Induction into viable but non culturable state and outgrowth heterogeneity of Listeria monocytogenes is affected by stress history and type of growth.

Exposure to sublethal stresses related to food-processing may induce a heterogenous mixture of cells that co-exist, comprising healthy, sublethally injured, dormant and dead cells. Heterogeneity in survival capacity and dormancy of single cells may impede the detection of foodborne pathogens. In this study, we exposed Listeria monocytogenes Scott A strain, to peracetic acid (PAA; 20-40 ppm) and to acidic conditions (hydrochloric (HCl) and acetic (AA) acid, adjusted to pH 2.7-3.0, to evaluate the resuscitation capacity and outgrowth kinetics of metabolically active cells in two different media. Injury and the viable-but-non-culturable (VBNC) status of cells were assessed by flow cytometry using CFDA (metabolically active) and PI (dead) staining. Stressed CFDA+PI- cells were sorted on Tryptic Soy (TS) Agar or in TS broth, both supplemented with 0.6 % Yeast Extract (TSAYE or TSBYE), to evaluate culturability. Resuscitation capacity of CFDA+PI-sorted cells (10 events/well) was monitored by visual inspection on TSAYE and by optical density measurement in TSBYE for 5 days. Sorting of L. monocytogenes viable cells (CFDA+PI-) in Ringer's solution on TSAYE and TSBYE showed 100 % recovery in both media (control condition), while the mean lag time in TSBYE was 9.6 h. Treatment with 20 ppm PAA for 90 and 180 min resulted in 74.79 % and 85.82 % of non-culturable cells in TSBYE and increased the average lag time to 41.7 h and 43.8 h, respectively, compared to the control (9.6 h). The longest average lag time (79.5 h) was detected after treatment with 30 ppm PAA for 90 min, while at the same condition sorting of CFDA+PI- cells resulted in 95.05 % and 93.94 % non-culturable cells on TSAYE and TSBYE, respectively. The highest percentage of wells with non-culturable cells (96.17 %) was detected on TSAYE after treatment with 40 ppm PAA for 30 min. Fractions of VBNC cells were detected in TSBYE after treatment with HCl pH 3.0 for 60 and 240 min, and in TSAYE and TSBYE after exposure to AA pH 2.7. Treatment with AA pH 2.7 for 150-300 min increased the range of recorded lag time values compared to 60 min, from 8.6 h up to 13.3 h, as well as the mean lag times in TSBYE. Modelling of the outgrowth kinetics comparing the two types of stress (oxidative vs acid) and the two systems of growth (colonial vs planktonic) revealed that low starting concentrations hindered the detection of viable L. monocytogenes cells, either due to VBNC induction or cell heterogeneity.

Deciphering the induction of Listeria monocytogenes into sublethal injury using fluorescence microscopy and RT-qPCR.

The adaptive response of bacterial cells to changing environmental conditions depends on the behavior of single cells within the population. Exposure of Listeria monocytogenes to sublethal acidic conditions in foods or in the gastrointestinal track of the host may induce injuries relevant to difficult physiological states within the dormancy continuum. In this study, exposure to acidic conditions (acetic-AA and hydrochloric acid-HCl adjusted to pH 3.0, 2.7, 2.5 at 20 °C for 5 h) was used to evaluate injury of L. monocytogenes, Scott A strain. To differentiate the resistant sub-population from the total, Tryptic Soy Agar with 0.6 % Yeast Extract (TSAYE) supplemented or not with 5 % NaCl were comparatively used. Sublethally injured cells were detected by comparing plate counts with fluorescence microscopy, using combinations of CFDA (viability) and Propidium-Iodide (death). Effect of acid stress on the relative transcription of clpP, mazE, mazF, relA, gadC, gadD, gadB, sigB, inlA and prfA upon transition of total population into different physiological stages was evaluated through RT-qPCR. AA treated cells showed measurable logarithmic reduction at pH 2.7 and 2.5, while there was a significant percentage of CFDA-/PI+ cells. Evaluation of the potentially culturable population on TSAYE, from the percentage of CFDA/PI-stained cells, revealed that unstained cells represented a non-culturable sub-population. Exposure to Ringer's solution pH 2.7, adjusted with AA, resulted in higher percentages of non-esterase active with membrane integrity cells (CFDA-/PI-) compared to the percentages of the enumerated culturable cells on TSAYE after 4 and 5 h. Under the same conditions, after 1 h of exposure macroscopic observation revealed size colony variations (SCVs) of the total population (CFU on TSAYE). L. monocytogenes retained its culturability after hydrochloric acid exposure, while cells remained metabolically active (CFDA+). However, a stochastic change in cell's shape, was detected after exposure to pH 3.0 and 2.5, adjusted with HCl, for 2 h at 20 °C. A pattern of gene up-regulation was observed during treatment with AA pH 2.7 and HCl pH 3.0 at the 3rd h of exposure. Deciphering L. monocytogenes sublethal injury sheds light into the physiological and molecular characteristics of this state and provides the food science community with quantitative data to improve risk assessment.

Listeria monocytogenes Sublethal Injury and Viable-but-Nonculturable State Induced by Acidic Conditions and Disinfectants.

The dormancy continuum hypothesis states that in response to stress, cells enter different stages of dormancy ranging from unstressed living cells to cell death, in order to ensure their long-term survival under adverse conditions. Exposure of Listeria monocytogenes cells to sublethal stressors related to food processing may induce sublethal injury and the viable-but-nonculturable (VBNC) state. In this study, exposure to acetic acid (AA), hydrochloric acid (HCl), and two disinfectants, peracetic acid (PAA) and sodium hypochlorite (SH), at 20°C and 4°C was used to evaluate the potential induction of L. monocytogenes strain Scott A into different stages of dormancy. To differentiate the noninjured subpopulation from the total population, tryptic soy agar with 0.6% yeast extract (TSAYE), supplemented or not with 5% NaCl, was used. Sublethally injured and VBNC cells were detected by comparing plate counts obtained with fluorescence microscopy and by using combinations of carboxyfluorescein and propidium iodide (viable/dead cells). Induction of sublethal injury was more intense after PAA treatment. Two subpopulations were detected, with phenotypes of untreated cells and small colony variants (SCVs). SCVs appeared as smaller colonies of various sizes and were first observed after 5 min of exposure to 5 ppm PAA at 20°C. Increasing the stress intensity from 5 to 40 ppm PAA led to earlier detection of SCVs. L. monocytogenes remained culturable after exposure to 20 and 30 ppm PAA for 3 h. At 40 ppm, after 3 h of exposure, the whole population was considered nonculturable, while cells remained metabolically active. These results corroborate the induction of the VBNC state. IMPORTANCE Sublethally injured and VBNC cells may evade detection, resulting in underestimation of a food product's microbial load. Under favorable conditions, cells may regain their growth capacity and acquire new resistant characteristics, posing a major threat for public health. Induction of the VBNC state is crucial for foodborne pathogens, such as L. monocytogenes, the detection of which relies almost exclusively on the use of culture recovery techniques. In the present study, we confirmed that sublethal injury is an initial stage of dormancy in L. monocytogenes that is followed by the VBNC state. Our results showed that PAA induced SCVs (a phenomenon potentially triggered by external factors) and the VBNC state in L. monocytogenes, indicating that tests of lethality based only on culturability may provide false-positive results regarding the effectiveness of an inactivation treatment.