Universal beta-diversity-functioning relationships are neither observed nor expected.

Widespread evidence shows that local species richness (α-diversity) loss hampers the biomass production and stability of ecosystems. ß-Diversity, namely the variation of species compositions among different ecological communities, represents another important biodiversity component, but studies on how it drives ecosystem functioning show mixed results. We argue that to better understand the importance of ß-diversity we need to consider it across contexts. We focus on three scenarios that cause gradients in ß-diversity: changes in (i) abiotic heterogeneity, (ii) habitat isolation, and (iii) species pool richness. We show that across these scenarios we should not expect universally positive relationships between ß-diversity, production, and ecosystem stability. Nevertheless, predictable relationships between ß-diversity and ecosystem functioning do exist in specific contexts, and can reconcile seemingly contrasting empirical relationships.