Neuroretinal rim measurement error using PC-based stereo software.

The neuroretinal rims of a set of glaucoma patients were measured using digitized stereo photographs, to determine the reproducibility of computerized stereo measurements of the neuroretinal rim. Each rim was measured five times at 18 locations, with measurement error (ME) defined as the mean of standard deviations of each set of measurements. The following ME were determined: (i) inter-sessional variability (n = 27 right and 24 left eyes, at t1 and t2); (ii) inter-assessor variability (n = 9, 2 assessors); and (iii) variability after colour adjustment algorithms were applied (n = 15). The results were as follows: (i) inter-sessional variability was 3.41+/-1.08 for t1 and 3.22+/-0.84 for t2; (ii) there was a significant difference between the two assessors, although the ME was still low; and (iii) there was no significant differences between the ME of unadjusted and adjusted images. With a measurement error of up to 11% of rim width, these results show that lowcost rim measurements can be made using PC-based software.

Methods and limits of digital image compression of retinal images for telemedicine.

PURPOSE: To investigate image compression of digital retinal images and the effect of various levels of compression on the quality of the images. METHODS: JPEG (Joint Photographic Experts Group) and Wavelet image compression techniques were applied in five different levels to 11 eyes with subtle retinal abnormalities and to 4 normal eyes. Image quality was assessed by four different methods: calculation of the root mean square (RMS) error between the original and compressed image, determining the level of arteriole branching, identification of retinal abnormalities by experienced observers, and a subjective assessment of overall image quality. To verify the techniques used and findings, a second set of retinal images was assessed by calculation of RMS error and overall image quality. RESULTS: Plots and tabulations of the data as a function of the final image size showed that when the original image size of 1.5 MB was reduced to 29 KB using JPEG compression, there was no serious degradation in quality. The smallest Wavelet compressed images in this study (15 KB) were generally still of acceptable quality. CONCLUSIONS: For situations where digital image transmission time and costs should be minimized, Wavelet image compression to 15 KB is recommended, although there is a slight cost of computational time. Where computational time should be minimized, and to remain compatible with other imaging systems, the use of JPEG compression to 29 KB is an excellent alternative.

Tele-ophthalmology screening for retinal and anterior segment diseases.

A digital indirect ophthalmoscope (DIO) was developed and tested for use in tele-ophthalmology screening for posterior and anterior segment diseases. Using custom software, images from the DIO were digitized, compressed, stored and transmitted to a centralized eye clinic for interpretation. A total of 43 subjects were primarily screened for glaucoma using the DIO, a hand-held fundus camera and a stereo fundus camera. The photographic slides from the stereo fundus camera used as gold standards. Images (390 x 300 pixels x 3 bits) were stored using a laptop computer together with patient information. Image quality received at the central eye clinic was good and showed adequate diagnostic information. An ophthalmologist estimated cup-disc ratios and graded the quality of the images. The sensitivity and specificity of each instrument was calculated. A high sensitivity and specificity was found when using the DIO, indicating that it could be used in tele-ophthalmic screenings. Further modifications are needed to make the instrument more user-friendly and to enable it to be used with undilated pupils, so that it can be easily operated by health-care personnel in remote areas. The camera can also be used to image gross external eye pathology.

Comparison of optic disc image assessment methods when examining serial photographs for glaucomatous progression.

AIM: To assess serial, simultaneous stereo optic disc images by four methods for glaucomatous progression. METHODS: Using varying techniques, two ophthalmologists assessed serial optic disc images of 52 eyes from 27 patients with a mean duration between images of 18 months. The neuroretinal rim width was qualitatively assessed by four assessment methods and compared with quantitative rim measurements made using PC based software. RESULTS: The highest sensitivity of 83% was achieved using computerised stereo chronoscopy. CONCLUSION: Stereo chronoscopy improved the detection of subtle optic disc changes when compared with simpler assessment techniques.

Computer-assisted planimetry associated with Sturge-Weber syndrome.

Photographs of the optic nerve head (optic disc) in the eye are used for the clinical assessment of the disease glaucoma. These images are usually subjectively assessed by a clinician. A case of Sturge-Weber Syndrome which includes glaucoma as a symptom, is presented here. Narrowing of the rim of the optic disc was measured using custom-made measurement software confirming glaucomatous progression. To maximize the information obtained from optic disc images, low cost software can assist with quantifying disc parameters aiding clinical interpretation.

Evaluation of a portable fundus camera for use in the teleophthalmologic diagnosis of glaucoma.

PURPOSE: The digital images of the optic disk from a portable fundus camera were evaluated for suitability in teleophthalmologic screening for glaucoma. METHODS: Fifty-one eyes of 27 consecutive patients from our glaucoma clinic were dilated and photographed with a Zeiss FF retinal camera (Carl Zeiss, Oberkochen, Germany) and a portable Nidek NM-100 (Nidek, Tokyo, Japan) fundus camera. Digital images from the portable fundus camera were digitized, compressed and stored in a Fujix DF-10M (Fuji, Tokyo, Japan) digitizer. Lossy compressed digital images and photographs from the Zeiss camera were presented separately in random order to three ophthalmologists for estimation of vertical cup:disk ratios (VCDR) and to evaluate image quality as good, acceptable, or unacceptable for screening glaucoma. Gold standard VCDRs were measured from monoscopic photographic slides obtained using the Zeiss camera by a fourth ophthalmologist. RESULTS: Measurement of agreement (Kappa values) between estimated VCDR of digital images and photographs by the three ophthalmologists were 0.52, 0.38, and 0.50 respectively. Agreement between gold standard and estimated VCDR from photographs were 0.87, 0.45, and 0.84 respectively (specificity between 79% and 97%, sensitivity between 70% and 95%). Kappa values obtained between gold standard and estimated VCDR from digital images were 0.52, 0.49, and 0.49, respectively (specificity between 68% and 79%, sensitivity between 67% and 87%. CONCLUSION: Moderate to good agreement indicates that the digital images from the portable fundus camera may be suitable for optic disk assessment in the current configuration. This easy to use Nidek hand-held camera could be a viable instrument for teleophthalmology if a better digitizing system is incorporated to improve the quality of the images.

A personal computer-based method of stereo chronometry for measuring neuroretinal rim width: a pilot study.

PURPOSE: Quantifying neuroretinal rim width from optic disc photographs to study glaucomatous progression requires precise, reproducible measurements. We explored the use of a personal computer with three-dimensional capabilities to enhance measurement accuracy and repeatability. METHODS: A simultaneous stereo retinal camera was used to serially photograph the optic discs often glaucomatous eyes with a mean interval of 18 months. The neuroretinal rims were qualitatively assessed as either stable (five) or narrowing (five). The images were measured using software written for an IBM compatible personal computer The measurements were compared from the earliest to the most recent image and the five narrowed rims were correctly identified. RESULTS: This simple, low-cost method allowed both three-dimensional viewing and measurement of the optic disc rim from simultaneous stereo images. CONCLUSIONS: This method is, potentially, more sensitive in identifying glaucomatous rim changes than conventional, subjective image comparison techniques.