American College of Rheumatology and Food and Drug Administration Summit: Summary of the Meeting May 17-18, 2022.

The American College of Rheumatology and the US Food and Drug Administration co-sponsored a public meeting in May 2022 about challenges in the clinical development of drugs for rheumatoid arthritis (RA) and psoriatic arthritis (PsA), focusing on innovative clinical trial designs, outcome measures, and data collection methods. Recommendations include early dose-ranging studies and use of active comparators. Challenges and opportunities in assessing long-term safety by leveraging real-world data from electronic health records (EHRs) and claims data are discussed, along with insights from European registries and the evolving role of real-world evidence and artificial intelligence in regulatory evaluations. Endpoints for assessing disease activity and outcome measures used in RA and PsA trials are explored, emphasizing challenges in defining remission, assessing clinical response, and evaluating structural progression. The need for outcome measures that better reflect treatment targets and the potential of advanced imaging in future trials are highlighted. Challenges with placebo-controlled trials in RA are discussed and use of non-inferiority clinical trial design, in which new drugs are evaluated with active comparators, is proposed. Pragmatic trials in RA and PsA, employing decentralized approaches, are highlighted for their real-world relevance and administrative efficiencies. Strategies for identifying at-risk populations for RA and the challenges of using EHRs and insurance claims data in drug development are discussed. Registry data and digital health technologies show promise in bridging the gap between clinical trials and real-world effectiveness.

Using Machine Learning to Determine a Suitable Patient Population for Anakinra for the Treatment of COVID-19 Under the Emergency Use Authorization.

A randomized, double-blind, placebo-controlled study (SAVEMORE trial) provided data to support an Emergency Use Authorization (EUA) of anakinra in hospitalized adults with positive results of direct severe acute respiratory syndrome-coronavirus 2 viral testing with pneumonia requiring supplemental oxygen (low- or high-flow oxygen) who are at risk of progressing to severe respiratory failure and likely to have an elevated plasma soluble urokinase plasminogen activator receptor (suPAR). Currently, the suPAR assay is not commercially available in the United States. An alternative method was needed to identify patients that best reflect the population in the clinical trial selected based on suPAR level ≥ 6 ng/mL at baseline. A machine learning approach based on data from the SAVEMORE trial was used to develop a scoring rule to identify patients who are likely to have a suPAR level ≥ 6 ng/mL at baseline. External validation of the scoring rule was conducted with data from a different trial (SAVE). This clinical scoring rule with high positive predictive value, high specificity, reasonable sensitivity, and biological relevance is expected to identify patients who are likely to have an elevated suPAR level ≥ 6 ng/mL at baseline. As such, it is included in the EUA to identify patients that fall within the authorized population for whom the known and potential benefits outweigh the known and potential risks of anakinra.

Therapeutic Development in Polyarticular Course Juvenile Idiopathic Arthritis: Extrapolation, Dose Selection, and Clinical Trial Design.

OBJECTIVE: Stakeholders met to address persistent challenges facing the development of therapeutics for polyarticular juvenile idiopathic arthritis (pJIA), which result in fewer approved therapies for children with pJIA than adults with rheumatoid arthritis (RA) and long lag times from adult RA approval to pediatric labeling. Ensuring that new medications are authorized in a timely manner to meet the needs of JIA patients worldwide is critically important to multiple stakeholders. METHODS: The Food and Drug Administration in collaboration with the University of Maryland Center for Regulatory Science and Innovation held a public workshop entitled "Accelerating Drug Development for pJIA" on October 2, 2019, to address challenges surrounding access to new medications for children and adolescents with pJIA. Regulatory, academic, and industry stakeholders, as well as patient representatives, participated in the workshop, which consisted of 4 sessions, including panel discussions. RESULTS: The workshop facilitated broad public discussion of challenges facing the development of pJIA therapeutics, highlighting areas of need and outlining opportunities to expedite development, while underscoring the necessity of close collaboration between all stakeholders, including patients and families. CONCLUSION: This report summarizes key aspects of the workshop, including the appropriate application of innovative approaches to the development of pJIA therapeutics, including extrapolation, to address current challenges and provide timely access to newer safe and effective treatments. Long-term safety assessment is of pressing concern to stakeholders and cannot be fully extrapolated from adult studies but requires consistent postmarketing long-term follow-up.

FDA/Arthritis Foundation osteoarthritis drug development workshop recap: Assessment of long-term benefit.

OBJECTIVE: To summarize proceedings of a workshop convened to discuss the current state of science in the disease of osteoarthritis (OA), identify the knowledge gaps, and examine the developmental and regulatory challenges in bringing these products to market. DESIGN: Summary of the one-day workshop held virtually on June 22nd, 2021. RESULTS: Speakers selected by the Planning Committee presented data on the current approach to assessment of OA therapies, biomarkers in OA drug development, and the assessment of disease progression and long-term benefit. CONCLUSIONS: Demonstrated by numerous failed clinical trials, OA is a challenging disease for which to develop therapeutics. The challenge is magnified by the slow time of onset of disease and the need for clinical trials of long duration and/or large sample size to demonstrate the effect of an intervention. The OA science community, including academia, pharmaceutical companies, regulatory agencies, and patient communities, must continue to develop and test better clinical endpoints that meaningfully reflect disease modification related to long-term patient benefit.

Concept End Points Informing Design Considerations for Confirmatory Clinical Trials in Osteoarthritis.

OBJECTIVE: There is an unmet need for therapies that target the underlying pathophysiology of osteoarthritis (OA). However, defining appropriate measures for clinical trials of such therapies is challenging. Our objective was to propose concept clinical end points that directly capture clinical benefit in this setting and evaluate the feasibility of their use. METHODS: This analysis used the multicenter, longitudinal, observational Osteoarthritis Initiative (OAI) database. OAI participants primarily had knee OA, with follow-up of up to 9 years and assessments of joints, surgical interventions, performance outcomes, and patient-reported outcomes. We examined this data set to identify existing outcome measures of direct clinical benefit. We evaluated the feasibility of conducting trials using these candidate end points by estimating incidence rates and resulting required sample sizes and study durations in time-to-event analyses. RESULTS: We identified candidate end points based on total knee replacement (TKR) and composite end points defined by TKR and conservative thresholds of patient-reported outcomes of pain and function. Using time to TKR as an end point, a study with an average follow-up time of 3 years requires approximately 3,000 to 18,000 subjects, depending on effect size. Alternatively, for a composite end point, such as "time to TKR or severe pain or severely impaired functioning," the required sample sizes ranged from approximately 2,000 to 11,000 for a 3-year study. CONCLUSION: The proposed concept end points can reliably and feasibly evaluate the effectiveness of therapies for this unmet need. In particular, the composite end point approach can substantially reduce sample sizes (up to approximately 40%) compared to the use of TKR alone.

Immunomodulatory Therapeutic Proteins in COVID-19: Current Clinical Development and Clinical Pharmacology Considerations.

The coronavirus disease 2019 (COVID-19) pandemic caused by infection with SARS-CoV-2 has led to more than 600 000 deaths worldwide. Patients with severe disease often experience acute respiratory distress characterized by upregulation of multiple cytokines. Immunomodulatory biological therapies are being evaluated in clinical trials for the management of the systemic inflammatory response and pulmonary complications in patients with advanced stages of COVID-19. In this review, we summarize the clinical pharmacology considerations in the development of immunomodulatory therapeutic proteins for mitigating the heightened inflammatory response identified in COVID-19.

A Comprehensive Updated Review on SARS-CoV-2 and COVID-19.

This literature review aims to provide a comprehensive current summary of the pathogenesis, clinical features, disease course, host immune responses, and current investigational antiviral and immunomodulatory pharmacotherapies to facilitate the development of future therapies and measures for prevention and control.

Noninferiority Trials to Evaluate Drug Effects in Rheumatoid Arthritis.

OBJECTIVE: The increased availability of highly effective treatments in rheumatoid arthritis (RA) necessitates a reexamination of study designs evaluating new treatments. We undertook this study to discuss possible specifications and considerations of noninferiority (NI) trials assessing drug effects in RA. METHODS: We focused on the use of approved tumor necrosis factor inhibitors (TNFi) as potential active controls and reviewed previous placebo-controlled studies. We summarized the similarities in baseline characteristics and study design of the historical placebo-controlled studies used. After performing meta-analyses to estimate the effects of TNFi on symptoms, physical function, and radiographic progression in RA, we proposed NI margins and evaluated the feasibility of NI trials in this therapeutic setting. RESULTS: We determined that an NI trial comparing an experimental treatment to a TNFi using the symptomatic end point of the American College of Rheumatology 20% improvement criteria response can feasibly provide evidence of a treatment effect, with a 12% absolute difference as one possible appropriate NI margin. For change from baseline in the Health Assessment Questionnaire disability index score, reasonable margins range from 0.10 to 0.12. In evaluating radiographic progression, an appropriate margin and the corresponding feasibility of the trial are dependent on the selected active control and the expected variability in progression. CONCLUSION: Active-controlled studies in RA with justified NI margins can provide persuasive evidence of treatment effects on symptomatic, functional, and radiographic end points. Such studies can also provide reliable, controlled safety data and relevant information for treatment decisions in clinical practice. Thus, we recommend considering NI designs in future clinical trials in RA.

An FDA perspective on the assessment of proposed biosimilar therapeutic proteins in rheumatology.

Biologic products have revolutionized the management of many rheumatic diseases, but access to these products might be limited by their relatively high costs. The US Biologics Price Competition and Innovation Act of 2009, which is contained within the Patient Protection and Affordable Care Act, established an abbreviated pathway for licensure by the FDA of biologic products that are demonstrated to be biosimilar to or interchangeable with FDA-licensed biologic products, termed reference products. This law allows for the approval of biosimilar biologic products, which are expected to increase access to treatment for patients, and ensuring the implementation of this Act is a high priority for the FDA. In this Perspectives article we describe the considerations for approval of proposed biosimilar products, including those to treat rheumatological conditions, by describing the FDA's rigorous approach to assessment of biosimilarity.

Predominant Glandular Cholinergic Dysautonomia in Patients With Primary Sjögren's Syndrome.

OBJECTIVE: The autonomic nervous system (ANS) modulates exocrine gland function. Available data show poor correlation between the degree of function and destruction of the exocrine glands in primary Sjögren's syndrome (SS), suggesting that other mechanisms, such as autonomic dysfunction, may be important in these patients. The aim of this study was to perform a comprehensive analysis of sympathoneural and sympathetic cholinergic function in well-characterized patients with primary SS. METHODS: Twenty-one patients with primary SS (mean ± SEM age 44.2 ± 2.8 years) and 13 healthy control subjects (mean ± SEM age 50.8 ± 1.9 years) were assessed during orthostasis and intravenous injection of edrophonium (10 mg). The postganglionic sympathetic cholinergic system was evaluated by assessing sweat production by means of the Quantitative Sudomotor Axon Reflex Test (QSART). Tests of gastric emptying were used to assess the gastrointestinal ANS in primary SS patients. RESULTS: The velocity index and the acceleration index were significantly higher (P < 0.05) in patients with primary SS as compared to controls, both before and during the orthostatic and edrophonium tests. Findings of other hemodynamic and neurochemical parameters did not differ between primary SS patients and controls during the orthostasis and edrophonium test; however, the edrophonium-induced saliva increment was lower in primary SS patients (P = 0.002). Abnormally low sweat production was found in 4 primary SS patients but in none of the controls, as determined by the QSART. Gastric empting was delayed in 53% of primary SS patients. CONCLUSION: We observed subtle differences in several ANS domains, including the gastrointestinal and sympathocholinergic systems, suggesting the presence of a complex ANS dysfunction in primary SS. The impact was greatest on the exocrine glands, with subtle differences in the cardiac parasympathetic function that were independent of glandular inflammation and atrophy, suggesting an alternative mechanism of disease pathogenesis in primary SS.

Early responses to adenoviral-mediated transfer of the aquaporin-1 cDNA for radiation-induced salivary hypofunction.

No conventional therapy exists for salivary hypofunction in surviving head and neck cancer patients with Radiation Therapy Oncology Group late grade 2-3 toxicity. We conducted a phase I clinical trial to test the safety and biologic efficacy of serotype 5, adenoviral-mediated aquaporin-1 cDNA transfer to a single previously irradiated parotid gland in 11 subjects using an open label, single-dose, dose-escalation design (AdhAQP1 vector; four dose tiers from 4.8 × 10(7) to 5.8 × 10(9) vector particles per gland). Treated subjects were followed at scheduled intervals. Multiple safety parameters were measured and biologic efficacy was evaluated with measurements of parotid salivary flow rate. Symptoms were assessed with a visual analog scale. All subjects tolerated vector delivery and study procedures well over the 42-d study period reported. No deaths, serious adverse events, or dose-limiting toxicities occurred. Generally, few adverse events occurred, and all were considered mild or moderate. No consistent changes were found in any clinical chemistry and hematology parameters measured. Objective responses were seen in six subjects, all at doses <5.8 × 10(9) vector particles per gland. Five of these six subjects also experienced subjective improvement in xerostomia. AdhAQP1 vector delivery to a single parotid gland was safe and transfer of the hAQP1 cDNA increased parotid flow and relieved symptoms in a subset of subjects.

Adrenomedullary response to glucagon in patients with primary Sjögren's syndrome.

Several studies showed signs of autonomic dysfunction in patients with primary Sjögren's syndrome (pSS). Adrenomedullary function might be of importance for pSS pathogenesis by affecting salivary gland functions and modulating immune responses. The aim of the study was to evaluate the adrenomedullary hormonal system in patients with pSS. The glucagon test (1 mg i.v.) was performed in 18 pSS patients and 13 control subjects. During the test each patient had electrocardiographic and impedance cardiographic monitoring. Plasma epinephrine and norepinephrine were assayed by liquid chromatography with electrochemical detection after batch alumina extraction. Baseline concentrations of epinephrine and norepinephrine were comparable between pSS and controls. Glucagon administration induced a significant increase in systolic blood pressure, diastolic blood pressure, heart rate, cardiac output (P < 0.01), and stroke volume; however, the changes were comparable between pSS and controls. Epinephrine levels increased (P < 0.01) in response to glucagon administration while norepinephrine concentration did not change. There was no significant difference in neurochemical responses to glucagon between pSS and controls. In conclusion, the present results suggest normal adrenomedullary function in pSS.

Systemic autoimmunity and defective Fas ligand secretion in the absence of the Wiskott-Aldrich syndrome protein.

Autoimmunity is a surprisingly common complication of primary immunodeficiencies, yet the molecular mechanisms underlying this clinical observation are not well understood. One widely known example is provided by Wiskott-Aldrich syndrome (WAS), an X-linked primary immunodeficiency disorder caused by mutations in the gene encoding the WAS protein (WASp) with a high incidence of autoimmunity in affected patients. WASp deficiency affects T-cell antigen receptor (TCR) signaling and T-cell cytokine production, but its role in TCR-induced apoptosis, one of the mechanisms of peripheral immunologic tolerance, has not been investigated. We find that WASp-deficient mice produce autoantibodies and develop proliferative glomerulonephritis with immune complex deposition as they age. We also find that CD4(+) T lymphocytes from WASp-deficient mice undergo reduced apoptosis after restimulation through the TCR. While Fas-induced cell death is normal, WASp deficiency affects TCR-induced secretion of Fas ligand (FasL) and other components of secretory granules by CD4(+) T cells. These results describe a novel role of WASp in regulating TCR-induced apoptosis and FasL secretion and suggest that WASp-deficient mice provide a good model for the study of autoimmune manifestations of WAS and the development of more specific therapies for these complications.

Development of a gene transfer-based treatment for radiation-induced salivary hypofunction.

A significant long-term side effect of radiation therapy for head and neck cancers is xerostomia, a dry mouth, due to salivary gland damage. Despite continuing efforts to eliminate this problem, many patients continue to suffer. This brief review describes our efforts to develop a gene transfer approach, employing the aquaporin-1 cDNA, to treat patients with existing radiation-induced salivary hypofunction. A Phase I/II clinical trial, using a recombinant adenoviral vector to mediate gene transfer, is currently underway.

Transient detection of E1-containing adenovirus in saliva after the delivery of a first-generation adenoviral vector to human parotid gland.

BACKGROUND: Radiation-induced salivary hypofunction is a common side-effect of treatment for head and neck cancers. Patients suffer significant morbidity and there is no suitable conventional therapy. We are conducting a Phase I clinical trial, using a first-generation serotype 5 adenoviral (Ad5) vector encoding human aquaporin-1 (AdhAQP1) to treat such patients. One week after the administration of AdhAQP1 to an enrolled, generally healthy patient, E1-containing adenovirus was detected in parotid saliva. METHODS: The real-time quantitative polymerase chain reaction (PCR) was used to measure the Ad5 E1 gene and AdhAQP1 in saliva and serum. PCR and sequencing were used to characterize viral/vector DNA extracted from saliva. The presence of infectious adenovirus was assessed by the inoculation of A549 cells with aliquots of saliva. Serum Ad5 neutralizing antibodies were measured by the inhibition of 293-cell transduction with an Ad5 vector encoding luciferase. Multiple clinical evaluations were performed. RESULTS: On day 7 after AdhAQP1 delivery, low levels of the Ad5 E1 gene were detected in parotid saliva (82 copies/microl). In addition, significant levels of AdhAQP1 were also detected (1.5 x 10(3) copies/microl). The patient was asymptomatic and subsequent analysis of parotid saliva samples prior to day 7 and after day 7 until day 42 was negative for both virus and vector. No virus or vector was detected in serum at any time. Detailed PCR analyses of DNA extracted from the day 7 parotid saliva sample suggested the absence of a recombination event, and no infectious virus was found. CONCLUSIONS: The patient most likely had a latent Ad5 infection in the targeted parotid gland that was activated after gene transfer and was without clinical consequence.

Sensitive and robust luminescent profiling of anti-La and other autoantibodies in Sjogren's syndrome.

Sjogren's syndrome (SjS) patients often have a variety of extraglandular manifestations including neurological and gastrointestinal involvement. In this study we evaluated the diagnostic performance of luciferase immunoprecipitation system (LIPS) that employs mammalian cell-produced recombinant antigens for analyzing SjS autoantibody responses. LIPS testing of mammalian cell-produced La, Ro60 and Ro52 recombinant antigens with defined commercial antibodies demonstrated highly specific immunoprecitation of each antigen without cross-reactivity. Next, sera from 57 SjS and 25 volunteers were evaluated by LIPS against a panel of human autoantigens. LIPS detected robust anti-La antibody levels in 43/57 SjS patients (75% sensitivity) and markedly outperformed an ELISA (46% sensitivity). Profiling of other SjS-associated autoantigens revealed the presence of anti-Ro60, anti-Ro52 in 63% and 61%, of SjS patients, respectively. Interestingly, a C-terminal fragment of Ro52 (Ro52-Delta2), a protein fragment not previously found to be antigenic by ELISA, also showed positive immunoreactivity in 42/57 SjS patients (65% sensitivity). Additional profiling of other autoantigens revealed that certain SjS patients also showed positive immunoreactivity with thyroid peroxidase (14%), AQP-4 (12%) and the H(+)/K(+) gastric ATPase (16%) suggesting potential autoantibody attack of thyroid, neuronal and gastric parietal cells, respectively. These heterogeneous autoantibody responses detected by LIPS in SjS will likely be useful for diagnosis and for evaluating extraglandular manifestations.

Pathogenesis of Sjögren's syndrome.

PURPOSE OF REVIEW: To summarize recent developments in our understanding of the pathogenesis of Sjögren's syndrome with a focus on the relationship between inflammation and exocrine dysfunction. RECENT FINDINGS: Animal models demonstrated the complex interactions between immunologic and nonimmunologic mechanisms in Sjögren's syndrome. Activation of the innate immune system can lead to exocrine dysfunction before or without significant inflammation, whereas in other models, salivary gland function is preserved despite intense inflammatory infiltrates. Primary or inflammation-related abnormalities in water channels contribute to the exocrinopathy. Activation of the innate immunity in patients is demonstrated by the upregulation of type-1 interferon-regulated genes (interferon signature) in peripheral blood and salivary glands and abnormal expression of B cell-activating factor and its receptors. Nonimmune mechanisms that may contribute to exocrine dysfunction include local and systemic androgen deficiency and autonomic nervous system dysfunction. Autoantibodies against the muscarinic acetylcholine receptors would provide a link between autoimmunity and exocrine dysfunction, but the data on the presence, frequency and physiologic affect of these antibodies remain controversial. SUMMARY: Recent discoveries from studies in patients with Sjögren's syndrome and animal models suggest a complex interplay between genetic factors, environmental and stochastic events that involve innate and adaptive immunity, hormonal mechanisms and the autonomic nervous system. Some of these findings suggest that exocrine gland dysfunction may precede autoimmunity or represent a process independent from inflammation in the pathogenesis of Sjögren's syndrome.

Rheumatologic and autoimmune manifestations of primary immunodeficiency disorders.

PURPOSE OF REVIEW: Although it may seem paradoxical, primary immunodeficiency disorders are frequently complicated by autoimmune and inflammatory conditions. These conditions pose significant diagnostic and therapeutic challenges for clinicians caring for these patients. There have been a number of new insights into how immunodeficiencies can predispose to autoimmunity, and rheumatologists should understand the basis for and manifestations of autoimmunity in primary immunodeficiency disorders to more effectively care for these patients. RECENT FINDINGS: A number of mechanisms have recently been found to link primary immunodeficiencies and autoimmunity, including increased homeostatic proliferation in primary immunodeficiencies associated with lymphopenia and defects in regulatory T cells in the Wiskott-Aldrich syndrome. Primary immunodeficiencies that affect the innate immune system can also lead to inappropriate inflammation through impairing negative regulatory mechanisms in innate immune cells. SUMMARY: The realization that primary immunodeficiencies can also impair negative regulation of immune responses has provided a new framework for the understanding of autoimmunity associated with these conditions. These insights may lead to new, more targeted therapies for autoimmune complications in primary immunodeficiency patients.

Technology Insight: hematopoietic stem cell transplantation for systemic rheumatic disease.

Hematopoietic stem cells (HSCs) have the capacity for self-renewal and the potential to differentiate into all types of hematopoietic and immune system cells. These features have been successfully used to treat a multitude of hematologic malignancies and nonmalignant diseases such as aplastic anemia, hemoglobinopathies, inborn errors of metabolism and congenital immunodeficiency states. The application of HSC transplantation has been expanded over the past decade to include immune-mediated diseases such as multiple sclerosis, treatment-refractory rheumatoid arthritis, systemic lupus erythematosus and systemic sclerosis. Transplantation of HSCs for the treatment of autoimmune diseases aims to fundamentally correct the dysregulated immune system, which could result in sustained clinical remission or potential cure. The use of this approach is currently restricted to clinical research, as there is no standard conditioning regimen to attain these aims in autoimmune diseases. HSC transplantation is associated with inherent morbidity and mortality, both treatment-related and disease-related, and selecting the correct group of patients with the best risk:benefit ratio is a challenging task.