Structural and functional variations of phytoplankton communities in the face of multiple disturbances.

The global decline of freshwater biodiversity caused by climate change and human activities are supposed to disrupt ecosystem services related to water quality and alter the structure and function of aquatic communities across space and time, yet the effects of the combination of these factors on plankton community ecosystem has received relatively little attention. This study aimed to explore the impacts of disturbances (e.g. human activity, temperature, precipitation, and water level) on phytoplankton community structure (i.e. community evenness and community composition) and function (i.e. resource use efficiency) in four subtropical reservoirs over 7 years from 2010 to 2016. Our results showed that community turnover (measured as community dissimilarity) was positively related to disturbance frequency, but no significant correlation was found between phytoplankton biodiversity (i.e. evenness) and disturbance frequency. Phytoplankton resource use efficiency (RUE = phytoplankton biomass/ total phosphorus) was increased with a higher frequency of disturbance with an exception of cyanobacteria. The RUE of Cyanobacteria and diatoms showed significantly negative correlations with their community evenness, while the RUE of Chlorophyta exhibited a positive correlation with their community turnover. We suggest that multiple environmental disturbances may play crucial roles in shaping the structure and functioning of plankton communities in subtropical reservoirs, and mechanism of this process can provide key information for freshwater uses, management and conservation.

Potential health risk assessment through ingestion and dermal contact arsenic-contaminated groundwater in Jianghan Plain, China.

Groundwater contamination with high arsenic (As) levels has caused serious health problem in Jianghan Plain. This study presents a framework to evaluate the results and their probable influencing factors of non-carcinogenic risk and carcinogenic risk in Shahu Village. An appropriate health risk assessment for residents exposing to As through ingestion and dermal contact pathways is also discussed in the paper. Hazard quotient (HQ) and target cancer risk (TR) are adopted to compute the non-carcinogenic and carcinogenic effects for residents, respectively. Monte Carlo simulation technique is used to quantify the uncertainty of the risk assessment. The assessment results show that the HQs and TRs of 10-m-deep and 25-m-deep wells exhibit seasonal variations with higher values in rainy season and lower values in dry season. The HQ values exceeding 1 at the depths of 10 (from 0.09 to 23.21 m) and 25 m (from 0.29 to 130.55 m) account for 61 and 94%, respectively, which associate with the As contents distribution in the aquifer sediments. The estimated TR values at the depths of 10 (from 3.86E-05 to 1.04E-02) and 25 m (from 1.32E-04 to 5.87E-02) exceeding the highest acceptable standard (10-4) account for 95 and 100%, respectively. Comparison of the two exposure pathways, the ingestion exposure contributes much more than the dermal contact exposure for both non-carcinogenic risk and carcinogenic risk. The results of sensitivity analysis indicate that a more accurate measurement and better definition of probability distributions for As concentration in the groundwater can increase the accuracy of health risk assessment in Jianghan Plain. The findings demonstrate the importance of the drinking water safety, and the government should take measures to ensure the drinking water safety.

Using generalized additive models to investigate factors influencing cyanobacterial abundance through phycocyanin fluorescence in East Lake, China.

East Lake is a shallow lake (in Wuhan, China) where cyanobacteria blooms occurred frequently from 1970 to 1985. During the study period, all Carlson trophic state index values were > 50, indicating that East Lake is in a eutrophic state. In this study, phycocyanin concentrations were measured through phycocyanin fluorometry for rapid assessment of cyanobacterial abundance. The smoothing splines of the optimal generalized additive model (GAM) indicated that Secchi depth (SD), total phosphorus (TP) and dissolved oxygen (DO) concentrations, electrical conductivity (EC), chemical oxygen demand (COD), and ratios of total nitrogen (TN) to TP (TN:TP) were the main environmental factors in a moderate nonlinear relationship with cyanobacterial phycocyanin concentrations in East Lake. The shape of the GAM smoother can be used to quantify the relationship between a response variable and an explanatory variable in the scatterplot. Phycocyanin concentrations were sharply and negatively related to both SD and EC when the SD was 20-80 cm and EC was > 270 mg/L. Phycocyanin concentrations increased with concentrations of TP, DO, and COD. Phycocyanin concentrations increased sharply with TP concentrations when TP concentrations were > 0.10 mg/L and approached to a constant when DO concentrations were > 8.20 mg/L. Approximately, 85% of the phycocyanin concentrations were negatively correlated with TN:TP of < 26. In summary, organic compounds and TP were inferred to the key factors limiting the potential growth of cyanobacteria in East Lake. These change points/thresholds of smoothing splines of aforementioned variables may serve as a framework for managing the cyanobacterial growth.

Characterization of spent nickel-metal hydride batteries and a preliminary economic evaluation of the recovery processes.

UNLABELLED: Valuable metal materials can be recovered from spent nickel-metal hydride (NiMH) batteries. However, little attention has been paid to the metal compositions of individual components of NiMH batteries, although this is important for the selection of the appropriate recycling process. In this study, NiMH batteries were manually disassembled to identify the components and to characterize the metals in each of these. A preliminary economic analysis was also conducted to evaluate the recovery of valuable metals from spent NiMH batteries using thermal melting versus simple mechanical separation. The results of this study show that metallic components account for more than 60% of battery weight. The contents of Ni, Fe, Co, and rare earth elements (REEs) (i.e., valuable metals of interest for recovery) in a single battery were 17.9%, 15.4%, 4.41%, and 17.3%, respectively. Most of the Fe was in the battery components of the steel cathode collector, cathode cap, and anode metal grid, while Ni (>90%) and Co (>90%) were mainly in the electrode active materials (anode and cathode metal powders). About 1.88 g of REEs (Ce, La, and Y) could be obtained from one spent NiMH battery. The estimated profits from recovering valuable metals from spent NiMH batteries by using thermal melting and mechanical processes are 2,329 and 2,531 USD/ton, respectively, when including a subsidy of 1,710 USD/ton. The findings of this study are very useful for further research related to technical and economic evaluations of the recovery of valuable metals from spent NiMH batteries. IMPLICATIONS: The spent nickel-metal hydride (NiMH) batteries were manually disassembled and their components were identified. The metals account for more than 60% of battery weight, when Ni, Fe, Co, and rare earth elements (REEs) were 17.9%, 15.4%, 4.41%, and 17.3%, respectively, in a single battery. The estimated profits of recovering valuable metals from NiMH batteries by using thermal melting and mechanical processing are 2,329 and 2,531 USD/ton, respectively, when including a subsidy of 1,710 USD/ton. These findings are very useful to develop or select the recovery methods of valuable metals from spent NiMH batteries.

Copper-induced alteration in sucrose partitioning and its relationship to the root growth of two Elsholtzia haichowensis Sun populations.

Hydroponic culture was used to comparatively investigate the copper (Cu)-induced alteration to sucrose metabolism and biomass allocation in two Elsholtzia haichowensis Sun populations with one from a Cu-contaminated site (CS) and the other from a non-contaminated site (NCS). Experimental results revealed that biomass allocation preferred roots over shoots in CS population, and shoots over roots in NCS population under Cu exposure. The difference in biomass allocation was correlated with the difference in sucrose partitioning between the two populations. Cu treatment (45 µM) significantly decreased leaf sucrose content and increased root sucrose content in CS population as a result of the increased activities of leaf sucrose synthesis enzymes (sucrose phosphate synthetase and sucrose synthase) and root sucrose cleavage enzyme (vacuolar invertase), which led to increased sucrose transport from leaves to roots. In contrast, higher Cu treatment increased sucrose content in leaves and decreased sucrose content in roots in NCS population as a result of the decreased activities of root sucrose cleavage enzymes (vacuolar and cell wall invertases) that led to less sucrose transport from leaves to roots. These results provide important insights into carbon resource partitioning and biomass allocation strategies in metallophytes and are beneficial for the implementation of phytoremediation techniques.

Phytoplankton dynamics of a subtropical reservoir controlled by the complex interplay among hydrological, abiotic, and biotic variables.

This study was conducted to identify the key factors related to the spatiotemporal variations in phytoplankton abundance in a subtropical reservoir from 2006 to 2010 and to assist in developing strategies for water quality management. Dynamic factor analysis (DFA), a dimension-reduction technique, was used to identify interactions between explanatory variables (i.e., environmental variables) and abundance (biovolume) of predominant phytoplankton classes. The optimal DFA model significantly described the dynamic changes in abundances of predominant phytoplankton groups (including dinoflagellates, diatoms, and green algae) at five monitoring sites. Water temperature, electrical conductivity, water level, nutrients (total phosphorus, NO3-N, and NH3-N), macro-zooplankton, and zooplankton were the key factors affecting the dynamics of aforementioned phytoplankton. Therefore, transformations of nutrients and reactions between water quality variables and aforementioned processes altered by hydrological conditions may also control the abundance dynamics of phytoplankton, which may represent common trends in the DFA model. The meandering shape of Shihmen Reservoir and its surrounding rivers caused a complex interplay between hydrological conditions and abiotic and biotic variables, resulting in phytoplankton abundance that could not be estimated using certain variables. Additional water quality and hydrological variables at surrounding rivers and monitoring plans should be executed a few days before and after reservoir operations and heavy storm, which would assist in developing site-specific preventive strategies to control phytoplankton abundance.

Degradation of N,N-diethyl-m-toluamid (DEET) on lead dioxide electrodes in different environmental aqueous matrixes.

This study investigates the electrochemical degradation of N,N-diethyl-m-toluamide (DEET) on PbO2 and Bi-PbO2 anodes. The difference in electrode crystalline structure was responsible for the better DEET degradation and TOC removal on PbO2 than on Bi-PbO2. In 1 M Na2SO4, the degradation efficiency and apparent rate constant (kapp) of DEET oxidation on PbO2 increased with the increase in current density or temperature (activation energy=24.4 kJ mol(-1)). The kapp values in DEET-spiked environmental matrixes (municipal wastewater treatment plant secondary effluent (MWTPSE), groundwater (GW), and river water (RW)) were the same (6.05×10(-4) s(-1)), but significantly smaller than that in 1 M Na2SO4 (2.23×10(-3) s(-1)). The TOC removal efficiency was better in MWTPSE than in RW and GW; however, the mineralization current efficiencies in MWTPSE and RW were similar but higher than that in GW. During electrolysis, the aromaticity was lower in GW than in RW.

Role of sodium ions in the vitrification process: glass matrix modification, slag structure depolymerization, and influence of metal immobilization.

This study investigates the role of Na ions, a common flux, in the vitrification process. Artificial glass systems composed of Al2O3, CaO, and SiO2 with various Na concentrations were melted at 1450 degrees C. The specimens were cooled by air cooling and water quenching and the metal mobility was evaluated using a sequential extraction procedure. The X-ray diffraction analysis and scanning electron microscopy observations showed that Na ions governed the air-cooled slag's structure. Na ions initially depolymerized CaSiO3-linked chains into CaSiO3 chains, and further cut them into shorter and nonuniform ones, making the slag structure amorphous. With even more Na ions, CaSiO3 chains were divided into single SiO4 tetrahedrons and formed Na-related crystals (Na2Ca3Si2O8 and NaAlSiO4). The phase distributions of Al, Cr, Cu Mn, and Ni showed that Na has a positive effect on the immobilization of heavy metals at suitable concentrations, but a negative effect when in excess amounts. Implications: Vitrification has been widely used to treat hazardous materials. The Na-bearing additives were often used as a flux to improve the melting process. This study described the role of Na played in the vitrification process. The Na ions acted as glass modifier and depolymerize the chain structure of slag. With adequate addition amount of Na ions, the immobilization of heavy metals was improved. The results provided much information about the crystalline phase variation, metal mobility, and surface characteristics while Na serves as a flux.

Evaluation of effect of reducing additives during vitrification via simulation and experiment.

This study investigates how reducing additives governed the vitrification of prepared specimens. In the experiments, pure CaO/CaCO3 and SiO2 served as the major components of glassy matrix (basicity = mass ratio of CaO/SiO2 = 2/3) with doping of hazardous metals (Cr Cu, and Ni). The substitution ratio of CaCO3 for CaO was used as an operating parameter. The specimens were vitrified at 1400 degrees C and a sequential extraction protocol was used to determine the phase distribution of Cr, Cu, and Ni. The volume fractions of crystalline and amorphous phases were measured using semiquantitative x-ray diffraction (XRD) analysis. A commercial software package (HSC Chemistry 6.0) was used to simulate the experiment to acquire additional information. The simulation results showed the addition of CaCO3 generated CO and CO2 at high temperature. This reducing atmosphere might enhance Cu and Ni to be easily separated from slags and elevated the levels of Cu and Ni in ingots. At higher CaCO3 mol(%), the polymerization of silicate (from sorosilicate to inosilicate) in slag rose and the CaSiO3 amount increased. In addition, the immobilization of metals and the acid resistance of slags were improved. The results indicate that CaCO3 addition is favorable for increasing the metal level in ingots and the metal encapsulation in slag in vitrification.

Recovery of valuable metals from electroplating sludge with reducing additives via vitrification.

In this study, vitrification was applied to treat Ni-Cu electroplating sludge. The sludge was mixed with additives (limestone:cullet = 4:6) and then heated to 1450 °C. The cooled product could be separated into slag and ingot. An atomic absorption spectrometer was used to determine the metal levels of specimens and toxicity characteristic leaching procedure (TCLP) tests, whereas the crystalline and surface characteristics were examined using quantitative X-ray diffraction (XRD) analysis and scanning electron microscopy, respectively. With a glassy structure, the slag was mainly composed of Ca, Si, and Mg. The TCLP results of slags met the Taiwan regulated standards, suggesting that slag can be used for recycling purposes. With the aid of additives, the crystalline phase of slag was transformed form CaMgSiO4 into CsSiO3. The ingots were mainly composed of Ni (563,000-693,800 mg/kg), Cu (79,900-87,400 mg/kg), and Fe (35,000-43,600 mg/kg) (target metals) due the gravity separation during vitrification. At appropriate additives/sludge ratios (>0.2), >95% of target metals gathered in the ingot as a recoverable form (Ni-Fe alloy). The high Ni level of slag suggests that the ingot can be used as the raw materials for smelters or the additives for steel making. Therefore, the vitrification approach of this study is a promising technology to recover valuable metals from Ni-Cu electroplating sludge.

Effects of NH4⁺ on Ce(IV) electro-regeneration in simulated and real spent TFT-LCD Cr-etching solutions.

This investigation studies the electro-regeneration of Ce(IV) from Ce(III) in 4 M HNO(3) in the presence/absence of NH(4)(+) and real spent thin-film transistor liquid-crystal display (TFT-LCD) Cr-etching solutions. On Pt, at 2 A and 70 °C for 100 min, the Ce(IV) yield and apparent rate constant of Ce(III) oxidation in 4 M HNO(3) without NH(4)(+) were 100% and 5.54 × 10(-4) s(-1), respectively (and the activation energy was 13.1 kJ mol(-1)). Cyclic voltammetric and electrolytic measurements consistently support the noticeable inhibition by NH(4)(+) of Ce(III) oxidation and lowering of the Ce(IV) yield, respectively. The apparent diffusion coefficients for 0.2 and 0.02 M Ce(III) oxidation in 4 M HNO(3) that contained 0-0.6 M NH(4)(+) were (0.38-0.25) × 10(-5) and (1.6-0.9) × 10(-5) cm(2) s(-1), respectively. Because of combined effects of NH(4)(+) and anion impurities, the 100 min Ce(IV) yield of a real spent TFT-LCD Cr-etching solution (with [NH(4)(+)]/[Ce(III)] = 0.74 M/0.39 M) was 82%, lower than that of 4 M HNO(3) without NH(4)(+), but higher than those of 4 M HNO(3) that contained anion impurities with/without 0.4 M NH(4)(+).

Stabilization of residues obtained from the treatment of laboratory waste: Part 2--transformation of plasma vitrified slag into composites.

The Sustainable Environment Research Center of National Cheng Kung University in Taiwan has set up a treatment plant to dispose of laboratory waste. In the treatment process, the residue from the incineration system and the physical and chemical system is vitrified by a plasma melting system. Part 1 of this study described the treatment path of metals during vitrification. In Part 2, plasma vitrified slag is reused by using a molding technology. Unsaturated polyester resin and glass fiber were used as the molding material and additive, respectively, in the molding process. With an appropriate mixing ratio of unsaturated polyester resin, glass fiber, and slag, the physical properties of composites improved, and the ultimate tensile strength reached 17.6 MPa. However, an excess amount of slag reduced the strength and even retarded the production of composites. Differential thermal analysis and the water bathing test results show that the composite decomposed at 80 degrees C and that it vaporized at 187 degrees C. Although the unsaturated polyester resin decomposed, the metal encapsulated in the slag did not leach out. The results show that the reuse of slag using molding technology should be taken into consideration.

Assessment of water quality under various environmental features using a site-specific weighting water quality index.

In a multiregional river system, environmental features such as natural conditions and anthropogenic activities vary among regions, resulting in spatiotemporal variations in water quality. Therefore, a robust water quality assessment method (e.g., water quality index [WQI]) that considers various environmental features is essential for water resources management. This study developed a min/max autocorrelation factor analysis (MAFA) based WQI framework (MAFAWQI). The statistical procedure reduces the bias of expert opinions. The MAFAWQI characterizes impaired water quality variables as indicators and assesses appropriate weighting values of indicators at each sampling site to reflect site-specific environmental features. The MAFAWQI was successful for assessing water quality in the middle and down streams of Han River in central China with site-specific pollution features such as nitrogen and phosphorus pollution related to multiple-source in tributaries, impacts of tributaries on the main stream, and phosphorus pollution related to nonpoint-source in agricultural regions. The MAFAWQI exhibited a balanced rating of water quality compared to the strict assessment method using a single indicator and the lenient assessment method using stationary weighting values of indicators. The MAFAWQI scores indicated that the water quality in tributaries and during the spring were significantly worse than those in and during the other regions and seasons in the middle and down streams of Han River, respectively. The framework and application of the MAFAWQI may provide a new perspective for developing WQIs.

Tidal driven nutrient exchange between mangroves and estuary reveals a dynamic source-sink pattern.

Nitrogen (N) and phosphorus (P) are vital nutrients regulating mangrove productivity and coastal ecosystems. Understanding of the nutrient cycling and interaction between mangroves and estuary is limited. Here we show tidal-driven nutrient exchange and a dynamic source-sink pattern across the mangrove-estuary interface. Lateral nutrient fluxes were quantified based on hourly concentrations observed at a tidal creek outlet during 2016-2018 and water mass estimated by a hydrodynamic model (FVCOM). The results of nutrient fluxes suggested that mangroves always serve as a source of ammonium (NH4-N) and dissolved reactive P (DRP) to estuary, but as a strong nitrate sink (NO3-N). Dissolved organic components (DON and DOP) shifted from net efflux (source) in spring to net influx (sink) in summer, likely due to the changing balance of P input and biological and physicochemical processes. Mangroves decreased the overall loading of dissolved inorganic N (DIN), dissolved total N (DTN) and total P (TP) to the estuary. Nevertheless, the effluents (aquaculture wastewater and domestic sewage) discharged from the upstream area during ebb tide increased the export of nutrients, especially NH4-N and DRP, offsetting the role of mangrove on mitigating coastal eutrophication.

Dynamic factor analysis for estimating ground water arsenic trends.

Drinking ground water containing high arsenic (As) concentrations has been associated with blackfoot disease and the occurrence of cancer along the southwestern coast of Taiwan. As a result, 28 ground water observation wells were installed to monitor the ground water quality in this area. Dynamic factor analysis (DFA) is used to identify common trends that represent unexplained variability in ground water As concentrations of decommissioned wells and to investigate whether explanatory variables (total organic carbon [TOC], As, alkalinity, ground water elevation, and rainfall) affect the temporal variation in ground water As concentration. The results of the DFA show that rainfall dilutes As concentration in areas under aquacultural and agricultural use. Different combinations of geochemical variables (As, alkalinity, and TOC) of nearby monitoring wells affected the As concentrations of the most decommissioned wells. Model performance was acceptable for 11 wells (coefficient of efficiency >0.50), which represents 52% (11/21) of the decommissioned wells. Based on DFA results, we infer that surface water recharge may be effective for diluting the As concentration, especially in the areas that are relatively far from the coastline. We demonstrate that DFA can effectively identify the important factors and common effects representing unexplained variability common to decommissioned wells on As variation in ground water and extrapolate information from existing monitoring wells to the nearby decommissioned wells.

Stabilization of residues obtained from the treatment of laboratory waste. Part 1--Treatment path of metals in a plasma melting system.

The objective of this study is to investigate the treatment path of metals during the plasma vitrification of fly ash, bottom ash, sludge, and activated carbon collected from a laboratory waste treatment plant. Sampling, digestion, and analysis procedures that followed the standard methods of the Taiwan Environmental Protection Administration were used to determine the composition of the input and output materials. The microstructure was qualitatively examined using a scanning electron microscope. The results show that the vitrification process successfully vitrified the toxic input materials into a stable, glassy, amorphous slag. During vitrification, metals with low boiling points (As, Cd, Hg, Pb, and Zn) were vaporized into the flue gas. Metals with high boiling points and high specific weights went into the ingot, and the residual metals remained in the molten materials as the slag. The distribution of metals shows their behavior during vitrification and can provide a reference for vitrifying hazardous materials.

Chemical and physical properties of plasma slags containing various amorphous volume fractions.

In this study, municipal solid waste incinerator fly ash was vitrified using a plasma torch. The fly ash contained rich Ca, causing a high basicity of 2.43. Pure quartz was used as an additive to adjust the basicity. BET surface area analysis, X-ray diffraction analysis, and a scanning electron microscope were used to examine the physical properties of slags. The chemical stability and the acid resistance of slags were evaluated using the toxicity characteristics leaching procedure and tests of acid bathing. The results indicate that the plasma torch effectively vitrified the fly ash. Anthropogenic metals with low boiling points, such as Cd, Pb, and Zn, were predominately vaporized into flue gas. Most of the metals with high boiling points, such as Cr, Cu, and Mn, remained in the slag. After the vitrification, hazardous metals were noticeably immobilized in all slags. However, the slags with higher amorphous volume fractions were more effective in metal immobilization and in resisting acid corrosion. This indicates that SiO(2) enhanced the formation of the glassy amorphous phase and improved the resistance of acid corrosion and the immobilization of hazardous metals.

Vitrification for reclaiming spent alkaline batteries.

The object of this study is to stabilize spent alkaline batteries and to recover useful metals. A blend of dolomite, limestone, and cullet was added to act as a reductant and a glass matrix former in vitrification. Specimens were vitrified using an electrical heating furnace at 1400 degrees C and the output products included slag, ingot, flue gas, and fly ash. The major constituents of the slag were Ca, Mn, and Si, and the results of the toxicity leaching characteristics met the standards in Taiwan. The ingot was a good material for use in production of stainless steel, due to being mainly composed of Fe and Mn. For the fly ash, the high level of Zn makes it economical to recover. The distribution of metals indicated that most of Co, Cr, Cu, Fe, Mn, and Ni moved to the ingot, while Al, Ca, Mg, and Si stayed in the slag; Hg vaporized as gas phase into the flue gas; and Cd, Pb, and Zn were predominately in the fly ash. Recovery efficiency for Fe and Zn was >90% and the results show that vitrification is a promising technology for reclaiming spent alkaline batteries.

Removal of color from real dyeing wastewater by Electro-Fenton technology using a three-dimensional graphite cathode.

This work investigates the removal of color from wastewater that contains low dyestuff concentrations by the Electro-Fenton process. The color was removed by in situ electrogenerated hydrogen peroxides at a three-dimensional graphite cathode with added ferrous sulfates. Experimental runs were conducted to evaluate the effect of the operating parameters, such as the oxygen contact mode, the oxygen sparging rate, the applied current density, the concentration of ferrous ions, the solution temperature and the pH among others, on the removal of color. The removal efficiency of the color in the cathodic chamber reached 70.6% under specified operation conditions in 150 min. The removal efficiency was controlled by the mass transfer when the oxygen-sparging rate was less than 0.3 dm(3)/min for the reactor configuration herein. The optimal applied current density was 68 A/m(2) when the energy consumption was considered. The highest removal efficiency was obtained by adding 20 mM Fe(II) to the solution. The optimal solution pH was 3 in this work. The temperature negatively affected color removal.

Effect of water quenching and SiO2 addition during vitrification of fly ash Part 1: on the crystalline characteristics of slags.

The objective of this study is to investigate how cooling rate and basicity in a vitrification process govern the crystalline characteristics of slags. In this experiment, the incineration fly ash mixtures with various SiO2 addition ratios were vitrified at 1450 degrees C and cooled down separately by air or water. Different thermal analysis, scanning electron microscopy and X-ray diffraction analysis with an internal standard addition were applied to investigate the crystalline characteristics of slags. The microanalytical mapping images showed that water quenching and the addition of SiO2, both enhanced the glassy amorphous phase to distribute more uniformly in slags. Addition of SiO2 would lower the melting temperature of fly ash mixtures and retard the formation of crystalline phases in slags. When the basicity (mass ratio of CaO to SiO2 before vitrification) was >0.990, the profiles of crystalline phases in slags with equal basicity were similar no matter how they were cooled. However, when the basicity <0.674, water quenching greatly enhanced the formation of the glassy amorphous phase in slags. For air cooled slags, an even lower basicity (<0.511) is required to vitrify fly ash well.