A systematic review of economic assessments for brucellosis control interventions in livestock populations.

Brucellosis in livestock is a disease of paramount importance to animal and human health authorities due to its socio-economic and public health consequences. Benefit cost analyses can help policymakers decide whether allocation of resources is economically beneficial to cover the costs of brucellosis control interventions in populations. One broad question of interest is: what are the consequences of acting, or failing to act, on policy options of selected intervention scenarios (e.g., vaccination, test-and-slaughter, vaccination combined with test-and-slaughter, versus a status-quo scenario). The objective of the systematic review reported here was to conduct a critical appraisal of published research reports of economic assessments of brucellosis control interventions in livestock populations. The systematic review followed standard guidelines using a Population, Intervention, Comparison, Outcome, and Context framework and Preferred Reporting Items for Systematic Review and Meta-Analysis. The review targeted research reports focused on brucellosis control interventions in livestock populations at the national or regional level. Economic outcomes of interest were benefit-cost ratio (BCR), net present value, internal rate of return, or payback period. Eleven studies conducted in Brazil, China, India, Iraq, Mexico, Mongolia, Spain, Turkey, or the USA met the inclusion criteria and were included. The baseline prevalence of brucellosis in selected study populations ranged from 1.4% in cattle in Turkey to 20% in goats in Mexico. In six studies, selected intervention scenarios of vaccination alone produced BCRs that ranged from 3.2 in yaks in China or in cattle, sheep and goats in Mongolia, to 21.3 in cattle and/or buffalo in India. In three studies, interventions of test-and-slaughter produced BCRs that ranged from - 1.2 in goats in Mexico to 0.6 in cattle in Spain. In four studies, vaccination in combination with test-and-slaughter produced BCRs that ranged from 0.2 in yaks in China to 3.7 in cattle and buffalo in India. In seven studies, using sensitivity analysis, different input parameters (prevalence of brucellosis, meat price, cashmere price, vaccination coverage, test-and-slaughter coverage, milk price, vaccination protection, abortion cost, abortion rate, or price of lamb) had an impact on economic outcomes. Vaccination alone was cost-effective, but test-and-slaughter was not, for brucellosis control in selected livestock populations in focus countries. Vaccination in combination with test-and-slaughter produced profitable or nonprofitable economic outcomes. While most studies reported the cost and benefits of implementing brucellosis control interventions, only one study explained socio-economic consequences of economic outcomes, when acting, or failing to act, on selected interventions in livestock populations.

Government veterinarians' perceptions of routine biosecurity focused on dairy cattle farms in north-western and north-eastern Spain.

The implementation of biosecurity measures in livestock production systems can be affected by the psychosocial factors of its stakeholders, which can be observed through their knowledge, attitudes and perceptions/practices. In Spain, there are no regulations per se to promote biosecurity. Of all stakeholders, farmers and veterinarians have been addressed in previous biosecurity studies, but not veterinarians belonging specifically to the government services. This study explores this particular group's perceptions of routine biosecurity in livestock production systems in north-western and north-eastern Spain, an understanding of which could help to improve the implementation of biosecurity measures on farms. Eleven interviews were conducted with veterinarians from different levels of the government services in Galicia and Catalonia, and were analyzed through content analysis. Dairy cattle farms were considered as the reference livestock production systems. The respondents stress the limited availability of staff and time resources for biosecurity. The advisory role of government veterinarians is not well recognized among farmers, who feel that their services prioritize their sanctioning role. In fact, government veterinarians consider that farmers only implement biosecurity measures to avoid being sanctioned, and not because they are aware of the importance of biosecurity. Meanwhile, the participants comment that biosecurity regulations should be flexible and need to consider the contexts of the farms where biosecurity measures are implemented. Finally, government veterinarians are willing to attend biosecurity meetings together with all farm stakeholders, at which the government services could be informed about biosecurity issues on farms. The person who could take on the biosecurity advisory role should be defined, along with further discussion of such matters as the responsibilities of each stakeholder. Government veterinary services need to be considered in studies of biosecurity operations in order to improve their implementation. It is therefore concluded that government veterinarians are seeking to balance their own institutional perspective with that of farmers and veterinarians in the routine implementation of biosecurity measures.

Assessment of Natural Transmission of Bovine Leukemia Virus in Dairies from Southern Chile.

Bovine leukemia virus (BLV) is a retrovirus that affects cattle worldwide. A longitudinal study was conducted with the aim to (a) estimate the incidence rate of the BLV infection of dairy farms in the regions of Los Ríos and Los Lagos (Chile), and (b) describe the frequency and epidemiological association of risk management practices related to new cases in cattle on dairy farms in Southern Chile. Infection status was based on commercial blocking ELISA results, on serum and milk. Individual information on animals and management practices was extracted from farm records, and then the most likely date of infection for new cases was estimated. The number of new infections was used to calculate the within-herd incidence rate. Adult animals had an incidence rate of 1.16 (95% CI 0.96; 1.20) cases per 100 cow-months at risk, while for young animals it was 0.64 (95% CI 0.44; 1.00) cases per 100 animal-months at risk. Rectal palpation, artificial insemination, and injections were the most common practices related to infection. Further studies are needed to determine if these are the only practices that facilitate spreading or if there are other practices that can be handled better in order to reduce the spread of BLV.

Factors Associated with the Introduction of Mycobacterium avium spp. Paratuberculosis (MAP) into Dairy Herds in Galicia (North-West Spain): The Perception of Experts.

This study aimed at quantifying expert opinions on the risk factors involved in Mycobacterium avium subsp. paratuberculosis (MAP) infection in dairy cattle herds. For this purpose, potential risk factors associated with the introduction of MAP into dairies were chosen based on a literature review and discussions with researchers and veterinarians. For each factor, a decision tree was developed, and key questions were included in each. Answers to these key questions led to different events within each decision tree. An expert opinion workshop was organized (following the recommendations of the OIE), and ordinal values ranging from 0 to 9 (i.e., a null to very high likelihood of infection) were assigned to each event. The potential risk factors were also incorporated into a structured questionnaire that was responded to by 93 farms where the sanitary status against MAP was known. Thereby, based on the values given by the experts and the information collected in the questionnaires, each farm was assigned a score based on their MAP entry risk. From these scores (contrast variable) and using a ROC curve, the cut-off that best discriminated MAP-positive and -negative farms was estimated. The most important risk factors for the introduction of MAP, according to expert opinions, involved purchase and grazing practices related to animals under six months of age. The scores obtained for each farm, also based on the expert opinions, allowed MAP positive/MAP negative farms to be discriminated with 68.8% sensitivity and 68.7% specificity. These data should be useful for focusing future training initiatives and improving risk-reduction strategies in the dairy industry.

Influence on the implementation of biosecurity measures in dairy cattle farms: Communication between veterinarians and dairy farmers.

This study was carried out in two regions in Spain (Catalonia and Galicia) through eight focus groups; four for dairy farmers and four for veterinarians. The results showed that dairy farmers and veterinarians attributed responsibility to one another for not following biosecurity practices. The study brings to light contradictions among veterinarians and certain individual veterinary practices that participated in the study, which lead to doubt and confusion on the part of dairy farmers. Distinct perceptions were also identified of the role that government authorities should play in relation both to training and sanctions as a means of improving biosecurity on dairy farms. Additionally, the participants expressed varying opinions as to whether biosecurity measures ought to be made mandatory or remain voluntary. Results from this study highlight the need to promote initiatives through which distinct stakeholders such as veterinarians, government authorities, and dairy farmers can develop consensus-based messages on the implementation of biosecurity practices.

Dairy farmers' decision-making to implement biosecurity measures: A study of psychosocial factors.

Biosecurity measures are a set of management procedures that prevent the risk of introducing and spreading infectious diseases to a farm, although these measures are rarely implemented in dairy farms. There are some studies that have identified that the decision to implement biosecurity measures can be influenced by several psychosocial factors (attitudes and behaviours). Thus, the objective of this study was to examine the psychosocial factors (and their interactions) influencing the implementation of biosecurity measures in dairy farms in Spain, through the views of dairy farmers and veterinarians from Catalonia (northeast Spain) and Galicia (northwest Spain). Face-to-face in-depth interviews were performed with 16 dairy farmers (nine from Catalonia and seven from Galicia) and 16 veterinarians (eight from Catalonia and eight from Galicia). Grounded theory analysis was performed on the transcripts, following the subtopics of: information sources, individual factors of the farmer, social dynamics, official veterinary services and other factors. The study identified the importance of veterinarians as a source of information, including their communication skills, the individual experiences of farmers, traditions of the farms and availability of time and space in the dairy farmer's decisions making. Further, it suggests the need to deepen the knowledge of the farm workers and the obligatory biosecurity measures. This research represents a starting point to develop future strategies to improve the implementation of biosecurity measures in dairy farms.

A survey of biosecurity measures and serological status for bovine viral diarrhoea virus and bovine herpesvirus 1 on dairy cattle farms in north-west and north-east Spain.

BACKGROUND: Biosecurity is a key measure to reduce and prevent the introduction of diseases to farms and minimise spread of diseases within a herd. The aim of the study was to characterise the current application of biosecurity measures on dairy cattle farms in Spain along with their bovine viral diarrhoea and infectious bovine rhinotracheitis status. METHODS: Data on biosecurity measures for 124 dairy herds were collected using a questionnaire. The sanitary status of these farms for bovine viral diarrhoea and infectious bovine rhinotracheitis was also assessed using antibody ELISA. Data were analysed using multiple correspondence analysis and a two-step cluster analysis. RESULTS: Three main clusters of farms were identified: clusters 1 and 2 included herds of small and intermediate sizes. These, particularly cluster 1, showed the most deficiencies in the control of vehicles and visitors. However, laboratory tests were always performed on purchased animals. Cluster 3 had the largest herd sizes, with somewhat better biosecurity control of vehicles and visitors. However, farms in this cluster also purchased the most animals, sometimes without testing, and hired external workers more often. CONCLUSION: The study indicated that, in the study population, there are serious shortcomings in the application of biosecurity measures on dairy farms, exposing them to disease transmission. This survey also highlights regional and herd size-related differences in the implementation of biosecurity. Collecting data is an important first step to identification of specific weaknesses in different farm typologies, and an adequate follow-up is needed to ensure that measures are implemented correctly on farms.

Evidencia molecular de Leptospira interrogans sensu stricto en Cavia porcellus (cuyes) destinados para el consumo humano en el municipio de Pasto, Nariño / Molecular evidence of Leptospira interrogans sensu stricto in Cavia porcellus (guinea pig) grown for human consumption in Pasto, Nariño

Introducción: La leptospirosis es una zoonosis emergente, endémica en Colombia, que afecta tanto animales domésticos como silvestres. Es considerada de riesgo laboral, ya que la transmisión al ser humano está asociada a la exposición con animales o ambientes infectados. En el departamento de Nariño, la producción de cuyes para el consumo humano se realiza en sistemas de crianza tradicionales que podrían favorecer la infección por Leptospira interrogans en esta especie. Objetivo: Detectar molecularmente la infección natural por especies patógenas del género Leptospira en cuyes que son destinados para el consumo humano en el municipio de Pasto. Materiales y métodos: Se tomaron 270 muestras de tejido renal en cuyes sacrificados en dos mataderos. Las muestras fueron analizadas mediante Reacción en Cadena de la Polimerasa (PCR) convencional y coloración diferencial de Warthin Starry (W-S). Resultados: En la evaluación de las 270 muestras, 4 (1,5%) fueron positivas para PCR y una de las muestras demostró la presencia de Leptospira bajo tinción W-S. Conclusiones: Mediante el uso de técnicas moleculares se evidenció L. interrogans en el tejido renal de Cavia porcellus. La circulación del patógeno en esta población representa un riesgo de infección para humanos y animales domésticos en contacto con estos sistemas productivos.

Introduction: Leptospirosis is an emerging zoonosis that is endemic in Colombia and affects both domestic and wild animals. It is considered an occupational risk since human transmission is associated with exposure to infected animals or environments. In the department of Nariño, the production of guinea pigs for human consumption applies traditional rearing systems that could cause animals to get infected with Leptosipira interrogans. Objective: To molecularly identify natural infection by pathogenic species of the genus Leptospira in guinea pigs used for human consumption in the municipality of Pasto (Colombia). Materials and methods: 270 kidney tissue samples were taken from guinea pigs slaughtered in two facilities. Samples were analyzed through conventional polymerase chain reaction (PCR) and Warthin Starry (W-S) differential staining. Results: While 4 (1.5%) out of the 270 samples were categorized as positive using PCR, only 1 sample showed the presence of Leptospira through W-S staining. Conclusions: Molecular techniques were useful to identify L. interrogans in kidney tissue of Cavia porcellus. Dissemination of this pathogen within this population represents an infection risk for humans and domestic animals that are in close proximity to these productive systems.

Molecular analysis of a fragment of bovine leukemia virus env gene by Nested-PCR in dairy cows from Pasto, Nariño / Análisis molecular de un fragmento del gen env del virus de leucosis bovina, por PCR anidada en vacas lecheras de Pasto, Nariño / Análise molecular pela reação em cadeia da polimerase de um fragmento do gene env do vírus de leucose bovina aninhada em vacas leiteiras de Pasto, Nariño

Abstract: Introduction: Routine diagnosis for bovine leukemia is performed using indirect serologic tests, although it is recommended to use polymerase chain reaction (PCR), which allows a reliable diagnosis in early stages and in young animals. Moreover, by amplifying the DNA, it is possible to sequence fragments of the virus, which allows to identify genotypes and to construct phylogenetic trees. Objective: To analyze a fragment of the env gene of bovine leukemia virus (BLV) isolated from indirect ELISA-positive animals in dairy farms in the municipality of Pasto (Nariño). Materials and methods: Once the presence of BLV was established in 48 animals over two years old in seven dairy farms in the municipality of Pasto by indirect ELISA test, a nested PCR test was performed to confirm diagnosis and to sequence a fragment of the env gene in positive animals and their daughters. The sequences obtained were compared with the seven genotypes described worldwide by MEGA 6 program. Results: The sequences of the compared fragments do not differ from those described; but they allow their grouping into different clusters according to their similarity. The genotypes found in these farms correspond to genotype 1 and 2 described in the literature. Conclusions: Only one genotype was found on farms with proper recovery and adequate biosecurity measures, and on farms with less control in management and recovery practices, both genotypes described for the region were evident.

Resumen: Introducción: El diagnóstico de rutina para la leucosis bovina se realiza con pruebas serológicas indirectas, aunque se recomienda usar la reacción en cadena de la polimerasa (PCR), que permite un diagnóstico confiable en fases iniciales y en animales jóvenes. Además, mediante la amplificación del ADN se pueden secuenciar fragmentos del virus, que permite identificar los genotipos presentes y construir árboles filogenéticos. Objetivo: Analizar un fragmento del gen env del virus de leucosis bovina (VLB) aislado de animales positivos a ELISA indirecta en fincas lecheras del municipio de Pasto, Nariño. Materiales y métodos: Una vez establecida la presencia del VLB en 48 animales mayores de dos años en siete fincas lecheras del municipio de Pasto mediante la prueba de ELISA indirecta, se realizó una prueba de PCR anidada para confirmar el diagnóstico y secuenciar un fragmento del gen env en los animales positivos y sus hijas. Las secuencias obtenidas se compararon con los siete genotipos descritos en el mundo mediante el programa MEGA 6. Resultados: Las secuencias de los fragmentos comparados no difieren de las descritas; pero permiten su agrupación en diferentes clústeres de acuerdo con su similitud. Los genotipos encontrados en estas fincas corresponden al genotipo 1 y 2 descritos en la literatura. Conclusiones: En las fincas con reposición propia y adecuadas medidas de bioseguridad solo se encontró un genotipo y en las fincas con menor control en las prácticas de manejo y de reposición se encontraron los dos genotipos descritos para la región.

Resumo: Introdução: O diagnóstico de rotina para a leucose bovina se realiza com provas serológicas indiretas, mesmo que se recomenda usar a reação em cadeia da polimerase (PCR), que permite um diagnóstico confiável em fases iniciais e em animais jovens. Além do mais, mediante a amplificação do ADN se podem sequenciar fragmentos do vírus, que permite identificar os genótipos presentes e construir árvores filogenéticas. Objetivo: Analisar um fragmento do gene env do vírus de leucose bovina (VLB) isolado de animais positivos a ELISA indireta em fazendas leiteiras do município de Pasto, Nariño. Materiais e métodos: Uma vez estabelecida a presença do VLB em 48 animais maiores de dois anos em sete fazendas leiteiras do município de Pasto mediante a prova de ELISA indireta, se realizou uma prova de PCR aninhada para confirmar o diagnóstico e sequenciar um fragmento do gene env nos animais positivos e suas filhas. As sequências obtidas foram compararam com os sete genótipos descritos no mundo mediante o programa MEGA 6. Resultados: As sequências dos fragmentos comparados não diferem das descritas; mas permitem a sua agrupação em diferentes clusters de acordo com sua similitude. Os genótipos encontrados nestas fazendas correspondem ao genótipo 1 e 2 descritos na literatura. Conclusões: Nas fazendas com reposição própria e adequadas medidas de biossegurança somente se encontrou um genótipo e nas fazendas com menos controle nas práticas de manejo e de reposição se encontraram os dois genótipos descritos para a região.

Estudio epidemiológico de paratuberculosis bovina en hatos lecheros del sur de Nariño, Colombia / Epidemiological Study of Bovine Paratuberculosis in Dairy Herds in Southern Narino, Colombia / Estudo epidemiológico de paratuberculose bovina em gado leiteiro do sul de Nariño, na Colômbia

Introducción: la paratuberculosis (PTBC), también llamada enfermedad de Johne, es un trastorno gastrointestinal crónico de rumiantes domésticos y silvestres causado por Micobacterium avium subespecie paratuberculosis (MAP). Está distribuida mundialmente y genera un alto impacto en la ganadería, debido a que disminuye la producción, se pierde potencial genético por reemplazos tempranos de animales infectados y se incrementa la mortalidad. Objetivos: evaluar la presencia de anticuerpos anti-MAP en fincas lecheras del sur de Nariño y describir su distribución de acuerdo con características poblacionales. Métodos: se realizó un estudio transversal descriptivo en 958 vacas mayores de 2 años en 16 fincas lecheras. Para determinar la presencia de anticuerpos, se usó la prueba diagnóstica de Elisa indirecto (kit comercial Svanova®). La seropositividad fue asociada con las variables de raza, edad, ubicación, condición corporal, número de lactancias y estadio clínico mediante la prueba estadística de chi cuadrado. Resultados: se encontraron 15 fincas (94 %) con al menos un animal positivo y 77 vacas (8 %) con anticuerpos anti-MAP. Se estableció una asociación significativa (p < 0,05) con la condición corporal del animal. Conclusiones: en los principales municipios lecheros se encontraron vacas con anticuerpos anti-MAP y no se encontró relación entre edad, raza, ubicación y estatus clínico con la seroprevalencia-MAP, pero sí con la condición corporal.

Introduction: Paratuberculosis (PTB), or Johne's disease, is a chronic gastrointestinal disorder in domestic and wild ruminants caused by Mycobacterium avium subspecies paratuberculosis (MAP). It is distributed worldwide and generates a high impact on livestock, due to a decrease in production, loss of genetic potential by early replacement of infected animals, and increase in mortality. Objectives: To evaluate the presence of anti-MAP antibodies in dairy farms in southern Narino and to describe their distribution according to population characteristics. Methods: A descriptive cross-sectional study was performed on 958 cows over 2 years of age in 16 dairy farms. To determine the presence of antibodies, the indirect Elisa diagnostic test was used (Svanova® commercial kit). Seropositivity was associated with variables of race, age, location, body condition, lactation number, and clinical state by using the chi-square test statistic. Results: There were found 15 farms (94%) with at least one positive animal and 77 cows (8%) with anti-MAP antibodies. A significant association (p < 0.05) with the animal's body condition was established. Conclusions: Cows with anti-MAP antibodies were found in major dairy municipalities; it was found that MAP-seroprevalence is not connected to age, race, location and clinical status, but it is linked to body condition.

Introdução: a paratuberculose (PTBC), também conhecida como doença de Johne, é um transtorno gastrointestinal crônico de ruminantes domésticos e silvestres causado por Mi-cobacterium avium subespécieparatuberculose (MAP). Está distribuída mundialmente e gera um alto impacto na pecuária, devido a que diminui a produção, se perde potencial genético por substituições precoces de animais infectados e aumenta a mortalidade. Objetivos: avaliar a presença de anticorpos anti-MAP em fazendas de gado do sul de Nariño e descrever sua distribuição de acordo com características populacionais. Métodos: realizou-se um estudo transversal descritivo em 958 vacas maiores de 2 anos em 16 fazendas produtoras de gado. Para determinar a presença de anticorpos, se usou a prova diagnóstica de Elisa indireto (kit comercial Svanova®). A soro positividade foi associada com as variáveis de raça, idade, localização, condição corporal, número de lactancia e estádio clínico através da prova estatística de chi quadrado. Resultados: se encontraram 15 fazendas (94 %) com pelo menos um animal positivo e 77 vacas (8 %) com anticorpos anti-MAP. Estabeleceu-se uma associação significativa (p < 0,05) com a condição corporal do animal. Conclusões: nos principais municípios produtores de leite se encontraram vacas com anticorpos anti-MAP e não se encontrou relação entre idade, raça, localização e status clínico com a soro prevalência-MAP, mas sim com a condição corporal.

Factores de riesgo asociados a la seroprevalencia de brucelosis y leptospirosis en los operarios de la planta de beneficio de Pasto, Nariño / Risk factors associated to the seroprevalence of brucellosis and leptospirosis in the Operators of the plant benefit Pasto, Nariño

El objetivo del trabajo fue identificar los factores de riesgo asociados a la seroprevalencia de Brucelosis y Leptospirosis en los operarios de la planta de beneficio de la ciudad de Pasto. La seropositividad para Brucella abortus se determinó mediante la prueba diagnóstica de Rosa de Bengala (RB) y para Leptospira spp, mediante la prueba diagnóstica de Microaglutinación (MAT). De los 37 sueros procesados, 3 (8%) fueron positivos a RB y no se encontraron respuestas positivas a los serovares de Leptospira spp evaluados con MAT. Para identificar los factores de riesgo se realizó una encuesta epidemiológica a cada operario, incluyendo variables relacionadas con la transmisión de las enfermedades estudiadas, las cuales fueron analizadas mediante regresión logística binaria para establecer el Odds Ratio (OR). Los factores de riesgo asociados a Brucelosis fueron: no usar guantes (OR = 3.11; IC95% 1.09-11.52) y no usar delantal (OR = 2.94; IC95% 1.12-43.04) como elementos de protección personal durante el proceso de beneficio de bovinos y porcinos. Por lo tanto, se recomienda aumentar las medidas de control sobre el uso de los elementos de protección personal en el trabajo dentro del programa de salud ocupacional para minimizar el riesgo de transmisión de enfermedades zoonóticas.

The aim of this study was to identify the risk factors associated with seroprevalence of Brucellosis and Leptospirosis in operators of the slaughterhouse in Pasto, Nariño. Seropositivity for Brucella abortus was determined by the diagnostic test Rose Bengal (RB) and Leptospira sp, through diagnostic Microagglutination Test (MAT).From the 37 serum processed, 3 (8%) were positive for RB and there were no positive responses to Leptospira sp serovars evaluated with MAT test. The risk factors were identified conducting an epidemiological survey to each operator, including variables related to the transmission of the diseases in study, which were analyzed by binary logistic regression to establish the odds ratio (OR). The biological risk factors associated with brucellosis were not wearing gloves (OR = 3.11, 95% CI 1.09-11.52) and not using apron (OR = 2.94, 95% CI 1.12-43.04) like personal protective equipment during cattle and pigs slaughter. Therefore, it is recommended to increase control measures on the use of personal protective equipment at work in the occupational health program to minimize the risk of transmission of zoonotic diseases.