Preclinical biomechanical testing models for the tibiotalar joint and its replacements: A systematic review.

ABSTRACT

In recent years, total ankle replacements have gained increasing popularity as an alternative to fusion. Preclinical testing of TARs requires reliable in vitro models which, in turn, need thorough knowledge of the kinematics of the tibiotalar joint. Surprisingly few studies have been published to simulate the in vivo kinematics of the tibiotalar joint. Among these studies, there is a wide range of methods and magnitudes of applied loads. The purpose of the present review was to summarize the applied loads, positions that were tested during static simulations, and ranges of motion simulated that have been used in human cadaveric models of the tibiotalar joint. Following Preferred Reporting Items for Systematic Reviews and Meta-Analyses (PRISMA) guidelines, PubMed and Google Scholar were searched for studies pertaining to cadaveric tibiotalar joint kinematics. Our search yielded 12 appropriate articles that were included in the systematic review. While it is well known that loads at the tibiotalar joint are frequently as high as 5 times bodyweight [1], these studies reported applied loads varying from 200N-750N, below average bodyweight. Three studies used dynamic loading of custom apparatuses to drive cadaver limbs along predetermined paths to simulate gait. Conversely, the other nine studies applied static loads (∼300N), performed at discreet points during the stance phase, considerably lower than physiological conditions. The present systematic review calls for an urgent need to establish a consensus for preclinical evaluation of TARs for biomechanical function.