Early outcome after laparoscopic and open floppy nissen fundoplication

AIMS: There remains debate regarding the best operative procedure for gastro-oesophageal reflux. For those who advocate a full 'floppy' Nissen fundoplication there is some scepticism that this can be completed effectively laparoscopically with division of all the short gastric vessels. This study therefore compared the results of patients operated on in two different hospitals in which floppy Nissen fundoplication was carried out either laparoscopically (hospital 1) or by open surgery (hospital 2). METHODS: All patients undergoing antireflux surgery in both hospitals were recorded prospectively and perioperative data were collected retrospectively from the case records. A postoperative questionnaire was sent to each patient to determine the modified DeMeester score and the impact of surgery on daily activities, which were then analysed anonymously by an independent clinician. RESULTS: Operating time was significantly longer (median 150 versus 75 min; P < 0.001), but postoperative stay (2 versus 4 days; P < 0.001) and return to normal activities (14 versus 25 days; P < 0.002) were shorter for the laparoscopic approach. There was no difference in gas bloat (both groups median 1.0, range 0-3), dysphagia (median 1.0 versus 0.0, range 0-3) or modified DeMeester score (both groups median 1.0, range 0-9) between the two techniques (median follow-up 10 and 15 months). CONCLUSIONS: As the postoperative results were comparable this study confirms that a 'floppy' Nissen fundoplication with complete mobilization of the gastric fundus can be performed laparoscopically. The advantages of a shorter hospital stay and earlier return to normal activities are offset by a longer operating time.

Benign anastomotic stricture following transthoracic subtotal oesophagectomy and stapled oesophago-gastrostomy: risk factors and management

AIMS: Benign anastomotic stricture (BAS) is a common cause of dysphagia following oesophagectomy. The aim of this study was to assess the incidence of BAS, identify risk factors for its development and evaluate the results of postoperative endoscopic dilatation. METHODS: A consecutive series of 234 patients undergoing oesophagectomy with a stapled intrathoracic oesophagogastric anastomosis (Autosuture CEEA gun) between April 1990 and April 1999 were studied. BAS was defined as dysphagia with anastomotic narrowing (XQ200 endoscope) and no suspicion of recurrence. Statistical analysis was by the chi2 and Mann-Whitney U tests. RESULTS: The postoperative mortality rate was 5 per cent (12 of 234) and the anastomotic leak rate 3 per cent (six of 234). One-third of patients (70 of 222) who survived surgery re-presented with dysphagia; 5 per cent (11 of 222) were found to have proven local recurrence and 27 per cent (59 of 222) BAS. The median time to development of BAS was 92 (range 24-210) days. BAS formation was significantly related to the size of the staple gun employed: 21 mm, 80 per cent (eight of ten); 25 mm, 32 per cent (25 of 78); 28 mm, 23 per cent (19 of 81); 31 mm, 19 per cent (seven of 37) and 34 mm, 0 per cent (none of five) (chi2 = 18.3, 4 d.f., P < 0.01). All patients underwent radiographically controlled endoscopic dilatation with no complications. Recurrent BAS occurred in over half of these patients (32 of 59), who had a median of 2 (range 2-17) recurrences all resolving within 532 (mean interval 68) days. Recurrent BAS formation was also significantly related to the size of the staple gun employed (chi2 = 11.6, 4 d.f., P < 0.05). Following the introduction of the Autosuture 'tilt-top' device in July 1995 the median size of gun used rose from 25 to 28 mm with an overall decrease in the incidence of BAS from 33 to 21 per cent (chi2 = 4.0, 1 d.f., P < 0.05). All patients with anastomotic leaks survived and none subsequently developed BAS. Similarly, no association was found between the development of BAS and the anastomotic site (measured from incisors), tumour subtype, resection margin length, sex, age or preoperative cardiorespiratory status. CONCLUSIONS: Staple gun size is an important risk factor for BAS formation and 'tilt-top' devices enable the use of a larger head with a subsequently lower incidence of BAS. Endoscopic dilatation is an effective treatment for BAS which rarely recurs and always resolves within 18 months.

Pattern of recurrence following subtotal oesophagectomy with two field lymphadenectomy

Aims: Despite increasingly radical surgery for oesophageal cancer many patients continue to represent with recurrent disease. This study aimed to evaluate the pattern of failure following attempted curative oesophagectomy with mediastinal and upper abdominal lymphadenectomy. METHODS: Some 212 consecutive patients undergoing R0 resection for malignancy between 1 April 1990 and 1 April 1999 were followed up for evidence of recurrence. Clinical evaluation was supported by ultrasonography, computed tomography, isotope scan, endoscopy and laparotomy with biopsy assessment if appropriate. Patients were excluded if recurrence was diagnosed on clinical grounds alone. Statistical analysis was performed using chi2 and log rank tests. RESULTS: Some 142 patients with adenocarcinoma and 70 with squamous carcinoma (SCC) were followed up for a median of 14 (range 1-108) months. Sex and age distribution were similar for both histological subtypes (men : women 3 : 1; median age 64 (30-79) years). Twenty patients died from non-cancer related causes, including 11 (5 per cent) from postoperative complications. Some 89 patients (42 per cent) developed proven recurrent disease of which seven are alive and 82 dead. The median time to recurrence was 11 (2-40) months with a median time to death thereafter of 3 (1-21) months. The pattern of recurrence was locoregional in 23 per cent (oesophageal bed 15 per cent, upper abdominal 3 per cent, upper mediastinal 3 per cent, cervical 2 per cent) and haematogenous in 18 per cent (comprising liver 8 per cent, bone 4 per cent, cerebral 3 per cent, lung 2 per cent, skin 1 per cent) with peritoneal dissemination in 1 per cent. While there was no difference in the overall pattern of dissemination for each histological subtype, the incidence of cervical and upper mediastinal recurrence was significantly higher for adenocarcinoma compared with SCC (chi2 = 5. 9, 1 d.f., P < 0.02). The timing of recurrence was similar for both histological subtypes: 60 per cent of all recurrence occurred within 12 months of surgery, with distant and locoregional recurrence occurring at a median of 10 (2-40) and 11 (2-32) months respectively. CONCLUSIONS: The low incidence of upper mediastinal and cervical recurrence suggests that more extensive lymphadenectomy is unlikely to impact upon survival. Improved staging modalities are required to identify the significant number of patients who develop early recurrence in the first year following surgery in order to offer them multimodality therapies of non-surgical palliation.

Management of spontaneous rupture of the oesophagus

AIMS: Spontaneous rupture of the oesophagus (SRO) is a rare and often fatal event. The aim of this study was to evaluate the presentation, management and outcome of SRO in a single unit. METHODS: Data were collected on all patients presenting with SRO over a 5-year period with respect to presenting features, diagnostic investigations and subsequent management. Statistical analysis was by Student's t test, chi2 and Fisher's exact tests. RESULTS: Fourteen patients were identified, 12 men and two women with a median age of 64 (range 18-78) years; eight were tertiary referrals. Thirteen of 14 patients presented with chest or upper abdominal pain following vomiting or retching and 13 had an abnormal initial chest radiograph; only one presented with Mackler's triad of pain, vomiting and surgical emphysema. The median delay to diagnosis was 21 (range 1-84) h; this delay did not significantly affect outcome (P = 0.16). An endoscopic assessment and contrast swallow were performed in all patients. Nine of ten patients with a demonstrable leak and full-thickness tear were managed surgically and the four patients with no leak were managed conservatively (P = 0.005); surgical management consisted of thoracotomy, lavage, repair of the perforation and a feeding jejunostomy. Seven patients had a repair over a T tube and two had a primary repair. All conservatively managed patients had contained, controlled or intramural perforations and two also required a feeding jejunostomy. Patients requiring surgery had a longer hospital stay (mean(s.d.) 57.9(34.8) versus 22.2(30.7) days; P = 0.081) and a significantly longer intensive care unit stay (P = 0.044). The overall mortality rate from SRO was 14 per cent (two patients); no deaths occurred in the conservatively managed group. CONCLUSIONS: SRO continues to be diagnosed late despite a classical history and/or abnormal chest radiograph. Endoscopic assessment of perforations is safe and in combination with a contrast swallow can confidently predict patients with contained or controlled rupture in whom non-operative management is successful.

Achalasia: management, outcome and surveillance in a specialist unit

AIMS: The management and surveillance of achalasia remains controversial at the present time. The aim of this study was therefore to evaluate the results of endoscopic management and subsequent surveillance of patients with achalasia presenting to a specialist unit. METHODS: A prospective cohort of 40 patients with a radiological and manometric diagnosis of achalasia who presented to this unit between 1991 and 1998 were studied; the male : female ratio was 1 : 1 and the median age 38 (range 15-84) years. Twenty-one patients presented de novo, seven had previously undergone cardiomyotomy and 12 were referred following unsuccessful dilatation. RESULTS: Some 36 patients were treated with balloon dilatation (Microvasive achalasia balloon, 35/40 mm). Results were graded 1-4 (1, asymptomatic; 2, symptomatic but significantly improved; 3, symptomatic with no change; and 4, symptomatic but worse); 29 of 36 patients were grade 1 at subsequent follow-up and the remaining seven were grade 2 (median follow-up 17 (range 5-96) months). There was a single complication of oesophageal perforation which was treated conservatively with full recovery. Following intervention, patients were enrolled in a prospective surveillance programme of chromoendoscopy at 2-year intervals; in a total of 74 patient-years' follow-up, two superficial squamous cell carcinomas (SCCs) and one adenocarcinoma (following cardiomyotomy) were detected, giving a relative risk of one cancer in 25 patient-years. CONCLUSIONS: Balloon dilatation is a safe and effective treatment for achalasia even in patients who have had previous unsuccessful dilatations or cardiomyotomy. There is a high risk of SCC and the adenocarcinoma may have resulted from previous refluxogenic therapy, so all patients with achalasia should be followed up with surveillance endoscopy.