Characterization of aerosol output from various nebulizer/compressor combinations.

OBJECTIVES: Different commercially available nebulizers and compressors are available. However, the optimal combination for drug delivery is unknown. METHODS: Flow rates of five different compressors (n = 3/compressor) tested alone and in combination with five different commercial nebulizers (n = 9 of each brand of nebulizer) were evaluated. Thereafter, the performances of the different nebulizers were evaluated using 2.5 mg albuterol solution (0.5 mL) added to 2.5 mL saline at flow rates of 2, 3, 4, and 5 L/minute using a laser particle analyzer. Volume median diameter and percentage of particles in the respirable range (1-5 microm) were calculated from this data. Time for nebulization (in seconds) and residual volume (in milliliters) were also recorded. RESULTS: The mean flow rates for the compressors evaluated without a nebulizer attached ranged from 6.6 L/minute (LifeCare Freedom-neb; LifeCare International, Lafayette, CO) to 12.2 L/minute (DeVilbiss Pulmo-Aide; DeVilbiss Health Care, Somerset, PA). Flow rates for the nebulizer/compressor combinations ranged from 2.08 L/minute (Pari LC Jet Proneb; Pari Respiratory Equipment, Richmond, VA) to 5.42 L/minute (Puritan Bennett Raindrop; Puritan Bennett, Lenexa, KS/Omron Compare; Omron, Health Care,Vernon Hills, IL). Using the repeated measure ANOVA model, the interaction between flow rate and device was significant (P < 0.001) for both percentage of particles in the respirable range and log volume median diameter. It was observed that the percentage of particles in the respirable range for the Pari LC Jet did not increase across flow rates in contrast to the other 4 nebulizers. All comparisons to the Pari LC Jet at 2 L/minute were significant. CONCLUSIONS: Marked variability exists in the flow rates among different commercially available compressors used for home nebulization of inhaled pulmonary medications. Different nebulizer/compressor combinations have markedly different performance characteristics which could result in different efficacy and safety profiles of the medications being administered via these devices. We recommend that this type of information be used as a starting point for selecting different nebulizer/compressor combinations. Further clinical evaluation is warranted.

Comparison of three commercial ultrasonic nebulizers.

BACKGROUND: The clinical acceptance of the initial ultrasonic nebulizers was impeded by their production of significant quantities of droplets larger than the respirable range that could have resulted in poor pulmonary deposition of nebulized medications. Subsequent modifications in the design of ultrasonic nebulizers have occurred. Overall nebulizer performance characteristics of the newer ultrasonic devices have not been evaluated. OBJECTIVE: Three commercially available ultrasonic nebulizers (DeVilbiss-Pulmosonic, Omron-Microair, Rhône Poulenc-Rorer-Fisoneb) were studied to compare the aerosol output characteristics. METHODS: The parameters studied were total volume output (TVO), time to nebulize total output (TTO), percent of droplets with volume diameters in the respirable range (PDVRR, 1 to 5 microm), albuterol concentration during nebulization, and the total drug delivered. All nebulizers were filled with 2.5 mL of saline and 0.5 mL of albuterol nebulizer solution. Three units from each manufacturer, each from a different lot, were evaluated in duplicate. RESULTS: The nebulizer with the largest volume output was the Omron (mean 2.94 mL), which also demonstrated the longest nebulization time (mean 10.3 min). The DeVilbiss and Rhône Poulenc-Rorer units delivered smaller volumes (mean 2.5 mL, 2.4 mL, respectively) but nebulized more rapidly (mean 2.21 min, 3.54 min, respectively). The Omron nebulizer generated the highest PDVRR with a mean of 38%. The DeVilbiss had a mean PDVRR of 16% and the Rhône Poulenc-Rorer a mean PDVRR of 21%. The majority of droplets from all three machines had a volume diameter smaller than the respirable range, ie, in the 0.5 to 1.0 microm range (Omron-60%, DeVilbiss-83%, Rhône Poulenc-Rorer-79%). For all three nebulizers there appeared to be no concentrating or diluting effect during nebulization implying that equal quantities of albuterol and diluent were delivered. The Rhône Poulenc-Rorer units demonstrated the greatest unit-to-unit variability with respect to TVO while the Omron units demonstrated the greatest unit to unit variability with respect to TTO. CONCLUSION: We conclude that several improvements in the design of ultrasonic nebulizers have resulted in the reduction of the size of the droplets generated. Our evaluation of the three commercially available ultrasonic nebulizers revealed that the majority of droplets generated were within or below the respirable range. There was no concentrating or diluting effect during nebulization for all three nebulizers. The output characteristics of the three devices differ and this will effect the delivery time as well as amount of drug delivered to the lungs.

Circadian variation in exhaled nitric oxide in nocturnal asthma.

Asthma is characterized by airway inflammation and shows a circadian variation with nocturnal exacerbations. Because exhaled nitric oxide (ENO) measurement appears to be a noninvasive marker of airway inflammation, we examined the hypothesis that ENO would increase at night. In five nocturnal and five non-nocturnal asthmatics, ENO was measured at 4 P.M., 10 P.M., and 4 A.M. before and after bronchodilator. Both pre- and post-bronchodilator ENO (mean pre- and post-bronchodilator +/- SEM, ppb) unexpectedly fell significantly in nocturnal asthma from 4 P.M. (77.2 +/- 8.2) compared to 10 P.M. (68.4 +/- 8.7, p < 0.003) and 4 A.M. (66.0 +/- 8.5, p < 0.001) with no significant difference between 10 P.M. and 4 A.M.. In contrast, there were no significant differences in mean ENO at 4 P.M., 10 P.M., and 4 A.M. in non-nocturnal asthma. (51.3 +/- 10.8, 57.7 +/- 13.4, 53.8 +/- 12.5 ppb, respectively). Following bronchodilator, ENO rose significantly by 10.5 +/- 1.8 ppb in the nocturnal asthma group alone. The circadian rhythm of ENO differed greatly between nocturnal and non-nocturnal asthma. The significant decrease in ENO in nocturnal asthma may reflect an important chronobiological defect in the endogenous production and/or increased disposition of nitric oxide, which in view of its bronchodilator action, could play a role in nocturnal exacerbations of asthma.

Irritant-associated vocal cord dysfunction.

Vocal cord dysfunction (VCD) is a poorly understood entity that is often misdiagnosed as asthma. We report eleven cases of VCD in which there was a temporal association between VCD onset and occupational or environmental exposure. We conducted a case-control study to determine if the characteristics of irritant-exposed VCD (IVCD) cases differed from non-exposed VCD controls. Chart review of VCD patients at the authors' institution produced 11 cases that met IVCD case criteria. Thirty-three control VCD subjects were selected by age matching. There were statistical differences between the groups in ethnicity and chest discomfort. There were no statistical differences between the groups for gender, tobacco, smoking habits, symptoms, or pulmonary function parameters. Varied irritant exposures were associated with IVCD. IVCD should be considered in patients presenting with respiratory symptoms occurring after irritant exposures.

Serum neopterin in chronic beryllium disease.

We evaluated serum neopterin as a biomarker of chronic beryllium disease (CBD), for use in conjunction with the beryllium lymphocyte proliferation test (BeLPT) in workplace screening. Serum neopterin levels were determined by radioimmunoassay, and we compared levels in three groups: CBD (n = 86), beryllium sensitized (BeS) (n = 22), and normal (Nor) (n = 20). Those in the diseased group underwent pulmonary function tests, bronchoalveolar lavage (BAL), and maximal exercise testing. We correlated neopterin levels with results of these clinical parameters of disease severity. To evaluate the optimum sensitivity, specificity, and neopterin cut-off value, receiver operator characteristic (ROC) curves were generated. The median serum neopterin level in CBD was significantly higher than in BeS or in Nor [median 1.45, 25th, 75th percentiles (1.00, 2.7) ng/ml, 0.82 (0.67, 1.16) ng/ml, and 0.92 (0.86, 1.16) ng/ml, respectively] (P < 0.05). In CBD, we observed statistically significant associations between neopterin and measures of gas exchange and BAL cellularity. Using a neopterin value of 1.27 ng/ml, test specificity is 88%. In those workers with an abnormal BeLPT, serum neopterin has high positive predictive value (92%), and can identify disease, helping to distinguish it from BeS without the risks of biopsy.

Observer variation and relationship of computed tomography to severity of beryllium disease.

Although high resolution computed tomography (HRCT) is commonly used to assess interstitial lung disease (ILD), relatively little is known about interrater reliability and construct validity of HRCT-reported nodules, ground-glass opacity, or other typical findings. We determined the interobserver and intraobserver variability of HRCT findings and correlated HRCT abnormalities with physiologic measures in 57 patients with chronic beryllium disease (CBD). Reliability of HRCT scan measurements were assessed using weighted kappa (K(W)) and intraclass correlation coefficients. We correlated HRCT with spirometry, body plethysmographic lung volumes, diffusing capacity for carbon monoxide (DL(CO)), maximal exercise testing with measurement of arterial blood gases, and bronchoalveolar lavage (BAL). Interobserver agreement for three of the HRCT abnormalities found in CBD was moderate: the K(W) for nodules, septal lines, and ground-glass attenuation were 0.53, 0.44, and 0.53, respectively. Agreement was poor for bronchial wall thickening (K(W) = 0.15). HRCT scores correlated significantly with DL(CO), gas exchange at rest and at maximal exercise, and lung volume. This study demonstrates that HRCT has good interrater reliability and correlates with indices of the severity of granulomatous lung diseases such as CBD.