenosyl Sulfamate Inhibitors Targeting the Ubiquitin-Activating Enzyme.

Targeting the activating enzymes (E1) of ubiquitin (Ub) and ubiquitin-like modifiers (Ubls) has emerged as a promising anti-cancer strategy, possibly overcoming the ineffectiveness of proteasome inhibitors against solid tumors. Here, we report crystal structures of the yeast ubiquitin E1 (Uba1) with three adenosyl sulfamate inhibitors exhibiting different E1 specificities, which are all covalently linked to ubiquitin. The structures illustrate how the chemically diverse inhibitors are accommodated within the adenylation active site. When compared with the previously reported structures of various E1 enzymes, our structures provide the basis of the preferences of these inhibitors for different Ub/Ubl-activating enzymes. In vitro inhibition assays and molecular dynamics simulations validated the specificities of the inhibitors as deduced from the structures. Taken together, the structures establish a framework for the development of additional compounds targeting E1 enzymes, which will display higher potency and selectivity.

Covalent Tethering of Fragments For Covalent Probe Discovery.

Covalent probes and drugs have found widespread use as research tools and clinical agents. Covalent probes are useful because of their increased intracellular potency and because covalent labeling of cellular proteins can be tracked using click chemistry. Covalent drugs, on the other hand, can overcome drug resistance toward their reversible counterparts. The discovery of covalent probes and drugs usually follows two trajectories: covalent natural products and their analogues are used directly as covalent probes or drugs; or alternatively, a non-covalent probe is equipped with a reactive group and converted into a covalent probe. In both cases, there is a need to either have a natural product or a potent non-covalent scaffold. The alternative approach to discover covalent probes is to start with a drug-like fragment that already has an electrophile, and then grow the fragment into a potent lead compound. In this approach, the electrophilic fragment will react covalently with the target protein, and therefore the initial weak binding of the fragment can be amplified over time and detected using mass spectrometry. With this approach the surface of the protein can be interrogated with a library of covalent fragments to identify covalent drug binding sites. One challenge with this approach is the danger of non-specific covalent labeling of proteins with covalent fragments. The second challenge is the risk of selecting the most reactive fragment rather than the best binder if the covalent fragments are screened in mixtures. This review will highlight how covalent tethering was developed, its current state, and its future.