Detecting and characterizing individual molecules with single nanopores.

Single-nanometer-scale pores have demonstrated the capability for the detection, identification, and characterization of individual molecules. This measurement method could soon extend the existing commercial instrumentation or provide solutions to niche applications in many fields, including health care and the basic sciences. However, that paradigm shift requires a significantly better understanding of the physics and chemistry that govern the interactions between nanopores and analytes. We describe herein some of our methods and approaches to address this issue.

Hofmeister effect in confined spaces: halogen ions and single molecule detection.

Despite extensive research in the nanopore-sensing field, there is a paucity of experimental studies that investigate specific ion effects in confined spaces, such as in nanopores. Here, the effect of halogen anions on a simple bimolecular complexation reaction between monodisperse poly(ethylene glycol) (PEG) and α-hemolysin nanoscale pores have been investigated at the single-molecule level. The anions track the Hofmeister ranking according to their influence upon the on-rate constant. An inverse relationship was demonstrated for the off-rate and the solubility of PEG. The difference among anions spans several hundredfold. Halogen anions play a very significant role in the interaction of PEG with nanopores although, unlike K(+), they do not bind to PEG. The specific effect appears dominated by a hydration-dehydration process where ions and PEG compete for water. Our findings provide what we believe to be novel insights into physicochemical mechanisms involved in single-molecule interactions with nanopores and are clearly relevant to more complicated chemical and biological processes involving a transient association of two or more molecules (e.g., reception, signal transduction, enzyme catalysis). It is anticipated that these findings will advance the development of devices with nanopore-based sensors for chemical and biological applications.

ATP hydrolysis-dependent asymmetry of the conformation of CFTR channel pore.

Despite substantial efforts, the entire cystic fibrosis transmembrane conductance regulator (CFTR) protein proved to be difficult for structural analysis at high resolution, and little is still known about the actual dimensions of the anion-transporting pathway of CFTR channel. In the present study, we therefore gauged geometrical features of the CFTR Cl(-) channel pore by a nonelectrolyte exclusion technique. Polyethylene glycols with a hydrodynamic radius (R (h)) smaller than 0.95 nm (PEG 300-1,000) added from the intracellular side greatly suppressed the inward unitary anionic conductance, whereas only molecules with R (h) ≤ 0.62 nm (PEG 200-400) applied extracellularly were able to affect the outward unitary anionic currents. Larger molecules with R (h) = 1.16-1.84 nm (PEG 1,540-3,400) added from either side were completely excluded from the pore and had no significant effect on the single-channel conductance. The cut-off radius of the inner entrance of CFTR channel pore was assessed to be 1.19 ± 0.02 nm. The outer entrance was narrower with its cut-off radius of 0.70 ± 0.16 nm and was dilated to 0.93 ± 0.23 nm when a non-hydrolyzable ATP analog, 5'-adenylylimidodiphosphate (AMP-PNP), was added to the intracellular solution. Thus, it is concluded that the structure of CFTR channel pore is highly asymmetric with a narrower extracellular entrance and that a dilating conformational change of the extracellular entrance is associated with the channel transition to a non-hydrolytic, locked-open state.

Interaction of heparins and dextran sulfates with a mesoscopic protein nanopore.

A mechanism of how polyanions influence the channel formed by Staphylococcus aureus alpha-hemolysin is described. We demonstrate that the probability of several types of polyanions to block the ion channel depends on the presence of divalent cations and the polyanion molecular weight and concentration. For heparins, a 10-fold increase in molecular weight decreases the half-maximal inhibitory concentration, IC(50), nearly 10(4)-fold. Dextran sulfates were less effective at blocking the channel. The polyanions are significantly more effective at reducing the conductance when added to the trans side of this channel. Lastly, the effectiveness of heparins on the channel conductance correlated with their influence on the zeta-potential of liposomes. A model that includes the binding of polyanions to the channel-membrane complex via Ca(2+)-bridges and the asymmetry of the channel structure describes the data adequately. Analysis of the single channel current noise of wild-type and site-directed mutant versions of alpha-hemolysin channels suggests that a single polyanion enters the pore due to electrostatic forces and physically blocks the ion conduction path. The results might be of interest for pharmacology, biomedicine, and research aiming to design mesoscopic pore blockers.

Transmembrane cholesterol migration in planar lipid membranes measured with Vibrio cholerae cytolysin as molecular tool.

The rate of transbilayer movement (flip-flop) of cholesterol was estimated using planar bilayers with defined initial asymmetry, formed by the opposing monolayers technique. Vibrio cholerae cytolysin (VCC) was utilized as a molecular tool for measuring the cholesterol concentration in the cis leaflet of asymmetric bilayers. To quantify cholesterol flip-flop in planar lipid bilayers, a mathematical model was developed. It considers both the lateral diffusion rate of cholesterol within each monolayer and the flip-flop rate. The difference in initial and steady-state cholesterol contents in bilayer leaflets was used as a start point. Assuming the lateral diffusion coefficient to be of 1 x 10(-8) cm(2) s(-1), the characteristic time of cholesterol flip-flop at 25 +/- 2 degrees C was estimated as <10 s.

Mechanism of KCl enhancement in detection of nonionic polymers by nanopore sensors.

The mechanisms of KCl-induced enhancement in identification of individual molecules of poly(ethylene glycol) using solitary alpha-hemolysin nanoscale pores are described. The interaction of single molecules with the nanopore causes changes in the ionic current flowing through the pore. We show that the on-rate constant of the process is several hundred times larger and that the off-rate is several hundred times smaller in 4 M KCl than in 1 M KCl. These shifts dramatically improve detection and make single molecule identification feasible. KCl also changes the solubility of poly(ethylene glycol) by the same order of magnitude as it changes the rate constants. In addition, the polymer-nanopore interaction is determined to be a strong non-monotonic function of voltage, indicating that the flexible, nonionic poly(ethylene glycol) acts as a charged molecule. Therefore, salting-out and Coulombic interactions are responsible for the KCl-induced enhancement. These results will advance the development of devices with sensor elements based on single nanopores.

Sizing the Bacillus anthracis PA63 channel with nonelectrolyte poly(ethylene glycols).

Nonelectrolyte polymers of poly(ethylene glycol) (PEG) were used to estimate the diameter of the ion channel formed by the Bacillus anthracis protective antigen 63 (PA(63)). Based on the ability of different molecular weight PEGs to partition into the pore and reduce channel conductance, the pore appears to be narrower than the one formed by Staphylococcus aureus alpha-hemolysin. Numerical integration of the PEG sample mass spectra and the channel conductance data were used to refine the estimate of the pore's PEG molecular mass cutoff (approximately 1400 g/mol). The results suggest that the limiting diameter of the PA(63) pore is <2 nm, which is consistent with an all-atom model of the PA(63) channel and previous experiments using large ions.

Single-molecule mass spectrometry in solution using a solitary nanopore.

We introduce a two-dimensional method for mass spectrometry in solution that is based on the interaction between a nanometer-scale pore and analytes. As an example, poly(ethylene glycol) molecules that enter a single alpha-hemolysin pore cause distinct mass-dependent conductance states with characteristic mean residence times. The conductance-based mass spectrum clearly resolves the repeat unit of ethylene glycol, and the mean residence time increases monotonically with the poly(ethylene glycol) mass. This technique could prove useful for the real-time characterization of molecules in solution.

Pore formation by Vibrio cholerae cytolysin requires cholesterol in both monolayers of the target membrane.

Vibrio cholerae cytolysin (VCC) forms oligomeric transmembrane pores in cholesterol-rich membranes. To better understand this process, we used planar bilayer membranes. In symmetric membranes, the rate of the channel formation by VCC has a superlinear dependency on the cholesterol membrane fraction. Thus, more than one cholesterol molecule can facilitate VCC-pore formation. In asymmetric membranes, the rate of pore formation is limited by the leaflet with the lower cholesterol content. Methyl-beta-cyclodextrin, which removes cholesterol from membranes, rapidly inhibits VCC pore formation, even when it is added to the side opposite that of VCC addition. The results suggest that cholesterol in both membrane leaflets aid VCC-pore formation and that either leaflet can function as a kinetic bottleneck with respect to the rate of pore-formation.

Single polymer molecules in a protein nanopore in the limit of a strong polymer-pore attraction.

The capture and release of single poly(ethylene glycol) molecules by the alpha-Hemolysin pore are observed as time-resolved reversible steps in ion conductance. The capture on rate, inferred from the step frequency, decreases monotonically with polymer size. However, the polymer residence time shows a crossover behavior, first increasing and then decreasing with molecular weight. Our interpretation is that, in the case of polymers which are too large to be accommodated within the pore, the out-of-the-pore part of the molecule pulls on the trapped part, thus acting as an entropic spring.

Conductance and ion selectivity of a mesoscopic protein nanopore probed with cysteine scanning mutagenesis.

Nanometer-scale proteinaceous pores are the basis of ion and macromolecular transport in cells and organelles. Recent studies suggest that ion channels and synthetic nanopores may prove useful in biotechnological applications. To better understand the structure-function relationship of nanopores, we are studying the ion-conducting properties of channels formed by wild-type and genetically engineered versions of Staphylococcus aureus alpha-hemolysin (alphaHL) reconstituted into planar lipid bilayer membranes. Specifically, we measured the ion selectivities and current-voltage relationships of channels formed with 24 different alphaHL point cysteine mutants before and after derivatizing the cysteines with positively and negatively charged sulfhydryl-specific reagents. Novel negative charges convert the selectivity of the channel from weakly anionic to strongly cationic, and new positive charges increase the anionic selectivity. However, the extent of these changes depends on the channel radius at the position of the novel charge (predominantly affects ion selectivity) or on the location of these charges along the longitudinal axis of the channel (mainly alters the conductance-voltage curve). The results suggest that the net charge of the pore wall is responsible for cation-anion selectivity of the alphaHL channel and that the charge at the pore entrances is the main factor that determines the shape of the conductance-voltage curves.

Protein electrostriction: a possibility of elastic deformation of the alpha-hemolysin channel by the applied field.

While conformational flexibility of proteins is widely recognized as one of their functionally crucial features and enjoys proper attention for this reason, their elastic properties are rarely discussed. In ion channel studies, where the voltage-induced or ligand-induced conformational transitions, gating, are the leading topic of research, the elastic structural deformation by the applied electric field has never been addressed at all. Here we examine elasticity using a model channel of known crystal structure-Staphylococcus aureus alpha-hemolysin. Working with single channels reconstituted into planar lipid bilayers, we first show that their ionic conductance is asymmetric with voltage even at the highest salt concentration used where the static charges in the channel interior are maximally shielded. Second, choosing 18-crown-6 as a molecular probe whose size is close to the size of the narrowest part of the alpha-hemolysin pore, we analyze the blockage of the channel by the crown/K(+) complex. Analysis of the blockage within the framework of the Woodhull model in its generalized form demonstrates that the model is able to correctly describe the crown effect only if the parameters of the model are considered to be voltage-dependent. Specifically, one has to include either a voltage-dependent barrier for crown release to the cis side of the channel or voltage-dependent interactions between the binding site and the crown. We suggest that the voltage sensitivity of both the ionic conductance of the channel seen at the highest salt concentration and its blockage by the crown reflects a field-induced deformation of the pore.

Field-dependent effect of crown ether (18-crown-6) on ionic conductance of alpha-hemolysin channels.

Closing linear poly(ethylene glycol) (PEG) into a circular "crown" dramatically changes its dynamics in the alpha-hemolysin channel. In the electrically neutral crown ether (C2H4O)6, six ethylene oxide monomers are linked into a circle that gives the molecule ion-complexing capacity and increases its rigidity. As with linear PEG, addition of the crown to the membrane-bathing solution decreases the ionic conductance of the channel and generates additional conductance noise. However, in contrast to linear PEG, both the conductance reduction (reporting on crown partitioning into the channel pore) and the noise (reporting on crown dynamics in the pore) now depend on voltage strongly and nonmonotonically. Within the whole frequency range accessible in channel reconstitution experiments, the noise power spectrum is "white", showing that crown exchange between the channel and the bulk solution is fast. Analyzing these data in the framework of a Markovian two-state model, we are able to characterize the process quantitatively. We show that the lifetime of the crown in the channel reaches its maximum (a few microseconds) at about the same voltage (approximately 100 mV, negative from the side of protein addition) where the crown's reduction of the channel conductance is most pronounced. Our interpretation is that, because of its rigidity, the crown feels an effective steric barrier in the narrowest part of the channel pore. This barrier together with crown-ion complexing and resultant interaction with the applied field leads to behavior usually associated with voltage-dependent binding in the channel pore.

Does VDAC insert into membranes in random orientation?

It is widely accepted that voltage-dependent anion-selective channel (VDAC) inserts into planar lipid bilayers in a random orientation. This is in contrast to the well-documented oriented insertion of various channel-forming proteins. Because of the potential importance of this issue, we have examined the orientation of VDAC inserted in membranes. The time constants of the VDAC-current relaxation in response to applied positive and negative voltage pulses were used to characterize the channel orientation. We have found that VDAC channels can be separated into two groups according to differences in the time constant ratio. The difference in time constant ratio between the two main groups of VDAC channels was quantitative, and not qualitative as would be expected for opposite topologies. This finding allows us to hypothesize that both groups of VDAC channels possess a qualitatively similar asymmetry with respect to the localization of voltage-gated domains and, consequently, with respect to its entire molecular structure. The probability of having each type of VDAC channel conformation is predetermined by the protein structure in aqueous solution. A striking resemblance between asymmetry in voltage sensitivity at the single-channel and multi-channel levels was also demonstrated. The first inserted channel seems to direct subsequent insertions of channels with a similar conformation.

Probing the volume changes during voltage gating of Porin 31BM channel with nonelectrolyte polymers.

To probe the volume changes of the voltage-dependent anion-selective channel (VDAC), the nonelectrolyte exclusion technique was taken because it is one of the few existing methods that may define quite accurately the rough geometry of lumen of ion channels (in membranes) for which there is no structural data.Here, we corroborate the data from our previous study [FEBS Lett. 416 (1997) 187] that the gross structural features of VDAC in its highest conductance state are asymmetric with respect to the plane of the membrane, and state that this asymmetry is not dependent on sign of voltage applied. Hence, the plasticity of VDAC does not play a role in the determination of lumen geometry at this state and the asymmetry is an internal property of the channel. We also show that the apparent diameter of the cis segment of the pore decreases slightly from 2 to 1.8 nm when the channel's conductance decreases from its high to low state. However, the trans funnel segment undergoes a more marked change in polymer accessible volume. Specifically, its larger diameter decreases from approximately 4 to 2.4 nm. Supposing the channel's total length is 4.6 nm, the apparent change in channel volume during this transition is estimated to be about 10 nm(3), i.e. about 40% of the channel's volume in the high conductance state.