Biomechanics of Insect Flight Stability and Perturbation Response.

Insects must fly in highly variable natural environments filled with gusts, vortices, and other transient aerodynamic phenomena that challenge flight stability. Furthermore, the aerodynamic forces that support insect flight are produced from rapidly oscillating wings of time-varying orientation and configuration. The instantaneous flight forces produced by these wings are large relative to the average forces supporting body weight. The magnitude of these forces and their time-varying direction add another challenge to flight stability, because even proportionally small asymmetries in timing or magnitude between the left and right wings may be sufficient to produce large changes in body orientation. However, these same large-magnitude oscillating forces also offer an opportunity for unexpected flight stability through nonlinear interactions between body orientation, body oscillation in response to time-varying inertial and aerodynamic forces, and the oscillating wings themselves. Understanding the emergent stability properties of flying insects is a crucial step toward understanding the requirements for evolution of flapping flight and decoding the role of sensory feedback in flight control. Here, we provide a brief review of insect flight stability, with some emphasis on stability effects brought about by oscillating wings, and present some preliminary experimental data probing some aspects of flight stability in free-flying insects.

Thrust enhancement and degradation mechanisms due to self-induced vibrations in bio-inspired flying robots.

Bio-inspired flying robots (BIFRs) which fly by flapping their wings experience continuously oscillating aerodynamic forces. These oscillations in the driving force cause vibrations in the motion of the body around the mean trajectory. In other words, a hovering BIFR does not remain fixed in space; instead, it undergoes oscillatory motion in almost all directions around the stationary point. These oscillations affect the aerodynamic performance of the flier. Assessing the effect of these oscillations, particularly on thrust generation in two-winged and four-winged BIFRs, is the main objective of this work. To achieve such a goal, two experimental setups were considered to measure the average thrust for the two BIFRs. The average thrust is measured over the flapping cycle of the BIFRs. In the first experimental setup, the BIFR is installed at the end of a pendulum rod, in place of the pendulum mass. While flapping, the model creates a thrust force that raises the model along the circular trajectory of the pendulum mass to a certain angular position, which is an equilibrium point and is also stable. Measuring the weight of the BIFR and the equilibrium angle it obtains, it is straightforward to estimate the average thrust, by moment balance about the pendulum hinge. This pendulum setup allows the BIFR model to freely oscillate back and forth along the circular trajectory about the equilibrium position. As such, the estimated average thrust includes the effects of these self-induced vibrations. In contrast, we use another setup with a load cell to measure thrust where the model is completely fixed. The thrust measurement revealed that the load cell or the fixed test leads to a higher thrust than the pendulum or the oscillatory test for the two-winged model, showing the opposite behavior for the four-winged model. That is, self-induced vibrations have different effects on the two BIFR models. We felt that this observation is worth further investigation. It is important to mention that aerodynamic mechanisms for thrust generation in the two and four-winged models are different. A two-winged BIFR generates thrust through traditional flapping mechanisms whereas a four-winged model enjoys a clapping effect, which results from wing-wing interaction. In the present work, we use a motion capture system, aerodynamic modeling, and flow visualization to study the underlying physics of the observed different behaviors of the two flapping models. The study revealed that the interaction of the vortices with the flapping wing robots may play a role in the observed aerodynamic behavior of the two BIFRs.

Sea urchin sperm exploit extremum seeking control to find the egg.

Sperm cells perform extremely demanding tasks with minimal capabilities. The cells must quickly navigate in a noisy environment to find an egg within a short time window for successful fertilization without any global positioning information. Many research efforts have been dedicated to derive mathematical principles that explain their superb navigation strategy. Here we show that the navigation strategy of sea urchin sperm, also known as helical klinotaxis, is a natural implementation of a well-established adaptive control paradigm known as extremum seeking. This bridge between control theory and the biology of taxis in microorganisms is expected to deepen our understanding of the process. For example, the formulation leads to a coarse-grained model of the signaling pathway that offers new insights on the peculiar switching-like behavior between high- and low-gain steering modes observed in sea urchin sperm. Moreover, it may guide engineers in developing bioinspired miniaturized robots with minimal sensors.

Flow visualization and force measurement of the clapping effect in bio-inspired flying robots.

In this paper, we perform experimental investigations of the aerodynamic characteristics due to wing clapping in bio-inspired flying robots; i.e., micro-air-vehicles (MAVs) that fly by flapping their wings. For this purpose, four flapping MAV models with different levels of clapping (from no clapping at all to full clapping) are developed. The aerodynamic performance of each model is then tested in terms of the average thrust and power consumption at various flapping frequencies. The results show that clapping enhance both thrust and efficiency. To gain some physical insight into the underlying physics behind this clapping-thrust-enhancement, we perform a smoke flow visualization over the wings of the four models at different instants during the flapping cycle.

A stability perspective of bioinspired unmanned aerial vehicles performing optimal dynamic soaring.

The phenomenon of dynamic soaring, as exhibited by soaring birds, has long been a biological inspiration for aerospace and control engineers. If this fascinating phenomenon, which allows soaring birds to perform almost unpowered flight using wind shear, can be mimicked by unmanned aerial vehicles (UAVs), then there is substantial potential for technological and economic enhancement of UAV performance. Although there has been a considerable amount of research covering the modeling, optimization, control and simulation aspects of different UAVs performing dynamic soaring, there is little to no conclusive work analyzing the stability of such UAVs in soaring orbits. In this paper we present a comprehensive framework for determining the stability of soaring UAVs utilizing both linear (Floquet-based) and nonlinear (contraction theory-based) techniques. Floquet stability analysis was inconclusive, which led to the use of a nonlinear contraction formulation to reach a conclusive stability assessment for an actual nonlinear fixed-wing UAV performing dynamic soaring. Furthermore, parametric variation along with numerical simulations were conducted to ascertain the response of the actual nonlinear system when perturbed from the nominal motion studied in this paper. The analysis and simulations revealed that the system possesses instability as the UAV motion diverges from its nominal trajectory and follows an undesirable path. From this result we conclude, for the first time in the literature as far as we are aware, that UAVs performing dynamic soaring in an optimal way to reduce wind shear requirements are inherently unstable. The results of this work suggest that mimicking of dynamic soaring by UAVs will require careful investigation of tracking and regulatory controls that need to be implemented.

Vibrational control: A hidden stabilization mechanism in insect flight.

It is generally accepted among biology and engineering communities that insects are unstable at hover. However, existing approaches that rely on direct averaging do not fully capture the dynamical features and stability characteristics of insect flight. Here, we reveal a passive stabilization mechanism that insects exploit through their natural wing oscillations: vibrational stabilization. This stabilization technique cannot be captured using the averaging approach commonly used in literature. In contrast, it is elucidated using a special type of calculus: the chronological calculus. Our result is supported through experiments on a real hawkmoth subjected to pitch disturbance from hovering. This finding could be particularly useful to biologists because the vibrational stabilization mechanism may also be exploited by many other creatures. Moreover, our results may inspire more optimal designs for bioinspired flying robots by relaxing the feedback control requirements of flight.

The need for higher-order averaging in the stability analysis of hovering, flapping-wing flight.

Because of the relatively high flapping frequency associated with hovering insects and flapping wing micro-air vehicles (FWMAVs), dynamic stability analysis typically involves direct averaging of the time-periodic dynamics over a flapping cycle. However, direct application of the averaging theorem may lead to false conclusions about the dynamics and stability of hovering insects and FWMAVs. Higher-order averaging techniques may be needed to understand the dynamics of flapping wing flight and to analyze its stability. We use second-order averaging to analyze the hovering dynamics of five insects in response to high-amplitude, high-frequency, periodic wing motion. We discuss the applicability of direct averaging versus second-order averaging for these insects.