Assessing professionalism in early medical education: experience with peer evaluation and self-evaluation in the gross anatomy course.

INTRODUCTION: As today's healthcare model moves toward more streamlined and corporate industrialism, it is our responsibility, as doctors, to ensure the integrity of medicine's foundation in professionalism. The erosion of professional values not only creates a climate of animosity, but reverberates negatively to impact the development of students, who model their behaviour after those they most respect. This hazard has spurred an evaluation of medical school curricula, with a new emphasis on professionalism in the philosophy of medical education. Courses such as Gross Anatomy that, in the past, offered "pure content," are now being used to teach and evaluate professionalism. The goal of this study was to determine if peer evaluation and self-evaluation used in conjunction and implemented early in the medical curriculum, can serve as useful tools to assess and provide feedback regarding professional behaviour in first-year medical students. MATERIALS AND METHODS: From 1999 to 2003, students at Mayo Clinic College of Medicine evaluated themselves and their peers during the Gross and Developmental Anatomy Course. Numerical evaluations and written comments were statistically analysed within established categories of professionalism and correlated with academic performance, gender, and peer rating and self-rating. RESULTS: The majority of written comments pertained to inter-professional respect, responsibility, and excellence. Students who gave higher peer evaluation and self-evaluation scores provided more positive comments, and students performing well in the course provided more positive comments about their peers and themselves than did those struggling academically. Students consistently rated their peers higher than themselves, and male students rated themselves higher than did female students. CONCLUSIONS: Implementing peer evaluation and self-evaluation early in the medical curriculum is a valuable exercise in teaching first-year medical students assessment skills when evaluating their behaviour, as well as the behaviour of their colleagues.

Nonalcoholic steatohepatitis: Mayo Clinic experiences with a hitherto unnamed disease.

Nonalcoholic steatohepatitis is a poorly understood and hitherto unnamed liver disease that histologically mimics alcoholic hepatitis and that also may progress to cirrhosis. Described here are findings in 20 patients with nonalcoholic steatohepatitis of unknown cause. The biopsy specimens were characterized by the presence of striking fatty changes with evidence of lobular hepatitis, focal necroses with mixed inflammatory infiltrates, and, in most instances, Mallory bodies; Evidence of fibrosis was found in most specimens, and cirrhosis was diagnosed in biopsy tissue from three patients. The disease was more common in women. Most patients were moderately obese, and many had obesity-associated diseases, such as diabetes mellitus and cholelithiasis. Presence of hepatomegaly and mild abnormalities of liver function were common clinical findings. Currently, we know of no effective therapy.

Mucosal vascular malformations of the gastrointestinal tract: clinical observations and results of endoscopic neodymium: yttrium-aluminum-garnet laser therapy.

Ninety-three consecutive patients with transfusion-dependent gastrointestinal bleeding from vascular malformations (VMs) underwent systematic assessment in our gastrointestinal laser suite with extended upper gastrointestinal endoscopy and colonoscopy. Of these patients, 83 had angiodysplasia and 10 had the Osler-Weber-Rendu (OWR) syndrome. The median age in each of these groups was 70 and 63 years, respectively. Cardiovascular disease, especially valvular disease, was common. A poor correlation existed between the results of endoscopically identified VMs and visceral angiography in patients with angiodysplasia. A combination of upper and lower gastrointestinal VMs was found in 11% of patients with angiodysplasia and 60% of those with the OWR syndrome. All identified VMs were completely obliterated by photocoagulation with use of a neodymium:yttrium-aluminum-garnet (Nd:YAG) laser. Bleeding was successfully controlled in 9 patients with the OWR syndrome and in 72 patients with angiodysplasia (range of follow-up, 1 to 39 months). In 243 laser treatments, 3 perforations and 5 episodes of delayed bleeding occurred. This experience demonstrates that extended upper endoscopy is useful in identifying VMs and that gastrointestinal bleeding from VMs can be safely and successfully controlled with use of endoscopic Nd:YAG laser therapy.

Treatment of benign esophageal stricture by Eder-Puestow or balloon dilators: a comparison between randomized and prospective nonrandomized trials.

To determine whether the natural history of strictures is affected by the type of dilator used to treat newly diagnosed peptic strictures, we designed a prospective randomized trial to compare the results after Eder-Puestow or Medi-Tech balloon dilation. We entered 31 patients into the trial. We also prospectively followed up all 92 nonrandomized patients who underwent their first dilation for a benign stricture during the same period as the prospective randomized trial. The nonrandomized patients also underwent dilation with either the Eder-Puestow or the balloon technique at the discretion of the gastroenterologist performing the endoscopy. We found no statistically significant differences in the immediate or long-term results of the two methods among the randomized, nonrandomized, and overall combined groups. All but 1 of the 123 patients had immediate relief of dysphagia. Within each group of patients, the probability of remaining free of dysphagia 1 year after the initial dilation was approximately 20%, and the probability of not requiring a second dilation was approximately 65% with either technique. Major (esophageal rupture) and minor (bleeding or chest pain) complications occurred in 1% and 5% of the patients and 0.4% and 3% of the total dilation procedures, respectively. The esophageal rupture and four of six minor complications occurred after repeated dilations. Five of the six minor complications occurred with use of the Eder-Puestow dilators. We conclude that Eder-Puestow and balloon dilations of benign esophageal strictures are associated with similar outcomes, but repeated dilations and the Eder-Puestow technique may be associated with an increased risk of complications.

Laser therapy for severe radiation-induced rectal bleeding.

Four patients with chronic hematochezia and transfusion-dependent anemia from postradiation rectal vascular lesions were successfully managed by endoscopic laser coagulation. In all four patients, symptomatic, hematologic, and endoscopic improvement was evident. Laser therapy for severe radiation-induced rectal bleeding seems to be safe and efficacious and should be considered before surgical intervention.

Endoscopic laser palliation of malignant dysphagia: a prospective study.

We prospectively studied the short-term and long-term efficacy and safety of endoscopic laser treatment in 25 patients with dysphagia from advanced esophageal cancer. Malignant stenoses were recanalized in all patients, and the ability to swallow was improved in about 80%. Results were best in patients with adenocarcinomas and in those who reported a good appetite. A single laser treatment provided adequate palliation in more than half the patients until the time of death. In those patients in whom stenosis recurred, re-treatment was necessary a median of 3.2 months after the initial laser treatment. No laser-related mortality or major morbidity occurred. We conclude that endoscopic laser therapy seems to be a feasible method of palliating malignant dysphagia.

Influence of hepatic reserve and cause of esophageal varices on survival and rebleeding before and after the introduction of sclerotherapy: a retrospective analysis.

Esophageal variceal sclerotherapy has been enthusiastically accepted as the procedure of choice for patients with variceal hemorrhage. Because the relationships among liver function, different causes of varices, survival, and rebleeding rates have not been well established in sclerotherapy trials, this enthusiasm may be unjustified. We studied these relationships in 80 patients with bleeding esophageal varices who were admitted to hospitals affiliated with our clinic between 1978 and 1980 and who did not receive sclerotherapy and in 162 patients admitted between 1980 and 1982 who received sclerotherapy with ethanolamine oleate. In both groups of patients, survival and bleeding-free intervals were significantly related (P less than 0.005 and P less than 0.01, respectively) to hepatic reserve (Child's class). In addition, patients with nonalcohol-related liver disease and poor hepatic reserve (Child's class C) had reduced survival and bleeding-free intervals compared with patients in class C with alcohol-related liver disease. Similar probabilities of survival and bleeding-free intervals were noted for Child's class subgroups and etiologic subgroups in the sclerotherapy and nonsclerotherapy groups, although a formal comparison was not made because of the retrospective nature of this study. Indications that sclerotherapy increases survival and reduces rebleeding may be due to different distributions of Child's classes and causes of varices within sclerotherapy and nonsclerotherapy groups in published control trials.

The Mayo Clinic's Clinician-Educator Award: A program to encourage educational innovation and scholarship.

In 1998, the Board of Governors of the Mayo Clinic requested that the Education Committee design and implement a program to grant time and resources to clinical faculty to support the development of educational projects. The essence of the resulting Clinician-Educator Award Program is the concept of using funding to award time and resources for educational projects judged to be meritorious by an impartial, peer-review-based faculty mentoring process. The authors report early experiences with the program, which was enthusiastically accepted by faculty, to provide a model to help other academic health centers, especially those with salary-based faculty, to facilitate educational innovation and scholarship despite the growing constraints on academic clinicians' time and resources.

Endoscopic YAG laser treatment of watermelon stomach (gastric antral vascular ectasia) in patients with systemic sclerosis.

OBJECTIVE: Gastric antral vascular ectasia (GAVE) has been recognized as a rare but important cause of chronic iron deficiency anemia. A number of reported patients were found to have evidence of autoimmune disorders or connective tissue diseases. We carried out this study in order to determine the clinical, endoscopic, and pathologic features in a large series of patients with systemic sclerosis (SSc) who were diagnosed with GAVE. We also determined the response to YAG laser treatment for chronic blood loss in these patients. METHODS: A retrospective chart review of 20 cases diagnosed over an 11-year period, with diagnoses of both SSc and GAVE. RESULTS: Twenty patients with SSc presented with prominent anemia and were diagnosed with GAVE. Treatment with endoscopic laser therapy was successful in preventing surgery for bleeding in GAVE in 85% of cases. CONCLUSIONS: GAVE should be considered in patients with SSc who develop chronic iron deficiency anemia. YAG laser treatment can be useful in the treatment of chronic blood loss anemia in SSc patients with GAVE.