Transcriptome-wide probing reveals RNA thermometers that regulate translation of glycerol permease genes in Bacillus subtilis.

RNA structure regulates bacterial gene expression by several distinct mechanisms via environmental and cellular stimuli, one of which is temperature. While some genome-wide studies have focused on heat shock treatments and the subsequent transcriptomic changes, soil bacteria are less likely to experience such rapid and extreme temperature changes. Though RNA thermometers (RNATs) have been found in 5' untranslated leader regions (5' UTRs) of heat shock and virulence-associated genes, this RNA-controlled mechanism could regulate other genes as well. Using Structure-seq2 and the chemical probe dimethyl sulfate (DMS) at four growth temperatures ranging from 23°C to 42°C, we captured a dynamic response of the Bacillus subtilis transcriptome to temperature. Our transcriptome-wide results show RNA structural changes across all four temperatures and reveal nonmonotonic reactivity trends with increasing temperature. Then, focusing on subregions likely to contain regulatory RNAs, we examined 5' UTRs to identify large, local reactivity changes. This approach led to the discovery of RNATs that control the expression of glpF (glycerol permease) and glpT (glycerol-3-phosphate permease); expression of both genes increased with increased temperature. Results with mutant RNATs indicate that both genes are controlled at the translational level. Increased import of glycerols at high temperatures could provide thermoprotection to proteins.

Tradeoffs in the design of RNA thermometers.

The synthesis of RNA thermometers is aimed at achieving temperature responses with desired thresholds and sensitivities. Although previous works have generated thermometers with a variety of thresholds and sensitivities as well as guidelines for design, possible constraints in the achievable thresholds and sensitivities remain unclear. We addressed this issue using a two-state model and its variants, as well as melt profiles generated from thermodynamic computations. In the two-state model, we found that the threshold was inversely proportional to the sensitivity, in the case of a fixed energy difference between the two states. Notably, this constraint could persist in variations of the two-state model with sequentially unfolding states and branched parallel pathways. Furthermore, the melt profiles generated from a library of thermometers exhibited a similar constraint. These results should inform the design of RNA thermometers as well as other responses that are mediated in a similar fashion.

Applications and limitations of regulatory RNA elements in synthetic biology and biotechnology.

Synthetic biology requires the design and implementation of novel enzymes, genetic circuits or even entire cells, which can be controlled by the user. RNA-based regulatory elements have many important functional properties in this regard, such as their modular nature and their ability to respond to specific external stimuli. These properties have led to the widespread exploration of their use as gene regulation devices in synthetic biology. In this review, we focus on two major types of RNA elements: riboswitches and RNA thermometers (RNATs). We describe their general structure and function, before discussing their potential uses in synthetic biology (e.g. in the production of biofuels and biodegradable plastics). We also discuss their limitations, and novel strategies to implement RNA-based regulatory devices in biotechnological applications. We close with a description of some common model organisms used in synthetic biology, with a focus on the current applications and limitations of RNA-based regulation.

RNA thermosensors: how might animals exploit their regulatory potential?

The secondary and tertiary orders of RNA structure are crucial for a suite of RNA-related functions, including regulation of translation, gene expression and RNA turnover. The temperature sensitivity of RNA secondary and tertiary structures is exploited by bacteria to fabricate RNA thermosensing systems that allow a rapid adaptive response to temperature change. RNA thermometers (RNATs) present in non-coding regions of certain mRNAs of pathogenic bacteria enable rapid upregulation of translation of virulence proteins when the temperature of the bacterium rises after entering a mammalian host. Rapid upregulation of translation of bacterial heat-shock proteins likewise is governed in part by RNATs. Turnover of mRNA may be regulated by temperature-sensitive RNA structures. Whereas the roles of temperature-sensitive RNA structures similar to RNATs in Eukarya and Archaea are largely unknown, there would appear to be a potential for all taxa to adaptively regulate their thermal physiology through exploitation of RNA-based thermosensory responses akin to those of bacteria. In animals, these responses might include regulation of translation of stress-induced proteins, alternative splicing of messenger RNA precursors, differential expression of allelic proteins, modulation of activities of small non-coding RNAs, regulation of mRNA turnover and control of RNA editing. New methods for predicting, detecting and experimentally modifying RNA secondary structure offer promising windows into these fascinating aspects of RNA biochemistry. Elucidating whether animals too have exploited the types of RNA thermosensing tools that are used so effectively by bacteria seems likely to provide exciting new insights into the mechanisms of evolutionary adaptation and acclimatization to temperature.

RNA-based mechanisms of virulence control in Enterobacteriaceae.

Enteric pathogens of the family Enterobacteriaceae colonize various niches within animals and humans in which they compete with intestinal commensals and are attacked by the host immune system. To survive these hostile environments they possess complex, multilayer regulatory networks that coordinate the control of virulence factors, host-adapted metabolic functions and stress resistance. An important part of these intricate control networks are RNA-based control systems that enable the pathogen to fine-tune its responses. Recent next-generation sequencing approaches revealed a large repertoire of conserved and species-specific riboregulators, including numerous cis- and trans-acting non-coding RNAs, sensory RNA elements (RNA thermometers, riboswitches), regulatory RNA-binding proteins and RNA degrading enzymes which regulate colonization factors, toxins, host defense processes and virulence-relevant physiological and metabolic processes. All of which are important cues for pathogens to sense and respond to fluctuating conditions during the infection. This review covers infection-relevant riboregulators of E. coli, Salmonella, Shigella and Yersinia, highlights their versatile regulatory mechanisms, complex target regulons and functions, and discusses emerging topics and future challenges to fully understand and exploit RNA-based control to combat bacterial infections.

Regulation of Pseudomonas aeruginosa virulence factors by two novel RNA thermometers.

In a number of bacterial pathogens, the production of virulence factors is induced at 37 °C; this effect is often regulated by mRNA structures formed in the 5' untranslated region (UTR) that block translation initiation of genes at environmental temperatures. At 37 °C, the RNA structures become unstable and ribosomes gain access to their binding sites in the mRNAs. Pseudomonas aeruginosa is an important opportunistic pathogen and the expression of many of its virulence-associated traits is regulated by the quorum-sensing (QS) response, but the effect of temperature on virulence-factor expression is not well-understood. The aim of this work is the characterization of the molecular mechanism involved in thermoregulation of QS-dependent virulence-factor production. We demonstrate that traits that are dependent on the QS transcriptional regulator RhlR have a higher expression at 37 °C, correlating with a higher RhlR concentration as measured by Western blot. We also determined, using gene fusions and point mutations, that RhlR thermoregulation is a posttranscriptional effect dependent on an RNA thermometer of the ROSE (Repression Of heat-Shock gene Expression) family. This RNA element regulates the expression of the rhlAB operon, involved in rhamnolipid production, and of the downstream rhlR gene. We also identified a second functional thermometer in the 5' UTR of the lasI gene. We confirmed that these RNA thermometers are the main mechanism of thermoregulation of QS-dependent gene expression in P. aeruginosa using quantitative real-time PCR. This is the first description, to our knowledge, of a ROSE element regulating the expression of virulence traits and of an RNA thermometer controlling multiple genes in an operon through a polar effect.

Chloroplast gene control: unlocking RNA thermometer mechanisms in photosynthetic systems.

RNA thermometers offer straightforward, protein-independent methods to regulate gene expression at the post-transcriptional level. In this context, Chung and colleagues have discovered a revolutionary RNA thermometer in the chloroplast genome of Chlamydomonas reinhardtii. This will facilitate temperature-driven control of inducible transgene expression for biotechnology applications in plant and algal systems.

RNA thermometers in bacteria: Role in thermoregulation.

An array of external factors, an important one being temperature, decide the fate of survival in a microbe. The ability of microbes to sense external cues and to regulate the expression of genes accordingly is critical for its likely survival. Among a myriad of cellular defence mechanisms, a strategy to recuperate stress involves RNA regulatory elements. RNAs own a repertoire of functions in a cell as messengers, for transfer or as a component of ribosomes. A shift from its indigenous role is as regulators of gene expression, where in the cis-encoded RNA termed as "RNA Thermometers" play a pivotal role in translational level of gene expression. In this paper, we review the occurrence, the different types and molecular mechanism of gene regulation by RNATs, with a special focus limited to the domain Bacteria. We discuss the role of RNATs in mediating expression of temperature-responsive genes like heat shock/cold attributing in heat/cold shock response and a cascade of virulence genes to evade host defence mechanisms.

Design of a Toolbox of RNA Thermometers.

RNA thermometers are RNA regulatory elements that convert temperature into a functional biological response through a temperature-induced conformational change. These regulatory elements have been investigated in numerous natural contexts and have been designed for synthetic biology as well. A basic challenge has been the design of an RNA thermometer whose final activity in response to temperature matches a prespecified response, in terms of its sensitivity, threshold, and leakiness. This chapter provides a methodology for the design of a toolbox of RNA thermometers. We describe considerations for the conceptual design, a computational assessment, and strategies for experimental synthesis and measurement.

RNA Secondary Structurome Revealed Distinct Thermoregulation in Plasmodium falciparum.

The development of Plasmodium parasites, a causative agent of malaria, requests two hosts and the completion of 11 different parasite stages during development. Therefore, an efficient and fast response of parasites to various complex environmental changes, such as ambient temperature, pH, ions, and nutrients, is essential for parasite development and survival. Among many of these environmental changes, temperature is a decisive factor for parasite development and pathogenesis, including the thermoregulation of rRNA expression, gametogenesis, and parasite sequestration in cerebral malaria. However, the exact mechanism of how Plasmodium parasites rapidly respond and adapt to temperature change remains elusive. As a fundamental and pervasive regulator of gene expression, RNA structure can be a specific mechanism for fine tuning various biological processes. For example, dynamic and temperature-dependent changes in RNA secondary structures can control the expression of different gene programs, as shown by RNA thermometers. In this study, we applied the in vitro and in vivo transcriptomic-wide secondary structurome approach icSHAPE to measure parasite RNA structure changes with temperature alteration at single-nucleotide resolution for ring and trophozoite stage parasites. Among 3,000 probed structures at different temperatures, our data showed structural changes in the global transcriptome, such as S-type rRNA, HRPII gene, and the erythrocyte membrane protein family. When the temperature drops from 37°C to 26°C, most of the genes in the trophozoite stage cause significantly more changes to the RNA structure than the genes in the ring stage. A multi-omics analysis of transcriptome data from RNA-seq and RNA structure data from icSHAPE reveals that the specific RNA secondary structure plays a significant role in the regulation of transcript expression for parasites in response to temperature changes. In addition, we identified several RNA thermometers (RNATs) that responded quickly to temperature changes. The possible thermo-responsive RNAs in Plasmodium falciparum were further mapped. To this end, we identified dynamic and temperature-dependent RNA structural changes in the P. falciparum transcriptome and performed a comprehensive characterization of RNA secondary structures over the course of temperature stress in blood stage development. These findings not only contribute to a better understanding of the function of the RNA secondary structure but may also provide novel targets for efficient vaccines or drugs.

Physical stimuli-responsive cell-free protein synthesis.

Cell-free protein synthesis has been developed as a critical platform in synthetic biology. Unlike the cell-based synthesis system, cell-free system activates transcriptional and translational mechanisms in vitro, and can control protein synthesis by artificially adding components or chemicals. However, the control method puts forward higher requirements in terms of accurate and non-toxic control, which cannot be achieved by chemical substances. For cell-free system, physical signal is a kind of ideal spatiotemporal control approach to replace chemical substances, realizing high accuracy with little side effect. Here we review the methods of using physical signals to control gene expression in cell-free systems, including studies based on light, temperature, electric field, and magnetic force. The transfer of these switches into cell-free system further expands the flexibility and controllability of the system, thus further expanding the application capability of cell-free systems. Finally, existing problems such as signal source and signal transmission are discussed, and future applications in pharmaceutical production, delivery and industrial production are further looked into.

RNA Thermometers for the PURExpress System.

Cell-free synthetic biology approaches enable engineering of biomolecular systems exhibiting complex, cell-like behaviors in the absence of living entities. Often essential to these systems are user-controllable mechanisms to regulate gene expression. Here we describe synthetic RNA thermometers that enable temperature-dependent translation in the PURExpress in vitro protein synthesis system. Previously described cellular thermometers lie wholly in the 5' untranslated region and do not retain their intended function in PURExpress. By contrast, we designed hairpins between the Shine-Dalgarno sequence and complementary sequences within the gene of interest. The resulting thermometers enable high-yield, cell-free protein expression in an inducible temperature range compatible with in vitro translation systems (30-37 °C). Moreover, expression efficiency and switching behavior are tunable via small variations to the coding sequence. Our approach and resulting thermometers provide new tools for exploiting temperature as a rapid, external trigger for in vitro gene regulation.

RNA Regulators: Formidable Modulators of Yersinia Virulence.

A large repertoire of RNA-based regulatory mechanisms, including a plethora of cis- and trans-acting noncoding RNAs (ncRNAs), sensory RNA elements, regulatory RNA-binding proteins, and RNA-degrading enzymes have been uncovered lately as key players in the regulation of metabolism, stress responses, and virulence of the genus Yersinia. Many of them are strictly controlled in response to fluctuating environmental conditions sensed during the course of the infection, and certain riboregulators have already been shown to be crucial for virulence. Some of them are highly conserved among the family Enterobacteriaceae, while others are genus-, species-, or strain-specific and could contribute to the difference in Yersinia pathogenicity. Importantly, the analysis of Yersinia riboregulators has not only uncovered crucial elements and regulatory mechanisms governing host-pathogen interactions, it also revealed exciting new venues for the design of novel anti-infectives.

Design of a Toolbox of RNA Thermometers.

Biomolecular temperature sensors can be used for efficient control of large-volume bioreactors, for spatiotemporal imaging and control of gene expression, and to engineer robustness to temperature in biomolecular circuit design. Although RNA-based sensors, called "thermometers", have been investigated in both natural and synthetic contexts, an important challenge is to design diverse responses to temperature differing in sensitivity and threshold. We address this issue by constructing a library of RNA thermometers based on thermodynamic computations and experimentally measuring their activities in cell-free biomolecular "breadboards". Using free energies of the minimum free energy structures as well as melt profile computations, we estimated that a diverse set of temperature responses were possible. We experimentally found a wide range of responses to temperature in the range 29-37 °C with fold-changes varying over 3-fold around the starting thermometer. The sensitivities of these responses ranged over 10-fold around the starting thermometer. We correlated these measurements with computational expectations, finding that although there was no strong correlation for the individual thermometers, overall trends of diversity, fold-changes, and sensitivities were similar. These results present a toolbox of RNA-based circuit elements with diverse temperature responses.

RNA structures are involved in the thermoregulation of bacterial virulence-associated traits.

Pathogenic bacteria are exposed to temperature changes during colonization of the human body and during exposure to environmental conditions. Virulence-associated traits are mainly expressed by pathogenic bacteria at 37°C. We review different cases of post-transcriptional regulation of virulence-associated proteins through RNA structures (called RNA thermometers or RNATs) that modulate the translation of mRNAs. The analysis of RNATs in pathogenic bacteria has started to produce a comprehensive picture of the structures involved, and of the genes regulated by this mechanism. However, we are still not able to predict the functionality of putative RNATs predicted by bioinformatics methods, and there is not a global approach to measure the effect of these RNA structures in gene regulation during bacterial infections.