MALDI Peptide Mapping for Fast Analysis in Protein Footprinting.

Although protein footprinting results are commonly obtained by ESI-based LC-MS/MS, a more rapid-turnaround alternative approach is desirable to expand the scope of protein footprinting and facilitate routine analysis such as monitoring protein high order structure in quality control or checking epitope maps. Considering that MALDI is a faster procedure that can be easily adapted for high-throughput analysis, we explore here the feasibility of developing a MALDI-based analysis "portfolio" of bottom-up peptide mass mapping for footprinting. The approach was applied to several model proteins that were submitted to two footprinting strategies, FPOP and GEE labeling, and their performance was evaluated. We found adequate coverage that can be improved with automatic off-line separation and spotting, demonstrating the capability to footprint accurately protein conformational change, showing that MALDI may be useful for selected applications in protein footprinting.

Advances in mass spectrometry-based footprinting of membrane proteins.

Structural biology is entering an exciting time where many new high-resolution structures of large complexes and membrane proteins (MPs) are determined regularly. These advances have been driven by over 15 years of technological improvements, first in macromolecular crystallography, and recently in cryo-electron microscopy. Obtaining information about MP higher order structure and interactions is also a frontier, important but challenging owing to their unique properties and the need to choose suitable detergents/lipids for their study. The development of mass spectrometry (MS), both instruments and methodology in the past 10 years, has also advanced it as a complementary method to study MP structure and interactions. In this review, we discuss advances in MS-based footprinting for MPs and highlight recent methodologies that offer new promise for MP study by chemical footprinting and mass spectrometry.

THE MAKING OF A FOOTPRINT IN PROTEIN FOOTPRINTING: A REVIEW IN HONOR OF MICHAEL L. GROSS.

Within the past decade protein footprinting in conjunction with mass spectrometry has become a powerful and versatile means to unravel the higher order structure of proteins. Footprinting-based approaches has demonstrated the capacity to inform on interaction sites and dynamic regions that participate in conformational changes. These findings when set in a biological perspective inform on protein folding/unfolding, protein-protein interactions, and protein-ligand interactions. In this review, we will look at the contribution of Dr. Michael L. Gross to protein footprinting approaches such as hydrogen deuterium exchange mass spectrometry and hydroxyl radical protein footprinting. This review details the development of novel footprinting methods as well as their applications to study higher order protein structure. © 2020 The Authors. Mass Spectrometry Reviews published by John Wiley & Sons Ltd. Mass Spec Rev.

Systematic workflow for studying domain contributions of bispecific antibodies to selectivity in multimodal chromatography.

In this article, a systematic workflow was formulated and implemented to understand selectivity differences and preferred binding patches for bispecific monoclonal antibodies (mAbs) and their parental mAbs on three multimodal cation exchange resin systems. This workflow incorporates chromatographic screening of the parent mAbs and their fragments at various pH followed by surface property mapping and protein footprinting using covalent labeling followed by liquid chromatography-mass spectrometry analysis. The chromatography screens on multimodal resins with the intact mAbs indicated enhanced selectivity as compared to single-mode interaction systems. While the bispecific antibody (bsAb) eluted between the two parental mAbs on most of the resins, the retention of the bispecific transitioned from co-eluting with one parental mAb to the other parental mAb on Capto MMC. To investigate the contribution of different domains, mAb fragments were evaluated and the results indicated that the interactions were likely dominated by the Fab domain at higher pH. Protein surface property maps were then employed to hypothesize the potential preferred binding patches in the solvent-exposed regions of the parental Fabs. Finally, protein footprinting was carried out with the parental mAbs and the bsAb in the bound and unbound states at pH 7.5 to identify the preferred binding patches. Results with the intact mAb analysis supported the hypothesis that interactions with the resins were primarily driven by the residues in the Fab fragments and not the Fc. Furthermore, peptide mapping data indicated that the light chain may be playing a more important role in the higher binding of Parent A as compared with Parent B in these resin systems. Finally, results with the bsAb indicated that both halves of the molecule contributed to binding with the resins, albeit with subtle differences as compared to the parental mAbs. The workflow presented in this paper lays the foundation to systematically study the chromatographic selectivity of large multidomain molecules which can provide insights into improved biomanufacturability and expedited downstream bioprocess development.

Mapping the interaction between eukaryotic initiation factor 4A (eIF4A) and the inhibitor hippuristanol using carbene footprinting and mass spectrometry.

Protein-ligand interactions are central to protein activity and cell functionality. Improved knowledge of these relationships greatly benefits our understanding of key biological processes and aids in rational drug design towards the treatment of clinically relevant diseases. Carbene footprinting is a recently developed mass spectrometry-based chemical labelling technique that provides valuable information relating to protein-ligand interactions, such as the mapping of binding sites and associated conformational change. Here, we show the application of carbene footprinting to the interaction between eIF4A helicase and a natural product inhibitor, hippuristanol, found in the coral Isis hippuris. Upon addition of hippuristanol we identified reduced carbene labelling (masking) in regions of eIF4A previously implicated in ligand binding. Additionally, we detected hippuristanol-associated increased carbene labelling (unmasking) around the flexible hinge region of eIF4A, indicating ligand-induced conformational change. This work represents further development of the carbene footprinting technique and demonstrates its potential in characterising medicinally relevant protein-ligand interactions.

The utilization of the search engine, Bolt, to decrease search time and increase peptide identifications in hydroxyl radical protein footprinting-based workflows.

Hydroxyl radical protein footprinting (HRPF) utilizes hydroxyl radicals to covalently modify solvent exposed regions of proteins. When coupled with mass spectrometry, HRPF can provide insightful information on protein structural changes including inside cells. However, the complex mixture of proteins and modifications makes identification a complicated task. To search all of the HRPF-induced modification combinations across the full proteome, requires substantial computational power and still can take days to search. To drastically decrease processing time and improve identifications, a novel cloud-based search engine, Bolt, was used to search for HRPF modifications in comparison to a commonly used search engine, Sequest. A 35% increase in the identification of modified peptides was observed in Bolt compared to Sequest with a decrease in computation time.

Free-Radical Membrane Protein Footprinting by Photolysis of Perfluoroisopropyl Iodide Partitioned to Detergent Micelle by Sonication.

A free-radical footprinting approach is described for integral membrane protein (IMP) that extends, significantly, the "fast photochemical oxidation of proteins" (FPOP) platform. This new approach exploits highly hydrophobic perfluoroisopropyl iodide (PFIPI) together with tip sonication to ensure efficient transport into the micelle interior, allowing laser dissociation and footprinting of the transmembrane domains. In contrast to water soluble footprinters, PFIPI footprints both the hydrophobic intramembrane and the hydrophilic extramembrane domains of the IMP vitamin K epoxide reductase (VKOR). The footprinting is fast, giving high coverage for Tyr (100 %) and Trp. The incorporation of the reagent with sonication does not significantly affect VKOR's enzymatic function, and tyrosine iodination does not compromise protease digestion and the subsequent analysis. The locations for the modifications are largely consistent with the corresponding solvent accessibilities, recommending this approach for future membrane protein footprinting.

Chemical Penetration Enhancers Increase Hydrogen Peroxide Uptake in C. elegans for In Vivo Fast Photochemical Oxidation of Proteins.

Fast photochemical oxidation of proteins (FPOP) is a hydroxyl radical protein footprinting method that covalently labels solvent-accessible amino acids by photolysis of hydrogen peroxide. Recently, we expanded the use of FPOP for in vivo (IV-FPOP) covalent labeling in C. elegans. In initial IV-FPOP studies, 545 proteins were oxidatively modified in all body systems within the worm. Here, with the use of chemical penetration enhancers (CPEs), we increased the number of modified proteins as well as the number of modifications per protein to gain more structural information. CPEs aid in the delivery of hydrogen peroxide inside C. elegans by disturbing the highly ordered lipid bilayer of the worm cuticle without affecting worm viability. IV-FPOP experiments performed using the CPE azone showed an increase in oxidatively modified proteins and peptides. This increase correlated with greater hydrogen peroxide uptake by C. elegans quantified using a chemical fluorophore demonstrating the efficacy of using CPEs with IV-FPOP. Mass spectrometry proteomics data are available via ProteomeXchange with identifier PXD019290.

The Application of Fluorine-Containing Reagents in Structural Proteomics.

Structural proteomics refers to large-scale mapping of protein structures in order to understand the relationship between protein sequence, structure, and function. Chemical labeling, in combination with mass-spectrometry (MS) analysis, have emerged as powerful tools to enable a broad range of biological applications in structural proteomics. The key to success is a biocompatible reagent that modifies a protein without affecting its high-order structure. Fluorine, well-known to exert profound effects on the physical and chemical properties of reagents, should have an impact on structural proteomics. In this Minireview, we describe several fluorine-containing reagents that can be applied in structural proteomics. We organize their applications around four MS-based techniques: a) affinity labeling, b) activity-based protein profiling (ABPP), c) protein footprinting, and d) protein cross-linking. Our aim is to provide an overview of the research, development, and application of fluorine-containing reagents in protein structural studies.

PepFoot: A Software Package for Semiautomated Processing of Protein Footprinting Data.

Covalent footprinting of proteins using reactive intermediates such as radicals and carbenes is emerging as a valuable tool for mapping surface accessibility, and hence binding sites of proteins. The approach generates a significant amount of mass spectrometry (MS) data, which can be time-consuming to process manually. PepFoot, a software package that allows semiautomated processing of MS data from footprinting experiments, is described. By using the open source .mz5 file format, it is able to accept data from all the major instrument manufacturers. Following manual user interrogation of one data file within a user-friendly GUI, the software then automates determination of the degree of fractional modification ( fm) with the footprinting agent across a batch of experimental data. This greatly increases efficiency and throughput compared to manual analysis of each file, and provides initial scrutiny and confidence compared to fully automated analysis. Histogram plots of fm for each peptide from the footprinted protein may be displayed within PepFoot and mapped onto an imported protein structure to reveal differential labeling patterns and hence binding sites. The software has been tested on data from carbene and hydroxyl radical labeling experiments to demonstrate its broad utility. PepFoot is released under the LGPL version 3 license, and is available for Windows, MacOS, and Linux systems at github.com/jbellamycarter/pepfoot .

Towards high-throughput fast photochemical oxidation of proteins: Quantifying exposure in high fluence microtiter plate photolysis.

Protein structural analysis by mass spectrometry has gained significant popularity in recent years, including high-resolution protein topographical mapping by fast photochemical oxidation of proteins (FPOP). The ability to provide protein topographical information at moderate spatial resolution makes FPOP an attractive technology for the protein pharmaceutical discovery and development processes. However, current technology limits the throughput and requires significant manual sample manipulation. Similarly, as FPOP is being used on larger samples, sample flow through the capillary becomes challenging. No systematic comparison of the performance of static flash photolysis with traditional flow FPOP has been reported. Here, we evaluate a 96-well microtiter-based laser flash photolysis method for the topographical probing of proteins, which subsequently could be used to analyze higher order structure of the protein in a high-throughput fashion with minimal manual sample manipulation. We used multiple metrics to compare microtiter FPOP performance with that of traditional flow FPOP: adenine-based hydroxyl radical dosimetry, oxidation efficiency of a model peptide, and hydroxyl radical protein footprint of myoglobin. In all cases, microtiter plate FPOP performed comparably with traditional flow FPOP, requiring a small fraction of the time for exposure. This greatly reduced sample exposure time, coupled with automated sample handling in 96-well microtiter plates, makes microtiter-based FPOP an important step in achieving the throughput required to adapt hydroxyl radical protein footprinting for screening purposes.

Probing the solution structure of Factor H using hydroxyl radical protein footprinting and cross-linking.

The control protein Factor H (FH) is a crucial regulator of the innate immune complement system, where it is active on host cell membranes and in the fluid phase. Mutations impairing the binding capacity of FH lead to severe autoimmune diseases. Here, we studied the solution structure of full-length FH, in its free state and bound to the C3b complement protein. To do so, we used two powerful techniques, hydroxyl radical protein footprinting (HRPF) and chemical cross-linking coupled with mass spectrometry (MS), to probe the structural rearrangements and to identify protein interfaces. The footprint of C3b on the FH surface matches existing crystal structures of C3b complexed with the N- and C-terminal fragments of FH. In addition, we revealed the position of the central portion of FH in the protein complex. Moreover, cross-linking studies confirmed the involvement of the C-terminus in the dimerization of FH.

High structural resolution hydroxyl radical protein footprinting reveals an extended Robo1-heparin binding interface.

Interaction of transmembrane receptors of the Robo family and the secreted protein Slit provides important signals in the development of the central nervous system and regulation of axonal midline crossing. Heparan sulfate, a sulfated linear polysaccharide modified in a complex variety of ways, serves as an essential co-receptor in Slit-Robo signaling. Previous studies have shown that closely related heparin octasaccharides bind to Drosophila Robo directly, and surface plasmon resonance analysis revealed that Robo1 binds more tightly to full-length unfractionated heparin. For the first time, we utilized electron transfer dissociation-based high spatial resolution hydroxyl radical protein footprinting to identify two separate binding sites for heparin interaction with Robo1: one binding site at the previously identified site for heparin dp8 and a second binding site at the N terminus of Robo1 that is disordered in the x-ray crystal structure. Mutagenesis of the identified N-terminal binding site exhibited a decrease in binding affinity as measured by surface plasmon resonance and heparin affinity chromatography. Footprinting also indicated that heparin binding induces a minor change in the conformation and/or dynamics of the Ig2 domain, but no major conformational changes were detected. These results indicate a second low affinity binding site in the Robo-Slit complex as well as suggesting the role of the Ig2 domain of Robo1 in heparin-mediated signal transduction. This study also marks the first use of electron transfer dissociation-based high spatial resolution hydroxyl radical protein footprinting, which shows great utility for the characterization of protein-carbohydrate complexes.

An efficient quantitation strategy for hydroxyl radical-mediated protein footprinting using Proteome Discoverer.

Hydroxyl radical protein footprinting coupled with mass spectrometry has become an invaluable technique for protein structural characterization. In this method, hydroxyl radicals react with solvent exposed amino acid side chains producing stable, covalently attached labels. Although this technique yields beneficial information, the extensive list of known oxidation products produced make the identification and quantitation process considerably complex. Currently, the methods available for analysis either involve manual analysis steps, or limit the amount of searchable modifications or the size of sequence database. This creates a bottleneck which can result in a long and arduous analysis process, which is further compounded in a complex sample. Here, we report the use of a new footprinting analysis method for both peptide and residue-level analysis, demonstrated on the GCaMP2 synthetic construct in calcium free and calcium bound states. This method utilizes a customized multi-search node workflow developed for an on-market search platform in conjunction with a quantitation platform developed using a free Excel add-in. Moreover, the method expedites the analysis process, requiring only two post-search hours to complete quantitation, regardless of the size of the experiment or the sample complexity.

Mass spectrometry-based footprinting reveals structural dynamics of loop E of the chlorophyll-binding protein CP43 during photosystem II assembly in the cyanobacterium Synechocystis 6803.

The PSII repair cycle is required for sustainable photosynthesis in oxygenic photosynthetic organisms. In cyanobacteria and higher plants, proteolysis of the precursor D1 protein (pD1) to expose a C-terminal carboxylate group is an essential step leading to coordination of the Mn4CaO5 cluster, the site of water oxidation. Psb27 appears to associate with both pD1- and D1-containing PSII assembly intermediates by closely interacting with CP43. Here, we report that reduced binding affinity between CP43 and Psb27 is triggered by the removal of the C-terminal extension of the pD1 protein. A mass spectrometry-based footprinting strategy was adopted to probe solvent-exposed aspartic and glutamic acid residues on the CP43 protein. By comparing the extent of footprinting between HT3ΔctpAΔ27PSII and HT3ΔctpAPSII, two genetically modified PSII assembly complexes, we found that Psb27 binds to CP43 on the side of Loop E distal to the pseudo-symmetrical D1-D2 axis. By comparing a second pair of PSII assembly complexes, we discovered that Loop E of CP43 undergoes a significant conformational rearrangement due to the removal of the pD1 C-terminal extension, altering the Psb27-CP43 binding interface. The significance of this conformational rearrangement is discussed in the context of recruitment of the PSII lumenal extrinsic proteins and Mn4CaO5 cluster assembly. In addition to CP43's previously known function as one of the core PSII antenna proteins, this work demonstrates that Loop E of CP43 plays an important role in the functional assembly of the Water Oxidizing Center (WOC) during PSII biogenesis.

Quantitative structural proteomics in living cells by covalent protein painting.

The fold and conformation of proteins are key to successful cellular function, but all techniques for protein structure determination are performed in an artificial environment with highly purified proteins. While protein conformations have been solved to atomic resolution and modern protein structure prediction tools rapidly generate near accurate models of proteins, there is an unmet need to uncover the conformations of proteins in living cells. Here, we describe Covalent Protein Painting (CPP), a simple and fast method to infer structural information on protein conformation in cells with a quantitative protein footprinting technology. CPP monitors the conformational landscape of the 3D proteome in cells with high sensitivity and throughput. A key advantage of CPP is its' ability to quantitatively compare the 3D proteomes between different experimental conditions and to discover significant changes in the protein conformations. We detail how to perform a successful CPP experiment, the factors to consider before performing the experiment, and how to interpret the results.

Toward a MALDI in-source decay (ISD) method for top-down analysis of protein footprinting.

Irreversible protein footprinting is a mass spectrometry-based approach in which solvent-accessible sites of a protein are modified to assess high-order protein structure. Structural insights can be gained by determining the position and extents of modification. The usual approach to obtain the "footprint" is to analyze the protein through bottom-up LC-MS/MS. In this approach, the proteins are digested to yield a mixture of peptides that are then separated by LC before locating the modification sites by MS/MS. This process consumes substantial amounts of time and is difficult to accelerate for applications that require quick and high-throughput analysis. Here, we describe employing matrix-assisted laser desorption/ionization (MALDI) in-source decay (ISD) to analyze a footprinted small test protein (ubiquitin) via a top-down approach. Matrix-assisted laser desorption/ionization is easily adapted for high-throughput analysis, and top-down strategies can avoid lengthy proteolysis and LC separation. We optimized the method with model peptides and then demonstrated its feasibility on ubiquitin submitted to two types of footprinting. We found that MALDI ISD can produce a comprehensive set of fragment ions for small proteins, affording footprinting information in a fast manner and giving results that agree with the established methods, and serve as a rough measure of protein solvent accessibility. To assist in the implementation of the MALDI approach, we developed a method of processing top-down ISD data.

Measuring Cysteine Exposure in Unfolded Proteins with Tetraphenylethene Maleimide and its Analogs.

When proteostasis is challenged and becomes unbalanced, unfolded proteins can accumulate in the cells. Protein unfolding causes conformational changes and subsequent differentials in side-chain solvent accessibility and reactivity. In particular, when protein unfolds, non-disulfide-bonded cysteines that are usually buried in the native state can become surface exposed and thus accessible. A series of fluorogenic dyes including tetraphenylethene maleimide (TPE-MI) and its analogs were developed to capture cysteine exposure in unfolded proteins as a measure of unfolded protein load and proteostasis capacity in cells. These dyes are inherently non-fluorescent but show fluorescence turn-on effect when conjugated to unfolded proteins via reacting with exposed cysteines on the protein. Reacting with small biothiols such as glutathione does not induce fluorescence of these dyes. Here we describe the routine workflow to characterize unfolded proteins in vitro or unfolded proteomes in cells by TPE-MIs.

Prolyl Isomerization-Mediated Conformational Changes Define ATR Subcellular Compartment-Specific Functions.

ATR is a PI3K-like kinase protein, regulating checkpoint responses to DNA damage and replication stress. Apart from its checkpoint function in the nucleus, ATR actively engages in an antiapoptotic role at mitochondria following DNA damage. The different functions of ATR in the nucleus and cytoplasm are carried out by two prolyl isomeric forms of ATR: trans- and cis-ATR, respectively. The isomerization occurs at the Pin1 Ser428-Pro429 motif of ATR. Here, we investigated the structural basis of the subcellular location-specific functions of human ATR. Using a mass spectrometry-based footprinting approach, the surface accessibility of ATR lysine residues to sulfo-NHS-LC-biotin modification was monitored and compared between the cis- and the trans-isomers. We have identified two biotin-modified lysine residues, K459 and K469, within the BH3-like domain of cis-ATR that were not accessible in trans-ATR, indicating a conformational change around the BH3 domain between cis- and trans-ATR. The conformational alteration also involved the N-terminal domain and the middle HEAT domain. Moreover, experimental results from an array of complementary assays show that cis-ATR with the accessible BH3 domain was able to bind to tBid while trans-ATR could not. In addition, both cis- and trans-ATR can directly form homodimers via their C-terminal domains without ATRIP, while nuclear (trans-ATR) in the presence of ATRIP forms dimer-dimer complexes involving both N- and C-termini of ATR and ATRIP after UV. Structural characteristics around the Ser428-Pro429 motif and the BH3 domain region are also analyzed by molecular modeling and dynamics simulation. In support, cis conformation was found to be significantly more energetically favorable than trans at the Ser428-Pro429 bond in a 20-aa wild-type ATR peptide. Taken together, our results suggest that the isomerization-induced structural changes of ATR define both its subcellular location and compartment-specific functions and play an essential role in promoting cell survival and DNA damage responses.

Self-Organized Amphiphiles Are Poor Hydroxyl Radical Scavengers in Fast Photochemical Oxidation of Proteins Experiments.

Analysis of membrane protein topography using fast photochemical oxidation of proteins (FPOP) has been reported in recent years but is still underrepresented in literature. Based on the hydroxyl radical reactivity of lipids and other amphiphiles, it is believed that the membrane environment acts as a hydroxyl radical scavenger decreasing effective hydroxyl radical doses and resulting in less observed oxidation of proteins. We found no significant change in bulk solvent radical scavenging activity upon the addition of disrupted cellular membranes up to 25600 cells/µL using an inline radical dosimeter. We confirmed the nonscavenging nature of the membrane in bulk solution with the FPOP results of a soluble model protein in the presence of cell membranes, which showed no significant difference in oxidation with or without membranes. The use of detergents revealed that, while soluble detergent below the critical micelle concentration is a potent hydroxyl radical scavenger, additional detergent has little to no hydroxyl radical scavenging effect once the critical micelle concentration is reached. Examination of both an extracellular peptide of the integral membrane protein bacteriorhodopsin as well as a novel hydroxyl radical dosimeter tethered to a Triton X-series amphiphile indicate that proximity to the membrane surface greatly decreases reaction with hydroxyl radicals, even though the oxidation target is equally solvent accessible. These results suggest that the observed reduced oxidation of solvent-accessible surfaces of integral membrane proteins is due to the high local concentration of radical scavengers in the membrane or membrane mimetics competing for the local concentration of hydroxyl radicals.