RESUMO
Over the past decade, the field of heart failure (HF) has witnessed remarkable progress in drug development, resulting in the approval of numerous groundbreaking drugs by the U.S. Food and Drug Administration. To address some of these challenges, the U.S. Food and Drug Administration has issued guidance documents that have been critical in contemporary HF drug development; however, there are still many challenges in need of investigation. This article leverages efforts of the Heart Failure Collaboratory and the scientific community to discuss the critical need for innovative trial designs, important concepts in clinical trials in the modern era, and the utilization of big data to accelerate HF drug development. At this inflection point in HF drug development, it is imperative that, as a global scientific community, we foster increased collaboration among researchers, clinicians, patients, and regulatory bodies. Only through such unified efforts can we navigate the complexities of HF, accelerate the development process, and ultimately deliver effective therapies that transform patient outcomes.
RESUMO
Clinical trials are vital for assessing therapeutic interventions. The associated data monitoring committees (DMCs) safeguard patient interests and enhance trial integrity, thus promoting timely, reliable evaluations of those interventions. We face an urgent need to recruit and train new DMC members. The HFC (Heart Failure Collaboratory), a multidisciplinary public-private consortium of academics, trialists, patients, industry representatives, and government agencies, is working to improve the clinical trial ecosystem. The HFC aims to improve clinical trial efficiency and quality by standardizing concepts, and to help meet the demand for experienced individuals on DMCs by creating a standardized approach to training new members. This paper discusses the HFC's training workshop, and an apprenticeship model for new DMC members. It describes opportunities and challenges DMCs face, along with common myths and best practices learned through previous experiences, with an emphasis on data confidentiality and need for quality independent statistical reporting groups.
Assuntos
Comitês de Monitoramento de Dados de Ensaios Clínicos , Insuficiência Cardíaca , Humanos , Insuficiência Cardíaca/terapia , Ensaios Clínicos como AssuntoRESUMO
Heart failure (HF) is a complex syndrome traditionally classified by left ventricular ejection fraction (LVEF) cutpoints. Although LVEF is prognostic for risk of events and predictive of response to some HF therapies, LVEF is a continuous variable and cutpoints are arbitrary, often based on historical clinical trial enrichment decisions rather than physiology. Holistic evaluation of the treatment effects for therapies throughout the LVEF range suggests the standard categorization paradigm for HF merits modification. The multidisciplinary Heart Failure Collaboratory reviewed data from large-scale HF clinical trials and found that many HF therapies have demonstrated therapeutic benefit across a large range of LVEF, but specific treatment effects vary across that range. Therefore, HF should practically be classified by association with an LVEF that is reduced or not reduced, while acknowledging uncertainty around the precise LVEF cutpoint, and future research should evaluate new therapies across the continuum of LVEF.
Assuntos
Insuficiência Cardíaca , Função Ventricular Esquerda , Humanos , Volume Sistólico/fisiologia , Função Ventricular Esquerda/fisiologia , Prognóstico , Fatores de TempoRESUMO
BACKGROUND: Mutations to the co-chaperone protein BAG3 (B-cell lymphoma-2-associated athanogene-3) are a leading cause of dilated cardiomyopathy (DCM). These mutations often impact the C-terminal BAG domain (residues 420-499), which regulates heat shock protein 70-dependent protein turnover via autophagy. While mutations in other regions are less common, previous studies in patients with DCM found that co-occurrence of 2 BAG3 variants (P63A, P380S) led to worse prognosis. However, the underlying mechanism for dysfunction is not fully understood. METHODS AND RESULTS: In this study, we used proteomics, Western blots, and myofilament functional assays on left ventricular tissue from patients with nonfailing, DCM, and DCM with BAG363/380 to determine how these mutations impact protein quality control and cardiomyocyte contractile function. We found dysregulated autophagy and increased protein ubiquitination in patients with BAG363/380 compared with nonfailing and DCM, suggesting impaired protein turnover. Expression and myofilament localization of BAG3-binding proteins were also uniquely altered in the BAG3,63/380 including abolished localization of the small heat shock protein CRYAB (alpha-crystallin B chain) to the sarcomere. To determine whether these variants impacted sarcomere function, we used cardiomyocyte force-calcium assays and found reduced maximal calcium-activated force in DCM and BAG363/380. Interestingly, myofilament calcium sensitivity was increased in DCM but not with BAG363/380, which was not explained by differences in troponin I phosphorylation. CONCLUSIONS: Together, our data support that the disease-enhancing mechanism for BAG3 variants outside of the BAG domain is through disrupted protein turnover leading to compromised sarcomere function. These findings suggest a shared mechanism of disease among pathogenic BAG3 variants, regardless of location.
Assuntos
Cardiomiopatia Dilatada , Insuficiência Cardíaca , Humanos , Sarcômeros/genética , Sarcômeros/metabolismo , Cálcio/metabolismo , Proteínas Reguladoras de Apoptose/genética , Proteínas Reguladoras de Apoptose/metabolismo , Insuficiência Cardíaca/genética , Autofagia , Proteínas Adaptadoras de Transdução de Sinal/genética , Proteínas Adaptadoras de Transdução de Sinal/metabolismoRESUMO
Left ventricular reverse remodeling in heart failure is associated with improved clinical outcomes. However, the molecular features that drive this process are poorly defined. Left ventricular assist devices (LVADs) are the therapy associated with the greatest reverse remodeling and lead to partial myocardial recovery in most patients. In this study, we examined whether autophagy may be implicated in post-LVAD reverse remodeling. We found expression of key autophagy factors increased post-LVAD, while autophagic substrates decreased. Autolysosome numbers increased post-LVAD, further indicating increased autophagy. These findings support the conclusion that mechanical unloading activates autophagy, which may underly the reverse remodeling observed.
RESUMO
We investigated the extent, biologic characterization, phenotypic specificity, and possible regulation of a ß1-adrenergic receptor-linked (ß1-AR-linked) gene signaling network (ß1-GSN) involved in left ventricular (LV) eccentric pathologic remodeling. A 430-member ß1-GSN was identified by mRNA expression in transgenic mice overexpressing human ß1-ARs or from literature curation, which exhibited opposite directional behavior in interventricular septum endomyocardial biopsies taken from patients with beta-blocker-treated, reverse remodeled dilated cardiomyopathies. With reverse remodeling, the major biologic categories and percentage of the dominant directional change were as follows: metabolic (19.3%, 81% upregulated); gene regulation (14.9%, 78% upregulated); extracellular matrix/fibrosis (9.1%, 92% downregulated); and cell homeostasis (13.3%, 60% upregulated). Regarding the comparison of ß1-GSN categories with expression from 19,243 nonnetwork genes, phenotypic selection for major ß1-GSN categories was exhibited for LV end systolic volume (contractility measure), ejection fraction (remodeling index), and pulmonary wedge pressure (wall tension surrogate), beginning at 3 months and persisting to study completion at 12 months. In addition, 121 lncRNAs were identified as possibly involved in cis-acting regulation of ß1-GSN members. We conclude that an extensive 430-member gene network downstream from the ß1-AR is involved in pathologic ventricular remodeling, with metabolic genes as the most prevalent category.
Assuntos
Produtos Biológicos , Cardiomiopatia Dilatada , Animais , Camundongos , Humanos , Cardiomiopatia Dilatada/genética , Redes Reguladoras de Genes , Transdução de Sinais , Camundongos Transgênicos , Receptores AdrenérgicosRESUMO
BACKGROUND: Thrombo-inflammation is central to COVID-19-associated coagulopathy. TF (tissue factor), a driver of disordered coagulation and inflammation in viral infections, may be a therapeutic target in COVID-19. The safety and efficacy of the novel TF inhibitor rNAPc2 (recombinant nematode anticoagulation protein c2) in COVID-19 are unknown. METHODS: ASPEN-COVID-19 was an international, randomized, open-label, active comparator clinical trial with blinded end point adjudication. Hospitalized patients with COVID-19 and elevated D-dimer levels were randomized 1:1:2 to lower or higher dose rNAPc2 on days 1, 3, and 5 followed by heparin on day 8 or to heparin per local standard of care. In comparisons of the pooled rNAPc2 versus heparin groups, the primary safety end point was major or nonmajor clinically relevant International Society of Thrombosis and Haemostasis bleeding through day 8. The primary efficacy end point was proportional change in D-dimer concentration from baseline to day 8, or discharge if before day 8. Patients were followed for 30 days. RESULTS: Among 160 randomized patients, median age was 54 years, 43.1% were female, and 38.8% had severe baseline COVID-19. There were no significant differences between rNAPc2 and heparin in bleeding or other safety events. Overall, median change in D-dimer was -16.8% (interquartile range, -45.7 to 36.8; P=0.41) with rNAPc2 treatment and -11.2% (-36.0 to 34.4; P=0.91) with heparin (Pintergroup=0.47). In prespecified analyses, in severely ill patients, D-dimer levels tended to increase more within the heparin (median, 29.0% [-14.9 to 145.2]; P=0.02) than the rNAPc2 group (median, 25.9% [-49.1 to 136.4]; P=0.14; Pintergroup=0.96); in mildly ill patients, D-dimer levels were reduced within each group with a numerically greater reduction with rNAPc2 versus heparin (rNAPc2 median, -32.7% [-44.7 to 4.3]; P=0.007 and heparin median, -16.8% [-36.0 to 0.5]; P=0.008, Pintergroup=0.34). CONCLUSIONS: rNAPc2 treatment in hospitalized patients with COVID-19 was well tolerated without excess bleeding or serious adverse events but did not significantly reduce D-dimer more than heparin at day 8. REGISTRATION: URL: https://www. CLINICALTRIALS: gov; Unique identifier: NCT04655586.
Assuntos
Antifibrinolíticos , Transtornos da Coagulação Sanguínea , COVID-19 , Produtos de Degradação da Fibrina e do Fibrinogênio , Tromboembolia Venosa , Feminino , Humanos , Masculino , Pessoa de Meia-Idade , Anticoagulantes/efeitos adversos , Hemorragia/induzido quimicamente , Heparina/efeitos adversos , Inflamação/induzido quimicamente , TromboplastinaRESUMO
SARS-CoV-2 vaccine-associated myocarditis/myocardial injury should be evaluated in the contexts of COVID-19 infection, other types of viral myocarditis, and other vaccine-associated cardiac disorders. COVID-19 vaccine-associated myocardial injury can be caused by an inflammatory immune cell infiltrate, but other etiologies such as microvascular thrombosis are also possible. The clinical diagnosis is typically based on symptoms and cardiac magnetic resonance imaging. Endomyocardial biopsy is confirmatory for myocarditis, but may not show an inflammatory infiltrate because of rapid resolution or a non-inflammatory etiology. Myocarditis associated with SARS-COVID-19 vaccines occurs primarily with mRNA platform vaccines, which are also the most effective. In persons aged >16 or >12 years the myocarditis estimated crude incidences after the first 2 doses of BNT162b2 and mRNA-1273 are approximately 1.9 and 3.5 per 100 000 individuals, respectively. These rates equate to excess incidences above control populations of approximately 1.2 (BNT162b2) and 1.9 (mRNA-1273) per 100 000 persons, which are lower than the myocarditis rate for smallpox but higher than that for influenza vaccines. In the studies that have included mRNA vaccine and SARS-COVID-19 myocarditis measured by the same methodology, the incidence rate was increased by 3.5-fold over control in COVID-19 compared with 1.5-fold for BNT162b2 and 6.2-fold for mRNA-1273. However, mortality and major morbidity are less and recovery is faster with mRNA vaccine-associated myocarditis compared to COVID-19 infection. The reasons for this include vaccine-associated myocarditis having a higher incidence in young adults and adolescents, typically no involvement of other organs in vaccine-associated myocarditis, and based on comparisons to non-COVID viral myocarditis an inherently more benign clinical course.
Assuntos
Vacinas contra COVID-19 , COVID-19 , Traumatismos Cardíacos , Miocardite , Adolescente , Humanos , Adulto Jovem , Vacina de mRNA-1273 contra 2019-nCoV , Vacina BNT162 , COVID-19/prevenção & controle , Vacinas contra COVID-19/efeitos adversos , Traumatismos Cardíacos/etiologia , Miocardite/epidemiologia , Miocardite/etiologia , SARS-CoV-2 , Vacinação/efeitos adversosRESUMO
Background Cardiac adrenergic receptor gene polymorphisms have the potential to influence risk of developing ventricular fibrillation (VF) during ST-segment-elevation myocardial infarction, but no previous study has comprehensively investigated those most likely to alter norepinephrine release, signal transduction, or biased signaling. Methods and Results In a case-control study, we recruited 953 patients with ST-segment-elevation myocardial infarction without previous cardiac history, 477 with primary VF, and 476 controls without VF, and genotyped them for ADRB1 Arg389Gly and Ser49Gly, ADRB2 Gln27Glu and Gly16Arg, and ADRA2C Ins322-325Del. Within each minor allele-containing genotype, haplotype, or 2-genotype combination, patients with incident VF were compared with non-VF controls by odds ratios (OR) of variant frequencies referenced against major allele homozygotes. Of 156 investigated genetic constructs, 19 (12.2%) exhibited significantly (P<0.05) reduced association with incident VF, and none was associated with increased VF risk except for ADRB1 Gly389 homozygotes in the subset of patients not receiving ß-blockers. ADRB1 Gly49 carriers (prevalence 23.0%) had an OR (95% CI) of 0.70 (0.49-0.98), and the ADRA2C 322-325 deletion (Del) carriers (prevalence 13.5%) had an OR of 0.61 (0.39-0.94). When present in genotype combinations (8 each), both ADRB1 Gly49 carriers (OR, 0.67 [0.56-0.80]) and ADRA2C Del carriers (OR, 0.57 [0.45- 0.71]) were associated with reduced VF risk. Conclusions In ST-segment-elevation myocardial infarction, the adrenergic receptor minor alleles ADRB1 Gly49, whose encoded receptor undergoes enhanced agonist-mediated internalization and ß-arrestin interactions leading to cardioprotective biased signaling, and ADRA2C Del322-325, whose receptor causes disinhibition of norepinephrine release, are associated with a lower incidence of VF. Registration URL: https://clinicaltrials.gov; Unique identifier: NCT00859300.
Assuntos
Infarto do Miocárdio com Supradesnível do Segmento ST , Fibrilação Ventricular , Humanos , Fibrilação Ventricular/diagnóstico , Fibrilação Ventricular/epidemiologia , Fibrilação Ventricular/genética , Estudos de Casos e Controles , Polimorfismo Genético , Receptores Adrenérgicos/genética , NorepinefrinaRESUMO
BACKGROUND: Organ fibrosis due to excessive production of extracellular matrix by resident fibroblasts is estimated to contribute to >45% of deaths in the Western world, including those due to cardiovascular diseases such as heart failure. Here, we screened for small molecule inhibitors with a common ability to suppress activation of fibroblasts across organ systems. METHODS: High-content imaging of cultured cardiac, pulmonary, and renal fibroblasts was used to identify nontoxic compounds that blocked induction of markers of activation in response to the profibrotic stimulus, transforming growth factor-ß1. SW033291, which inhibits the eicosanoid-degrading enzyme, 15-hydroxyprostaglandin dehydrogenase, was chosen for follow-up studies with cultured adult rat ventricular fibroblasts and human cardiac fibroblasts (CF), and for evaluation in mouse models of cardiac fibrosis and diastolic dysfunction. Additional mechanistic studies were performed with CFs treated with exogenous eicosanoids. RESULTS: Nine compounds, including SW033291, shared a common ability to suppress transforming growth factor-ß1-mediated activation of cardiac, pulmonary, and renal fibroblasts. SW033291 dose-dependently inhibited transforming growth factor-ß1-induced expression of activation markers (eg, α-smooth muscle actin and periostin) in adult rat ventricular fibroblasts and normal human CFs, and reduced contractile capacity of the cells. Remarkably, the 15-hydroxyprostaglandin dehydrogenase inhibitor also reversed constitutive activation of fibroblasts obtained from explanted hearts from patients with heart failure. SW033291 blocked cardiac fibrosis induced by angiotensin II infusion and ameliorated diastolic dysfunction in an alternative model of systemic hypertension driven by combined uninephrectomy and deoxycorticosterone acetate administration. Mechanistically, SW033291-mediated stimulation of extracellular signal-regulated kinase 1/2 mitogen-activated protein kinase signaling was required for the compound to block CF activation. Of the 12 exogenous eicosanoids that were tested, only 12(S)-hydroxyeicosatetraenoic acid, which signals through the G protein-coupled receptor, GPR31, recapitulated the suppressive effects of SW033291 on CF activation. CONCLUSIONS: Inhibition of degradation of eicosanoids, arachidonic acid-derived fatty acids that signal through G protein-coupled receptors, is a potential therapeutic strategy for suppression of pathological organ fibrosis. In the heart, we propose that 15-hydroxyprostaglandin dehydrogenase inhibition triggers CF-derived autocrine/paracrine signaling by eicosanoids, including 12(S)-hydroxyeicosatetraenoic acid, to stimulate extracellular signal-regulated kinase 1/2 and block conversion of fibroblasts into activated cells that secrete excessive amounts of extracellular matrix and contribute to heart failure pathogenesis.
Assuntos
Insuficiência Cardíaca , Camundongos , Ratos , Humanos , Animais , Fator de Crescimento Transformador beta1/metabolismo , Proteína Quinase 3 Ativada por Mitógeno/metabolismo , Miocárdio/metabolismo , Insuficiência Cardíaca/metabolismo , Fibroblastos/metabolismo , Fibrose , Células CultivadasRESUMO
SARS CoV-2 enters host cells via its Spike protein moiety binding to the essential cardiac enzyme angiotensin-converting enzyme (ACE) 2, followed by internalization. COVID-19 mRNA vaccines are RNA sequences that are translated into Spike protein, which follows the same ACE2-binding route as the intact virion. In model systems, isolated Spike protein can produce cell damage and altered gene expression, and myocardial injury or myocarditis can occur during COVID-19 or after mRNA vaccination. We investigated 7 COVID-19 and 6 post-mRNA vaccination patients with myocardial injury and found nearly identical alterations in gene expression that would predispose to inflammation, coagulopathy, and myocardial dysfunction.
RESUMO
BACKGROUND: Abnormalities in Ca2+ homeostasis are associated with cardiac arrhythmias and heart failure. Triadin plays an important role in Ca2+ homeostasis in cardiomyocytes. Alternative splicing of a single triadin gene produces multiple triadin isoforms. The cardiac-predominant isoform, mouse MT-1 or human Trisk32, is encoded by triadin exons 1 to 8. In humans, mutations in the triadin gene that lead to a reduction in Trisk32 levels in the heart can cause cardiac dysfunction and arrhythmias. Decreased levels of Trisk32 in the heart are also common in patients with heart failure. However, mechanisms that maintain triadin isoform composition in the heart remain elusive. METHODS: We analyzed triadin expression in heart explants from patients with heart failure and cardiac arrhythmias and in hearts from mice carrying a knockout allele for Trdn-as, a cardiomyocyte-specific long noncoding RNA encoded by the antisense strand of the triadin gene, between exons 9 and 11. Catecholamine challenge with isoproterenol was performed on Trdn-as knockout mice to assess the role of Trdn-as in cardiac arrhythmogenesis, as assessed by ECG. Ca2+ transients in adult mouse cardiomyocytes were measured with the IonOptix platform or the GCaMP system. Biochemistry assays, single-molecule fluorescence in situ hybridization, subcellular localization imaging, RNA sequencing, and molecular rescue assays were used to investigate the mechanisms by which Trdn-as regulates cardiac function and triadin levels in the heart. RESULTS: We report that Trdn-as maintains cardiac function, at least in part, by regulating alternative splicing of the triadin gene. Knockout of Trdn-as in mice downregulates cardiac triadin, impairs Ca2+ handling, and causes premature death. Trdn-as knockout mice are susceptible to cardiac arrhythmias in response to catecholamine challenge. Normalization of cardiac triadin levels in Trdn-as knockout cardiomyocytes is sufficient to restore Ca2+ handling. Last, Trdn-as colocalizes and interacts with serine/arginine splicing factors in cardiomyocyte nuclei and is essential for efficient recruitment of splicing factors to triadin precursor mRNA. CONCLUSIONS: These findings reveal regulation of alternative splicing as a novel mechanism by which a long noncoding RNA controls cardiac function. This study indicates potential therapeutics for heart disease by targeting the long noncoding RNA or pathways regulating alternative splicing.
Assuntos
Processamento Alternativo , Proteínas de Transporte , Insuficiência Cardíaca , Proteínas Musculares , RNA Longo não Codificante , Animais , Arritmias Cardíacas , Proteínas de Transporte/genética , Catecolaminas , Coração/fisiologia , Insuficiência Cardíaca/genética , Insuficiência Cardíaca/metabolismo , Humanos , Hibridização in Situ Fluorescente , Peptídeos e Proteínas de Sinalização Intracelular/metabolismo , Camundongos , Camundongos Knockout , Proteínas Musculares/genética , Proteínas Musculares/metabolismo , Miócitos Cardíacos/metabolismo , Isoformas de Proteínas/genética , Isoformas de Proteínas/metabolismo , Fatores de Processamento de RNA/genética , Fatores de Processamento de RNA/metabolismo , RNA Longo não Codificante/genéticaRESUMO
AIMS: Cardiac resynchronization therapy (CRT) reduces morbidity and mortality for patients with heart failure, reduced left ventricular ejection fraction, QRS duration >130 ms and in sinus rhythm. The aim of this study was to identify patient characteristics that predict the effect, specifically, of CRT pacemakers (CRT-P) on all-cause mortality or the composite of hospitalization for heart failure or all-cause mortality. METHODS AND RESULTS: We conducted an individual patient data meta-analysis of the Comparison of Medical Therapy, Pacing, and Defibrillation in Heart Failure (COMPANION) and Cardiac Resynchronization-Heart Failure (CARE-HF) trials. Only patients assigned to CRT-P or control (n = 1738) were included in order to avoid confounding from concomitant defibrillator therapy. The influence of baseline characteristics on treatment effects was investigated. Median age was 67 (59-73) years, most patients were men (70%), 68% had a QRS duration of 150-199 ms and 80% had left bundle branch block. Patients assigned to CRT-P had lower rates for all-cause mortality (hazard ratio [HR] 0.68, 95% confidence interval [CI] 0.56-0.81; p < 0.0001) and the composite outcome (HR 0.67, 95% CI 0.58-0.78; p < 0.0001). No pre-specified characteristic, including sex, aetiology of ventricular dysfunction, QRS duration (within the studied range) or morphology or PR interval significantly influenced the effect of CRT-P on all-cause mortality or the composite outcome. However, CRT-P had a greater effect on the composite outcome for patients with lower body surface area and those prescribed beta-blockers. CONCLUSIONS: Cardiac resynchronization therapy-pacemaker reduces morbidity and mortality in appropriately selected patients with heart failure. Benefits may be greater in smaller patients and in those receiving beta-blockers. Neither QRS duration nor morphology independently predicted the benefit of CRT-P. CLINICAL TRIAL REGISTRATION: COMPANION, NCT00180258; CARE-HF, NCT00170300.
Assuntos
Terapia de Ressincronização Cardíaca , Desfibriladores Implantáveis , Insuficiência Cardíaca , Antagonistas Adrenérgicos beta , Idoso , Terapia de Ressincronização Cardíaca/métodos , Desfibriladores , Feminino , Insuficiência Cardíaca/epidemiologia , Insuficiência Cardíaca/terapia , Humanos , Masculino , Morbidade , Volume Sistólico , Resultado do Tratamento , Função Ventricular EsquerdaRESUMO
BACKGROUND: Heart failure (HF) patients with atrial fibrillation (AF) often have conduction system disorders, which may be worsened by ß-blocker therapy. OBJECTIVE: In a post hoc analysis we examined the prevalence of bradycardia and its association with adverse events (AEs) and failure to achieve target dose in the GENETIC-AF trial. METHODS: Patients randomized to metoprolol (n = 125) or bucindolol (n = 131) entering 24-week efficacy follow-up and receiving study medication were evaluated. Bradycardia was defined as an electrocardiogram (ECG) heart rate (HR) <60 beats per minute (bpm) and severe bradycardia <50 bpm. RESULTS: Mean HR in sinus rhythm (SR) was 62.6 ± 12.5 bpm for metoprolol and 68.3 ± 11.1 bpm for bucindolol (P < .0001), but in AF HRs were not different (87.5 bpm vs 89.7 bpm, respectively). Episodes per patient for bucindolol vs metoprolol were 0.82 vs 2.08 (P < .001) for bradycardia and 0.24 vs 0.57 for severe bradycardia (P < .001), with 98.9% of the episodes occurring in SR. Patients experiencing bradycardia had a 4.15-fold higher prevalence of study medication dose reduction (P <.0001) compared to patients without bradycardia. Fewer patients receiving metoprolol were at target dose (61.7% vs 74.9% for bucindolol, P < .0001) at ECG recordings, and bradycardia AEs were more prevalent in the metoprolol group (13 vs 1 for bucindolol, P = .001). On multivariate analysis of 21 candidate bradycardia predictors including presence of a device with pacing capability, bucindolol treatment was associated with the greatest degree of prevention (Zodds ratio -4.24, P < .0001). CONCLUSION: In AF-prone HF patients bradycardia may limit the effectiveness of ß blockers, and this property is agent-dependent.