Identifying assessment criteria for in vitro studies: a method and item bank.

To support the development of appraisal tools for assessing the quality of in vitro studies, we developed a method for literature-based discovery of study assessment criteria, used the method to create an item bank of assessment criteria of potential relevance to in vitro studies, and analyzed the item bank to discern and critique current approaches for appraisal of in vitro studies. We searched four research indexes and included any document that identified itself as an appraisal tool for in vitro studies, was a systematic review that included a critical appraisal step, or was a reporting checklist for in vitro studies. We abstracted, normalized, and categorized all criteria applied by the included appraisal tools to create an "item bank" database of issues relevant to the assessment of in vitro studies. The resulting item bank consists of 676 unique appraisal concepts from 67 appraisal tools. We believe this item bank is the single most comprehensive resource of its type to date, should be of high utility for future tool development exercises, and provides a robust methodology for grounding tool development in the existing literature. While we set out to develop an item bank specifically targeting in vitro studies, we found that many of the assessment concepts we discovered are readily applicable to other study designs. Item banks can be of significant value as a resource; however, there are important challenges in developing, maintaining, and extending them of which researchers should be aware.

Encapsulation of Pseudomonas aeruginosa elastase inside the P22 virus-like particle for controlling enzyme-substrate interactions.

Controlling interactions between enzymes and interaction partners, such as substrates, is important for applications in cellular biology and molecular biochemistry. A strategy for controlling enzyme access with substrate interaction partners is to exploit encapsulation of enzymes inside nanoparticles to limit the accessibility of the enzymes to large macromolecules, but allow free exchange of small-molecule substrates. The research here evaluates the encapsulation of Pseudomonas aeruginosa elastase inside the bacteriophage P22 virus-like particle (VLP) to examine the ability to allow free soluble substrates access to the enzyme while blocking large macromolecular substrate interactions. The results show that the active elastase protease can be encapsulated inside the P22 VLP, which blocks its ability to disrupt cell monolayers, but allows soluble substrates to be catalytically cleaved, supporting the viability of this approach for future investigations.