Potential business model for a European vaccine R&D infrastructure and its estimated socio-economic impact.

Background: Research infrastructures are facilities or resources that have proven fundamental for supporting scientific research and innovation. However, they are also known to be very expensive in their establishment, operation and maintenance. As by far the biggest share of these costs is always borne by public funders, there is a strong interest and indeed a necessity to develop alternative business models for such infrastructures that allow them to function in a more sustainable manner that is less dependent on public financing. Methods: In this article, we describe a feasibility study we have undertaken to develop a potentially sustainable business model for a vaccine research and development (R&D) infrastructure. The model we have developed integrates two different types of business models that would provide the infrastructure with two different types of revenue streams which would facilitate its establishment and would be a measure of risk reduction. For the business model we are proposing, we have undertaken an ex ante impact assessment that estimates the expected impact for a vaccine R&D infrastructure based on the proposed models along three different dimensions: health, society and economy. Results: Our impact assessment demonstrates that such a vaccine R&D infrastructure could achieve a very significant socio-economic impact, and so its establishment is therefore considered worthwhile pursuing. Conclusions: The business model we have developed, the impact assessment and the overall process we have followed might also be of interest to other research infrastructure initiatives in the biomedical field.

A novel asexual blood-stage malaria vaccine candidate: PfRipr5 formulated with human-use adjuvants induces potent growth inhibitory antibodies.

PfRipr is a highly conserved asexual-blood stage malaria vaccine candidate against Plasmodium falciparum. PfRipr5, a protein fragment of PfRipr inducing the most potent inhibitory antibodies, is a promising candidate for the development of next-generation malaria vaccines, requiring validation of its potential when formulated with adjuvants already approved for human use. In this study, PfRipr5 antigen was efficiently produced in a tank bioreactor using insect High Five cells and the baculovirus expression vector system; purified PfRipr5 was thermally stable in its monomeric form, had high purity and binding capacity to functional monoclonal anti-PfRipr antibody. The formulation of purified PfRipr5 with Alhydrogel®, GLA-SE or CAF®01 adjuvants accepted for human use showed acceptable compatibility. Rabbits immunized with these formulations induced comparable levels of anti-PfRipr5 antibodies, and significantly higher than the control group immunized with PfRipr5 alone. To investigate the efficacy of the antibodies, we used an in vitro parasite growth inhibition assay (GIA). The highest average GIA activity amongst all groups was attained with antibodies induced by immunization with PfRipr5 formulated with CAF®01. Overall, this study validates the potential of adjuvanted PfRipr5 as an asexual blood-stage malaria vaccine candidate, with PfRipr5/CAF®01 being a promising formulation for subsequent pre-clinical and clinical development.

Asexual Blood-Stage Malaria Vaccine Candidate PfRipr5: Enhanced Production in Insect Cells.

The malaria asexual blood-stage antigen PfRipr and its most immunogenic fragment PfRipr5 have recently risen as promising vaccine candidates against this infectious disease. Continued development of high-yielding, scalable production platforms is essential to advance the malaria vaccine research. Insect cells have supplied the production of numerous vaccine antigens in a fast and cost-effective manner; improving this platform further could prove key to its wider use. In this study, insect (Sf9 and High Five) and human (HEK293) cell hosts as well as process-optimizing strategies (new baculovirus construct designs and a culture temperature shift to hypothermic conditions) were employed to improve the production of the malaria asexual blood-stage vaccine candidate PfRipr5. Protein expression was maximized using High Five cells at CCI of 2 × 106 cell/mL and MOI of 0.1 pfu/cell (production yield = 0.49 mg/ml), with high-purity PfRipr5 binding to a conformational anti-PfRipr monoclonal antibody known to hold GIA activity and parasite PfRipr staining capacity. Further improvements in the PfRipr5 expression were achieved by designing novel expression vector sequences and performing a culture temperature shift to hypothermic culture conditions. Addition of one alanine (A) amino acid residue adjacent to the signal peptide cleavage site and a glycine-serine linker (GGSGG) between the PfRipr5 sequence and the purification tag (His6) induced a 2.2-fold increase in the expression of secreted PfRipr5 over using the expression vector with none of these additions. Performing a culture temperature shift from the standard 27-22°C at the time of infection improved the PfRipr5 expression by up to 1.7 fold. Notably, a synergistic effect was attained when combining both strategies, enabling to increase production yield post-purification by 5.2 fold, with similar protein quality (i.e., purity and binding to anti-PfRipr monoclonal antibody). This work highlights the potential of insect cells to produce the PfRipr5 malaria vaccine candidate and the importance of optimizing the expression vector and culture conditions to boost the expression of secreted proteins.

A gaps-and-needs analysis of vaccine R&D in Europe: Recommendations to improve the research infrastructure.

The COVID-19 pandemic has brought into sharp focus the importance of strategies supporting vaccine development. During the pandemic, TRANSVAC, the European vaccine-research-infrastructure initiative, undertook an in-depth consultation of stakeholders to identify how best to position and sustain a European vaccine R&D infrastructure. The consultation included an online survey incorporating a gaps-and-needs analysis, follow-up interviews and focus-group meetings. Between October 2020 and June 2021, 53 organisations completed the online survey, including 24 research institutes and universities, and 9 pharmaceutical companies; 24 organisations participated in interviews, and 14 in focus-group meetings. The arising recommendations covered all aspects of the vaccine-development value chain: from preclinical development to financing and business development; and covered prophylactic and therapeutic vaccines, for both human and veterinary indications. Overall, the recommendations supported the expansion and elaboration of services including training programmes, and improved or more extensive access to expertise, technologies, partnerships, curated databases, and-data analysis tools. Funding and financing featured as critical elements requiring support throughout the vaccine-development programmes, notably for academics and small companies, and for vaccine programmes that address medical and veterinary needs without a great potential for commercial gain. Centralizing the access to these research infrastructures via a single on-line portal was considered advantageous.

Controlled Human Infection Studies: Proposals for guidance on how to design, develop and produce a challenge strain.

There is an increasing need to establish quality principles for designing, developing and manufacturing challenge agents as currently these agents are classified differently by various jurisdictions. Indeed, considerations for challenge agent manufacturing vary between countries due to differences in regulatory oversight, the categorization of the challenge agent and incorporation into medicinal/vaccine development processes. To this end, a whitepaper on the guidance has been produced and disseminated for consultation to researchers, regulatory experts and regulatory or advisory bodies. This document is intended to discuss fundamental principles of selection, characterization, manufacture, quality control and storage of challenge agents for international reference. In the development phase, CMC documentation is needed for a candidate challenge agent, while standard operating procedure documentation is needed to monitor and control the manufacturing process, followed by use of qualified methods to test critical steps in the manufacturing process, or the final product itself. These activities are complementary: GMP rules, which intervene only at the time of the routine manufacturing of batches, do not contribute to the proper development and qualification of the candidate product. Some considerations regarding suitability of premises for challenge manufacturing was discussed in the presentation dedicated to "routine manufacturing".

Animal testing for vaccines. Implementing replacement, reduction and refinement: challenges and priorities.

Transition to in vitro alternative methods from in vivo in vaccine release testing and characterization, the implementation of the consistency approach, and a drive towards international harmonization of regulatory requirements are most pressing needs in the field of vaccines. It is critical for global vaccine community to work together to secure effective progress towards animal welfare and to ensure that vaccines of ever higher quality can reach the populations in need in the shortest possible timeframe. Advancements in the field, case studies, and experiences from Low and Middle Income Countries (LMIC) were the topics discussed by an international gathering of experts during a recent conference titled "Animal Testing for Vaccines - Implementing Replacement, Reduction and Refinement: Challenges and Priorities". This conference was organized by the International Alliance for Biological Standardization (IABS), and held in Bangkok, Thailand on December 3 and 4 2019. Participants comprised stakeholders from many parts of the world, including vaccine developers, manufacturers and regulators from Asia, Europe, North America, Australia and New Zealand. In interactive workshops and vibrant panel discussions, the attendees worked together to identify the remaining barriers to validation, acceptance and implementation of alternative methods, and how harmonization could be promoted, especially for LMICs.

Pipeline analysis of a vaccine candidate portfolio for diseases of poverty using the Portfolio-To-Impact modelling tool.

Background: The Portfolio-To-Impact (P2I) P2I model is a recently developed product portfolio tool that enables users to estimate the funding needs to move a portfolio of candidate health products, such as vaccines and drugs, along the product development path from late stage preclinical to phase III clinical trials, as well as potential product launches over time. In this study we describe the use of this tool for analysing the vaccine portfolio of the European Vaccine Initiative (EVI). This portfolio includes vaccine candidates for various diseases of poverty and emerging infectious diseases at different stages of development. Methods: Portfolio analyses were conducted using the existing assumptions integrated in the P2I tool, as well as modified assumptions for costs, cycle times, and probabilities of success based on EVI's own internal data related to vaccine development. Results: According to the P2I tool, the total estimated cost to move the 18 candidates currently in the EVI portfolio along the pipeline to launch would be about US $470 million, and there would be 0.69 cumulative expected launches during the period 2019-2031. Running of the model using EVI-internal parameters resulted in a significant increase in the expected product launches. Conclusions: The P2I tool's underlying assumptions could not be tested in our study due to lack of data available. Nevertheless, we expect that the accelerated clinical testing of vaccines (and drugs) based on the use of controlled human infection models that are increasingly available, as well as the accelerated approval by regulatory authorities that exists for example for serious conditions, will speed up product development and result in significant cost reduction. Project findings as well as potential future modifications of the P2I tool are discussed with the aim to improve the underlying methodology of the P2I model.

Recommendations of the VAC2VAC workshop on the design of multi-centre validation studies.

Within the Innovative Medicines Initiative 2 (IMI 2) project VAC2VAC (Vaccine batch to vaccine batch comparison by consistency testing), a workshop has been organised to discuss ways of improving the design of multi-centre validation studies and use the data generated for product-specific validation purposes. Moreover, aspects of validation within the consistency approach context were addressed. This report summarises the discussions and outlines the conclusions and recommendations agreed on by the workshop participants.

A mouse monoclonal antibody to the TSHR.

INTRODUCTION: Mouse monoclonal antibodies (mAbs) with the ability to inhibit thyrotropin (TSH) binding to the TSH receptor (TSHR) are useful tools to study TSH-TSHR interaction. The 3C3 mAb we produced was found to inhibit binding of TSH to human (h)TSHR but not to porcine (p)TSHR. MATERIAL/METHODS: Purified 3C3 immunoglobulin G (IgG) and its antibody-binding fragment were prepared using standard methods and their ability to inhibit TSH binding to hTSHR or pTSHR was analyzed using a coated tube assay. The TSHR epitope reactive with 3C3 IgG was determined using Western blotting, ELISA based on peptides corresponding to the TSHR sequence, and the SPOT synthesis technique. RNA was isolated from 3C3 hybridoma cells and the mAb variable (V) region genes were sequenced and analyzed. RESULTS: 3C3 mAb had a 1 x 108 l/mol binding affinity to the hTSHR as assessed by Scatchard analysis. 3C3 reacted with the hTSHR region between amino acids (aa) 212-230, and two aa differences were found between the corresponding regions in the hTSHR and pTSHR. The light chain (LC) genes of 3C3 were derived from the Vk21 germ-line (97.6% homology) and Jk2 genes. The heavy chain (HC) genes were from the V130 germ-line (94.6% homology) combined with a D gene (not identified) and JH3 gene. The replacement/ silent mutation ratios of 6.0 and 6.5 for the LC and the HC V regions, respectively, indicated that 3C3 underwent antigen-driven maturation. CONCLUSIONS: Mouse mAbs of this type should be useful in studying the interactions between the TSHR, TSH, and mAbs in more detail.

Monoclonal antibody IAC-1 is specific for activated alpha2beta1 and binds to amino acids 199 to 201 of the integrin alpha2 I-domain.

In this study we describe the first monoclonal antibody, integrin activated conformation-1 (IAC-1), to recognize the active form of the platelet-collagen receptor, the integrin alpha(2)beta(1). IAC-1 has the following properties: (1) IAC-1 fails to bind to resting platelets but readily interacts with platelets stimulated by the glycoprotein VI-specific agonist, convulxin, and by other agonists; (2) similar concentration response relationships for binding of IAC-1 and soluble collagen were observed in convulxin-stimulated platelets; (3) the epitope for IAC-1 is T199Y200K201, which is located at the opposite site of the metal ion-dependent adhesion site in a region not involved in the I-domain "shifts" that occur upon ligand binding; (4) IAC-1 strongly binds to recombinant alpha(2) I-domain, therefore suggesting that the neo-epitope appears to be exposed by an "unmasking" of I-domain-covering regions upon activation; (5) IAC-1 binds to platelets during adhesion to collagen under shear conditions, demonstrating activation of alpha(2)beta(1); (6) as IAC-1 does not interfere with platelet-collagen binding, it defines a new class of antibodies that is distinct from those belonging to the "cation- and ligand-induced binding sites" (CLIBSs) and the "ligand mimetic" group. These characteristics make IAC-1 a very powerful tool to study alpha(2)beta(1) activation under dynamic and physiologically relevant conditions.

Analysis of the thyrotropin receptor-thyrotropin interaction by comparative modeling.

We have used the most advanced programs currently available to construct the first three-domain structure of the human thyrotropin receptor (TSHR) using comparative modeling. The model consists of a leucine-rich domain (LRD; amino acids 36-281; porcine ribonuclease inhibitor used as a template for modeling), a cleavage domain (CD; amino acids 282-409; tissue inhibitor of matrix metalloproteinases 2 as template) and transmembrane domain (TMD amino acids 410-699; bovine rhodopsin as template). Models of human, porcine, and bovine TSH were also constructed (human chorionic gonadotropin [hCG] and human follicle stimulating hormone [hFSH] as templates). The LRD has a characteristic horseshoe shape with 10 tandem homologous repeats. The CD consists of beta-barrel and alpha helix structures (OB-like fold) with two disulfide bridges and the structure around these disulfide bridges remains stable after cleavage. The TMD presents the typical seven membrane-spanning helices. The TSH, LRD, CD, and TMD models were brought together in an extensive series of docking experiments. Known features of the TSH-TSHR interaction were used for selection of appropriate complexes that were then validated using a different set of experimental data. A similar approach was used to build a model of a complex between the TSHR and a monoclonal TSHR antibody with weak thyroid stimulating activity. Human thyrotropin (hTSH) alpha chains were found to make contact with many amino acids on the LRD surface and CD surface whereas no interaction between the beta chains and the CD were found. The higher affinity of bovine thyrotropin (bTSH) and porcine thyrotropin (pTSH) (relative to hTSH) for the TSHR is explained well by the models in terms of charge-charge interactions between their alpha chains and the receptor. Experimental observations showing increased sensitivity of the TSHR to hCG after mutation of TSHR Lys209 to Glu are explained well by our model. Furthermore, several mutations in the TMD that are associated with increased TSHR basal activity are predicted from our model to be caused by the formation of new interactions that stabilize the activated form of the TMD.

A consensus tetrapeptide selected by phage display adopts the conformation of a dominant discontinuous epitope of a monoclonal anti-VWF antibody that inhibits the von Willebrand factor-collagen interaction.

Monoclonal antibody (mAb) 82D6A3 is an anti-von Willebrand factor (VWF) mAb directed against the A3-domain of VWF that inhibits the VWF binding to fibrillar collagens type I and III in vitro and in vivo. To identify the discontinuous epitope of this mAb, we used phage display, mutant analysis, and peptide modeling. All 82D6A3-binding phages displayed peptides containing the consensus sequence SPWR that could be aligned with P981W982 in the VWF A3-domain. Next, the binding of mAb 82D6A3 to 27 Ala mutants with mutations in the A3-domain of VWF revealed that amino acids Arg963, Pro981, Asp1009, Arg1016, Ser1020, Met1022, and His1023 are part of the epitope of mAb 82D6A3. Inspection of residues Ser1020, Arg1016, Pro981, and Trp982 in the three-dimensional structure of the A3-domain demonstrated that these residues are close together in space, pointing out that the structure of the SPWR consensus sequence might mimic this discontinuous epitope. Modeling of a cyclic 6-mer peptide containing the consensus sequence and superposition of its three-dimensional structure onto the VWF A3-domain demonstrated that the Ser and Arg in the peptide matched the Ser1020 and Arg1016 in the A3-domain. The Pro residue of the peptide served as a spacer, and the side chain of the Trp pointed in the direction of Trp982. In conclusion, to our knowledge, this is the first report where a modeled peptide containing a consensus sequence could be fitted onto the three-dimensional structure of the antigen, indicating that it might adopt the conformation of the discontinuous epitope.

Inhibition of the von Willebrand (VWF)-collagen interaction by an antihuman VWF monoclonal antibody results in abolition of in vivo arterial platelet thrombus formation in baboons.

The interaction between collagen, von Willebrand factor (VWF), and glycoprotein Ib is the first step in hemostasis and thrombosis especially under high shear conditions. We studied the inhibition of the VWF-collagen interaction by using an antihuman VWF monoclonal antibody 82D6A3 to prevent arterial thrombosis in baboons to develop a new kind of antithrombotic strategy and determine for the first time experimental in vivo data concerning the importance of the collagen-VWF interaction. We used a modified Folts model to study the antithrombotic efficacy of 82D6A3, where cyclic flow reductions (CFRs) were measured in the femoral artery. Administering a dose of 100, 300, and 600 microg/kg resulted in a 58.3%, 100%, and 100% reduction in the CFRs, respectively. When 100 microg/kg 82D6A3 was infused into the baboons, 80% of VWF-A3 domain was occupied, corresponding to 30% to 36% ex vivo inhibition of VWF binding to collagen, with no prolongation of the bleeding time. The bleeding time was also not significantly prolonged when the CFRs were abolished at doses of 300 microg/kg and 600 microg/kg. At these doses 100% of VWF was occupied by the antibody and 100% ex vivo inhibition of the VWF-collagen binding was observed. 82D6A3 has a high affinity for VWF; after 48 hours still 68% VWF (300 microg/kg) was occupied with a pharmacologic effect up to 5 hours after administration (80%-100% occupancy). In conclusion, these results clearly indicate that the VWF-collagen interaction is important in vivo in thrombosis under high shear conditions and thus might be a new target for preventing arterial thrombosis.

Thyroid-stimulating monoclonal antibodies.

Thyrotropin (TSH) receptor monoclonal antibodies (TSHR mAbs) were obtained from cDNA-immunized NMRI mice. Three mAb immunoglobulin Gs (IgGs) (TSmAbs 1-3) that had distinct V(H )and V(L) region sequences stimulated cyclic adenosine monophosphate (cAMP) production in isolated porcine thyroid cells greater than 10x basal and as little as 20 ng/mL (0.13 nmol/L) of TSmAb 1 IgG caused a 2x basal stimulation. TSmAb 1 and 2 Fab fragments were also effective stimulators and thyroid-stimulating activities of the IgGs and Fabs were confirmed using TSHR transfected Chinese hamster ovary (CHO) cells. The TSmAbs also inhibited (125)I-labeled TSH binding to TSHR-coated tubes by 50% or more at concentrations of 1 microg/mL or less and gave 15%-20% inhibition at 20-50 ng/mL. (125)I-labeled TSmAbs bound to TSHR-coated tubes with high affinity (approximately 10(10) L/mol) and this binding was inhibited by TSHR autoantibodies with both TSH agonist and antagonist activities. Inhibition of labeled TSmAb binding by Graves' sera correlated well with inhibition of TSH binding (r = 0.96; n = 18; p < 0.001 for TSmAb 2). The TSmAbs have considerable potential as (1) new probes for TSHR structure-function studies, (2) reagents for new assays for TSHR autoantibodies, and (3) alternatives to recombinant TSH in various in vivo applications.

Characterization of the thyrotropin binding pocket.

A panel of monoclonal antibodies (mAbs) to the thyrotropin receptor (TSHR) was prepared using three different immunization strategies. The mAbs obtained (n = 138) reacted with linear epitopes covering most of the TSHR extracellular domain and with conformational epitopes. mAbs that bound to five different regions of the TSHR (amino acids [aa] 32-41, aa 36-42, aa 246-260, aa 277-296, and aa 381-385) were able to inhibit (125)I-labeled thyrotropin (TSH) binding to solubilized TSHR preparations. Fab and immunoglobulin G (IgG) preparations were similarly effective inhibitors for mAbs reactive with aa 246-260, aa 277-291 and aa 381-385 suggesting that these three regions of the TSHR are involved in TSH binding. In contrast mAbs reactive with aa 32-41 and aa 36-42 were not effective at inhibiting TSH binding when Fab preparations were used, suggesting that these N terminal regions of the TSHR were less critical for TSH binding. Our studies suggest that three distinct and discontinuous regions of the TSHR (aa 246-260 and 277-296 on the TSHR A subunit) and aa 381-385 (on the TSHR B subunit) fold together to form a complex TSH binding pocket. Alignment of the aa sequences of these three regions in TSHRs from different species indicates that they are highly conserved.