Realization of Higher Resolution Charge Detection Mass Spectrometry.

Charge detection mass spectrometry (CD-MS) allows mass distributions to be measured for heterogeneous samples that cannot be analyzed by conventional MS. With CD-MS, the m/z and charge are measured for individual ions using a detection cylinder embedded in an electrostatic linear ion trap (ELIT). Imprecision in both the m/z and charge measurements contribute to the mass resolution. However, if the charge can be measured with a precision of <0.2 e the charge state can be assigned with a low error rate and the mass resolving power only depends on the m/z resolution. Prior to this work, the best resolving power demonstrated experimentally for CD-MS was 700. Here we demonstrate a resolving power of >14,600, 20-times higher than the previous best. Trajectory simulations were used to optimize the geometry and electrostatic potentials of the ELIT. We found conditions where the energy dependence of the oscillation frequency becomes parabolic, and then operated with a nominal ion energy at the minimum of the parabola. The 14,600 resolving power was obtained with a beam collimator before the ELIT. With the collimator removed, the resolving power of the optimized ELIT is 7300, which is still an order of magnitude higher than the previous best. The resolving power was demonstrated by resolving the isotope distributions for peptides and proteins. High resolution CD-MS measurements were then used to resolve the glycans on a monoclonal antibody and applied to the analysis of hepatitis B virus capsids. The results indicate that procedures for adduct removal need to be improved for the full benefit of the higher resolving power to be realized for higher mass species. However, these results represent a key step toward using CD-MS to analyze very complex protein mixtures where charge states are not well resolved in the m/z spectrum because of congestion from numerous overlapping peaks.

Complementary Nanoparticle Characterization by Resistive-Pulse Sensing, Electron Microscopy, and Charge Detection Mass Spectrometry.

Nanotechnology has provided novel modalities for the delivery of therapeutic and diagnostic agents. In particular, nanoparticles (NPs) can be engineered at a low cost for drug loading and delivery. For example, silica NPs have proven useful as a controlled release platform for anti-inflammatory drugs. Despite the wide-ranging potential applications for NPs, robust characterization across all size ranges remains elusive. Electron microscopy (EM) is the conventional tool for measuring NP diameters. However, imitations in throughput and the inability to provide comprehensive information on physical properties, such as mass and density, without underlying assumptions, hinder a complete analysis. In addition, assessing sample heterogeneity, aggregation, or coalescence in solution by traditional EM analysis is not possible. Resistive-pulse sensing (RPS) provides a high throughput, solution-phase method for characterizing particle heterogeneity based on volume. Complementing these methods, charge detection mass spectrometry (CD-MS), a single particle technique, provides accurate mass information for heterogeneous samples including NPs. By combining EM, RPS and CD-MS, accurate volume, mass, and densities were obtained for silica NPs of various sizes. The results show that the density for 20 nm silica NPs is close to the density of fused silica (2.2 g/cm3). Larger silica NPs were found to have densities that were either smaller or larger, while also falling outside the range of densities usually found for silica colloids and NPs (1.9-2.3 g/cm3). Lower densities are attributed to pores (i.e., porous particles). For one sample, the mass distribution showed two components attributed to two populations of particles in the sample with different densities. The synergistic combination of EM, RPS, and CD-MS measurements outlined here for NP samples, allows much more extensive information to be obtained than from any of the techniques alone.

Charge Detection Mass Spectrometry Reveals Favored Structures in the Assembly of Virus-Like Particles: Polymorphism in Norovirus GI.1.

The main capsid protein (CP) of norovirus, the leading cause of gastroenteritis, is expected to self-assemble into virus-like particles with the same structure as the wild-type virus, a capsid with 180 CPs in a T = 3 icosahedron. Using charge detection mass spectrometry (CD-MS), we find that the norovirus GI.1 variant is structurally promiscuous, forming a wide variety of well-defined structures, some that are icosahedral capsids and others that are not. The structures that are present evolve with time and vary with solution conditions. The presence of icosahedral T = 3 and T = 4 capsids (240 CPs) under some conditions was confirmed by cryo-electron microscopy (cryo-EM). The cryo-EM studies also confirmed the presence of an unexpected prolate geometry based on an elongated T = 4 capsid with 300 CPs. In addition, CD-MS measurements indicate the presence of well-defined peaks with masses corresponding to 420, 480, 600, and 700 CPs. The peak corresponding to 420 CPs is probably due to an icosahedral T = 7 capsid, but this could not be confirmed by cryo-EM. It is possible that the T = 7 particles are too fragile to survive vitrification. There are no mass peaks associated with the T = 9 and T = 12 icosahedra with 540 and 720 CPs. The larger structures with 480, 600, and 700 CPs are not icosahedral; however, their measured charges suggest that they are hollow shells. The use of CD-MS to monitor virus-like particles assembly may have important applications in vaccine development and quality control.

Compaction, Relaxation, and Linearization of Megadalton-Sized DNA Plasmids: DNA Structures Probed by CD-MS.

High purity plasmid DNA is a raw material for recombinant protein production as well as an active ingredient in DNA vaccines. There are four primary plasmid structures that can be observed in a typical plasmid formulation: supercoiled, relaxed (circular), linearized, and condensed. Determining what structures are present in a sample is important, as the structure can affect activity; the supercoiled structure has the highest activity, and >90% supercoiled is desired for industry standards. Recently, charge detection mass spectrometry (CD-MS) was used to distinguish two of the structures, supercoiled and condensed, by measuring the charge deposited on the ions by positive mode electrospray. Here, CD-MS is used to probe the structures of DNA plasmids during compaction with polycations, and through enzymatic treatment to relax and linearize plasmids. We find that all four structural types for plasmid DNA have unique charging profiles that can be distinguished using CD-MS. The extent of mechanical shearing of the DNA plasmids during electrospray is strongly influenced by the structural type.

Point mutation in a virus-like capsid drives symmetry reduction to form tetrahedral cages.

Protein capsids are a widespread form of compartmentalization in nature. Icosahedral symmetry is ubiquitous in capsids derived from spherical viruses, as this geometry maximizes the internal volume that can be enclosed within. Despite the strong preference for icosahedral symmetry, we show that simple point mutations in a virus-like capsid can drive the assembly of unique symmetry-reduced structures. Starting with the encapsulin from Myxococcus xanthus, a 180-mer bacterial capsid that adopts the well-studied viral HK97 fold, we use mass photometry and native charge detection mass spectrometry to identify a triple histidine point mutant that forms smaller dimorphic assemblies. Using cryoelectron microscopy, we determine the structures of a precedented 60-mer icosahedral assembly and an unexpected 36-mer tetrahedron that features significant geometric rearrangements around a new interaction surface between capsid protomers. We subsequently find that the tetrahedral assembly can be generated by triple-point mutation to various amino acids and that even a single histidine point mutation is sufficient to form tetrahedra. These findings represent a unique example of tetrahedral geometry when surveying all characterized encapsulins, HK97-like capsids, or indeed any virus-derived capsids reported in the Protein Data Bank, revealing the surprising plasticity of capsid self-assembly that can be accessed through minimal changes in the protein sequence.

Point mutation in a virus-like capsid drives symmetry reduction to form tetrahedral cages.

Protein capsids are a widespread form of compartmentalisation in nature. Icosahedral symmetry is ubiquitous in capsids derived from spherical viruses, as this geometry maximises the internal volume that can be enclosed within. Despite the strong preference for icosahedral symmetry, we show that simple point mutations in a virus-like capsid can drive the assembly of novel symmetry-reduced structures. Starting with the encapsulin from Myxococcus xanthus, a 180-mer bacterial capsid that adopts the well-studied viral HK97 fold, we use mass photometry and native charge detection mass spectrometry to identify a triple histidine point mutant that forms smaller dimorphic assemblies. Using cryo-EM, we determine the structures of a precedented 60-mer icosahedral assembly and an unprecedented 36-mer tetrahedron that features significant geometric rearrangements around a novel interaction surface between capsid protomers. We subsequently find that the tetrahedral assembly can be generated by triple point mutation to various amino acids, and that even a single histidine point mutation is sufficient to form tetrahedra. These findings represent the first example of tetrahedral geometry across all characterised encapsulins, HK97-like capsids, or indeed any virus-derived capsids reported in the Protein Data Bank, revealing the surprising plasticity of capsid self-assembly that can be accessed through minimal changes in protein sequence.

A novel class of self-complementary AAV vectors with multiple advantages based on cceAAV lacking mutant ITR.

Self-complementary AAV vectors (scAAV) use a mutant inverted terminal repeat (mITR) for efficient packaging of complementary stranded DNA, enabling rapid transgene expression. However, inefficient resolution at the mITR leads to the packaging of monomeric or subgenomic AAV genomes. These noncanonical particles reduce transgene expression and may affect the safety of gene transfer. To address these issues, we have developed a novel class of scAAV vectors called covalently closed-end double-stranded AAV (cceAAV) that eliminate the mITR resolution step during production. Instead of using a mutant ITR, we used a 56-bp recognition sequence of protelomerase (TelN) to covalently join the top and bottom strands, allowing the vector to be generated with just a single ITR. To produce cceAAV vectors, the vector plasmid is initially digested with TelN, purified, and then subjected to a standard triple-plasmid transfection protocol followed by traditional AAV vector purification procedures. Such cceAAV vectors demonstrate yields comparable to scAAV vectors. Notably, we observed enhanced transgene expression as compared to traditional scAAV vectors. The treatment of mice with hemophilia B with cceAAV-FIX resulted in significantly enhanced long-term FIX expression. The cceAAV vectors hold several advantages over scAAV vectors, potentially leading to the development of improved human gene therapy drugs.

Biophysical and structural characterization of a multifunctional viral genome packaging motor.

The large dsDNA viruses replicate their DNA as concatemers consisting of multiple covalently linked genomes. Genome packaging is catalyzed by a terminase enzyme that excises individual genomes from concatemers and packages them into preassembled procapsids. These disparate tasks are catalyzed by terminase alternating between two distinct states-a stable nuclease that excises individual genomes and a dynamic motor that translocates DNA into the procapsid. It was proposed that bacteriophage λ terminase assembles as an anti-parallel dimer-of-dimers nuclease complex at the packaging initiation site. In contrast, all characterized packaging motors are composed of five terminase subunits bound to the procapsid in a parallel orientation. Here, we describe biophysical and structural characterization of the λ holoenzyme complex assembled in solution. Analytical ultracentrifugation, small angle X-ray scattering, and native mass spectrometry indicate that 5 subunits assemble a cone-shaped terminase complex. Classification of cryoEM images reveals starfish-like rings with skewed pentameric symmetry and one special subunit. We propose a model wherein nuclease domains of two subunits alternate between a dimeric head-to-head arrangement for genome maturation and a fully parallel arrangement during genome packaging. Given that genome packaging is strongly conserved in both prokaryotic and eukaryotic viruses, the results have broad biological implications.

CDMS Analysis of Intact 19S, 20S, 26S, and 30S Proteasomes: Evidence for Higher-Order 20S Assemblies at a Low pH†.

Charge detection mass spectrometry (CDMS) was examined as a means of studying proteasomes. To this end, the following masses of the 20S, 19S, 26S, and 30S proteasomes from Saccharomyces cerevisiae (budding yeast) were measured: m(20S) = 738.8 ± 2.9 kDa, m(19S) = 926.2 ± 4.8 kDa, m(26S) = 1,637.0 ± 7.6 kDa, and m(30S) = 2,534.2 ± 10.8 kDa. Under some conditions, larger (20S)x (where x = 1 to ∼13) assemblies are observed; the 19S regulatory particle also oligomerizes, but to a lesser extent, forming (19S)x complexes (where x = 1 to 4, favoring the x = 3 trimer). The (20S)x oligomers are favored in vitro, as the pH of the solution is lowered (from 7.0 to 5.4, in a 20 mM ammonium acetate solution) and may be related to in vivo proteasome storage granules that are observed under carbon starvation. From measurements of m(20S)x (x = 1 to ∼13) species, it appears that each multimer retains all 28 proteins of the 20S complex subunit. Several types of structures that might explain the formation of (20S)x assemblies are considered. We stress that each structural type [hypothetical planar, raft-like geometries (where individual proteasomes associate through side-by-side interactions); elongated, rodlike geometries (where subunits are bound end-to-end); and geometries that are roughly spherical (arising from aggregation through nonspecific subunit interactions)] is highly speculative but still interesting to consider, and a short discussion is provided. The utility of CDMS for characterizing proteasomes and related oligomers is discussed.

Antibody Binding to Recombinant Adeno Associated Virus Monitored by Charge Detection Mass Spectrometry.

Recombinant adeno-associated virus (rAAV) is a leading gene therapy vector. However, neutralizing antibodies reduce its efficacy. Traditional methods used to investigate antibody binding provide limited information. Here, charge detection mass spectrometry (CD-MS) was used to investigate the binding of monoclonal antibody ADK8 to AAV serotype 8 (AAV8). CD-MS provides a label-free approach to antibody binding. Individual binding events can be monitored as each event is indicated by a shift of the antibody-antigen complex to a higher mass. Unlike other methods, the CD-MS approach reveals the distribution of antibodies bound on capsids, allowing AAV8 subpopulations with different affinities to be identified. The charge state generated by the electrospray of large ions is normally correlated with the structure, and the charge is expected to increase when an antibody binds to the capsid exterior. Surprisingly, binding of the first ADK8 to AAV8 causes a substantial decrease in the charge, suggesting that the first antibody binding event causes a significant structural change. The charge increases for subsequent binding events. Finally, high ADK8 concentrations cause agglutination, where ADK8 links AAV capsids to form dimers and higher order multimers.

Electrostatic Linear Ion Trap Optimization Strategy for High Resolution Charge Detection Mass Spectrometry.

Single ion mass measurements allow mass distributions to be recorded for heterogeneous samples that cannot be analyzed by conventional mass spectrometry. In charge detection mass spectrometry (CD-MS), ions are detected using a conducting cylinder coupled to a charge sensitive amplifier. For optimum performance, the detection cylinder is embedded in an electrostatic linear ion trap (ELIT) where trapped ions oscillate between end-caps that act as opposing ion mirrors. The oscillating ions generate a periodic signal that is analyzed by fast Fourier transforms. The frequency yields the m/z, and the magnitude provides the charge. With a charge precision of 0.2 elementary charges, ions can be assigned to their correct charge states with a low error rate, and the m/z resolving power determines the mass resolving power. Previously, the best mass resolving power achieved with CD-MS was 300. We have recently increased the mass resolving power to 700, through the better optimization of the end-cap potentials. To make a more dramatic improvement in the m/z resolving power, it is necessary to find an ELIT geometry and end-cap potentials that can simultaneously make the ion oscillation frequency independent of both the ion energy and ion trajectory (angular divergence and radial offset) of the entering ion. We describe an optimization strategy that allows these conditions to be met while also adjusting the signal duty cycle to 50% to maximize the signal-to-noise ratio for the charge measurement. The optimized ELIT provides an m/z resolving power of over 300 000 in simulations. Coupled with the high precision charge determination available with CD-MS, this will yield a mass resolving power of 300 000. Such a high mass resolving power will be transformative for the analysis of heterogeneous samples.

Analysis of Megadalton-Sized DNA by Charge Detection Mass Spectrometry: Entropic Trapping and Shearing in Nanoelectrospray.

The analysis of nucleic acids by conventional mass spectrometry is complicated by counter ions which cause mass heterogeneity and limit the size of the DNA that can be analyzed. In this work, we overcome this limitation using charge detection mass spectrometry to analyze megadalton-sized DNA. Using positive mode electrospray, we find two dramatically different charge distributions for DNA plasmids. A low charge population that charges like compact DNA origami and a much higher charge population, with charges that extend over a broad range. For the high-charge population, the deviation between the measured mass and mass expected from the DNA sequence is consistently around 1%. For the low-charge population, the deviation is larger and more variable. The high-charge population is attributed to the supercoiled plasmid in a random coil configuration, with the broad charge distribution resulting from the rich variety of geometries the random coil can adopt. High-resolution measurements show that the mass distribution shifts to slightly lower mass with increasing charge. The low-charge population is attributed to a condensed form of the plasmid. We suggest that the condensed form results from entropic trapping where the random coil must undergo a geometry change to squeeze through the Taylor cone and enter an electrospray droplet. For the larger plasmids, shearing (mechanical breakup) occurs during electrospray or in the electrospray interface. Shearing is reduced by lowering the salt concentration.

Charge detection mass spectrometry for the analysis of viruses and virus-like particles.

Heterogeneity usually restricts conventional mass spectrometry to molecular weights less than around a megadalton. As a single-particle technique, charge detection mass spectrometry (CDMS) overcomes this limitation. In CDMS, the mass-to-charge (m/z) ratio and charge are measured simultaneously for individual ions, giving a direct mass measurement for each ion. Recent applications include the analysis of viruses, virus-like particles, vaccines, heavily glycosylated proteins, and gene therapy vectors.

Characterization of Classical Vaccines by Charge Detection Mass Spectrometry.

Vaccines induce immunity by presenting disease antigens through several platforms ranging from individual protein subunits to whole viruses. Due to the large difference in antigen size, the analytical techniques employed for vaccine characterization are often platform-specific. A single, robust analytical technique capable of widespread, cross-platform use would be of great benefit and allow for comparisons across manufacturing processes. One method that spans the antigen mass range is charge detection mass spectrometry (CDMS). CDMS is a single-ion approach where the mass-to-charge ratio (m/z) and charge are measured simultaneously, allowing accurate mass distributions to be measured for heterogeneous analytes over a broad size range. In this work, CDMS was used to characterize the antigens from three classical multivalent vaccines, inactivated poliomyelitis vaccine (IPOL), RotaTeq, and Gardasil-9, directly from commercial samples. For each vaccine, the antigen purity was inspected, and in the whole virus vaccines, empty virus particles were detected. For IPOL, information on the extent of formaldehyde cross-linking was obtained. RotaTeq shows a narrow peak at 61.06 MDa. This is at a slightly lower mass than expected for the double-layer particle, suggesting that around 10 pentonal trimers are missing. For Gardasil-9, buffer exchange of the vaccine resulted in very broad mass distributions. However, removal of the virus-like particles from the aluminum adjuvant using a displacement reaction generated a spectrum with narrow peaks.

Heterogeneity of Glycan Processing on Trimeric SARS-CoV-2 Spike Protein Revealed by Charge Detection Mass Spectrometry.

The heterogeneity associated with glycosylation of the 66 N-glycan sites on the protein trimer making up the spike (S) region of the SARS-CoV-2 virus has been assessed by charge detection mass spectrometry (CDMS). CDMS allows simultaneous measurement of the mass-to-charge ratio and charge of individual ions, so that mass distributions can be determined for highly heterogeneous proteins such as the heavily glycosylated S protein trimer. The CDMS results are compared to recent glycoproteomics studies of the structure and abundance of glycans at specific sites. Interestingly, average glycan masses determined by "top-down" CDMS measurements are 35-47% larger than those obtained from the "bottom-up" glycoproteomics studies, suggesting that the glycoproteomic measurements underestimated the abundances of larger, more-complex glycans. Moreover, the distribution of glycan masses determined by CDMS is much broader than the distribution expected from the glycoproteomics studies, assuming that glycan processing on each trimer is not correlated. The breadth of the glycan mass distribution therefore indicates heterogeneity in the extent of glycan processing of the S protein trimers, with some trimers being much more heavily processed than others. This heterogeneity may have evolved as a way of further confounding the host's immune system.