Effect of Direction and Frequency of Skull Motion on Mechanical Vulnerability of the Human Brain.

Strain energy and kinetic energy in the human brain were estimated by magnetic resonance elastography (MRE) during harmonic excitation of the head, and compared to characterize the effect of loading direction and frequency on brain deformation. In brain MRE, shear waves are induced by external vibration of the skull and imaged by a modified MR imaging sequence; the resulting harmonic displacement fields are typically "inverted" to estimate mechanical properties, like stiffness or damping. However, measurements of tissue motion from MRE also illuminate key features of the response of the brain to skull loading. In this study, harmonic excitation was applied in two different directions and at five different frequencies from 20 to 90 Hz. Lateral loading induced primarily left-right head motion and rotation in the axial plane; occipital loading induced anterior-posterior head motion and rotation in the sagittal plane. The ratio of strain energy to kinetic energy (SE/KE) depended strongly on both direction and frequency. The ratio of SE/KE was approximately four times larger for lateral excitation than for occipital excitation and was largest at the lowest excitation frequencies studied. These results are consistent with clinical observations that suggest lateral impacts are more likely to cause injury than occipital or frontal impacts, and also with observations that the brain has low-frequency (∼10 Hz) natural modes of oscillation. The SE/KE ratio from brain MRE is potentially a simple and powerful dimensionless metric of brain vulnerability to deformation and injury.

Comparison of Deformation Patterns Excited in the Human Brain In Vivo by Harmonic and Impulsive Skull Motion.

Noninvasive measurements of brain deformation in human participants in vivo are needed to develop models of brain biomechanics and understand traumatic brain injury (TBI). Tagged magnetic resonance imaging (tagged MRI) and magnetic resonance elastography (MRE) are two techniques to study human brain deformation; these techniques differ in the type of motion and difficulty of implementation. In this study, oscillatory strain fields in the human brain caused by impulsive head acceleration and measured by tagged MRI were compared quantitatively to strain fields measured by MRE during harmonic head motion at 10 and 50 Hz. Strain fields were compared by registering to a common anatomical template, then computing correlations between the registered strain fields. Correlations were computed between tagged MRI strain fields in six participants and MRE strain fields at 10 Hz and 50 Hz in six different participants. Correlations among strain fields within the same experiment type were compared statistically to correlations from different experiment types. Strain fields from harmonic head motion at 10 Hz imaged by MRE were qualitatively and quantitatively similar to modes excited by impulsive head motion, imaged by tagged MRI. Notably, correlations between strain fields from 10 Hz MRE and tagged MRI did not differ significantly from correlations between strain fields from tagged MRI. These results suggest that low-frequency modes of oscillation dominate the response of the brain during impact. Thus, low-frequency MRE, which is simpler and more widely available than tagged MRI, can be used to illuminate the brain's response to head impact.