fMRI of human olfaction at the individual level: interindividual variability.

PURPOSE: To determine whether the range of normal variation of human olfactory functional magnetic resonance imaging (fMRI) activations in healthy single subjects is compatible with the detection of atypical patterns. MATERIALS AND METHODS: In an event-related olfactory experiment, the variability of fMRI activation in six bilateral olfactory areas known to be affected in neurodegenerative diseases was measured in a region of interest (ROI) analysis in terms of intensity, localization, and overlap on 51 subjects. fMRI measurements were compared against measurements from a visual experiment performed on 25 subjects. RESULTS: Olfaction induced activations with low intensity, high variability, and a 4-fold lower contrast-to-noise ratio (CNR) than vision. Even in the best case (piriform cortex), mean pairwise activation overlap was still less than 40%. None of the olfactory ROIs showed significant activation for all subjects at the permissive threshold of P < 0.001. A gender-dependent significantly stronger activation was found in the bilateral piriform cortex of male subjects. CONCLUSION: Linking t-statistics and CNR showed that for all olfactory ROIs, CNR is either near or below the estimated threshold of 0.73 found to be necessary to obtain significant activations. In our experimental conditions the low reliability of olfactory activations should prompt major reservations over using fMRI of human olfaction as a diagnostic tool in single subjects.

Brain processing of biologically relevant odors in the awake rat, as revealed by manganese-enhanced MRI.

BACKGROUND: So far, an overall view of olfactory structures activated by natural biologically relevant odors in the awake rat is not available. Manganese-enhanced MRI (MEMRI) is appropriate for this purpose. While MEMRI has been used for anatomical labeling of olfactory pathways, functional imaging analyses have not yet been performed beyond the olfactory bulb. Here, we have used MEMRI for functional imaging of rat central olfactory structures and for comparing activation maps obtained with odors conveying different biological messages. METHODOLOGY/PRINCIPAL FINDINGS: Odors of male fox feces and of chocolate flavored cereals were used to stimulate conscious rats previously treated by intranasal instillation of manganese (Mn). MEMRI activation maps showed Mn enhancement all along the primary olfactory cortex. Mn enhancement elicited by male fox feces odor and to a lesser extent that elicited by chocolate odor, differed from that elicited by deodorized air. This result was partly confirmed by c-Fos immunohistochemistry in the piriform cortex. CONCLUSION/SIGNIFICANCE: By providing an overall image of brain structures activated in awake rats by odorous stimulation, and by showing that Mn enhancement is differently sensitive to different stimulating odors, the present results demonstrate the interest of MEMRI for functional studies of olfaction in the primary olfactory cortex of laboratory small animals, under conditions close to natural perception. Finally, the factors that may cause the variability of the MEMRI signal in response to different odor are discussed.

Systematic ratio normalization of gas chromatography signals for biological sample discrimination and biomarker discovery.

The present paper introduces a new gas chromatography data processing procedure dubbed systematic ratio normalization (SRN) enabling to improve both sample set discrimination and biomarker identification. SRN consists in (1) calculating, for each sample, all the log-ratios between abundances of chromatography-analyzed compounds, then (2) selecting the log-ratio(s) that best maximize the discrimination between sample-sets. The relevance of SRN was evaluated on two data sets acquired through gas chromatography-mass spectrometry as part of separate studies designed (i) to discriminate source-origins between vegetable oils analyzed via an analytical system exposed to instrument drift (data set 1) and (ii) to discriminate animal feed between meat samples aged for different durations (data set 2). Applying SRN to raw data made it possible to obtain robust discrimination models for the two data sets by enhancing the contribution to the data variance of the factor-of-interest while stabilizing the contribution of the disturbance factor. The most discriminant log-ratios were shown to employ the most relevant biomarkers presenting relative independence of the factor-of-interest as well as co-behavior of the disturbance effects potentially biasing the discrimination, such as instrument drift or sample biochemical changes. SRN can be run a posteriori on any data set, and might be generalizable to most of separating methods.

Mapping of muscle deformation during heating: in situ dynamic MRI and nonlinear registration.

We present developments in dynamic magnetic resonance imaging that allow internal structural muscle markers to be followed during heating. This monitoring is based on quantitative characterization of the experimental conditions and their temperature time course. A nonlinear image registration technique was optimized and applied to consecutively acquired images to measure the deformation fields in the muscle. A model coupling local deformation and temperature was obtained, which for the first time takes into account the variations of deformation and temperature in the sample. This modeling opens the way to a better understanding of the mechanisms responsible for mass loss and degradation of the textural properties of muscle during heating.

Effects of manganese injected into rat nostrils: implications for in vivo functional study of olfaction using MEMRI.

Manganese-enhanced magnetic resonance imaging (MEMRI) is a powerful tool for visualizing neuronal pathways and mapping brain activity modulation. A potential drawback of MEMRI lies in the toxic effects of manganese (Mn), which also depend on its administration route. The aim of this study was to analyze the effects of Mn doses injected into the nostrils of rats on both olfactory perception and MRI contrast enhancement. For this purpose, doses in the range 0-8 µmol MnCl(2) were tested. Behavioral items were quantified with and without odor stimulation during the first 2 h following Mn injection. The MRI study was performed after 16 h of intermittent olfactory stimulations. Behavioral results showed that, during the early period following Mn administration, spontaneous motor activity was not affected, while odor-related behaviors were dose-dependently reduced. MRI results showed that, in the primary olfactory cortex, contrast was rapidly enhanced for Mn doses up to 0.3 µmol and very slowly above. This dose of 0.3 µmol Mn can thus be taken as the optimal dose for injection into rat nostrils to ensure a reproducible contrast in MRI studies while sparing olfactory perception.

Iterative algorithm for spatial and intensity normalization of MEMRI images. Application to tract-tracing of rat olfactory pathways.

Manganese (Mn)-enhanced magnetic resonance imaging (MEMRI) is an emerging technique for visualizing neuronal pathways and mapping brain activity modulation in animal models. Spatial and intensity normalizations of MEMRI images acquired from different subjects are crucial steps as they can influence the results of groupwise analysis. However, no commonly accepted procedure has yet emerged. Here, a normalization method is proposed that performs both spatial and intensity normalizations in a single iterative process without the arbitrary choice of a reference image. Spatial and intensity normalizations benefit from this iterative process. On one hand, spatial normalization increases the accuracy of region of interest (ROI) positioning for intensity normalization. On the other hand, improving the intensity normalization of the different MEMRI images leads to a better-averaged target on which the images are spatially registered. After automatic fast brain segmentation and optimization of the normalization process, this algorithm revealed the presence of Mn up to the posterior entorhinal cortex in a tract-tracing experiment on rat olfactory pathways. Quantitative comparison of registration algorithms showed that a rigid model with anisotropic scaling is the best deformation model for intersubject registration of three-dimensional MEMRI images. Furthermore, intensity normalization errors may occur if the ROI chosen for intensity normalization intersects regions where Mn concentration differs between experimental groups. Our study suggests that cross-comparing Mn-injected animals against a Mn-free group may provide a control to avoid bias introduced by intensity normalization quality. It is essential to optimize spatial and intensity normalization as the detectability of local between-group variations in Mn concentration is directly tied to normalization quality.