Novel approaches for the control of helminth parasites of livestock VI: summary of discussions and conclusions.

Gastrointestinal helminth parasites impact on livestock production systems throughout the world, and the use of anthelmintics to control this problem has lead to the inevitable development of populations of helminths resistant to these treatments. This, coupled with consumer desires for minimal chemical inputs into food and fibre production, has prompted research into non-chemical approaches to helminth control. Scientists of the "Novel Approaches to the Control of Helminth Parasites of Livestock" group met for the 6th time in August 2010 and this paper summarises that meeting. Six scientific sessions addressed current approaches and topics of interest through formal presentations and discussion of issues raised by the contributing authors. Close interaction between researchers and extension specialists during the meeting has contributed to enhanced prospects for field application of research outcomes in the future.

The use of DNA markers to map anthelmintic resistance loci in an intraspecific cross of Haemonchus contortus.

The use of DNA markers to track the development of anthelmintic resistance in parasites of livestock would allow informed choices for the management of this important problem. We describe a genetic mapping approach for the discovery of DNA markers for anthelmintic resistance in Haemonchus contortus. We crossed a multi-drug resistant field isolate of H. contortus with a well-characterized laboratory strain susceptible to 4 drug classes. The F2 were separately selected with 5 anthelmintics from 4 drug classes, producing drug-resistant populations carrying gene variants derived from both the field isolate and the laboratory strain. Individual F2 worms were analysed using amplicon length polymorphisms (ALPs). We looked for field isolate alleles over- or under-represented in F2 populations compared to the unselected F2 and/or the laboratory strain. The data we obtained suggest that marker association can be used to link neutral markers with resistance, but also that more markers and perhaps more inbred laboratory strains would make the procedure more likely to succeed.

Genetic and phenotypic differences between isolates of Haemonchus contortus in Australia.

We believe this study is the first to consider the genetic and phenotypic divergence between isolates of Haemonchus contortus in Australia. Microsatellite markers have been used to investigate genetic divergence, whilst phenotypic divergence has been considered through individual worm morphology, isolate life history traits and the effect of isolates upon the host. The results are discussed in the context of the likely introduction of H. contortus to Australia, its recent isolation, and the characteristics of sheep and goat farming which might act to either isolate or distribute parasites. We conclude that there is significant observable genetic divergence between isolates of H. contortus in Australia. The divergence may have been under-estimated in this study due to a variety of factors. Phenotypic divergence is also observed, and potentially has significant implications for both economic losses due to haemonchosis on individual properties and for decisions regarding the regulation of stock movements in Australia.

Adjusting worm egg counts for faecal moisture in sheep.

The number of eggs from gastrointestinal nematodes per gram of faeces (worm egg count WEC) is commonly used to determine the need for anti-parasite treatments and the breeding value of animals when selecting for worm resistance. Diarrhoea increases faecal moisture and may dilute the number of worm eggs observed. To quantify this effect, egg counts in sheep at pasture were simulated by dosing 15 animals with chromic oxide particles. The simulated WEC diminished as faecal moisture increased. When faeces were dried, simulated WEC per unit dry matter was not influenced by the amount of faecal moisture present prior to drying. The results suggest that adjustment for faecal moisture may provide an improved estimate of FEC. Drying faeces to calculate the WEC per unit dry matter would provide such an adjustment but may not be practical for industry application. In the past, the CSIRO McMaster Laboratory has used an adjustment factor developed by Gordon based on the classification of faecal consistency derived from the morphology of faeces. To examine the utility of an adjustment factor based on faecal consistency score (FCS), the relationships between FCS and simulated WEC and dry matter were examined. Dry matter and simulated WEC exhibited an exponential decline as FCS increased. The relationship between FCS and dry matter was further examined in 368 samples collected over 12 months from sheep at pasture, where it was observed that dry matter showed a linear decline as FCS increased. Adjustment factors based on dry matter were similar to those proposed by Gordon however adjustment factors predicted from simulated WEC diverged from the remainder for FCS>4. As no samples scored FCS 5 in the study of simulated FEC, the adjustment factors based on the larger study that included samples with FCS 5 was therefore considered more robust. Adjustment factors were given by the equation: WEC(estimated)=(WEC(observed)/(34.21-5.15 FCS))x29.06. This equation estimates for samples with FCS>1 the WEC that would be expected if the samples were FCS 1, the faecal consistency score for normal faeces. The impact of adjustment of observed WEC for faecal moisture predicted by FCS on decision points for treatment and on estimated breeding values requires further examination.

Eradication of targeted species of internal parasites.

Eradication can be defined as the permanent reduction to zero of the incidence of infection caused by a specific agent as a result of deliberate efforts. Eradication strategies must be designed to increase access to and utilization of veterinary and animal health support services beyond that normally achieved by routine services. Consequently, before undertaking an eradication program, proponents must be certain that they can be sure of a commitment of resources sufficient to complete the project. A helminth eradication campaign would require the application of anthelmintics to all hosts at a level aimed at killing heterozygote resistant individuals. This strategy runs counter to the prevailing opinion that resistance to chemicals will always occur and control schemes should accept some production loss by letting a proportion of parasites escape selection (in refugia) and thereby increase the useful life of the chemical. Under certain circumstances, environmental constraints may make some species of parasitic nematodes vulnerable to an eradication program. Anthelmintics have been used to exploit these constraints in past control programs and have lead to local eradication of several species of gastro-intestinal parasitic nematodes. Also, there are at present eradication programs for nematode parasites of human that are based on anthelmintic treatment. However, the suppressive pesticide treatment required to bring about the virtual elimination of species is a high-risk strategy and should only be undertaken if eradication is an achievable goal. It is also important to plan an exit strategy if eradication fails.

A modified larval migration assay for detection of resistance to macrocyclic lactones in Haemonchus contortus, and drug screening with Trichostrongylidae parasites.

We have developed a modified migration assay system in 96-well plate format which is able to detect resistance to the macrocyclic lactone group of drugs in Haemonchus contortus. The assay involves exposure of infective stage larvae to drug for a 24 h period, then counting the numbers of larvae that are able to migrate through an agar and filter mesh system over a further 48 h. The agar barrier greatly increased the sensitivity of the assay for resistance detection compared to use of filter mesh alone. The assay was able to detect the presence of 10% resistant worms in an otherwise susceptible background. However, the assay was ineffective with Trichostrongylus colubriformis and Ostertagia circumcincta indicating that its usefulness for field monitoring will be restricted to situations where H. contortus is of most significance. A small-scale drug screening exercise showed that the assay identifies some anthelmintic activities distinct from those identified by larval development assays. The assay therefore also has a potential role in drug discovery programmes in screening for new anthelmintics.

Characterization of moxidectin resistant Trichostrongylus colubriformis and Haemonchus contortus.

The development of moxidectin resistance (MOX-R) in sheep parasitic gastrointestinal nematodes already carrying multiple resistances to other anthelmintic groups has made control of these strains very difficult. The anthelmintic resistance patterns of MOX-R strains of Trichostrongylus colubriformis and Haemonchus contortus were characterized to provide an insight into the remaining role of anthelmintics in the control of such strains. Homozygous MOX-R individuals of both genera were unaffected by moxidectin. For MOX-R heterozygotes a dose rate of 200 microg/kg abamectin (ABA) given orally removed 25% of H. contortus while 200 microg/kg MOX given orally achieved a 72% reduction. Doubling the dose rate of ABA improved the mean efficacy to 37%. Consequently, in H. contortus, the degree of dominance differs markedly between the two anthelmintics. A dose rate of 8 mg/kg levamisole and 185 mg/kg napthalophos achieved >95% reduction in worm count of the MOX-R homozygous H. contortus but only 85 and 7%, respectively against the MOX-R homozygous T. colubriformis.

Use of lectin binding characteristics to identify gastrointestinal parasite eggs in faeces.

Identification of the presence and abundance of species is important when choosing therapies and control strategies for internal parasitism of livestock. Here we examine lectin binding characteristics of eggs isolated from sheep faeces as a means for identifying the parasite genera contributing to infection. The intensity of lectin staining varied with incubation time, incubation volume, concentration of lectin and concentration of eggs. Formalin fixed eggs had greater autofluorescence but exhibited the same lectin staining pattern as fresh eggs. The stage of egg development did not influence staining. Eggs from Haemonchus contortus, H. placei, Trichostrongylus colubriformis, T. vitrinus, Ostertagia circumcincta, Nematodirus spathiger and the cestode Monezia expansa were incubated with a panel of fluoroscein isothiocyanate (FITC)-labelled lectins. Lectin binding exhibited a genus specific pattern. Haemonchus spp. stained strongly positive with peanut agglutinin (PNA), and were positive for concanavalin A (ConA), Ricinus communis agglutinin (RCA) and Maclura pomifera lectin (MPA). Trichostrongylus spp. were PNA-, ConA-, RCA- and strongly MPA+. O. circumcincta were weakly positive for PNA, MPA, ConA and negative for RCA. N. spathiger were weakly positive for the four lectins, and M. expansa were weakly positive for PNA, RCA and MPA and were strongly ConA+. The genus specificity of lectin staining was used to identify the presence of Trichostrongylus and Haemonchus eggs in faeces from sheep with mixed field infections, however correspondence between lectin staining and larval differentiation for identifying a low prevalence of Ostertagia in the field infection was poor. Refinements in methods for rapid egg isolation may improve egg differentiation on the basis of lectin staining, which could be undertaken by flow cytometry or microscopy.

Selection of different genotype larvae and adult worms for anthelmintic resistance by persistent and short-acting avermectin/milbemycins.

To understand the factors that influence selection for anthelmintic resistance, it is necessary to examine the impact of drug treatment, particularly persistent drugs, on all phases of the worm life cycle. The efficacy of various avermectin/milbemycin anthelmintics was determined against resident worms, incoming larvae (L3) and development of eggs in faecal culture. Homozygote-resistant and maternal and paternal F1-heterozygote genotypes of Haemonchus contortus were used to infect sheep before or after treatment with ivermectin (IVM) oral, IVM capsule, moxidectin (MOX) oral or MOX injectable. Total worm count and quantitative larval culture were used to determine efficacy against parasitic and free-living stages, respectively. Selection for resistance by IVM capsules occurred at the adult and L3 stages because of poor efficacy against these stages for all resistant genotypes. However, the selective advantage of these surviving worms was reduced due to the low development of their eggs to L3 in faecal culture. For MOX, selection for resistance predominantly occurred after treatment because of high efficacy against resident adult worms of all resistant genotypes but poor efficacy against resistant L3 ingested after drug administration. The results indicated no evidence of sex-linked inheritance for IVM resistance. Mean IVM efficacies against homozygous and heterozygous resistant adult worms were not different, and IVM capsule efficacy against incoming L3 was approximately 70% for all resistant genotypes, consistent with a dominant trait. MOX was highly effective against adults of all resistant genotypes and approximately 76% effective against incoming L3 regardless of resistance genotype, also consistent with a dominant trait. These results will enable the impact of persistent drugs on worm control and anthelmintic resistance to be estimated. The results indicate that IVM capsules should not be used in populations where avermectin/milbemycin resistance is present.

Principles for the use of macrocyclic lactones to minimise selection for resistance.

OBJECTIVE: To provide principles for the appropriate use of avermectin/milbemycin or macrocyclic lactone (ML) anthelmintics in sheep, to ensure effective worm control and to minimise selection for ML resistance. STRATEGY: The principles were based on an assessment of the information currently available. The MLs were categorised into three groups (ivermectin [IVM], abamectin [ABA] and moxidectin [MOX]) based on structural differences, persistence and efficacy against ML resistant strains. The reported order of activity or efficacy against ML resistant worm strains was IVM

Inheritance of avermectin resistance in Haemonchus contortus.

A larval development assay was used to compare the responses of the Chiswick Avermectin Resistant (CAVRS) isolate of Haemonchus contortus, an avermectin-susceptible isolate (VRSG) and their crosses to avermectins. The F(1) and F(2) generations of reciprocal crosses between CAVRS and VRSG were denoted as CAVRS malesxVRSG females=CXV, and VRSG malesxCAVRS females=VXC. The levels of avermectin resistance in the developing larvae of the F(1) of both CXV and VXC were indistinguishable from that in the avermectin-resistant parent, indicating that the resistance trait is completely dominant. Avermectin dose-response curves for the CXV F(1) did not show a 50% mortality rate at low concentrations, indicating that avermectin resistance is not sex-linked. This conclusion was confirmed when adult male worms of the F(1) of the CXV mating were found to have survived treatment of the host with 200microgkg(-1) ivermectin. This dose rate (200microgkg(-1) ivermectin) caused a 50% reduction in the number of adult males in the F(1) from both CXV and VXC crosses, but only a non-significant reduction in the number of adult females in the F(1). Dose-response curves obtained for the F(2) generations in the larval development assay indicated the presence of 25% of avermectin-susceptible individuals, suggesting that a single major gene largely controls the avermectin-resistance trait. This genetic analysis of avermectin resistance in an Australian H. contortus isolate indicates that the expression of the gene for avermectin resistance is an autosomal, complete dominant in the larvae; however, in adults its expression is sex-influenced, with males having a lower resistance to avermectin than females.

Selection for anthelmintic resistance by macrocyclic lactones in Haemonchus contortus.

Two morphologically marked strains of Haemonchus contortus, CAVRS (smooth-macrocyclic lactone resistant) and McMaster (linguiform-macrocyclic lactone susceptible), were used to investigate the selection for anthelmintic resistance following exposure to ivermectin (IVM), a non-persistent anthelmintic. and a more persistent anthelmintic, oral moxidectin (MOX). Three types of selection were investigated: (1) selection of resident worms at the time of treatment (Head selection); (2) selection of incoming-larvae post-treatment (Tail selection); and (3) selection of both resident population and incoming larvae (Head + Tail selection). The experimental animals were adult sheep and lambs. In the controls where there was no anthelmintic selection, the proportion of CAVRS in the adult worm population was the same as the proportion in larvae given to both adults and lambs indicating that CAVRS and McMaster H. contortus were equally infective. There was a significant effect of anthelmintic on total worm numbers in adult sheep with MOX treated adults having less worms, but selection type was non-significant. Anthelmintic type had a significant effect on numbers of resistant worms in adult sheep with less resistant worms in the MOX treated groups, but selection type had no effect. Analysis of variance of arcsine-transformed proportions of resistant worms found that the type of anthelmintic had a highly significant effect, with MOX treated adults having a higher proportion of resistant worms, while type of selection was not significant. In the lambs, nil treated controls and IVM Head + Tail and Tail selected groups had similar geometric mean total worm burdens while Head selected had less total worms. In the MOX treated lamb groups the worm burdens were similar within selection type but less than the IVM treated groups. In the lambs, the types of selection that resulted in more resistant worms were IVM Tail, MOX Head + Tail and MOX Tail. Resistant worm numbers were similar in both adult and lamb groups with Head selection by either MOX or IVM. Moxidectin selected out higher proportions of resistant worms than did IVM in the lambs, with Tail and Head + Tail being stronger selectors than Head. Computer simulations were used to estimate the rate at which resistance developed in the field using the information generated in the present study. The anthelmintic treatments used in the simulation followed a strategic parasite control program for H. contortus in which all sheep receive three Closantel (CLS) treatments in summer. all sheep receive a broad-spectrum (BS) drench or capsule at weaning and lambs receive an additional two BS drenches insummer or no further treatment in the case of the capsule. Moxidectin, IVM-capsule and IVM were the broad spectrum anthelmintics simulated. All simulations were run four times assuming high or low efficacy against resident resistant worms and in the presence or absence of CLS resistance. The simulations indicated that the presence of CLS resistance hastened selection for macrocyclic lactone (ML) resistance. While the IVM-capsule will select most rapidly for ML resistance, IVM oral is expected to be least selective. Moxidectin treatment is intermediate, except in simulations with no CLS resistance and when MOX is assumed to be highly effective against resident ML-resistant worms, in which case MOX can be expected to select more slowly than IVM oral treatments.

Workshop on irradiated larval vaccines.

The development of anthelmintic resistance in gastrointestinal parasites of sheep and goats has meant that there is an urgent need for non-chemical control of these parasites. In order to investigate a potential alternative method of control, a workshop on irradiated larval vaccines (ILV) was held in conjunction with the Second International Conference on Novel Approaches to the Control of Helminth Parasites of Livestock. The objectives of the workshop were to: (1) Review knowledge of irradiated helminth vaccines through the presentation of invited and contributed papers. (2) Identify opportunities for an ILV and in which host/parasite/production systems. (3) Determine what are the gaps in knowledge required to produce and apply an ILV. The workshop concluded that ILVs could be useful as research tools in the further definition of immune responses to parasites and in stimulating the immune response in young sheep and goats to facilitate the estimating of heritability of faecal egg counts. Although the workshop identified some problems associated with a live attenuated vaccine, an ILV could be a useful control measure in the production systems identified by the workshop. Before an ILV could be used on farms, additional research is required into the period of protection afforded by an ILV especially under field conditions. The efficacy of an ILV could be improved by interaction between host genotype and nutritional status and is deserving of further investigation.

A hybridisation technique to identify anthelmintic resistance genes in Haemonchus.

The identification of genes associated with anthelmintic resistance can be facilitated in Haemonchus contortus by the ability of this species to hybridise with Haemonchus placei. Although the hybrid males are sterile, the lines can be rescued by backcrossing the females to either parental species. Resistance genes can be retained in Haemonchus hybrids, while the unwanted contortus background is removed through backcrossing to H. placei and anthelmintic selection of the progeny. Under this selection, genes involved in resistance would retain the H. contortus nucleotide sequence, while those that are not would either be H. placei or a random mixture of both, depending on the amount of backcrossing that had occurred. The first candidate gene to be tested in this system was a Haemonchus P-glycoprotein, hcpgp-1. hcpgp-1 was amplified, cloned and sequenced from H. contortus and H. placei. Two restriction sites were then identified in the sequenced product; one specific to H. contortus hcpgp-1 and the other found only in the H. placei gene. These genes were identified from macrocyclic lactone selected and non-selected worms by restricting PCR products from individual worms. Fitted occurrence of the H. contortus allele was 49% of unselected worms and 69% of macrocyclic lactone selected worms. The probability of this percentage occurring by chance was P = 0.006. Thus macrocyclic lactone selection was acting to increase the percentage of hcpgp-1 from macrocyclic-lactone-resistant CAVRS.

The value of circulating eosinophil count as a selection criteria for resistance of sheep to trichostrongyle parasites.

In merino sheep bred for either increased or decreased resistance to Haemonchus contortus, faecal worm egg counts (FEC) were lower in the resistant line (6,831 vs 17,645 epg, P < 0.01), and circulating eosinophils (EOS) were higher, but not significantly so (3.40 x 10(4) ml(-1) vs 1.40 x 10(4) ml(-1), P = 0.1 1). Another flock was artificially infected with Trichostrongylus colubriformis and significant genetic variation was found in both FEC (heritability 0.40 +/- 0.11) and EOS (0.19 +/- 0.08). In a third flock comprising tropical sheep breeds, a natural challenge with T. colubriformis resulted in significant sire effects on FEC (heritability 0.20 +/- 0.10) but not EOS (heritability inestimable). We conclude that EOS offers no advantage over FEC as it selection criterion for resistance.

Characterisation of an avermectin resistant strain of Australian Haemonchus contortus.

A strain of Haemonchus contortus (CAVR) isolated in Australia was found to be resistant to ivermectin (IVM) with 0.4 mg kg-1 of the anthelmintic failing to significantly reduce worm burdens. Resistance to IVM was sex-influenced in the CAVR strain with adult males showing a greater sensitivity to IVM. Cross resistance to moxidectin was evident with approximately 15% of the population surviving a dose of 0.1 mg kg-1. The free-living stages of the CAVR isolate had a reduced sensitivity to avermectin (AVM) inhibition of development and motility. Similar structure-activity patterns and resistance factors were obtained for a series of related AVMs as inhibitors of larval development and L3 motility in CAVR and White River II, an IVM-resistant H. contortus isolate from South Africa. Further, both isolates were found to be 3 times more sensitive to paraherquamide than a susceptible H. contortus isolate. This suggest that the same resistance mechanism is operating in both isolates. The CAVR strain is susceptible to the benzimidazoles, levamisole and closantel.

Anthelmintic resistance in nematode parasites of sheep: learning from the Australian experience.

In recent years the problem of anthelmintic resistance has become of major importance in sheep and goat flocks throughout the world. In Australia, concerted efforts were initiated in the mid 1980s to halt the increase in resistance by the development and promotion of regional worm control programmes. This article outlines the genesis of these programmes, the way in which they were promoted and successfully adopted by farmers, and the concerns for effective parasitic control of sheep and goat flocks in the future. The principles outlined should be applicable in other countries where anthelmintics are relied upon for the control of nematodes in livestock.

Relationship of blood loss to worm numbers, biomass and egg production in Haemonchus infected sheep.

Chromium51 labelled erythrocytes were used to measure blood loss in sheep infected with either H. contortus, H. placei or the F1 of their reciprocal cross hybrids (H. contortus males x H. placei females = CXP, H. placei males x H. contortus females = PXC). CXP consisted of sterile males and semi-sterile females and sheep infected with this hybrid had nil egg counts; while PXC consisted of semi-sterile males and females and their hosts had some eggs in their faeces. Immediately after their blood loss was estimated the sheep were killed and their worms counted. One hundred male and 100 female worms from each sheep were dried at 60 degrees C overnight and then weighed to give an estimate of the biomass in each infection. Total daily egg production was calculated from egg counts made on 3 random 2 g samples from the 24 h faecal collection. The relationship of the log blood loss to log worm number, to log biomass of infection in each sheep and to log total egg production in the parental species was linear. Biomass was no better an estimator of blood loss than was worm number. There was no improvement in the estimation of blood loss by regressing the male and female worms separately. In all of the analyses, there was no improvement by regressing H. contortus and H. placei or their hybrids separately. It appeared that egg production was not a major factor in the requirement for blood by Haemonchus. The size of individual female worms was negatively correlated with the number of worms in the infection.(ABSTRACT TRUNCATED AT 250 WORDS)

A comparison of plasma metabolite levels in goats and sheep during continuous low-level administration of fenbendazole.

Plasma levels of fenbendazole (FBZ) and its sulphoxide (OFZ) and sulphone (FBZ.SO2) metabolites were measured in goats and sheep during low-level administration of FBZ given by intraruminal infusion or formulated into a urea-molasses feed supplement block (UMB). In experiment 1, 6 goats and 6 sheep were offered UMB containing 0.5 g FBZ/kg (MUMB) and individual block consumption was measured daily for 18 days. In experiment 2, some of the same animals (n = 4 for each species) received FBZ by intraruminal infusion at 1, 1.5 and 3 mg/kg liveweight per day for 7 days at each dosage. FBZ, OFZ and FBZ.SO2 levels were determined in plasma collected every 3 days in experiment 1 and on days 4, 5 and 6 of each infusion period in experiment 2. In both experiments, higher equilibrium levels were observed for the three metabolites in sheep than in goats. Significant linear relationships were observed between the daily FBZ dosages and the plasma levels of the three metabolites in both species. The regression coefficients were significantly higher in sheep than in goats for FBZ and OFZ but not for FBZ.SO2, and they were also significantly higher during MUMB administration than during infusion for all three metabolites in both species. FBZ is a suitable anthelmintic for incorporation into a MUMB formulation for use in livestock production systems where responses to molasses urea supplementation have been demonstrated and gastrointestinal parasitism impairs productivity. The results indicate that target dose rates for goats should be 0.75 mg/kg per day compared with 0.5 mg/kg per day for sheep.