Surgical Treatment of Metatarsalgia and Severe Instability of Lesser Metatarsophalangeal Joints.

The main object of this prospective cohort study was to compare surgical treatment options for primary metatarsalgia and the severe instability of lesser metatarsophalangeal joints. The outcomes of triple Weil osteotomy combined with direct plantar plate repair and triple Weil osteotomy, performed with proximal interphalangeal joint arthrodesis, are analyzed and compared. One hundred thirteen patients (117 feet) were enrolled in the study. They were split into 2 groups. In the first group, undergoing Weil osteotomy, combined with the plantar plate repair, good results, including complete pain reduction, elimination of hyperkeratosis, and American Orthopedic Foot and Ankle Society Score improvement, were achieved in 84.7% of the cases. The second group, where the combination of Weil osteotomy and proximal interphalangeal joint K-wire arthrodesis was used, demonstrated good results in 52.4% of the cases. Weil osteotomy, combined with the plantar plate repair, achieves better results in comparison to osteotomy, performed with the interphalangeal joint arthrodesis.

Treatment of Lesser Metatarsophalangeal Joint Instability With Plantar Plate Repair: A Systematic Review and Meta-Analysis.

Recognition of metatarsophalangeal joint plantar plate injuries has improved over time as the condition has become more widely understood and identified. With the diagnosis of a plantar plate injury as a subset of metatarsalgia becoming more common place, there are multiple surgical options that have been utilized to address the condition. Direct repair of the plantar plate has emerged as the treatment of choice for foot surgeons with a tendency to favor a direct dorsal approach for the repair. We performed a systematic review and meta-analysis using preferred reporting items for systematic reviews and meta-analysis guidelines, to determine the magnitude of change that can be expected in visual analog scale pain and American Orthopedic Foot and Ankle Society scores postoperatively. A total of 12 studies involving 537 plantar plate tears were included who underwent direct repair of the plantar plate through either a dorsal (10 articles) or plantar approach (2 articles). Summary estimates were calculated which revealed improvement in visual analog scale pain (pooled mean change of -5.01 [95%CI -5.36, -4.66] pre-to postoperative) and improvement in American Orthopedic Foot and Ankle Society scores (pooled postoperative mean improvement 40.44 [95%CI 37.90, 42.97]) of patients within the included studies. Random effects models were used for summary estimates. I2 statistic was used to assess for heterogeneity. We concluded there is a predictable level of improvement in pain and function in patients undergoing a direct dorsal approach plantar plate repair with follow-up out to 2 years.

Outcomes Study of an Innovative Method of Direct Repair of Metatarsophalangeal Joint Instability With an Angiocatheter Needle.

Plantar plate tears are a common cause of forefoot pain and digital deformity. Repair of the plantar plate has been described from both a dorsal and plantar approach, each with its own benefits and drawbacks. Many of the approaches use costly devices. Our innovative repair method uses low-cost materials available in most operating room settings. We undertook a retrospective case series study to evaluate outcomes in patients who had undergone plantar plate repair with our method of repair. A review was performed to identify patients with plantar plate disruptions treated with this approach by a single surgeon. Clinical position and patient satisfaction of the involved joints were evaluated. Six patients (9 joints) underwent plantar plate repair using this innovative method and were evaluated at a median follow-up time of 19 (range 19 to 39) months. The mean visual analog scale pain score at final follow up was 0.8 ± 2.0. The median sagittal plane position of the toe was 2 mm (range 0 to 6) from the plantar skin of the digit to the ground. Five of the 6 patients (83%) stated that they would have the procedure again. We were able to obtain satisfactory outcomes with good alignment by repairing the plantar plate with this innovative method. Our data suggest that the described method of plantar plate repair can be used as an effective way to treat metatarsal phalangeal joint instability.

Technique using interference fixation repair for plantar plate ligament disruption of lesser metatarsophalangeal joints.

Lesser metatarsophalangeal joint instability is a challenging disorder for the foot and ankle surgeon to repair. We believe that disruption of the plantar plate is common, and its repair should be carefully considered. However, we believe that most current techniques inadequately address repair of the complete plantar plate ligament tear, and, thus, instability and pain commonly persist after disruption of the plantar plate. In the present report, we present a technique we have found useful for repair of a complete plantar plate ligament rupture. The method we have described uses interference screw fixation through a dorsal incision to stabilize the lesser metatarsophalangeal joint.

Clinical examination of plantar plate abnormality: a diagnostic perspective.

BACKGROUND: Plantar plate tears can cause pain and deformity in the forefoot but are frequently missed on initial examination. The purpose of this article was to evaluate the diagnostic statistics of common clinical examination parameters using observed intraoperative abnormality as the referenced standard. METHODS: Medical records of 90 patients (109 feet) who underwent a plantar plate repair were reviewed for the presence and onset of pain, plantar edema, instability of the second metatarsophalangeal (MTP) joint (drawer sign), pain with range of motion of the lesser MTP joint, first MTP joint range of motion, crossover toes, previous first ray surgery, and previous corticosteroid injections. Clinical examination findings were compared with intraoperative findings. Diagnostic statistics were calculated. RESULTS: Parameters with a high sensitivity (greater than 80%) were gradual onset of pain (93%), previous first ray surgery (100%), pain at the second metatarsal head (98%), edema at the second metatarsal head (95.8%), and a positive drawer sign (80.6%). High specificity (greater than 80%) was found for a positive drawer test (99.8%) and crossover toes (88.9%). Parameters with odds ratios greater than 1 were gradual onset of pain (1.104), pain at the second metatarsal head (6.125), edema at the second metatarsal head (2.875), and a positive drawer sign (1.389). CONCLUSION: Ninety-five percent of patients with a plantar plate tear presented with a gradual onset of forefoot pain, edema, and a positive drawer sign. A comprehensive clinical examination can heighten the suspicion for plantar plate tears when the data are interpreted correctly. LEVEL OF EVIDENCE: Level III, retrospective, diagnostic.

Direct Plantar Approach to Plantar Plate Repair and Associated Wound Complications.

BACKGROUND: Lesser toe metatarsophalangeal joint (MTPJ) instability, secondary to plantar plate tear, has been the focus of numerous recent publications, the majority reporting on repair through a dorsal approach. A plantar approach has been described with the advantage of direct ligamentous repair or repair to bone, which follows conventional techniques employed throughout the body. Previous clinical studies have shown success in deformity correction and the longevity of both approaches. The proponents of the dorsal approach advocate that indirect repair of the plantar plate avoids perceived risks of complications with a plantar incision without evidence of superior outcomes. The purpose of this study was to investigate the safety and efficacy of the direct plantar approach to plantar plate repairs (PPRs) by reporting the rate of specific complications in a large clinical series. METHODS: This was the institutional review board (IRB) approved retrospective study of 204 PPRs in 185 patients (194 lesser MTP, 10 hallux MTP) with an average age of 56 and a mean body mass index (BMI) of 28. Surgical technique involved repair with absorbable braided suture (88%) versus suture anchor (12%) with or without MTPJ pinning (80%). Mean follow up was 53 weeks (range 5-170). Patients were screened for associated risk factors, including diabetes mellitus (8%), tobacco use (5%), neuropathy (1%), and additional concurrent procedures (96%). Complications were defined as superficial or deep infection, painful scars, and reoperation. Analysis was conducted using the Wilcoxon-Mann-Whitney test or Fisher's exact tests for continuous and categorical variables, respectively. Risk factors were analyzed using univariate logistic analysis to produce odds ratios (OR) with a 95% confidence interval (CI) and an inclusion criterion of a P-value, P > .2 for multivariate analysis as determined by Wald tests (significance at P < .05 for final modeling). RESULTS: Overall, there were 31 total complications (15%) demonstrated by 14 superficial infections (6.8%) and 17 painful scars (8.3%) along with three reoperations (1.4%). All reoperations were performed for deformity or instability, not scar revision. There were no deep infections. No increased odds of complications were found with suture anchor repair, MTPJ pinning, neuropathy, or diabetes. Patients that used tobacco had 7.5 (CI 1.66, 34.06) the odds of developing any wound complication compared with nonsmokers. Tobacco use was also found to significantly increase the odds of superficial infection by 9.8 (CI 2.08, 46.15). There was no increase in painful scars or reoperation in tobacco users. This study did not find an increased complication rate with additional ipsilateral procedures performed at the time of surgery. CONCLUSION: To our knowledge, this is the largest study evaluating the direct plantar approach to PPR as well as the evaluation of associated complications with the plantar incision. With low complication and minimal reoperation rates, the results of this study have demonstrated the clinical viability of plantar-based incisions. Previous studies have demonstrated the success of PPR and correction of deformity with a direct approach. This case series further demonstrates the safety and efficacy of plantar-based incisions, particularly for direct PPRs. LEVEL OF EVIDENCE: IV Retrospective Case Series. CATEGORY: Lesser Toes.

Plantar Plate Repair for Metatarsophalangeal Joint Instability of the Lesser Toes.

The plantar plate is a known stabilizer of the lesser toe metatarsophalangeal (MTP) joint. MTP instability is a known common cause of metatarsalgia, most commonly in the second toe. In the last decade, clinical staging and anatomic grading mechanisms have been published to guide the surgeons on the treatment of MTP instability; this has also led to an understanding of how plantar plate tears relate to MTP joint instability. Direct surgical repair of the plantar plate has been described, short-term outcomes have been published, and the results are not perfect, but promising with respect to patient satisfaction and pain relief.

A Rare Case of Habitual Dislocation of the Fourth Metatarsophalangeal Joint.

Introduction: Dislocations of lesser metatarsophalangeal joints (MTPJs) following trauma, inflammatory arthritis, and synovitis are not uncommon. Closed reduction is sufficient in most instances. However, if it is not addressed scientifically in the first instance; rarely, a habitual dislocation may result. Case Report: We present a case of a 43-year-old male patient with painful habitual dorsal dislocation of the fourth MTPJ following a trivial trauma 2 years back, resulting in an inability to wear closed footwear. The patient was managed with the repair of the plantar plate, excision of the neuroma, and transfer of long flexor to dorsum to act as dynamic check rein. At 3 months, he was able to wear shoes and returned to normal activities. There was no radiographic evidence of arthritis or avascular necrosis at 2 years follow-up, and he was comfortably using closed footwear. Conclusion: Isolated dislocation of the lesser MTPJs is an uncommon entity. Traditional practice is closed reduction. However, if the reduction is inadequate, open reduction should be performed to prevent chances of recurrence.

Lesser Metatarsophalangeal Joint Instability: Advancements in Plantar Plate Reconstruction.

The plantar plate and associated collateral ligaments are the main stabilizers of each of the lesser metatarsophalangeal joints. Although clinical examination and plain radiographs are usually sufficient to establish the diagnosis of a plantar plate tear, MRI or fluoroscopic arthrograms may help in specific cases. Recent results with a dorsal approach to plantar plate repair are promising with respect to pain relief and patient satisfaction.

Plantar Plate Repair for Lesser Metatarsophalangeal Joint Instability.

BACKGROUND: Lesser metatarsophalangeal (MTP) joint instability is a common cause of forefoot pain. Advances in operative technique and instrumentation have made it possible to anatomically treat plantar plate tears through a dorsal approach. Our goal was to evaluate the subjective, functional, and radiographic outcomes of plantar plate repair (PPR) from a dorsal approach. METHODS: A prospective case series was performed evaluating the results of PPR in 97 feet with 138 plantar plate tears. Patients underwent PPR from a dorsal approach with a Weil osteotomy. We followed patients at regular intervals for 12 months and collected data preoperatively and postoperatively with respect to visual analog scale (VAS) scores, MTP range of motion (ROM), paper pull-out test, American Orthopaedic Foot & Ankle Society (AOFAS) scores, satisfaction, and radiographic measures. RESULTS: Eighty percent of patients scored "good" to "excellent" satisfaction scores at 12 months. The mean VAS pain score preoperatively was 5.4/10, and postoperatively was 1.5/10. The mean AOFAS scores increased from 49 to 81 points following surgery. The mean MTP ROM preoperatively was 43 degrees and postoperatively 31 degrees. Forty-two percent of toes passed the paper pull out test prior to surgery and 54% at 12 months. Mean metatarsal shortening was 2.4/3.1/1.2 mm for the second, third, and fourth metatarsals, respectively. The mean MTP joint angles preoperatively were 2/4.9/-1.3 degrees and postoperatively were 7.4/9.6/0.2 degrees, respectively, for the second, third, and fourth MTP joints. CONCLUSION: We found that the plantar plate could be repaired through a dorsal approach with reliable outcomes. PPR was a viable option to anatomically restore the ligamentous support in the unstable lesser MTP joint. LEVEL OF EVIDENCE: Level IV, retrospective case series.

Cadaveric Evaluation of Dorsal Intermetatarsal Approach for Plantar Plate and Lateral Collateral Ligament Repair of the Lesser Metatarsophalangeal Joints.

BACKGROUND: Access to the plantar plate has been described using either a plantar approach or an extensive dorsal approach that required complete joint destabilization and often a metatarsal osteotomy. Clinical scenarios related to plantar plate tear vary and the pathologies in early stages are frequently limited to unilateral soft tissue structures; a less invasive operative approach may be possible. A novel approach requiring a release of only the lateral collateral ligament and the lateral half of the plantar plate is presented in this cadaver model; the extent of joint exposure possible is described. The ability to place a secure suture through the lateral collateral ligament and the plantar plate was analyzed. METHODS: Nine fresh-frozen cadaveric specimens were dissected in a randomized fashion across the second to fourth metatarsophalangeal joints through the intermetatarsal space dorsally. Under distraction, soft tissue was sequentially released, including dorsal capsule, lateral collateral ligament, and the lateral half of the plantar plate. Integrity of the extensor tendons, deep transverse intermetatarsal ligament, proximal attachment of the plantar plate, and osseous structures was carefully preserved. The joint exposure was quantified after each step with sizing rods. Using a suture passer, 2-0 nonabsorbable braided sutures were passed into the lateral collateral ligament and the plantar plate, and the construct strength was measured using a tensiometer. RESULTS: Progressive increase in mean joint exposure was noted after each step of soft tissue release with the final exposure of 6 mm after release of the lateral half of the plantar plate. Joint exposures after a capsulotomy and a lateral collateral release were 3 mm and 4 mm, respectively. Under distraction, the unilateral release of soft tissue created a lateral opening of the joint while the proximal phalangeal base adducted and medially deviated. Successful suture passage was noted in all specimens that could sustain a minimum tension of 25 N without a catastrophic failure. There was no statistically significant correlation with age, sex, foot length, and rays of the specimens when joint exposure was considered. CONCLUSION: The dorsal intermetatarsal approach appeared to be feasible for access to the lateral collateral ligament and the lateral half of the plantar plate. The average joint exposure of 6 mm allowed a quality suture passage by a suture passer in both structures in all specimens without the need of a metatarsal osteotomy. CLINICAL RELEVANCE: This operative approach may be appropriate for early stages plantar plate tear when only lateral soft tissue repair is needed. This technique should not preclude conversion to a more extensile operative approach or an additional metatarsal osteotomy if needed. Applicability of this operative approach in cases with more advanced pathologies or involving only medial soft tissue structures requires further studies.

Technique Tip: The Use of McGlamry Elevator to Assist Suture Passing in the Dorsal Technique of Plantar Plate Repair With Weil Osteotomy for Lesser Metatarsophalangeal Joint Instability.

UNLABELLED: The combination of a dorsal approach to the plantar plate with a Weil's metatarsal osteotomy has been shown to provide an adequate exposure for plantar plate repair. However, soft tissues in a restricted area of the metatarsophalangeal joint could present as a technical difficulty during suture retrieval during repair of the plantar plate. The purpose of this article is to describe the use of the McGlamry elevator for assistance in the retrieval of sutures through the proximal phalanx. LEVEL OF EVIDENCE: Level V: Expert opinion.

Exposure via sequential release of the metatarsophalangeal joint for plantar plate repair through a dorsal approach without an intraarticular osteotomy.

BACKGROUND: Traditionally, plantar plate repairs have been performed from either a direct plantar approach or through a dorsal approach utilizing an intraarticular metatarsal osteotomy. It is unknown if a plantar plate repair can be reliably performed through a dorsal approach without an osteotomy. METHODS: The second through fourth metatarsal phalangeal (MTP) joints of 4 fresh frozen cadavers were sequentially dissected and the exposure of the plantar plate was quantified with a digital micrometer. A suture passer was then utilized to pass a suture through the released plantar plate without a metatarsal osteotomy. RESULTS: The mean plantar plate exposure after capsulotomy was 1.1 mm, after capsulotomy and release of the collateral ligaments exposure was 2.5 mm, after the addition of a release of plantar structures with a McGlamry elevator exposure was 4.1 mm, and after the addition of a plantar plate takedown the exposure was 5.3 mm. Every specimen had a minimum of 4 mm of exposure. Two sutures were successfully passed through every plantar plate with the exposure obtained. CONCLUSION: Significant improvement in exposure of the plantar plate was achieved with each successive structure released . CLINICAL RELEVANCE: Successful plantar plate repair can be reliably performed through a dorsal approach without a metatarsal osteotomy in a cadaveric model.

The plantar plate of the first metatarsophalangeal joint: an anatomical study.

The plantar plate of the first metatarsophalangeal (MP) joint is a critical structure of the forefoot that has been identified as a major stabilizer within the capsuloligamentous complex. Many studies have clarified and documented the anatomy of the lesser toe MP plantar plates, but few have looked closely at the anatomy of the first MP joint. Ten cadaveric specimens were examined to identify and document the objective anatomic relationship of the plantar plate, tibial sesamoid, and surrounding osseus structures. The average distance of the plantar plate distal insertion from the joint line into the proximal phalanx was 0.33 mm. The plantar plate was inserted into the metatarsal head on average 17.29 mm proximal from the joint line. The proximal aspect of the sesamoid was 18.55 mm proximal to the distal attachment of the plantar plate to the phalanx. The distal aspect of the sesamoid averaged 4.69 mm away from the distal attachment into the proximal phalanx. The footprint of the distal plate insertion was on average 6.33 mm in length in the sagittal plane. The authors hope that these objective data measures can aid in the understanding and subsequent surgical repair of this important forefoot structure.

Dorsal Approach for Plantar Plate Repair With Weil Osteotomy: Operative Technique.

UNLABELLED: In recent years, the role of the plantar plate in lesser metatarsophalangeal joint stability has increasingly been recognized. Tearing or attenuation of the plantar plate often will result in crossover or hammertoe deformity with hyperextension of the MTP joint. Some patients are able to have resolution of painful symptoms with conservative treatment but for those that fail these measures, surgical fixation of the plantar plate is indicated. While, there have been some described techniques for direct repair of the plantar plate, we present a surgical technique through a dorsal approach with a Weil osteotomy which accomplishes great clinical correction of the plantar plate tear and associated toe deformity as well as relief of patient's pain. Additionally, we believe this technique is safe, efficient and reproducible. LEVEL OF EVIDENCE: Level V, expert opinion.

Prospective evaluation of protocol for surgical treatment of lesser MTP joint plantar plate tears.

BACKGROUND: Instability of the lesser metatarsophalangeal (MTP) joints is a common cause of deformity and pain. The purpose of this study was to prospectively evaluate the surgical outcomes for the different grades of plantar plate tears and propose a treatment protocol. METHODS: Sixty-eight patients (100 MTP joints) were prospectively enrolled and graded according to the anatomical grade system for plantar plate tears. Based on this classification, the appropriate surgical procedure was chosen as follows: grades 0 and I, thermal shrinkage with radiofrequency; grades II and III, direct reinsertion of the plantar plate; and grade IV, flexor-to-extensor tendon transfer. All surgical procedures were associated with a Weil metatarsal osteotomy. Evaluations were performed before and after surgical treatment with a mean follow-up of 2 years (12-36 months), using clinical and radiological parameters: American Orthopaedic Foot and Ankle Society (AOFAS) Lesser MTP-IF Scale, visual analog scale (VAS), ground touch, joint stability, and toe purchase. RESULTS: The analysis of the clinical parameters demonstrated a significant improvement of all groups (P < .0001) after surgical treatment, but grade IV had less VAS improvement and a fair AOFAS average score (72 points). All groups improved regarding physical examination parameters, but grade I, III, and IV tears had proportionally less stable MTP joints following surgery, as well as a lower proportion of normal postoperative toe purchase and ground touch. All groups showed a significant improvement regarding radiographic parameters. CONCLUSION: All groups of operatively treated patients had significant improvement with regard to subjective and objective parameters. Grades I, III, and IV presented inferior results compared with grades 0 and II. LEVEL OF EVIDENCE: Level IV, case series.