Decreased frequency of somatic hypermutation and impaired affinity maturation but intact germinal center formation in mice expressing antisense RNA to DNA polymerase zeta.

To examine a role of DNA polymerase zeta in somatic hypermutation, we generated transgenic mice that express antisense RNA to a portion of mouse REV3, the gene encoding this polymerase. These mice express high levels of antisense RNA, significantly reducing the levels of endogenous mouse REV3 transcript. Following immunization to a hapten-protein complex, transgenic mice mounted vigorous Ab responses, accomplished the switch to IgG, and formed numerous germinal centers. However, in most transgenic animals, the generation of high affinity Abs was delayed. In addition, accumulation of somatic mutations in the V(H) genes of memory B cells from transgenic mice was decreased, particularly among those that generate amino acid replacements that enhance affinity of the B cell receptor to the hapten. These data implicate DNA polymerase zeta, a nonreplicative polymerase, in the process of affinity maturation, possibly through a role in somatic hypermutation, clonal selection, or both.

Relative roles of somatic and Darwinian evolution in shaping the antibody response.

The need for a highly specific system of recognition in immunity has resulted in the evolution of several somatic mechanisms such as V(D)J recombination, to diversify the repertoire of B cells. Therefore, repertoire diversification is the driving force for the cells that constitute the bulk of the response to unpredictable pathogens, the B2 naive B cells. Predictability of antigen, on the other hand, has played a major role in shaping the neonatal repertoire, in which evolution to recognize commonly encountered pathogens has driven the germline sequence of several VH segments that are used frequently in the neonatal repertoire. A third population, the memory B cell population, is generated to respond to a known pathogen, but predictability of the pathogen is not acquired until after a first exposure. Therefore, it is somatic evolution in germinal centers that drives the generation of high-affinity memory B cells.

B cell maintenance in aged mice reflects both increased B cell longevity and decreased B cell generation.

In aged mice the population of mature peripheral B cells is maintained despite a severalfold decrease in the population of bone marrow B cell progenitors. The analysis of the rate of accumulation of 5'-bromo-2-deoxyuridine (BrdU)-labeled splenic B cells in mice fed BrdU for 8 days to 8 wk demonstrated a severalfold increase in the half-life of mature B cells in aged mice. Consistent with a role for decreased B cell turnover in maintaining the mature B cell population of aged mice, several findings indicate that fewer newly generated B cells enter the spleen from the bone marrow in aged vs young adult mice. These include 1) a fourfold decrease in the population of relatively immature splenic B cells, defined as cells that express high levels of heat-stable Ag and accumulate BrdU within 8 wk of labeling; and 2) an equivalent decrease in the population of bone marrow cells representative of later stages of B cell maturation (sIgD-sIgM(int-high)). Surprisingly, despite a four- to sixfold decrease in pre-B cells, the population of least mature bone marrow B cells (IgD-sIgM(very low)) remains intact. Because this population accumulates BrdU-labeled cells more slowly in aged mice than in younger mice, and bone marrow B cells at more mature developmental stages are diminished, it appears that in aged mice B cell development beyond the sIgM(very low) stage may be retarded and that cells, therefore, accumulate within this population.

Pre-B cell receptor-mediated selection of pre-B cells synthesizing functional mu heavy chains.

Ig gene rearrangements could generate V(H)-D-J(H) joining sequences that interfere with the correct folding of a mu-chain, and thus, its capability to pair with IgL chains. Surrogate light (SL) chain might be the ideal molecule to test the capacity of a mu-chain to pair with a L chain early in development, in that only pre-B cells that assemble a membrane mu-SL complex would be permitted to expand and further differentiate. We have previously identified two SL chain nonpairing V(H)81X-mu-chains with distinct V(H)-D-J(H) joining regions. Here, we show that one of these V(H)81X-mu-chains does not rescue B cell development in J(H) knock-out mice, because flow cytometric analysis of bone marrow cells from V(H)81X-mu transgenic J(H) knock-out mice revealed normal numbers of pro-B cells, but essentially no pre-B and surface IgM+ B cells. Immunoprecipitation analysis of transfected pre-B and hybridoma lines revealed that the same mu-chain fails to pair not only with SL chain but also with four distinct kappa L chains. These findings demonstrate that early pre-B cells are selected for maturation on the basis of the structure of a mu-chain, in particular its V(H)-D-J(H) joining or CDR3 sequence, and that one mechanism for this selection is the capacity of a mu-chain to assemble with SL chain. Therefore, we propose a new function of SL chain in early B cell development: SL chain is part of a quality control mechanism that tests a mu-chain for its ability to pair with conventional L chains.

The cellular origins of memory B cells.

Recent evidence indicates that memory B cells may originate from a precursor cell subset that is distinct from AFC precursors. Most convincing is the finding that fractionation of naive peripheral B-cell populations on the basis of surface heat stable antigen (HSA) expression yields two populations; one greatly enriched for progenitors of memory B cells (HSAlo), and the other enriched for AFC precursors (HSAint-hi). Antigenic stimulation of HSAlo B cells in vitro leads to the generation of memory B-cell clones in the absence of any detectable antibody formation whereas stimulation of HSAint-hi cells yield AFC responses but not memory B cells. Furthermore, the progeny of HSAlo cells are unique in their ability to accumulate somatic mutations and originate germinal centers (GC). The pre-existence of two distinct precursor cell populations may help resolve the disparate biological characteristics of AFC precursors which appear to be terminally differentiated versus memory progenitors which retain stem cell characteristics in their capacity to self renew, undergo multiple divisions, and generate progeny that express enzymes characteristic of stem cells or pro-pre B cells and acquire tolerance susceptibility.

The B-cell biology of aging.

Although both the number and responsiveness of peripheral B cells in aged mice remain relatively intact, there are dramatic changes in B-cell generation. Alterations in B-cell development include both a skewing of V-gene utilization, especially in cells responsive to phosphorylcholine, and a decrease in the generation of various developmental B-cell subsets. The altered representation of these subsets appears to be the consequence of two developmental blocks. The first developmental block occurs during the maturation of pro-B cells and is evidenced by a decrease in the number of pre-B cells. The second developmental block occurs at the earliest stage of sIg(+)-cell maturation (sIgMvery lo). Because of this block in B-cell maturation, in spite of a decrease in incoming pre-B cells, the number of sIgMvery lo cells appears to increase in aged mice. Additionally, the time of residence of cells within this maturational stage increases dramatically, while the proportion of cells in more mature (sIgMhi) stages of bone marrow development are decreased. In addition to the decreased number of maturing bone marrow B cells, the population of splenic B cells that represent recent bone marrow émigrés (HSAvery hi) is markedly decreased. In the face of this decrease in newly emerging cells from the bone marrow, the population of mature splenic B cells is maintained by their increased longevity.

Antigen-independent changes in naive CD4 T cells with aging.

In the elderly, a dramatic shift within the CD4+ T cell population occurs, with an increased proportion having a memory phenotype with markedly decreased responsiveness. To determine what aspects of the aged phenotype are dependent upon repeated contact with antigen in the environment, we examined CD4+ cells isolated from TCR Tg mice. There is good evidence that no cross-reacting antigens for the Tg TCR recognizing pigeon cytochrome c are found in the environment of the animal, so that alterations in the Tg CD4+ cells with aging are likely to be due to antigen-independent processes. We found that in aged animals, TCR transgene(pos) CD4+ cells, although decreased in number and antigen responsiveness, maintain a naive phenotype rather than acquiring a prototypical aged memory phenotype. In contrast, the population of transgene(1o-neg) CD4+ cells increase in proportion and express the aged phenotype. Consistent with their naive status, transgene(pos) cells of aged individuals remain CD44lo CD45RBhi, secrete IL-2 and not IL-4 or IFN-gamma upon antigenic stimulation, and require co-stimulation to proliferate to anti-CD3 stimulation. These findings suggest that the aging-associated shift to CD4 cells expressing the memory phenotype is dependent on antigenic stimulation. However, the decrease in antigen responsiveness of naive transgenepos cells, as revealed by a lower secretion of IL-2 and IL-3 and a lower proliferative capacity, suggests that additional intrinsic changes occur with aging that do not depend on encounter with antigen.

Phosphotyrosine-dependent association between CD22 and protein tyrosine phosphatase 1C.

CD22 is a B lymphocyte-specific cell surface glycoprotein that becomes tyrosine phosphorylated upon B cell activation. To determine if tyrosine phosphorylated CD22 couples signaling through membrane immunoglobulin (mIg) to down-stream elements, we looked for molecules coprecipitating with CD22 after anti-Ig stimulation. We found that a 60-kDa molecule was stably associated with CD22 following cross-linking of mIg and have identified this molecule as protein tyrosine phosphatase 1C (PTP1C). The association between PTP1C and CD22 is dependent upon tyrosine phosphorylation of CD22, but does not appear to require tyrosine phosphorylation of PTP1C.

Heavy chain V gene-specific elimination of B cells during the pre-B cell to B cell transition.

As developing B cells acquire their surface Ig (sIg) receptors, they become highly susceptible to sIg-mediated negative selection, a process best exemplified by tolerance induction. Recent studies with sIg transgenic mice have suggested that B cells may become inactivated by tolerogens only after a developmental stage wherein they express low levels of sIgM and during the course of up-regulating their expression of sIgM. To determine whether inactivation of B cells of conventional mice occurs at this or other maturational stages, we have analyzed the ratio of productive vs nonproductive rearrangements of VH81X gene segments in developmental subsets of adult bone marrow cells. Earlier studies had demonstrated that cells whose productively rearranged H chain V region contained a VH81X gene segment were selectively disfavored both during pre-B cell development and subsequent to sIg expression. Contrary to the expectations for elimination by tolerance, no decrease in the proportion of cells expressing productive rearrangements of VH81X was observed as cells matured from the sIgMlow to the sIgMhigh maturational stage. However, a significant decrease in the proportion of productively rearranged VH81X gene segments was observed following the transition from sIg- pre-B cells to sIgMlow immature B cells. Additionally, the proportion of productively rearranged VH81X gene segments was significantly higher in sIgMhigh bone marrow cells than in splenic B cells. These findings demonstrate that B cells are susceptible to H chain-specific elimination at two developmental stages other than that wherein B cells are generally assumed to be negatively selected by tolerance.

Defining subsets of naive and memory B cells based on the ability of their progeny to somatically mutate in vitro.

The increased affinity of memory antibody responses is due largely to the generation and selection of memory B cells that accumulate somatic mutations after initial antigenic stimulation. Further affinity maturation and mutation also accompany subsequent immunizations. Previous studies have suggested that, like primary antibody-forming cell (AFC) clones, secondary AFC do not accumulate further mutations and, therefore, the origins of progressive affinity maturation remain controversial. Here, we report the generation of somatically mutated memory B cell clones in vitro. Our findings confirm the existence of a naive B cell subset whose progeny, rather than generating AFC, somatically mutate and respond to subsequent antigenic stimulation. Interestingly, upon stimulation, a subset of memory B cells also generates antigen-responsive cells that accumulate further somatic mutations.

Specific immunoglobulin cDNA clones produced from hybridoma cell lines and murine spleen fragment cultures by 3SR amplification.

The isothermal 3SR amplification method has been employed to assist in cloning the VL and VH genes from cells of hybridomas and splenic fragment cultures expressing antibodies for phosphorylcholine (PC) and estradiol (E2), respectively. As a first step, pools of degenerate primer pairs were identified complementary to immunoglobulin light and heavy chain variable (V) genes and capable of amplifying immunoglobulin RNA specifically at 42 degrees C. To evaluate the functionality of the 3SR-cloned immunoglobulin genes, anti-PC VH and VL cDNAs were joined together to form a single chain (sc) antibody construct and were expressed in Escherichia coli under the regulation of the alkaline phosphatase (phoA) promoter. Similarly, the combination of a murine spleen fragment and 3SR methodologies were employed to clone a selected pool of cDNAs for cultures producing anti-estradiol antibodies. This approach of using the murine spleen fragment and 3SR isothermal amplification offers the advantages of B-cell follicle architecture for antigen-driven B-cell maturation and proliferation and RNA-specific amplification, respectively. The potential utility of these advantages for the production of monoclonal antibodies and for providing the capability of studying memory B-cell development are discussed.

Selection in the expression of functionally distinct B-cell subsets.

Although the isolation and characterization of functionally distinct B-cell subsets has been a major preoccupation of immunologists for the past two decades, only recently has it been recognized that the various B-cell subsets may be disparately selected during their development and maturation on the basis of their expressed Ig V regions. Thus, pre-B cells are selected for clonal expansion and maturation by virtue of the amino-acid sequence of their nascent H chains and newly emerging B cells may be selected for longevity and subset distribution on the basis of both clonotype-specific and relatively non-specific interactions of their surface Ig receptors.

The use of Bayesian analysis of PCR-derived genomic DNA sequences to enable a biologically relevant interpretation of immunoglobulin variable region gene expression.

We analyzed by means of polymerase chain reactions (PCRs) and DNA sequencing techniques the immunoglobulin heavy chain variable region genes of bone marrow B lineage cells. We first formulated an explanatory model to guide understanding of the biological mechanisms determining both the size of the total available pool of relevant genes and clonal expansion following heavy chain gene rearrangement. We then followed Box's paradigm of criticism and estimation to interpret our experimental findings.

Among naive precursor cell subpopulations only progenitors of memory B cells originate germinal centers.

Immunization leads to the generation of both antibody-forming cells (AFC) and memory B cells which are thought to arise in germinal centers within lymphoid follicles. The findings that the precursors to memory B cells reside in the J11Dlo subpopulation of the spleens in non-immune mice and that this subpopulation is distinct from conventional AFC precursors, including CD5+ B cells, suggest that the precursors of germinal centers might also reside in the J11Dlo subpopulation. To test this hypothesis, SCID mice were repopulated with CD4+ carrier-primed T cells and T-depleted J11Dlo, J11Dhi or CD5+ B cells and immunized with a hapten-carrier conjugate. Only the J11Dlo population was enriched for cells that produced germinal centers. Thus, the subpopulation of precursors that generates memory B cells also originates germinal centers.

The generation of memory B cells.

Immunization leads to the generation of antibody forming cells (AFC) and secondary B cells which differ substantially from primary B cells. Based on the function of the progeny of enriched precursor cell populations, naive progenitors of memory B cells have been separated from primary AFC precursors. Precursors of memory cells: (1) require multiple antigenic stimulations to generate antibody responses which are prolonged, of increased magnitude, and generated with rapid kinetics; (2) have the capacity to form germinal centers; (3) accumulate somatic mutations; (4) display repertoire similarities with secondary B cells; and (5) can be stimulated with cross-reactive antigens. The primary AFC precursors responded with characteristic primary responses.