A strategy for high throughput HLA-DQ typing.

We have developed a high throughput HLA typing methodology that is a modification of the standard sequence-specific primer method. This approach is distinct from other methods using an automated DNA analyzer, as more than one gene is typed in a single lane. We have optimized the method for use on an ABI 373 automated genotyping machine. Primers were designed to preferentially amplify DNA fragments of the generic allelic groups of the DQA1 and DQB1 loci. PCR products representing alleles at the DQA1 locus were amplified using a different fluorescent dye than the PCR products from the DQB1 locus. Only three PCR reactions are required for low resolution typing of DQA1 and DQB1. Use of different labeled primers enables genotyping for both loci in a single gel lane, allowing for 64 samples to be typed at low resolution for both DQA1 and DQB1 on a single gel. Automated allele assignments were determined based on DNA migration distance through a polyacrylamide gel using a standard genotype allele-calling program. Accuracy of this method is greater than 98% for both loci. The strategy described here may be adapted to include more loci or to produce higher resolution typing of alleles encoded by these loci. It can be readily optimized for use on other slab gel or capillary electrophoresis systems.

Prospective randomized trial of azathioprine in cryopreserved valved allografts in children.

BACKGROUND: The purpose of this study was to prospectively assess the effects of azathioprine on the humoral immune response to HLA alloantigens and allograft function in children receiving cryopreserved valved allografts. METHODS: We randomized 13 children to receive azathioprine or not to receive azathioprine (controls) after receiving a cryopreserved valved allograft. Azathioprine patients received intraoperatively 4 mg/kg of azathioprine and 2.0 +/- 0.5 mg/kg once daily for 3 months after operation. Panel reactive antibodies against HLA class I and class II alloantigens were measured before, 1 month, and 3 months after operation. RESULTS: Panel reactive antibodies were not significantly different between the azathioprine and control groups before (0.0% +/- 0% versus 1.6% +/- 1%), 1 month (59% +/- 17% versus 71% +/- 12%), or 3 months (84% +/- 15% versus 96% +/- 1.3%) after operation. There were no differences in degree of allograft valve stenosis between azathioprine (31.5 +/- 26 mm Hg, 13.4 +/- 7 months postoperatively) and control groups (25.4 +/- 11 mm Hg, 17.2 +/- 10 months postoperatively) or allograft valve insufficiency. CONCLUSIONS: Azathioprine does not significantly decrease the immune response to HLA alloantigens or affect the function of cryopreserved valved allografts used in children to repair congenital heart defects.

Transplantation of ABO group A2 kidneys from living donors into group O and B recipients.

Fifteen blood group O and B recipients have been transplanted with kidneys from subtype A2 living donors since April 1992. ABO red cell grouping was performed by local licensed blood banks with A2 subtype determined using an anti-A1 lectin and, retrospectively, by a polymerase chain reaction (PCR)-based molecular method. All grafts functioned immediately and no patient has required dialysis. Three patients each experienced one reversible rejection episode. With the exception of one cardiac death at 9months and one patient with profound toxicity to calcineurin inhibitors, all allografts continue to function normally. One donor, mistyped as a group A2 using lectin, was by PCR typing an A1O1 nonsecretor; the graft continues to function normally at 30 months. Transplantation of living donor A2 renal allografts into non-A recipients produces excellent long-term allograft survival and expands the potential living donor pool for nonblood group A recipients.

A prospective analysis of the immunogenicity of cryopreserved nonvalved allografts used in pediatric heart surgery.

BACKGROUND: The purpose of this study was to prospectively determine the immunogenicity of nonvalved allograft tissue used to repair congenital heart defects. METHODS AND RESULTS: We prospectively analyzed the immune response of 11 children, 1.4 months to 10 years of age, who required nonvalved allografts to alleviate stenosis during repair of congenital heart defects. In 7 patients, pulmonary arterial grafts were used; in 3 patients, monocusp pulmonary artery grafts were used; and in 1 patient, a section of glutaraldehyde-preserved allograft pericardium was used. We measured the level of HLA panel-reactive antibody (PRA) before surgery, 1 week after, 1 month after, and 3 months after surgery. PRA was determined by the antiglobulin technique and flow cytometry. HLA class I and class II antibodies measured by either technique were negligible before and 1 week after surgery. Nine of 11 patients (82%) exhibited a significant immune response at 1 month after surgery that further increased at 3 months. The measured PRA for class I antibodies with the antiglobulin technique increased to 43+/-36% at 1 month and to 69+/-38% at 3 months after surgery. Flow cytometry class I PRA measurements were similar. Class II PRA increased to 26+/-34% at 1 month and to 41+/-36% at 3 months. Age negatively correlated with the degree of elevation of PRA, but neither allograft area nor the area indexed to patient body surface area correlated with PRA. CONCLUSIONS: Cryopreserved nonvalved allografts induce a strong HLA antibody response in the majority of children.

Class I and class II anti-HLA antibodies after implantation of cryopreserved allograft material in pediatric patients.

OBJECTIVES: Very little is known regarding the immune response to cryopreserved allograft valves and patch material used in the surgical repair of congenital heart defects. METHODS: We prospectively measured the frequency of panel reactive antibodies directed against HLA class I (HLA-A, B, and C) and class II (HLA-DR/DQ) alloantigens in 24 children receiving cryopreserved allografts. We compared them with results in 11 previously reported control patients. Sixteen of the study patients underwent placement of a valved conduit (11 pulmonic, 5 aortic) between the right ventricle and pulmonary arteries, 6 underwent patch angioplasty of stenotic vessels with cryopreserved pulmonary artery, and 2 underwent placement of a pulmonary monocusp patch. Study patients had panel reactive antibodies measured before, 1 month, 3 months, and 1 year after the operation. RESULTS: With allograft implantation, panel reactive antibodies increased from 1.9% +/- 5% before the operation to 62% +/- 33% at 31 +/- 8 days after the operation, 92% +/- 15% at 3.3 +/- 0.6 months after the operation, and 85% +/- 18% at 1.1 +/- 0.2 years after the operation. The control group showed no change in panel reactive antibodies, with a level of 1.6% +/- 1% before the operation, 3.2% +/- 1% 28 +/- 5 days after the operation, and 1.7% +/- 1% 2.7 +/- 0.3 months after the operation. Class II antibodies (anti-HLA-DR/DQ) rose to 49% +/- 35% at 30 +/- 8 days and 70% +/- 26% at 3.3 +/- 0.6 months after the operation. CONCLUSIONS: Cryopreserved allograft material induces a marked response that involves both class I and class II anti-HLA antibodies within 3 months after operation in children. This alloantibody response may represent a form of "rejection," may have implications for those who require subsequent cardiac transplantation, and may play a role in early allograft failure.

Repeat donor HLA-DR mismatches in renal transplantation: is the increased failure rate caused by noncytotoxic HLA-DR alloantibodies?

INTRODUCTION: Data from the UCLA/UNOS and Collaborative Transplant Studies Registries indicate that mismatched HLA-DR alloantigens expressed on a former donor renal allograft should not be repeated because of significantly poorer long-term survival. METHODS: Retransplant candidates waiting for another renal allograft were screened for HLA class II alloantibodies (aAb) using direct complement-dependent cytotoxicity and several sensitive aAb binding assays. RESULTS: When screened by complement-dependent cytotoxicity, 46% of the patients were aAb negative. In contrast, using aAb binding assays, 90% of the patients had HLA-DR aAb specific for previous HLA-DR allograft mismatches. Most important, no directly cytotoxic HLA-DR antibody was detected in 9 of 27 patients. CONCLUSION: Our studies suggest that crossing the same HLA-DR mismatch in a subsequent transplant may result in poorer survival due to underlying donor-specific HLA-DR aAb. If confirmed in a retrospective study of retransplant patients, B cell donor cross-matches using antiglobulin complement-dependent cytotoxicity or flow cytometry would appear essential if this barrier were to be crossed.

The humoral immune response against an HLA class I allodeterminant correlates with the HLA-DR phenotype of the responder.

BACKGROUND: The genetic basis for control of alloantibody responses against foreign HLA histocompatibility antigens has never been delineated. The most likely postulate would be that HLA class II alloantigens of the host regulate the response through their ability to present processed HLA allopeptide fragments for the cognate interaction between CD4+ T lymphocytes and B lymphocytes that leads to IgG antibody synthesis. METHODS: We have analyzed our allosensitized transplant patient population with regard to humoral responsiveness to a serologically defined public HLA class I epitope, Bw4. Peptides representing the linear sequence of the Bw4 epitope (amino acids 74-86) and the alternative Bw6 epitope were synthesized and assayed for binding to a panel of HLA homozygous lymphoblastoid B cells using a quantitative fluorescence binding assay. RESULTS: We found that 73% of patients who have produced a HLA-Bw4-specific alloantibody express either the HLA-DRB1*01 or HLA-DRB1*03 alloantigen; 19% of the remaining responders expressed HLA-DRB1*04. Analysis of the United Network for Organ Sharing Transplant Registry indicated that the survival of cadaver renal allografts mismatched for Bw4 was significantly compromised in sensitized DRB1*01+ or DRB1*03+ recipients (P<0.01). In vitro, the Bw4 peptide bound strongly to DRB1*01+ and DRB1*03+ lymphoblastoid B cells; no similar binding was observed with Bw6 peptide. These findings were confirmed using murine fibroblast lines transfected with HLA-DR alpha/beta genes and by solid-phase enzyme-linked immunosorbent assay using purified HLA-DR alloantigen. CONCLUSIONS: We conclude that there are at least two human Ir genes, HLA-DRB1*01 and HLA-DRB1*03, that confer a high risk for both humoral allosensitization and renal allograft failure in situations of HLA-Bw4 incompatibility. These findings may be of future benefit in devising new antigen matching strategies for reducing the risk of humoral HLA allosensitization and chronic allograft rejection.

Avoidance of cellular blood product transfusions in LVAD recipients does not prevent HLA allosensitization.

BACKGROUND: Transfusion of cellular blood products during left ventricular assist device (LVAD) implantation has been associated with HLA allosensitization, resulting in the need for a negative prospective cross-match and prolonged transplant waiting times. In order to prevent this risk, we developed a protocol to avoid transfusion of cellular blood products. METHODS: The protocol included preoperative patient stabilization, perioperative recombinant erythropoietin and blood conservation strategies, and postoperative monitoring of mixed venous oxygen saturation (SVO2) to assure adequate peripheral oxygen delivery. Panel reactive antibody (PRA) was measured in all patients pre and post LVAD placement to assess HLA sensitization. RESULTS: Seven consecutive patients underwent LVAD implantation without transfusion of blood or platelets, one of whom expired perioperatively. Mean hematocrit was 35.2% preoperatively, and 21.8% postoperatively, reaching a nadir of 20.2%. Postoperative SVO2 was >60% in all patients. In the six survivors, mean hematocrit reach 24.3%, 27.3%, and 33.0% by postoperative day seven, fourteen, and thirty, respectively. PRA in three patients was 0% preoperatively and remained 0% until transplantation after 33, 34, and 50 days of support. In two patients, preoperative PRA was 7% and 17%, dropped to 3% and 0% after thirty days, then progressively rose to 96% and 100% after 60 and 90 days, respectively. In one other patient, preoperative PRA was 0%, remained at 0% after thirty days, then rose to 96% by 60 days. CONCLUSIONS: Avoiding transfusion of cellular blood products in LVAD recipients is safe and well tolerated, but does not universally protect from HLA allosensitization. Other factors may also produce sensitization, such as immunogenic components of the LVAD, soluble antigen in fresh frozen plasma, or latent sensitization which is not initially evident in critically ill and possibly anergic patients.

Persistence of human leukocyte antigen (HLA) antibodies after one year in children receiving cryopreserved valved allografts.

This study shows that the broad anti-HLA antibody response against cryopreserved valved allografts used for surgical repair of congenital heart disease persists beyond 1 year after implantation. In 3 patients, there were clearly defined HLA antibody specificities consistent with the HLA phenotypes of the patients, i.e., the panel-reactive antibody was directed against major alloantigen groups that were not expressed by the antibody responders.

HLA alloantibodies and the mechanism of the antiglobulin-augmented lymphocytotoxicity procedure.

HLA Class I alloantigens express multiple epitopes which can be defined serologically using human HLA alloantibodies (aAb). We have shown that the vast majority of HLA antisera exhibit the CYNAP phenomenon (complement-dependent cytotoxicity (CDC) negative, adsorption positive) which can be identified by conversion to direct CDC positive reactivity with the addition of an antihuman immunoglobulin (Ig) light chain (AHG) reagent. In this study, the immunochemical mechanisms responsible for the CYNAP phenomena and how AHG overrides CYNAP have been further characterized using affinity-purified HLA aAb, class-specific anti-IgH reagents and human C1q binding assays quantified by flow cytometry. We have found that CYNAP reactions are not the result of low affinity aAb or generally caused by non-complement fixing HLA aAb. Our experiments illustrate that only anti-human IgL AHG reagents can consistently augment CDC and override CYNAP; anti-IgH have not effective. Two noncompeting HLA aAb of different epitopic specificity or one aAb in conjunction with the AHG-augmenting reagent results in striking synergy with a 200 to 400% increase in binding of C1q. We conclude from these and other experiments detailed in this article that an IgM aAb or either two adjacent, noncompeting IgG HLA aAb bound to spatially distinct epitopes on a single HLA molecule or a monospecific IgG HLA aAb in concert with the AHG binding to this HLA aAb, is required for efficient (bivalent) C1q binding and initiation of C-mediated lympholysis. In contrast, the CYNAP phenomenon usually occurs because monospecific HLA aAb directed against a single epitope cannot effect high affinity, bivalent interaction with Clq and activate complement that would ultimately lead to cytolysis.

Epitope specificity of HLA class I alloantibodies: II. Stability of cross-reactive group antibody patterns over extended time periods.

The stability of HLA alloantibodies was studied in 128 antibody-positive, potential kidney transplant recipients over an average period of 3 years. Antibody detection was performed using an anti-human globulin-complement-dependent cytotoxicity technique. In this study, the specificity of antibodies was categorized as against either private epitopes or cross-reactive group (CREG) epitope clusters. Definable antibodies were found in 94% of patients, and 89.5% of the definable antibodies had specificity for CREG clusters. Patterns of antibody reactivity were stable in most of the patients evaluated, even though the percentage of panel-reactive antibody (PRA) often demonstrated considerable fluctuations. Of the 220 definable private-specific or CREG cluster-specific antibodies identified in the patients, nearly 80% persisted throughout the observation period. The fluctuations in % PRA were common, but usually were not due to the acquisition of new HLA antibodies. Most fluctuations were attributable to variable detection of specificities within the same CREG cluster, possibly due to technique variation or changes in antibody avidity or titer or in cell panel composition. This study demonstrates that patterns of antibody specificity are remarkably stable in this patient population, even though PRA values fluctuated. This study further suggests that HLA antibody specificity analysis is a more useful clinical parameter of lymphocytotoxicity testing than simple reporting of % PRA when identifying potential donors for individual patients.

Prospective analysis of HLA immunogenicity of cryopreserved valved allografts used in pediatric heart surgery.

BACKGROUND: The HLA immunogenicity of cryopreserved valved allografts used in the surgical repair of congenital heart defects is unknown. METHODS AND RESULTS: To determine the immunogenicity of these allografts, we measured prospectively the frequency of panel-reactive HLA class I alloantibodies (PRA) before, 1 month after, and 3 months after allograft implantation in 9 children (age, 5.4 +/- 2.1 years) and after open-heart surgery without allograft implantation in 11 age-matched control children (age, 4.0 +/- 1.5 years). PRA was determined against an HLA-select frozen T-lymphocyte panel using the antiglobulin cytotoxicity technique. After allograft implantation, PRA increased from 3.2 +/- 2.7% before surgery to 63.3 +/- 12% at 25 +/- 2 days after surgery and 99.7 +/- 0.3% at 3.4 +/- 0.3 months after surgery. The use of dithiothreitol to remove IgM alloantibodies resulted in a modest decrease in PRA at 1 month (33.2 +/- 13%) but no change at 3 months (93.0 +/- 3.4%), suggesting the initial humoral response is an IgM alloantibody that switches almost exclusively to IgG by 3 months. Control patients showed no increase in PRA over time: 1.6 +/- 1% before surgery, 3.2 +/- 1% at 28 +/- 5 days after surgery, and 1.7 +/- 1% at 2.7 +/- 0.3 months after surgery. CONCLUSIONS: Cryopreserved valved allografts in children induce a marked HLA alloantibody response that increases to broad panel reactivity within 3 months after surgery. This HLA sensitization has potential not only for causing deleterious effects on allograft function but also for limiting the future opportunity of heart transplantation in patients who receive cryopreserved valved allografts.

HLA-B27 screening by flow cytometry.

A flow cytometric assay for lymphocyte HLA-B27 expression using a two-color direct immunofluorescent assay was compared to traditional microlymphocytotoxicity testing on 209 clinical samples. For the flow cytometric assay, whole blood was mixed with a monoclonal anti-B27 conjugated to fluorescein-isothiocyanate (FITC) and anti-CD3 conjugated to phycoerythrin (PE). The samples were analyzed with flow cytometry by gating on CD3 positive events and anti-B27 staining intensity was evaluated as median channel fluorescence of the histogram peak. The median channel fluorescence was least with B27 negative and B7 negative samples (84 +/- 17), intermediate with samples that were B27 negative but B7 positive (118 +/- 13), and greatest with samples that were B27 positive (155 +/- 13). In addition to cross-reactivity with the B7 antigen (n = 38), the monoclonal anti-B27 cross-reacted with HLA-B37 positive samples (n = 3) and HLA-B39 positive samples (n = 3). Using a median channel fluorescence cutoff of 136, 39 of the 40 B27 positive samples gave positive results in the flow cytometric assay for a sensitivity of 97.6%. The specificity was 95.9% with 7 false positives of 169 B27 negative samples. The flow cytometric HLA-B27 assay is a convenient, useful screening test. For greatest specificity, samples positive by flow cytometry should be confirmed by conventional microlymphocytotoxicity or by use of other monoclonal antibodies directed against B27.

Monitoring HLA alloimmunization. Analysis of HLA alloantibodies in the serum of prospective transplant recipients.

The identification of serum HLA alloantibody in clinical transplantation can only be considered meaningful if the information derived from clinical tests can be used to predict crossmatch outcome. Drawing on the foundations and principles of blood transfusion medicine, this article presents a strategy for efficient, cost-effective patient HLA antibody monitoring that relies on a screening technique identical in sensitivity to the final donor crossmatch method. Application of this approach to the successful transplantation of highly immunized patients using HLA disparate cadaver renal allografts supports the contentions advanced within this article.

Topographic map of the HLA-A2 CREG epitopes using human alloantibody probes.

The topographic architecture of the epitopes expressed on the HLA-A2 glycoprotein using murine monoclonal antibody (mAb) probes indicates at least two sterically distinct domains. Previously, we have demonstrated using human HLA alloantibodies (aAb) that multiple determinants are expressed on each HLA antigen: the highly polymorphic private epitopes and the public determinants that are shared within a family of crossreactive groups (CREG). Our objectives now focus on probing the antigenic structure of the HLA-A2-28-9-B17 CREG using highly specific aAb in conjunction with mAb that have previously been used for structural studies. Both mAb-mediated blockage of complement-dependent cytotoxic aAb and reciprocal antibody (Ab) binding inhibition assays with quantitation by fluorescence flow cytometry have been utilized. We have found that xenogeneic mAb directed against A2-69, A2-B17, and A2-28 crossblock aAb of the same serologic specificity, and vice versa, indicating that the epitopes they respectively recognize are at least in close steric proximity. However, additional HLA-A2, A28, and B17 aAb of private specificity and A2-28-9 aAb of public specificity, for which there are no known mAb counterparts, paint an additional complexity not previously known. We conclude that at least four different alloepitopes can be expressed by each serologically defined HLA antigen. Based on the primary sequence data, we have assigned the location and the amino acid substitutions which most likely account for these discrete epitopes. The unique private determinants are located on the alpha 1 domain together with the interlocus A2-B17 epitope while the public epitopes A2-69, A2-28-9 and A2-28 are located on the alpha 2 domain.

Epitope map of the HLA-B7 CREG using affinity-purified human alloantibody probes.

Monoclonal antibodies (mAb) recognizing the B7 CREG have been used to construct an epitopic map of HLA-B7. Similar studies with human HLA alloantisera have been lacking due to the polyclonal nature of the alloantibodies (aAb). Detergent-solubilized HLA Class I antigens were purified and coupled to activated CH-Sepharose 4B. Sequential affinity isolation of aAb populations using a series of HLA antigen columns enabled us to produce a battery of aAb eluates against both the private B7, B13, B27, and B omega 60 determinants and the public B7-42, B7-60, B7-60-61, B7-27-13-60, B7-42-22-27, B7-8-42-60-41, and B omega 6 epitopes. The topographic relationship of the B7 family of determinants recognized by the Ab probes was derived using crosscompetition Ab blocking assays with quantitation by indirect immunofluorescence and FACS analysis. We have found that aAb and mAb of similar specificity crossblock; Ab of different specificity give complex patterns including both overlapping blocking between the alpha domains and Ab-induced conformational change of the molecule. From these investigations, we conclude that HLA Class I alloantigens bear both multiple, topographically distinct public epitopes and separate private determinants that can be distinguished using human aAb probes. At least four discrete epitopes are expressed by each molecule of the HLA-B7 CREG and can be ascribed to unique aa substitutions on the hydrophilic beta loops of the distal heavy chain domains and also on several exposed areas of the alpha helices. These findings are extremely similar to those of the HLA-A2 CREG and suggest that possibly all Class I molecules possess a comparable, complex degree of serologic polymorphism.

1,000 renal transplants at the Massachusetts General Hospital: improved allograft survival for high-risk patients without regard to HLA matching.

Excellent allograft survival is now routinely accomplished following renal transplantation. Changes in immunosuppression have resulted in a significant improvement in early survival for recipients of primary LRD and CD allografts. In our series, crossmatching techniques which accurately assess alloantibody reactivity and not the degree of HLA mismatch have also permitted successful transplantation of such high-risk groups as recipients of second transplants and highly sensitized recipients. However, a yearly attrition rate of allograft loss persists for all recipients. These long-term observations stress the need for newer approaches to immunosuppression in the future, which include protocols that allow for an indefinite tolerance to incompatible donor antigens.