Alcohol Solvent Effects in the Synthesis of Co3O4 Metal-Oxide Nanoparticles: Disproof of a Surface-Ligand Thermodynamic Effect en Route to Alternative Kinetic and Thermodynamic Explanations.

The synthesis of Co3O4 core nanoparticles from cobalt acetate is explored in alcohol solvents plus limited water using O2 as oxidant and NH4OH as the base, all in comparison to controls in water alone employing the otherwise identical synthetic procedure. Syntheses in EtOH or t-BuOH cosolvents with limited water yield phase-pure and size-controlled (3 ± 1 nm) Co3O4-core nanoparticles. In marked contrast, the synthesis in water alone yields mixed phases of Co3O4 and ß-Co(OH)2 with a very large particle-size range (14-400 nm). Importantly, acidic reductive digestion of the Co3O4 particles followed by 1H NMR on the resultant solution yields no detectable EtOH in nanoparticles prepared in EtOH, nor any detectable t-BuOH in nanoparticles prepared in t-BuOH (∼5% detection limits for each alcohol), despite the dramatic effect of each alcohol cosolvent on the resultant cobalt-oxide product. Instead, in both cases HOAc is detected and quantified, indicative of OAc- as a surface ligand-and not EtO- or t-BuO- as the surface ligand. The resultant ROH cosolvent-derived particles were characterized by powder X-ray diffraction, Fourier transform infrared spectroscopy, high-resolution transmission electron microscopy, plus elemental analysis to arrive at an approximate, average molecular formula in the case of the particles prepared in EtOH, {[Co3O4(C2H3O2)]-[(NH4+)0.3(H+0.7)]+·(H2O)}∼216. The key finding is that, because EtOH and t-BuOH have a substantial effect on the phase- and size-dispersion of the cobalt-oxide nanoparticle product, yet the intact alcohol does not show up in the final Co3O4 nanoparticle product, the effect of these alcohols cannot be a surface-ligand thermodynamic effect on the net nanoparticle formation reaction. A careful search of the literature provided scattered, but consistent, literature in which anions or other additives have large effects on metal-oxide nanoparticle formation reactions, yet also do not show up in the nanoparticle products-that is, where the observed effects are again not due to binding by that anion or other additive in a surface-ligand thermodynamic effect on the overall reaction. Alternative hypotheses are provided as to the origin of ROH solvent effects on metal-oxide nanoparticles.