Effect of different fish feeds on water quality and growth of crucian carp (Carassius carassius) in the presence and absence of prometryn.

Few data are available regarding comprehensive or quantitative assessment of fish feed considering both the environmental and feeding impacts. Aiming to fill the gap, an experimental study to investigate the effects of three fish feeds on concentrations of nutrients and crucian carp (Carassius carassius) growth was conducted in laboratory aquariums in the presence and absence of prometryn. Results showed that weight gain rates of crucian carp treated with Tong Wei (TW) feed were 106.3% and 2.0% higher than that of Zhong Shan (ZS) and Zhong Liang (ZL) feeds, a possible explanation was that the quality of protein in TW feed was highest as evidenced by the protein efficiency ratios. Meanwhile, TW feed posed relatively lighter effects on water qualities (between ZL and ZS). Prometryn significantly inhibited the growth of crucian carp and thus affected concentrations of nutrients in water indirectly. The relationships between weight gain rates of fish and concentrations of nutrients in water (R2 = 0.929-0.990) were developed. In sum, this study suggested that it is realizable to obtain better fish growth performance with lesser degrading effects on water qualities by producing and selecting appropriate feed regardless of prometryn existence, and the developed equations could be used as a basis for future studies.

Effects of fish feed addition scenarios with prometryn on Microcystis aeruginosa growth and water qualities.

The number of undesirable environmental impacts of fish feed has been reported widely. Although repeated fish feed exposures are more prospective to occur in water, previous studies were mostly conducted as a single exposure of fish feed. In order to fill these gaps, a 40 days incubator experiment was conducted to explore the effects of fish feed addition scenarios during the lag phase with prometryn on both Microcystis aeruginosa growth and concentrations of nutrients. The maximum algae densities in groups of single exposure were 6.0-26.2% and 8.8-74.4% higher than those in groups of double and triple exposures, respectively (P < 0.05). At the beginning of the experiment, concentrations of nutrients in groups with different feed exposure scenarios were significantly different. The pattern of nutrient limitation showed a transformation from phosphorus limitation to nitrogen limitation generally. Furthermore, the average inhibition rates of algae by prometryn in the case of a single fish feed exposure were 4.6-9.4% lower than those under double exposures, and 22.0-26.8% lower than those under triple exposures (P < 0.05). In addition, algae growth rates have been developed as a function of concentrations of consumed nutrients (R2 = 0.410-0.932). Based on the above results, we concluded that in terms of limiting algae growth multiple low-dosage additions of fish feed were considered as a better addition pattern. By optimizing feed addition scenarios, there is considerable potential to increase the environmental sustainability of aquaculture.