Foundations of Arrogance: A Broad Survey and Framework for Research.

We consider the topic of arrogance from a cross-disciplinary viewpoint. To stimulate further research, we suggest three types of arrogance (individual, comparative, and antagonistic) and six components contributing to them, each logically related to the next. The components progress from imperfect knowledge and abilities to an unrealistic assessment of them, an unwarranted attitude of superiority over other people, and related derisive behavior. Although each component presumably is present to some degree when the next one operates, causality might flow between components in either direction. The classification of components of arrogance should reduce miscommunication among researchers, as the relevant concepts and mechanisms span cognitive, motivational, social, and clinical domains and literatures. Arrogance is an important concept warranting further study for both theoretical and practical reasons, in both psychopathology and normal social interaction. Everyone seems to have qualities of arrogance to some degree, and we consider the importance of arrogance on a spectrum. We contend that humankind can benefit from a better understanding of the cognitive limitations and motivational biases that, operating together, appear to contribute to arrogance. We bring together information and questions that might lead to an invigorating increase in the rate and quality of cross-disciplinary research on arrogance.

ß2 nAChR Activation on VTA DA Neurons Is Sufficient for Nicotine Reinforcement in Rats.

Mesolimbic nicotinic acetylcholine receptor (nAChRs) activation is necessary for nicotine reinforcement behavior, but it is unknown whether selective activation of nAChRs in the dopamine (DA) reward pathway is sufficient to support nicotine reinforcement. In this study, we tested the hypothesis that activation of ß2-containing (ß2*) nAChRs on VTA neurons is sufficient for intravenous nicotine self-administration (SA). We expressed ß2 nAChR subunits with enhanced sensitivity to nicotine (referred to as ß2Leu9'Ser) in the VTA of male Sprague Dawley (SD) rats, enabling very low concentrations of nicotine to selectively activate ß2* nAChRs on transduced neurons. Rats expressing ß2Leu9'Ser subunits acquired nicotine SA at 1.5 µg/kg/infusion, a dose too low to support acquisition in control rats. Saline substitution extinguished responding for 1.5 µg/kg/inf, verifying that this dose was reinforcing. ß2Leu9'Ser nAChRs also supported acquisition at the typical training dose in rats (30 µg/kg/inf) and reducing the dose to 1.5 µg/kg/inf caused a significant increase in the rate of nicotine SA. Viral expression of ß2Leu9'Ser subunits only in VTA DA neurons (via TH-Cre rats) also enabled acquisition of nicotine SA at 1.5 µg/kg/inf, and saline substitution significantly attenuated responding. Next, we examined electrically-evoked DA release in slices from ß2Leu9'Ser rats with a history of nicotine SA. Single-pulse evoked DA release and DA uptake rate were reduced in ß2Leu9'Ser NAc slices, but relative increases in DA following a train of stimuli were preserved. These results are the first to report that ß2* nAChR activation on VTA neurons is sufficient for nicotine reinforcement in rats.

Relapse-like behavior and nAChR sensitization following intermittent access nicotine self-administration.

Many tobacco smokers consume nicotine intermittently, but the underlying mechanisms and neurobiological changes associated with intermittent nicotine intake are unclear. Understanding intermittent nicotine intake is a high priority, as it could promote therapeutic strategies to attenuate tobacco consumption. We examined nicotine intake behavior and neurobiological changes in male rats that were trained to self-administer nicotine during brief (5 min) trials interspersed with longer (15 min) drug-free periods. Rats readily adapted to intermittent access (IntA) SA following acquisition on a continuous access (ContA) schedule. Probabilistic analysis of IntA nicotine SA suggested reduced nicotine loading behavior compared to ContA, and nicotine pharmacokinetic modeling revealed that rats taking nicotine intermittently may have increased intake to maintain blood levels of nicotine that are comparable to ContA SA. After IntA nicotine SA, rats exhibited an increase in unreinforced responses for nicotine-associated cues (incubation of craving) and specific alterations in the striatal proteome after 7 days without nicotine. IntA nicotine SA also induced nAChR functional upregulation in the interpeduncular nucleus (IPN), and it enhanced nicotine binding in the brain as determined via [11C]nicotine positron emission tomography. Reducing the saliency of the cue conditions during the 5 min access periods attenuated nicotine intake, but incubation of craving was preserved. Together, these results indicate that IntA conditions promote nicotine SA and nicotine seeking after a nicotine-free period.

Scalable and modular wireless-network infrastructure for large-scale behavioural neuroscience.

The use of rodents to acquire understanding of the function of neural circuits and of the physiological, genetic and developmental underpinnings of behaviour has been constrained by limitations in the scalability, automation and high-throughput operation of implanted wireless neural devices. Here we report scalable and modular hardware and software infrastructure for setting up and operating remotely programmable miniaturized wireless networks leveraging Bluetooth Low Energy for the study of the long-term behaviour of large groups of rodents. The integrated system allows for automated, scheduled and real-time experimentation via the simultaneous and independent use of multiple neural devices and equipment within and across laboratories. By measuring the locomotion, feeding, arousal and social behaviours of groups of mice or rats, we show that the system allows for bidirectional data transfer from readily available hardware, and that it can be used with programmable pharmacological or optogenetic stimulation. Scalable and modular wireless-network infrastructure should facilitate the remote operation of fully automated large-scale and long-term closed-loop experiments for the study of neural circuits and animal behaviour.

The sigma receptor ligand N-phenylpropyl-N'-(4-methoxyphenethyl)3piperazine (YZ-067) enhances the cocaine conditioned-rewarding properties while inhibiting the development of sensitization of cocaine in mice.

RATIONALE: The N-phenylpropyl-N'-substituted piperazines SA-4503 (N-phenylpropyl-N'-(3,4-dimethoxyphenethyl)piperazine) and YZ-185 (N-phenylpropyl-N'-(3-methoxyphenethyl)piperazine) bind to sigma (σ) receptors and block the development of cocaine-induced conditioned place preference at concentrations that inhibit cocaine-induced hyperactivity. YZ-067 (N-phenylpropyl-N'-(4-methoxyphenethyl)piperazine) also binds to sigma receptors and attenuates cocaine-induced hyperactivity in mice. OBJECTIVES: The present study determined the effect of YZ-067 on the development and expression of cocaine (66 µmol/kg or 33 µmol/kg) conditioned place preference (CPP) and locomotor sensitization in mice. RESULTS: YZ-067 (10 or 31.6 µmol/kg) did not have intrinsic effects on place preference or place aversion. Interestingly, the 31.6 µmol/kg YZ-067 dose enhanced the development of cocaine place preference, while 10 µmol/kg YZ-067 attenuated the development of cocaine-induced locomotor sensitization. However, YZ-067 did not alter the expression of cocaine place preference nor cocaine-induced locomotor sensitization. In follow-up studies, YZ-067 did not affect performance in the zero maze or rotarod, indicating that sigma receptors probed by this ligand do not regulate anxiety-like or coordinated motor skill behaviors, respectively. CONCLUSION: Overall, these results are consistent with previous studies demonstrating a role for sigma receptors in the behavioral effects of cocaine. However, the present findings also indicate that N-phenylpropyl-N'-substituted piperazines do not strictly block cocaine's behavioral effects and that sigma receptor may differentially mediate cocaine-induced hyperactivity and place conditioning.

Sex differences in hedonic and homeostatic aspects of palatable food motivation.

Feeding behaviors can be modified via homeostatic and hedonic mechanisms. Homeostasis, while primarily concerned with maintaining energy balance via food consumption and energy expenditure, can alter food reward and motivation in response to food deprivation. Alternatively, reward and motivation of food is also driven by its palatability or hedonic nature, and this process can be augmented by opioid receptor activation. The present study examined sex differences in the motivational properties of sucrose pellets through manipulation of homeostatic and hedonic processes via acute food deprivation and acute systemic administration of morphine, respectively. The results showed that regardless of sex, systemic injections of morphine did not alter the motivation to obtain a sucrose pellet on a progressive ratio schedule of reinforcement but does significantly increase consumption of sucrose pellets when freely available. Male and female rats demonstrated similar increased consumption of sucrose pellets under free feeding conditions following acute (24-hours) food deprivation, compared to the non-deprived conditions. Overall, the findings from these experiments indicate that female rats work harder in order to obtain a sucrose pellet (under a Progressive Ratio (PR) schedule of reinforcement) and consume more sucrose pellets than males. However, while acute morphine administration causes similar increases on feeding in males and females, it does not alter motivation as measured by breakpoint on a PR schedule of reinforcement.

Sigma-1 receptor ligand PD144418 and sigma-2 receptor ligand YUN-252 attenuate the stimulant effects of methamphetamine in mice.

RATIONALE: Previous research indicates that the selective sigma-1 receptor ligand PD144418 and the selective sigma-2 ligands YUN-252 can inhibit cocaine-induced hyperactivity. The effects of these ligands on other stimulants, such as methamphetamine, have not been reported. OBJECTIVES: The present study examined the effects of PD144418 and YUN-252 pretreatment on methamphetamine-induced hyperactivity after acute treatment. METHODS: Mice (n = 8-14/group) were injected with PD144418 (3.16, 10, or 31.6 µmol/kg), YUN-252 (0.316, 3.16, 31.6 µmol/kg), or saline. After 15 min, mice injected with 2.69 µmol/kg methamphetamine or saline vehicle, where distance traveled during a 60-min period was recorded. Additionally, the effect of PD144418 on the initiation and expression of methamphetamine sensitization was determined by treating mice (n = 8-14/group) with PD144418, methamphetamine or saline repeatedly over a 5-day period, and testing said mice with a challenge dose after a 7-day withdrawal period. RESULTS: Results indicate that both PD144418 and YUN-252, in a dose-dependent manner, attenuated hyperactivity induced by an acute methamphetamine injection. Specifically, 10 µmol/kg or 31.6 µmol/kg of PD144418 and 31 µmol/kg of YUN-252 suppressed methamphetamine-induced hyperactivity. In regard to methamphetamine sensitization, while 10 µmol/kg PD144418 prevented the initiation of methamphetamine sensitization, it did not have an effect on the expression. CONCLUSIONS: Overall, the current results suggest an intriguing potential for this novel sigma receptor ligand as a treatment for the addictive properties of methamphetamine. Future analysis of this novel sigma receptor ligand in assays directly measuring reinforcement properties will be critical.

Sex dependent effects of physical activity on diet preference in rats selectively bred for high or low levels of voluntary wheel running.

Considering the current obesity epidemic is due in large part to an energy imbalance, it is crucial to explore biological mechanisms that mediate palatable high energy food intake and physical activity behavior levels. Previous research demonstrates a unique sex dependent influence of physical activity on diet preference, specifically changes in palatable high-fat diet intake. Therefore, factors of motivation may be underlying the differential effect of physical activity in male and female rats on their diet preference. The present study extends this hypothesis by assessing diet preference in male and female Wistar rats selectively bred for high (HVR) and low (LVR) levels of voluntary wheel running distances. HVR and LVR rats were housed under either sedentary (SED) or voluntary wheel running access (RUN) conditions for the duration of the study. Following a 1 week acclimation period to these conditions, standard chow was replaced with concurrent ad libitum access to a choice of 3 pelleted diets (high-fat, high-sucrose, and high-corn starch); all 3 were provided in the home cage. Body weight, running distance, and intake of each diet was measured daily. At the conclusion of the 4 week diet preference test, animals were sacrificed and ventral striatum tissue was collected for later analysis. Results demonstrated intake patterns of diets were uniquely influenced by physical activity dependent on both the sex and the selectively bred line of rat. In addition, reward related ventral striatal mRNA expression was also dependent on both the sex and the selectively bred line of rat. Overall, the pattern of both behavioral and mRNA results suggest that voluntary wheel running behavior differentially mediates palatable diet consumption in males and females. Considering the pervasive abundance of both physical inactivity, combined with over-consumption of energy dense palatable diets, it is vital to understand the nature of these behavioral interactions.

Voluntary wheel running effects on intra-accumbens opioid driven diet preferences in male and female rats.

Palatability driven feeding and voluntary physical activity are mediated by and influence similar neural mechanisms, notably through the actions of opioids within the nucleus accumbens. Recent studies suggest that access to a voluntary running wheel results in sex dependent behavioral and physiological adaptations related to opioid mediated palatability-driven feeding. To explore this relationship, male and female Wistar rats were given either access to a voluntary running wheel (RUN group) or no access (SED group) for one week prior to being stereotaxically implanted with bilateral cannulae targeting the nucleus accumbens. Following 7 days of recovery, with RUN or SED conditions continuing the duration of the experiment, all rats were assessed daily (2 h/day) for feeding behavior of concurrently accessible high-carbohydrate and high-fat diet for one week. Following this week, all rats were administered the µ-opioid receptor agonist D-Ala2, NMe-Phe4, Glyol5-enkephalin (DAMGO) (0.0025  µg, 0.025  µg, or 0.25 µg/0.5 µl/side) or the opioid antagonist naloxone (20 µg/0.5 µl/side) into the nucleus accumbens and given concurrent access (2 h) to both diets. All groups expressed a significant baseline preference for the high-carbohydrate diet. DAMGO administration, compared to saline treatment, led to significant increased consumption of the high-carbohydrate diet in all treatment groups. While high-fat diet consumption also increased following DAMGO administration, the influence of DAMGO was much more robust for the preferred high-carbohydrate diet in all groups. Compared to males, females consumed significantly more of both diets at baseline and following DAMGO treatment. Both male and female rats in the RUN condition consumed more high-carbohydrate diet compared to rats in the SED condition. While males exhibited similar increased consumption of both diets regardless of RUN or SED condition, females in the RUN condition displayed a greater sensitivity to DAMGO-driven consumption of the preferred high-carbohydrate, compared to SED females.

Sigma-1 receptor antagonist PD144418 suppresses food reinforced operant responding in rats.

Sigma-1 (σ1) receptors have been investigated for their involvement in learning, rewarding and motivational processes, particularly as it relates to substances of abuse. Few studies have examined the effects of σ1 receptor agonists and antagonists on the rewarding and motivational properties of natural reinforcers, such as food. Studies that have investigated σ1 receptor agonists and antagonists has produced conflicting results. σ1 receptor antagonist PD144418 has been found to produce a dose-dependent attenuation of locomotor activity induced by cocaine, and by itself, does not suppress basal locomotor activity in mice. However, its effects on reward and motivation as it relates to food are unknown. The present study examined the involvement of σ1 receptors in mediating the rewarding and motivational properties of food using an operant task. The results indicated that at the highest dose (10 µmol/kg), PD144418 significantly attenuated the number of active lever responses for chow pellets but did not decrease the number of active lever responses for sucrose pellets under a fixed ratio (FR2) schedule of reinforcement. However, under a progressive ratio (PR) reinforcement schedule, 10 µmol/kg of PD14418 significantly reduced the breakpoint, a measure indicative of effort or motivation, for both chow and sucrose pellets. When ad libitum chow or sucrose pellets were made freely available (i.e. no lever press required) inside the operant chamber, 10 µmol/kg, PD144418 did not have an effect on number of pellets consumed. These findings indicate that PD144418 reduces the motivational effort of a food reinforced behavior.

Sigma-1 receptor antagonist, PD144418, selectively reduces female motivation for food during negative energy balance.

Sigma-1 (σ1) receptors have been investigated for their involvement in learning, rewarding and motivational processes. PD144418, a σ1 receptor antagonist, has been found to produce a dose-dependent attenuation of locomotor activity induced by cocaine, and by itself, does not suppress basal locomotor activity in mice. Moreover, PD144418 decreases the motivational effort of a food-reinforced behavior in male rats, without altering appetite or food palatability. It remains unknown whether the PD144418 can alter the motivational effort of a food-reinforced behavior in response to altered energy homeostasis, as is the case under 24 -h food deprivation. Additionally, while the previous experiments indicate effects in male rats, there has been no research examining the effects of PD144418, or any other σ1 receptor antagonist, on motivational aspects of feeding in females. The present study examined the effects of PD144418 on motivational aspects of feeding in male and female rats using an operant task under sated or food deprived conditions. Results indicated that when animals are sated, at the highest dose (10 µmol/kg), under a progressive ratio (PR) reinforcement schedule, PD144418 significantly attenuated the breakpoint and the number of active lever responses for sucrose pellets in both males and females. When animals are in a state of energy deficit, as is the case following 24-hr food deprivation, PD144418 does not alter motivationally driven operant responding as measured by the breakpoint in either sex but does alter the number of earned reinforcers responses in females.