A Shadow of Doubt: Is There Implicit Bias Among Orthopaedic Surgery Faculty and Residents Regarding Race and Gender?

BACKGROUND: Orthopaedic surgery continues to be one of the least diverse medical specialties. Recently, increasing emphasis has been placed on improving diversity in the medical field, which includes the need to better understand existing biases. Despite this, only about 6% of orthopaedic surgeons are women and 0.3% are Black. Addressing diversity, in part, requires a better understanding of existing biases. Most universities and residency programs have statements and policies against discrimination that seek to eliminate explicit biases. However, unconscious biases might negatively impact the selection, training, and career advancement of women and minorities who are underrepresented in orthopaedic surgery. Although this is difficult to measure, the Implicit Association Test (IAT) by Project Implicit might be useful to identify and measure levels of unconscious bias among orthopaedic surgeons, providing opportunities for additional interventions to improve diversity in this field. QUESTIONS/PURPOSES: (1) Do orthopaedic surgeons demonstrate implicit biases related to race and gender roles? (2) Are certain demographic characteristics (age, gender, race or ethnicity, or geographic location) or program characteristics (geographic location or size of program) associated with the presence of implicit biases? (3) Do the implicit biases of orthopaedic surgeons differ from those of other healthcare providers or the general population? METHODS: A cross-sectional study of implicit bias among orthopaedic surgeons was performed using the IAT from Project Implicit. The IAT is a computerized test that measures the time required to associate words or pictures with attributes, with faster or slower response times suggesting the ease or difficulty of associating the items. Although concerns have been raised recently about the validity and utility of the IAT, we believed it was the right study instrument to help identify the slight hesitation that can imply differences between inclusion and exclusion of a person. We used two IATs, one for Black and White race and one for gender, career, and family roles. We invited a consortium of researchers from United States and Canadian orthopaedic residency programs. Researchers at 34 programs agreed to distribute the invitation via email to their faculty, residents, and fellows for a total of 1484 invitees. Twenty-eight percent (419) of orthopaedic surgeons and trainees completed the survey. The respondents were 45% (186) residents, 55% (228) faculty, and one fellow. To evaluate response biases, the respondent population was compared with that of the American Academy of Orthopaedic Surgeons census. Responses were reported as D-scores based on response times for associations. D-scores were categorized as showing strong (≥ 0.65), moderate (≥ 0.35 to < 0.65), or slight (≥ 0.15 to < 0.35) associations. For a frame of reference, orthopaedic surgeons' mean IAT scores were compared with historical scores of other self-identified healthcare providers and that of the general population. Mean D-scores were analyzed with the Kruskal-Wallis test to determine whether demographic characteristics were associated with differences in D-scores. Bonferroni correction was applied, and p values less than 0.0056 were considered statistically significant. RESULTS: Overall, the mean IAT D-scores of orthopaedic surgeons indicated a slight preference for White people (0.29 ± 0.4) and a slight association of men with career (0.24 ± 0.3), with a normal distribution. Hence, most respondents' scores indicated slight preferences, but strong preferences for White race were noted in 27% (112 of 419) of respondents. There was a strong association of women with family and home and an association of men with work or career in 14% (60 of 419). These preferences generally did not correlate with the demographic, geographic, and program variables that were analyzed, except for a stronger association of women with family and home among women respondents. There were no differences in race IAT D-scores between orthopaedic surgeons and other healthcare providers and the general population. Gender-career IAT D-scores associating women with family and home were slightly lower among orthopaedic surgeons (0.24 ± 0.3) than among the general population (0.32 ± 0.4; p < 0.001) and other healthcare professionals (0.34 ± 0.4; p < 0.001). All of these values are in the slight preference range. CONCLUSION: Orthopaedic surgeons demonstrated slight preferences for White people, and there was a tendency to associate women with career and family on IATs, regardless of demographic and program characteristics, similar to others in healthcare and the general population. Given the similarity of scores with those in other, more diverse areas of medicine, unconscious biases alone do not explain the relative lack of diversity in orthopaedic surgery. CLINICAL RELEVANCE: Implicit biases only explain a small portion of the lack of progress in improving diversity, equity, inclusion, and belonging in our workforce and resolving healthcare disparities. Other causes including explicit biases, an unwelcoming culture, and perceptions of our specialty should be examined. Remedies including engagement of students and mentorship throughout training and early career should be sought.

Mechanochemical Endovenous Ablation of the Saphenous Vein: A Look at Contemporary Outcomes.

BACKGROUND: Endovenous ablation techniques have replaced greater saphenous vein (GSV) ligation and stripping for treatment of venous insufficiency. Our objective was to investigate our initial procedural experience and clinical presentation of patients undergoing mechanochemical ablation (MOCA) at a single institution. We hypothesized that closure level and success rate improved over time and were comparable to other endovenous ablation techniques. METHODS: We retrospectively reviewed all MOCA procedures performed at the Greater Los Angeles Veterans Affairs Hospital from 2015 - 2020. Variables included CEAP and VCSS scores, patient symptoms, post procedure duplex ultrasound, closure level, and need for anticoagulation. Success was defined as GSV thrombosis on initial post procedure duplex ultrasound. Procedure associated extension of thrombus into the deep veins was defined using the American Venous Forum (AVF) endothermal heat induced thrombosis (EHIT) classification. RESULTS: 104 venous ablation procedures were performed on 86 patients. Eleven (12.8%) patients received bilateral interventions, and six (7%) patients had asynchronous interventions on the same leg. The average age was 58.4 years (SD 12) and 93% were male. Pre-procedural symptoms included pain (102, 98.1%), varicose veins (87, 83.7%), edema (58, 55.8%), and active ulcers (19, 18.3%). A CEAP category of C2 was the most common indication (34.6%), followed by C3 (22.1%) and C6 (21.2%). Forty-five (43.2%) patients had deep system reflux, and 53% had concomitant phlebectomies. Average VCSS score was 7.5 (SD 3.5).We observed a GSV ablation rate of 92.7% (n = 89) in the 96 procedures which had post-procedure follow up, with no temporal evidence of a learning curve. On post procedure duplex of the 89 technically successful ablations, 77 (86.5%) patients had AVF EHIT level 1 closure, three (3.4%) had level 2 closure, eight (8.9%) had level 3 closure, and one had a level 4 closure. Fourteen (15.7%) patients were newly started on anticoagulation for an average of 33.2 days (SD 34.1). Of the 19 legs treated for active venous ulcers, 13 (68.4%) had improvement or resolution of their venous ulcers. No pulmonary embolic complications were reported. CONCLUSIONS: We observed a successful GSV thrombosis rate of 92.7% using MOCA without evidence of a learning curve and comparable to that reported in the literature. The rate of thrombus extension into the deep veins was 14.6%, with no adverse effects associated with anticoagulation or clinically significant sequelae of AVF EHIT level 2 or greater. Comparisons with MOCA associated thrombus extension into deep veins in the literature are limited as post procedure screening duplex are not standard of care. However, we demonstrated that MOCA ablation of the GSV is a safe procedure that may be performed with good technical success.

Pediatric hallux valgus: An overview of history, examination, conservative, and surgical management.

Pediatric hallux valgus (PHV), while relatively rare, is still often encountered by general pediatricians. Herein, we concisely summarize the existing literature regarding the pathogenesis, associated conditions, clinical diagnosis, radiographic characteristics, conservative management, and surgical management of PVH. Though PHV is generally considered benign, the progression of hallux valgus can result in complications. The presence of an open physis in the pediatric age group delineates first line treatment choices, whenever possible, as nonoperative. The general exception to this recommendation is for children with neuromuscular and connective tissues disease who may benefit from earlier surgical management. If conservative approaches fail prior to skeletal maturity, the risk of recurrence and need for revision surgery should be discussed with patients and their families before surgical referral is made. The current review was conducted to aid primary care providers in better understanding the pathogenesis, associated conditions, and intervention options available to manage PHV.

Which surgical approach is optimal for joint preparation in talonavicular fusion - A cadaver study.

BACKGROUND: Fusion of the talonavicular joint has proven challenging in literature. The optimal surgical approach for talonavicular arthrodesis is still uncertain. This study compares the amount of physical joint preparation between dorsal and medial approaches to the talonavicular joint. METHODS: Twenty fresh frozen cadaver specimens were randomly assigned to receive either a dorsal or medial operative approach to the talonavicular joint. The joint surface was prepared, and the joint was disarticulated. Image analysis, using ImageJ, was performed by two blinded reviewers to assess the joint surface preparation and this was compared by surgical approach. RESULTS: The dorsal approach had a higher median percentage of talar and total talonavicular joint surface area prepared (75% vs. 59% (p = .007) and 82% vs. 70% (p = .005)). Irrespective of approach, the talus was significantly more difficult to prepare than the navicular (62% vs 88% (p = .001)). CONCLUSION: The dorsal approach provides superior talonavicular joint preparation. The lateral »th of the talar head was the most difficult surface to prepare, and surgeons performing double or triple arthrodesis may prepare the lateral talar head from the lateral approach. LEVEL OF EVIDENCE: Level V.

LPS enhances CTB-INSULIN induction of IDO1 and IL-10 synthesis in human dendritic cells.

Autoantigen-specific immunotherapy promises effective treatment for devastating tissue specific autoimmune diseases like multiple sclerosis (MS) and type 1 diabetes (T1D). Because activated dendritic cells (DCs) stimulate the differentiation of autoreactive T cells involved in the initiation of autoimmunity, blocking the activation of DCs may be an effective strategy for inhibiting tissue specific autoimmunity. Following this approach, immature DCs were shown to remain inactive after treatment with chimeric fusion proteins composed of the cholera toxin B subunit adjuvant linked to autoantigens like proinsulin (CTB-INS). Mass spectrometer analysis of human DCs treated with CTB-INS suggest that upregulation of the tryptophan catabolic enzyme indoleamine 2, 3-dioxygenase (IDO1) is responsible for inhibiting DC activation thereby resulting in a state of immunological tolerance within the DC. Here we show that the fusion protein CTB-INS inhibits human monocyte derived DC (moDC) activation through stimulation of IDO1 biosynthesis and that the resultant state of DC tolerance can be further enhanced by the presence of residual E. coli lipopolysaccharide (LPS) present in partially purified CTB-INS preparations. Additional experiments showed that LPS enhancement of DC tolerance was dependent upon stimulation of IDO1 biosynthesis. LPS stimulation of increased levels of IDO1 in the DC resulted in increased secretion of kynurenines, tryptophan degradation products known to suppress DC mediated pro-inflammatory T cell differentiation and to stimulate the proliferation of regulatory T cells (Tregs). Further, the presence of LPS in CTB-INS treated DCs stimulated the biosynthesis of costimulatory factors CD80 and CD86 but failed to upregulate maturation factor CD83, suggesting CTB-INS treated DCs may be maintained in a state of semi-activation. While treatment of moDCs with increasing amounts of LPS free CTB-INS was shown to increase DC secretion of the anti-inflammatory cytokine IL-10, the presence of residual LPS in partially purified CTB-INS preparations dramatically increased IL-10 secretion, suggesting that CTB-INS may enhance DC mediated immunological tolerance by stimulating the proliferation of anti-inflammatory T cells. While the extraction of LPS from bacterial generated CTB-INS may remove additional unknown factors that may contribute to the regulation of IDO1 levels, together, our experimental data suggest that LPS stimulates the ability of CTB-INS to induce IDO1 and IL-10 important factors required for establishment of a state of functional immunological tolerance in human DCs. Regulation of the ratio of LPS to CTB-INS may prove to be an effective method for optimization of readily available "off the shelf" CTB-INS mediated immune-therapy for tissue specific autoimmune diseases including type 1 diabetes.

Delayed Presentation of Popliteal Artery Injury after Salter-Harris III Proximal Tibia Fracture.

Introduction: Proximal tibia physeal fractures in children are not very common but can be dangerous because they can harm popliteal fossa structures, especially the popliteal artery. Popliteal artery injuries (PAI) are most commonly the result of trauma to the lower extremity, including blunt force, hyperextension injuries, complex fractures, and knee dislocations that can compromise popliteal neurovascular structures. Case Presentation. A 14-year-old boy presents to the emergency department after being transferred from an outside hospital 24 hours after a left lower extremity hyperextension injury. Radiographs demonstrated a Salter-Harris III proximal tibia fracture with posterior displacement. ABIs were deferred due to palpable distal pulses and no evidence of compartment syndrome. Closed reduction and percutaneous pinning were planned to correct the fracture. Intraoperatively, it was discovered that knee extension decreased lower extremity perfusion while knee flexion returned perfusion. An angiography revealed a popliteal artery occlusion with no distal flow. Based on this, an above-knee to below-knee popliteal bypass using the contralateral great saphenous vein was performed followed by closed reduction and percutaneous pinning of the proximal tibia. Conclusion: Proximal tibia physeal injuries, especially the Salter-Harris III and IV injuries, warrant a high index of suspicion of popliteal artery injuries. Palpable pulses and delayed presentation in the distal lower extremity do not rule out a PAI because collateral flow to the anterior and posterior tibial arteries may mask signs of an avascular limb, highlighting the need for a thorough history and physical exam. The authors present this case to reaffirm the importance of an ankle-brachial index when evaluating hyperextension injuries with proximal tibial epiphyseal fractures.

Comparison of nonoperative versus operative management in pediatric gustilo-anderson type I open tibia fractures.

BACKGROUND: Recent studies suggest pediatric Gustilo-Anderson type I fractures, especially of the upper extremity, may be adequately treated without formal operative debridement, though few tibial fractures have been included in these studies. The purpose of this study is to provide initial data suggesting whether Gustilo-Anderson type I tibia fractures may be safely treated nonoperatively. METHODS: Institutional retrospective review was performed for children with type I tibial fractures managed with and without operative debridement from 1999 through 2020. Incomplete follow-up, polytrauma, and delayed diagnosis of greater than 12 h since the time of injury were criteria for exclusion. Data including age, sex, mechanism of injury, management, time-to-antibiotic administration, and complications were recorded. RESULTS: Thirty-three patients met inclusion criteria and were followed to union. Average age was 9.9 ± 3.7 years. All patients were evaluated in the emergency department and received intravenous antibiotics within 8 h of presentation. Median time-to-antibiotics was 2 h. All patients received cefazolin except one who received clindamycin at an outside hospital and subsequent cephalexin. Three patients (8.8%) received augmentation with gentamicin. Twenty-one patients (63.6%) underwent operative irrigation and debridement (I&D), and of those, sixteen underwent surgical fixation of their fracture. Twelve (36.4%) patients had bedside I&D with saline under conscious sedation, with one requiring subsequent operative I&D and intramedullary nailing. Three infections (14.3%) occurred in the operative group and none in the nonoperative group. Complications among the nonoperative patients include delayed union (8.3%), angulation (8.3%), and refracture (8.3%). Complications among the operative patients include delayed union (9.5%), angulation (14.3%), and one patient experienced both (4.8%). Other operative group complications include leg-length discrepancy (4.8%), heterotopic ossification (4.8%), and symptomatic hardware (4.8%). CONCLUSION: No infections were observed in a small group of children with type I tibia fractures treated with bedside debridement and antibiotics, and similar non-infectious complication rates were observed relative to operative debridement. This study provides initial data that suggests nonoperative management of type I tibial fractures may be safe and supports the development of larger studies.

Institutional performance and validation of severity of illness score for children with acute hematogenous osteomyelitis.

A scoring system has recently been published that uses parameters within the first 4-5 days of hospitalization to determine the severity of illness (SOI) in children with acute hematogenous osteomyelitis (AHO). To our knowledge, no additional studies to date have examined the validity of the SOI score outside of the institution of origin. This study evaluates the performance of the SOI score in a retrospective cohort of cases at our institution. Patients admitted to our institution over the past 5 years with AHO who met inclusion and exclusion criteria were analyzed. Parameters including C reactive protein over the first 96 h of hospitalization, febrile days on antibiotics, ICU admission, and presence of disseminated disease were used to calculate the SOI score for each patient. Pearson and Spearman correlations were used when appropriate. SOI score comparison between groups was achieved with the Kruskal-Wallis and Wilcoxon two-sample tests. Seventy-four patients were analyzed. Significantly higher SOI scores were noted for patients with bacteremia, ICU admission, fever for two or more days on presentation, multiple surgeries, and any complication. Markers of disease severity that significantly correlated with SOI score were total length of stay, LOS, duration of antibiotic course, number of surgical procedures, and case mix index. The SOI score functioned well as higher scores were associated with sicker patients. The SOI score is helpful for determining which patients will require longer hospitalizations and more intense treatment in a setting other than the institution of origin.

Analysis of risk factors for nonunion in pediatric lateral column lengthening.

The lateral column lengthening procedure is a commonly used osteotomy for correction of pes planus performed by inserting a graft in the anterior aspect of the calcaneus through a transverse osteotomy. Though nonunion and calcaneo-cuboid subluxation have been previously reported, these complications have not been extensively studied in pediatric patients. After IRB approval, 111 patients (151 feet) who underwent lateral column lengthening at a single institution were identified. Fifty-three females (70 feet) and 58 males (81 feet) with an average age of 11.4 years (2.6 SD; range 5-17) were analyzed. The primary outcome was nonunion defined as a lack of radiographic evidence of osteotomy healing by 9 months. Underlying diagnosis, pre and postoperative radiographic measurements, age, operative technique, fixation, calcaneo-cuboid subluxation, graft material and concomitant procedures were analyzed for their relationship to nonunion. Nonunion occurred in 7 of 151 feet (4.6%). Patient age at the time of surgery and calcaneo-cuboid subluxation trended toward a significant association with nonunion ( P = 0.053, 0.054, respectively). The degree of surgical correction, as determined by radiographic analysis, and the use of calcaneo-cuboid fixation were not significantly associated with nonunion. None of the other factors evaluated were significantly associated with nonunion. There were three cases of postoperative infections (2.0%), two were superficial and 1 (0.7%) was deep. Thirty-five of 151 feet disclosed radiographic evidence of subluxation. Excluding subluxation, the overall complication rate was 8.6%. Nonunion occurred in 4.6% of pediatric feet undergoing lateral column lengthening. Fixation type was not significantly associated with nonunion. Older age at the time of surgery and calcaneocuboid subluxation trended towards significance. The placement of a calcaneo-cuboid pin was not found to be a significant factor in preventing calcaneo-cuboid subluxation or nonunion.

Novel Use of a Shoulder Spica: Treatment for Midshaft Humerus Fracture in the Presence of Limb Deficiency.

Pediatric midshaft humerus fractures are typically managed with a hanging arm cast, Sarmiento bracing, coaptation splint, or a combination of these treatment options. Here we report a novel use of a shoulder spica cast in the treatment of a midshaft humerus fracture in the presence of limb deficiency. Current treatments proved unsuccessful in maintaining adequate alignment, specifically the varus deformity of the fracture. A shoulder spica was able to successfully maintain acceptable alignment throughout the duration of the patient's healing process. This nontraditional use of a shoulder spica cast shows the practicality of its ability to be utilized for the treatment of unique upper extremity orthopedic obstacles.