RESUMO
Understanding the drivers of improvements in child undernutrition at only the national level can mask subnational differences. This paper aimed to understand the contributions of factors in the enabling environment to observed differences in stunting reduction between districts in Rwanda. In 2017, we conducted 58 semi-structured interviews with mid-level actors (n = 38) and frontline workers (n = 20) implementing Rwanda's multi-sectoral nutrition policy in five districts in which stunting decreased (reduced districts) and five where it increased or stagnated (non-reduced districts) based on Rwanda's 2010 and 2014/15 Demographic and Health Surveys. Mid-level actors are government officials and service providers at the subnational level who represent the frontline of government policy. Interviews focused on political commitment to and policy coherence in nutrition, and contributors to nutrition changes. Responses were coded to capture themes on the changes and challenges of these topics and compared between reduced and non-reduced districts. Descriptive statistics described district characteristics. Political commitment to nutrition was high in both reduced and non-reduced districts. Respondents from reduced districts were more likely to define commitment to nutrition as an optimal implementation of policy, whereas those from non-reduced districts focused more on financial commitment. Regarding coherence, respondents from reduced compared to non-reduced districts were more likely to report the optimal implementation of multi-sectoral nutrition planning meetings, using data to assess plans and progress in nutrition outcomes and integration of nutrition into the agriculture sector. In contrast, respondents from non-reduced districts more often reported challenges in their relationships with national-level stakeholders and nutrition and/or monitoring and evaluation capacities. Enhancing the integration of nutrition in different sectors and improving mid-level actors' capacity to plan and advocate for nutrition programming may contribute to reductions in stunting.
Assuntos
Política Nutricional , Humanos , Ruanda/epidemiologia , Desnutrição/prevenção & controle , Desnutrição/epidemiologia , Transtornos da Nutrição Infantil/prevenção & controle , Transtornos da Nutrição Infantil/epidemiologia , Pré-Escolar , Transtornos do Crescimento/prevenção & controle , Transtornos do Crescimento/epidemiologia , Feminino , Lactente , Estado Nutricional , MasculinoRESUMO
Investments in social assistance programmes (SAPs) have accelerated alongside interest in using SAPs to improve health and nutrition outcomes. However, evidence of how design features within and across programme types influence the effectiveness of SAPs for improving diet and nutrition outcomes among women and children is limited. To address this, we reviewed evaluations of cash, in-kind and voucher programmes conducted between 2010 and 2020 among women and children, and examined associations between design features (targeting, including household and individual transfers, fortified foods and behaviour change communication) and positive impacts on diet (diet diversity, micronutrient intake) and nutrition (anthropometric indicators, haemoglobin, anaemia) outcomes. Our review has several key findings. First, SAPs improve dietary diversity and intake of micronutrient-rich foods among women and children, as well as improve several nutrition outcomes. Second, SAPs were more likely to impact diet and nutrition outcomes among women compared with children (23/45 [51%] vs. 52/144 [36%] of outcomes measured). Third, in-kind (all but one of which included fortified foods) compared with cash transfer programmes were more likely to significantly increase women's body mass index and children's weight-for-height/length Z-score, and both women's and children's haemoglobin and anaemia. However, there is limited evidence on the effectiveness of SAPs for improving micronutrient status and preventing increased prevalence of overweight and obesity for all populations and for improving diet and nutrition outcomes among men, adolescents and the elderly. Further research in these areas is urgently needed to optimize impact of SAPs on diet and nutrition outcomes as countries increase investments in SAPs.
Assuntos
Anemia , Estado Nutricional , Adolescente , Idoso , Criança , Dieta , Feminino , Alimentos Fortificados , Humanos , Masculino , MicronutrientesRESUMO
BACKGROUND: Little is known about the sustained effects of nutrition- and gender-sensitive agricultural programs (NSAPs) after they end. OBJECTIVES: To examine the 4-year effects (2010-2014) of a 2-year NSAP (2010-2012) on women's outcomes in rural Burkina Faso. METHODS: We used baseline (2010) and endline (2012) data from a cluster-randomized controlled trial of Helen Keller International's Enhanced Homestead Food Production (EHFP) program and baseline (2014) data from a new program. We included 134 women: 82 who participated in the 2-year EHFP program (treatment) and 52 who did not (control). We examined program (2010-2012), post-program (2012-2014), and overall 4-year effects (2010-2014) using difference-in-difference analysis (DID). RESULTS: We found significant positive program effects (2010-2012) on women's underweight prevalence (DID: 16.44 percentage points [pp]; P = .09) and on women's knowledge about appropriate age to introduce liquids (DID: 28.40 pp; P = .01). Although there were no significant postprogram effects (2012-2014), differences found in 2012 between the treatment and control group were sustained resulting in an overall 4-year (2010-2014) reduction in women's underweight prevalence (DID: 18.26 pp; P = .02) and an improvement in women's knowledge about appropriate age to introduce liquids (DID: 31.29 pp; P = .02). We observed no postprogram or overall 4-year effects on women's knowledge of child feeding and handwashing practices or women's empowerment. CONCLUSIONS: Nutrition- and gender-sensitive agricultural programs demonstrate potential for sustained improvements in women's nutritional status and nutritional knowledge. Postprogram assessments of NSAPs should be embedded in program evaluations to help further understand the potential of NSAPs to generate sustainable impacts on women's outcomes.
Assuntos
Conhecimentos, Atitudes e Prática em Saúde , Estado Nutricional , Agricultura , Burkina Faso/epidemiologia , Empoderamento , Feminino , Humanos , Avaliação de Programas e Projetos de Saúde , População Rural , Magreza/epidemiologiaRESUMO
BACKGROUND: Rwanda's commitment to reducing malnutrition is evident in their multisectoral nutrition policy and wide array of nutrition partners. However, the prevalence of micronutrient deficiencies and the suitability of current strategies to address existing deficiencies is unclear. OBJECTIVE: To review the available evidence related to the prevalence of micronutrient deficiencies across the life cycle and strategies in place to address them. METHODS: We reviewed scientific and grey literature on nutritional problems in Rwanda, emphasizing micronutrient deficiencies and anemia, and current strategies to address micronutrient malnutrition. RESULTS: Overall, there is scant evidence related to the types and prevalence of micronutrient deficiencies among populations across the life cycle in Rwanda. Existing evidence is primarily limited to outdated or small regional surveys focusing on iron or vitamin A among women and young children. Surveys have assessed the prevalence of anemia and indicate that anemia is very high among young children and moderately high among other age-groups. However, there are limited data on the context-specific causes of anemia in Rwanda across population groups. Current nutrition strategies mainly target women and young children and are primarily designed to reduce vitamin A deficiency and/or anemia caused by micronutrient deficiencies. CONCLUSIONS: Rwanda has many nutrition programs in place that address micronutrient deficiencies in young children and a few for women of reproductive age. However, gaps exist in knowledge of the extent of different types of micronutrient deficiencies among all populations across the life cycle and whether the delivery of nutrients through current programs is meeting actual needs.
Assuntos
Anemia Ferropriva , Anemia , Desnutrição , Anemia/epidemiologia , Anemia/prevenção & controle , Anemia Ferropriva/epidemiologia , Anemia Ferropriva/prevenção & controle , Criança , Pré-Escolar , Feminino , Humanos , Desnutrição/epidemiologia , Desnutrição/prevenção & controle , Micronutrientes , Estado Nutricional , Prevalência , Ruanda/epidemiologiaRESUMO
BACKGROUND: Little is known about the impact of food-assisted maternal and child health programs (FA-MCHN) on child wasting. OBJECTIVES: We assessed the impact of Tubaramure, a FA-MCHN program in Burundi, on child (0 to 24 months) wasting and the differential impacts by socio-economic characteristics and age. The program targeted women and their children during the first 1000 days and included 1) food rations, 2) strengthening and promotion of use of health services, and 3) behavior change communication (BCC). METHODS: We conducted a 4-arm, cluster-randomized, controlled trial (2010-2012). Clusters were defined as "collines" (communities). Impact was estimated using repeated cross-sectional data (n = â¼2620 children in each round). Treatment arms received household and individual (mother or child in the first 1000 days) food rations (corn-soy blend and micronutrient-fortified vegetable oil) from pregnancy to 24 months (T24 arm), from pregnancy to 18 months (T18), or from birth to 24 months (TNFP). All beneficiaries received the same BCC for the first 1000 days. The control arm received no rations or BCC. RESULTS: Wasting (weight-for-length Z-score <2 SD) increased from baseline to follow-up in the control group (from 6.5% to 8%), but Tubaramure had a significant (P < 0.05) protective effect on wasting [treatment arms combined, -3.3 percentage points (pp); T18, -4.5 pp] and on the weight-for-length z-score (treatment arms combined, +0.15; T24, +0.20; T18, +0.17). The effects were limited to children whose mother and household head had no education, and who lived in the poorest households. The largest effect was found in children 6 to 12 months of age: the group with the highest wasting prevalence. CONCLUSIONS: FA-MCHN programs in highly food-insecure regions can protect the most disadvantaged children from wasting. These findings are particularly relevant in the context of the economic crisis due to the coronavirus disease 2019 pandemic, which is expected to dramatically increase child wasting.
Assuntos
Assistência Alimentar , Desnutrição/prevenção & controle , Adulto , Burundi/epidemiologia , COVID-19/epidemiologia , COVID-19/virologia , Criança , Análise por Conglomerados , Feminino , Humanos , Lactente , Fenômenos Fisiológicos da Nutrição do Lactente , Desnutrição/epidemiologia , Desnutrição/fisiopatologia , Gravidez , SARS-CoV-2/isolamento & purificação , Adulto JovemRESUMO
Data on dietary nutrient intakes of adolescents in low- and middle-income countries (LMIC) is lacking partly due to the absence of validation studies of the 24-h recall method in adolescents. We conducted a validation study of 24-h recall (24HR) compared with observed weighed records (OWR) in adolescents (n = 132, 10-11 years; n = 105, 12-14 years). Dietary data were collected for the same day by both methods by conducting the 24HR the day after the OWR. For OWR, all foods consumed by adolescents from the first to last meal of the day were weighed; for 24HR adolescents reported foods consumed using portion aids. Food intakes were converted to nutrients. Nutrient intakes by both methods were tested for equivalence by comparing the ratios (24HR/OWR) with equivalence margins of within ±10%, 15% and 20% of the ratio. Prevalences of inadequacy (POIs) were obtained using the NCI method. Mean ratios for energy were 0.88 and 0.92, for younger and older adolescents, respectively, and other nutrients ranged between 0.84 and 1.02. Energy intakes were equivalent within the 15% bound, and most nutrients fell within the 20% bound. POI was overestimated by 24HR, but differences were less than 25 percentage points for most nutrients. Half of adolescents omitted foods in recalls, mainly sweet or savoury snacks, fruits and beverages. Our study showed that adolescents underestimated intakes by 24HR; however, the degree of underestimation was generally acceptable for 12-14-year-olds within a bound of 15%. Errors could possibly be reduced with further training and targeted probing.
Assuntos
Dieta , Ingestão de Alimentos , Adolescente , Burkina Faso , Inquéritos sobre Dietas , Ingestão de Energia , HumanosRESUMO
Development is a multi-faceted process; achieving development goals thus requires a multi-sectoral approach. For over two decades, our research group of economists and nutritionists has designed and implemented randomized trials to assess the effectiveness of multisectoral programs in improving nutrition, food security, and other measures of well-being, largely at the request of developing country governments, development partners, and non-governmental organizations. Our approach addresses three perceived pitfalls of RCTs: the "black box" nature of RCTs, limited external validity, and challenges in translation of results to impacts at scale. We address these concerns by identifying and assessing programmatic pathways to impact with quantitative and qualitative methods; studying similar programs implemented by different organizations across various settings; and working closely with implementing partners in the design, research, and dissemination processes to inform adaptation and scale-up of programs and policies.
RESUMO
Anaemia is a persistent problem among young Burkinabe children, yet population-specific information on its determinants is scant. We used baseline data from an evaluation of Helen Keller International's Enhanced Homestead Food Production Program (n=1210 children) to quantify household-, mother-, and child-level factors associated with anaemia in Burkinabe children aged 6-12 months. We used structural equation modelling to assess a theoretical model, which tested four categories of factors: (a) household food security and dietary diversity, (b) household sanitation and hygiene (latrine and poultry access and bednet ownership), (c) maternal factors (anaemia, stress, cleanliness, and health, hygiene and feeding knowledge and practices), and (d) child nutrition and health (iron deficiency (ID), retinol binding protein (RBP), malaria, and inflammation). The model also included household socio-economic status, size, and polygamy; maternal age and education; and child age and sex. Results showed that ID, malaria, and inflammation were the primary direct determinants of anaemia, contributing 15%, 10%, and 10%, respectively. Maternal knowledge directly explained improved child feeding practices and household bednet ownership. Household dietary diversity directly explained 18% of child feeding practices. Additionally, RBP, child age and sex, and maternal anaemia directly predicted child haemoglobin. Our findings suggest that program effectiveness could be increased by addressing the multiple, context-specific contributors of child anaemia. For young Burkinabe children, anaemia control programs that include interventions to reduce ID, malaria, and inflammation should be tested. Other potential intervention entry points suggested by our model include improving maternal knowledge of optimal health, hygiene, and nutrition practices and household dietary diversity.
Assuntos
Anemia/epidemiologia , Saúde do Lactente/etnologia , Análise de Classes Latentes , Burkina Faso/epidemiologia , Causalidade , Feminino , Humanos , Lactente , Masculino , Fatores de RiscoRESUMO
BACKGROUND: Nutrition-sensitive programs can accelerate progress in addressing malnutrition. However, evidence gaps exist related to their effectiveness and how to optimize program design and implementation. OBJECTIVE: We present the process the International Food Policy Research Institute and the World Food Programme (WFP) used to develop nutrition-sensitive program guidance and plans for improving program effectiveness and contributing to the evidence base through rigorous evaluations. METHODS: A 5-step process, using principles of design thinking (a systematic, iterative analytical approach to problem solving), was used to develop, test, and refine WFP's nutrition-sensitive guidance. The guidance focuses on improving nutrition outcomes for nutritionally vulnerable groups across the life cycle: women and children in the first 1000 days, preschoolers, schoolchildren, and adolescents. RESULTS: Through iterative consultations, we created WFP's nutrition-sensitive guidance that includes harmonized theories of change across WFP's programs; 7 opportunities to enhance the programs' nutrition-sensitivity; and mapping of these opportunities to WFP programs and key evidence gaps. This guidance has been rolled out to WFP's offices worldwide to support improved nutrition outcomes. Finally, several evaluation designs have been proposed to fill identified evidence gaps. CONCLUSIONS: By leveraging our implementation-research partnership, we expect that WFP's programs will be more effective and cost effective for improving nutrition. This can be assessed through coupling newly designed nutrition-sensitive programs with rigorous evaluations. Evaluation results will be used to refine WFP's nutrition-sensitive guidance and improve their programs globally. This guidance, and creation process, could be useful for others interested in designing nutrition-sensitive programs and increasing program effectiveness for nutrition.
Assuntos
Ciência da Implementação , Cooperação Internacional , Desnutrição , Avaliação de Programas e Projetos de Saúde/métodos , Modelo Transteórico , Adolescente , Adulto , Criança , Pré-Escolar , Feminino , Saúde Global , Humanos , Lactente , Recém-Nascido , Masculino , Pessoa de Meia-Idade , Política Nutricional , Adulto JovemRESUMO
Evidence on the cost-effectiveness of multisectoral maternal and child health and nutrition programmes is scarce. We conducted a prospective costing study of two food-assisted maternal and child health and nutrition programmes targeted to pregnant women and children during the first 1,000 days (pregnancy to 2 years). Each was paired with a cluster-randomized controlled trial to evaluate impact and compare the optimal quantity and composition of food rations (Guatemala, five treatment arms) and their optimal timing and duration (Burundi, three treatment arms). We calculated the total and per beneficiary cost, conducted cost consequence analyses, and estimated the cost savings from extending the programme for 2 years. In Guatemala, the programme model with the lowest cost per percentage point reduction in stunting provided the full-size family ration with an individual ration of corn-soy blend or micronutrient powder. Reducing family ration size lowered costs but failed to reduce stunting. In Burundi, providing food assistance for the full 1,000 days led to the lowest cost per percentage point reduction in stunting. Reducing the duration of ration eligibility reduced per beneficiary costs but was less effective. A 2-year extension could have saved 11% per beneficiary in Guatemala and 18% in Burundi. We found that investments in multisectoral nutrition programmes do not scale linearly. Programmes providing smaller rations or rations for shorter durations, although less expensive per beneficiary, may not provide the necessary dose to improve (biological) outcomes. Lastly, delivering effective programmes for longer periods can generate cost savings by dispersing start-up costs and lengthening peak operating capacity.
Assuntos
Custos e Análise de Custo , Assistência Alimentar/economia , Serviços de Saúde Materno-Infantil/economia , Avaliação de Programas e Projetos de Saúde/economia , Ensaios Clínicos Controlados Aleatórios como Assunto , Burundi/epidemiologia , Feminino , Guatemala/epidemiologia , Humanos , Lactente , Gravidez , Estudos ProspectivosRESUMO
BACKGROUND: Food-assisted maternal and child health and nutrition (FA-MCHN) programs are widely used to reduce household food insecurity and maternal and child undernutrition in low- and middle-income countries. These programs, however, may unintentionally lead to excessive energy intake and unhealthy weight gain, especially in food-secure populations. OBJECTIVE: We evaluated the impact of an FA-MCHN program implemented in Guatemala on maternal weight from pregnancy to 24 mo postpartum. The program was earlier shown to reduce stunting. METHODS: We used a longitudinal, cluster-randomized controlled trial with arms varying in family ration size [full (FFR), reduced (RFR), none (NFR)] and individual maternal ration type [corn-soy blend (CSB), lipid-based nutrient supplement (LNS), micronutrient powder (MNP)]: A: FFR + CSB; B: RFR + CSB; C: NFR + CSB; D: FFR + LNS; E: FFR + MNP; F: control. Weight was measured during pregnancy and at 1, 4, 6, 9, 12, 18, and 24 mo postpartum. We used linear mixed models controlling for pregnancy weight with random cluster and mother effects. Data on 3535 women were analyzed. RESULTS: Significant (P < 0.05) or marginally significant (P < 0.10) effects of 0.50-0.65 kg were found at all time points (except 9 mo) in arm A. Similar-sized effects were found in arms B (1, 4, 6, and 12 mo) and C (1 and 12 mo). Marginally significant effects (0.51-0.66 kg) were found in arm D (1, 6, 9, and 12 mo); in arm E, marginally significant effects (0.48-0.75 kg) were found from 6 to 24 mo. CONCLUSIONS: The effect on maternal postpartum weight is of concern because of the high existing prevalence of overweight. Programs need to include "double-duty" objectives and actions, to ensure that addressing child undernutrition does not exacerbate the problem of unhealthy weight gain. This trial was registered at clinicaltrials.gov as NCT01072279.
Assuntos
Assistência Alimentar , Ganho de Peso na Gestação , Fenômenos Fisiológicos da Nutrição do Lactente , Fenômenos Fisiológicos da Nutrição Materna , Período Pós-Parto , Criança , Feminino , Guatemala , Humanos , Lactente , GravidezRESUMO
BACKGROUND: Child development is affected by multiple factors throughout pregnancy and childhood. Multisectoral programs addressing these factors may improve children's development. OBJECTIVE: We evaluated the impact of a food-assisted multisectoral nutrition program (Tubaramure) on children's (4-41.9 mo) motor and language development. Tubaramure was targeted to Burundian women and children in the first 1000 d and provided micronutrient-fortified food rations; nutrition, health, and hygiene behavior change communication; and health system-strengthening activities. METHODS: Program impact was assessed using a cluster-randomized controlled trial with repeated cross-sections: 2010 (baseline, children 4-41.9 mo), 2012 (follow-up during implementation, children 4-23.9 mo), and 2014 (follow-up postimplementation, children 24-41.9 mo). Sixty villages were randomly assigned to 4 groups with varying timing and duration of food rations: pregnancy-24 mo; pregnancy-18 mo; 0-24 mo; and control, no direct Tubaramure benefits. Treatment groups were pooled and compared with control using difference-in-difference estimates. We examined impact pathways by assessing program impacts on intermediary variables and their associations with development outcomes. RESULTS: At first follow-up, Tubaramure positively affected language (0.4 milestones, P < 0.05) but not motor development among children aged 4-23.9 mo. Among the 12-23.9 mo age subgroup, the program positively affected language (0.7 milestones, P < 0.01) and motor (0.6 milestones, P = 0.08) development. At second follow-up, among children aged 24-41.9 mo, Tubaramure marginally affected motor development (0.4 milestones, P = 0.09). In age subgroup analyses, program impacts were limited to children aged 24-29.9 mo [0.4 motor (P = 0.09) and 1.0 language (P < 0.01) milestones]. Pathway analyses revealed significant positive impacts on diet, health, and nutritional indicators of children aged 12-23.9 mo and health and nutritional indicators of children aged 24-29.9 mo, supporting the plausibility of program impacts on child development. CONCLUSIONS: Tubaramure had small positive impacts on children's motor and language development through multiple pathways, demonstrating the role multisectoral nutrition programs can play in improving children's development. This trial was registered at clinicaltrials.gov as NCT01072279.
Assuntos
Serviços de Saúde da Criança , Desenvolvimento da Linguagem , Serviços de Saúde Materna , Destreza Motora/fisiologia , Adulto , Burundi , Pré-Escolar , Análise por Conglomerados , Feminino , Assistência Alimentar , Humanos , Lactente , Estado Nutricional , Avaliação de Programas e Projetos de SaúdeRESUMO
Nutrition-sensitive programs in low- and middle-income countries often aim to improve child nutrition outcomes in part by empowering women. Although previous studies have found cross-sectional associations linking women's empowerment and child nutritional status, there is limited empirical evidence supporting the hypothesis that empowering women as part of an intervention will, in turn, improve child nutritional outcomes. We tested this hypothesis using two waves of data from a cluster-randomized controlled trial of a nutrition-sensitive agricultural program in Burkina Faso. With structural equation models, we examined whether four domains of women's empowerment-purchasing decisions, healthcare decisions, family planning decisions, and spousal communication-mediated the program's impact on reducing wasting and increasing hemoglobin among children who were three to 12 months old at the start of the two-year program. We found that improvements in women's empowerment in the domains of spousal communication, purchasing decisions, healthcare decisions, and family planning decisions contributed to the program's impact on reducing wasting with the largest share being attributable to spousal communication. Improvements in women's empowerment did not contribute to the increase in hemoglobin. These findings provide the first evidence from a randomized controlled trial that women's empowerment is a pathway by which a nutrition-sensitive program can improve child wasting. Programs that aim to improve child nutritional status should incorporate interventions designed to empower women.
Assuntos
Agricultura , Empoderamento , Mães/estatística & dados numéricos , Estado Nutricional/fisiologia , Adulto , Burkina Faso , Fenômenos Fisiológicos da Nutrição Infantil , Pré-Escolar , Comunicação , Estudos Transversais , Tomada de Decisões , Feminino , Humanos , Lactente , Síndrome de Emaciação/prevenção & controleRESUMO
Background: Food-assisted maternal and child health and nutrition (FA-MCHN) programs may foster child growth during the first 1000 d (pregnancy and the first 2 y of a child's life), but evidence is scant. Objective: We evaluated the impact of an FA-MCHN program, PROCOMIDA, on linear growth (stunting [length-for-age z score (LAZ) < -2] and length-for-age difference [LAD]) among children aged 1-24 mo. PROCOMIDA was implemented in Guatemala by Mercy Corps and was available to beneficiaries throughout the first 1000 d. Methods: We used a longitudinal, cluster-randomized controlled trial with groups varying in family ration sizes [full (FFR), reduced (RFR), and none (NFR)] and individual ration types provided to mothers (pregnancy to 6 mo postpartum) and children (6-24 mo of age) [corn-soy blend (CSB), lipid-based nutrient supplement (LNS), micronutrient powder (MNP)]: 1) FFR + CSB (n = 576); 2) RFR + CSB (n = 575); 3) NFR + CSB (n = 542); 4) FFR + LNS (n = 550); 5) FFR + MNP (n = 587); 6) control (n = 574). Program impacts compared with control, and differential impacts between groups varying family ration size or individual ration type, were assessed through the use of linear mixed-effects models and post hoc simple effect tests (significant if P < 0.05). Results: PROCOMIDA significantly reduced stunting at age 1 mo in FFR + CSB, RFR + CSB, and FFR + MNP groups compared with control [5.05, 4.06, and 3.82 percentage points (pp), respectively]. Stunting impact increased by age 24 mo in FFR + CSB and FFR + MNP relative to control (impact = 11.1 and 6.5 pp at age 24 mo, respectively). For CSB recipients, the FFR compared with RFR or NFR significantly reduced stunting (6.47-9.68 pp). CSB reduced stunting significantly more than LNS at age 24 mo (8.12 pp). Conclusions: FA-MCHN programs can reduce stunting during the first 1000 d, even in relatively energy/food-secure populations. Large family rations with individual rations of CSB or MNP were most effective. The widening of impact as children age highlights the importance of intervening throughout the full first 1000 d. This trial was registered at clinicaltrials.gov as NCT01072279.
Assuntos
Saúde da Criança , Assistência Alimentar , Transtornos do Crescimento/epidemiologia , Transtornos do Crescimento/prevenção & controle , Saúde Materna , Estatura , Peso Corporal , Desenvolvimento Infantil/fisiologia , Pré-Escolar , Suplementos Nutricionais , Ingestão de Energia , Feminino , Guatemala/epidemiologia , Humanos , Lactente , Fenômenos Fisiológicos da Nutrição do Lactente , Recém-Nascido , Estudos Longitudinais , Masculino , Fenômenos Fisiológicos da Nutrição Materna , Micronutrientes/administração & dosagem , Estado Nutricional , Gravidez , Avaliação de Programas e Projetos de SaúdeRESUMO
Evidence is emerging from rigorous evaluations about the effectiveness of nutrition-sensitive agriculture programmes in improving nutritional outcomes. Additional evidence can elucidate how different programme components and pathways contribute and can be optimized for impact. The International Food Policy Research Institute, with Helen Keller International, designed a comprehensive framework to evaluate the delivery, utilization, and impact of Helen Keller International's enhanced homestead food production programme in Burkina Faso. After 18 months of implementation, a process evaluation was conducted to examine programme impact pathways, using key informant and semistructured interviews with implementing agents and beneficiaries, and with residents of control communities. Data were analyzed by International Food Policy Research Institute and reviewed with project managers and partners through multiple workshops to identify opportunities to strengthen implementation. Findings illuminated gaps between intended and actual delivery schemes, including input constraints, knowledge gaps among community agents in agriculture and young child nutrition practices, and lower than expected activity by community volunteers. In response, staff developed measures to overcome water constraints and expand vegetable and poultry production, retrained volunteers in certain techniques of food production and counselling for nutrition behaviour change, added small incentives to motivate volunteers, and shaped both immediate and long-term changes to the programme model. Working closely with International Food Policy Research Institute on the evaluation activities also expanded the repertoire of research methods and skills of Helen Keller International staff. Process evaluation can strengthen programme delivery, utilization, and design. Collaboration between researchers and implementers can improve programme effectiveness, project staff capacity, and advance delivery science.
Assuntos
Desnutrição/epidemiologia , Política Nutricional , Avaliação de Programas e Projetos de Saúde , Burkina Faso/epidemiologia , Pré-Escolar , Análise por Conglomerados , Produtos Agrícolas , Dieta , Feminino , Abastecimento de Alimentos , Comportamentos Relacionados com a Saúde , Conhecimentos, Atitudes e Prática em Saúde , Humanos , Lactente , Estado Nutricional , Fatores SocioeconômicosRESUMO
BACKGROUND: Recent evidence demonstrates the benefits of integrated agriculture and nutrition programs for children's health and nutrition outcomes. These programs may also improve mothers' nutrition and empowerment outcomes. However, evidence from rigorous evaluations is scarce. OBJECTIVE: We examined impacts of Helen Keller International's 2-y enhanced-homestead food production (E-HFP) program in Burkina Faso on the secondary impact measures of mothers' nutrition and empowerment. METHODS: We used a cluster-randomized controlled trial whereby 55 villages with 1767 mothers of young children were randomly assigned to 3 groups: 1) control, 2) E-HFP with the behavior change communication (BCC) strategy implemented by older women leaders, or 3) E-HFP with BCC implemented by health committee members. Data for the treatment groups were pooled for this analysis because no differences were found between the 2 groups in key mothers' outcomes. We used difference-in-differences (DID) estimates to assess impacts on mothers' dietary intake, diversity, body mass index (BMI; in kg/m(2)), prevalence of underweight (BMI <18.5), and empowerment. RESULTS: The E-HFP program significantly increased mothers' intake of fruit (DID = 15.8 percentage points; P = 0.02) and marginally increased their intake of meat/poultry (DID = 7.5 percentage points; P = 0.08) and dietary diversity (DID = 0.3 points; P = 0.08). The prevalence of underweight was significantly reduced among mothers in treatment compared with control villages by 8.7 percentage points (P < 0.01). Although the changes in BMI did not differ between mothers in treatment and control villages, there was a marginally significant interaction (baseline underweight × change in BMI; P-interaction = 0.07), indicating that underweight mothers had a greater increase in BMI than did mothers who were not underweight. The E-HFP program also positively affected mothers' overall empowerment score (DID = 3.13 points out of 37 possible points; P < 0.01) and 3 components of empowerment: meeting with women (DID = 1.21 points out of 5 possible points; P < 0.01), purchasing decisions (DID = 0.86 points out of 8 possible points; P = 0.01), and health care decisions (DID = 0.24 points out of 2 possible points; P = 0.05). CONCLUSIONS: Helen Keller International's E-HFP program in Burkina Faso substantially improved mothers' nutrition and empowerment outcomes. These positive impacts benefit the mothers themselves and may also improve their ability to care for their children. This trial was registered at clinicaltrials.gov as NCT01825226.
Assuntos
Comunicação , Dieta , Comportamento Alimentar , Mães , Poder Psicológico , Avaliação de Programas e Projetos de Saúde , Magreza/dietoterapia , Adulto , Agricultura , Índice de Massa Corporal , Burkina Faso , Humanos , Lactente , Prevalência , Adulto JovemRESUMO
BACKGROUND: Among young children in Burkina Faso, anemia and chronic and acute undernutrition are widespread. OBJECTIVE: This study assessed the impact of Helen Keller International's (HKI) 2-y integrated agriculture [homestead food production (HFP)] and nutrition and health behavior change communication (BCC) program, targeted to women, on children's (3-12.9 mo old at baseline) anthropometry (stunting, wasting, and underweight), mean hemoglobin (Hb), anemia (Hb < 11 g/dL), and diarrhea prevalence. METHODS: We used a cluster-randomized controlled trial, with 55 villages randomly assigned to a control group (n = 25) or 1 of 2 treatment groups (n = 15 each), which differed by who delivered the BCC messages [older women leaders or health committee (HC) members]. We used difference-in-difference (DID) estimates to assess impacts on child outcomes. RESULTS: We found marginally significant (P < 0.10) impacts on Hb (DID: 0.51 g/dL; P = 0.07) and wasting [DID: -8.8 percentage point (pp); P = 0.08] and statistically significant (P < 0.05) impacts on diarrhea (-15.9 pp; P = 0.00) in HC compared with control villages among children aged 3-12.9 mo and larger impacts for anemia (DID: -14.6 pp; P = 0.03) and mean Hb (DID: 0.74 g/dL; P = 0.03) among younger children (aged 3-5.9 mo). However, we found no significant impacts on stunting or underweight prevalence. Plausibility was supported by greater improvements in women's agricultural production and maternal infant and young child feeding and care knowledge and practices in HC compared with control villages. CONCLUSIONS: HKI's 2-y integrated HFP+BCC program (HC group) significantly improved several child outcomes, including wasting (marginal), diarrhea, Hb, and anemia, especially among the youngest children. This is the first cluster-randomized controlled trial of an HFP program that documents statistically significant positive effects on these child nutrition outcomes. This trial was registered at clinicaltrials.gov as NCT01825226.
Assuntos
Anemia/epidemiologia , Diarreia/epidemiologia , Comportamento Alimentar , Comportamentos Relacionados com a Saúde , Promoção da Saúde/métodos , Magreza/epidemiologia , Anemia/prevenção & controle , Burkina Faso/epidemiologia , Análise por Conglomerados , Diarreia/prevenção & controle , Feminino , Seguimentos , Hemoglobinas/metabolismo , Humanos , Lactente , Fenômenos Fisiológicos da Nutrição do Lactente , Masculino , Estado Nutricional , Prevalência , Magreza/prevenção & controleRESUMO
BACKGROUND: Evidence of the impact of homestead food production programs on nutrition outcomes such as anemia and growth is scant. In the absence of information on program impact pathways, it is difficult to understand why these programs, which have been successful in increasing intake of micronutrient-rich foods, have had such limited documented impact on nutrition outcomes. OBJECTIVE: To conduct a process evaluation of Helen Keller International's (HKI's) homestead food production program in Cambodia to assess whether the program was operating as planned (in terms of design, delivery, and utilization) and to identify ways in which the program might need to be strengthened in order to increase its potential for impact. METHODS: A program theory framework, which laid out the primary components along the hypothesized program impact pathways, was developed in collaboration with HKI and used to design the research. Semistructured interviews and focus group discussions with program beneficiaries (n = 36 and 12, respectively), nonbeneficiaries (n = 12), and program implementers (n = 17 and 2, respectively) and observations of key program delivery points, including health and nutrition training sessions (n = 6), village model farms (n = 6), and household gardens of beneficiaries (n = 36) and nonbeneficiaries (n = 12), were conducted to assess the delivery and utilization of the primary program components along the impact pathways. RESULTS: The majority of program components were being delivered and utilized as planned. However, challenges with some of the key components posited to improve outcomes such as anemia and growth were noted. Among these were a gap in the expected pathway from poultry production to increased intake of eggs and poultry meat, and some weaknesses in the delivery of the health and nutrition training sessions and related improvements in knowledge among the village health volunteers and beneficiaries. CONCLUSIONS: Although the program has been successful in delivering the majority of the program components as planned and has documented achievements in improving household production and intake of micronutrient-rich foods, it is likely that strengthening delivery and increasing utilization of some program components would increase its potential for nutritional impacts. This research has highlighted the importance of designing a program theory framework and assessing the components that lie along the primary program impact pathways to optimize program service delivery and utilization and, in turn, potential for impact.
Assuntos
Produtos Agrícolas/crescimento & desenvolvimento , Abastecimento de Alimentos , Avaliação de Programas e Projetos de Saúde , Agricultura/educação , Agricultura/métodos , Camboja , Criança , Proteção da Criança , Comércio , Produtos Agrícolas/economia , Feminino , Assistência Alimentar , Programas Governamentais , Educação em Saúde , Promoção da Saúde , Humanos , Bem-Estar Materno , Micronutrientes/administração & dosagem , Ciências da Nutrição/educação , Estado NutricionalRESUMO
BACKGROUND: Children's development is affected by the interplay of internal and external factors and changes in one factor can precipitate changes in multiple developmental domains. AIMS: The aim of this study was to test a theoretical model of children's development using structural equation modeling. STUDY DESIGN: This was designed as a substudy of a randomized, placebo-controlled, 2 × 2 factorial trial of the effects of daily supplementation with iron (12.5 mg) + folic acid (50 µg) (FeFA) with or without zinc (10 mg) (Zn) on child mortality. SUBJECTS: Zanzibari children aged 5-9 mo (n = 106) and 10-14 mo (n = 141) at baseline were included in this sub study. OUTCOME MEASURES: Longitudinal data on children's hemoglobin, growth, malaria infection, motor development, motor activity, and language development and caregiver behavior were used to test the fit of the theoretical model for two age groups and to examine the direct and indirect relationships among the variables in the model. RESULTS: The theoretical models were a good fit to the data for both age groups and revealed that FeFA with or without Zn had positive effects on motor development. FeFA alone had negative effects on language development in both age groups and Zn alone had negative effects on language development in children aged 10-14 mo. The incidence of malaria had negative effects on the majority of health and development outcomes in children aged 5-9 mo, and on motor development and hemoglobin in children aged 10-14 mo. CONCLUSIONS: These findings illustrate how nutrition and health factors can affect different domains of development and how these changes can precipitate changes in other domains. More work is needed to better understand the multiple impacts of internal and external factors on children's development and how changes in developmental domains interact with each other over time to determine children's overall developmental trajectory. The randomized, placebo-controlled study was registered as an International Standard Randomized Controlled Trial, number ISRCTN59549825.
Assuntos
Desenvolvimento Infantil/efeitos dos fármacos , Suplementos Nutricionais , Malária/epidemiologia , Micronutrientes/uso terapêutico , Modelos Teóricos , Fatores Etários , Cuidadores , Interpretação Estatística de Dados , Índices de Eritrócitos/efeitos dos fármacos , Ácido Fólico/uso terapêutico , Humanos , Mortalidade Infantil , Recém-Nascido , Ferro/uso terapêutico , Desenvolvimento da Linguagem , Tanzânia , Zinco/uso terapêuticoRESUMO
This article reviews the potential of four broad types of platforms, health, agriculture, market-based, and social protection programs, to deliver multiple micronutrient (MMN) interventions (supplementation, fortification, and dietary modification). We assessed the platforms' potential based on seven performance criteria related to programs within these platforms: 1) targeting, 2) efficacy of interventions, 3) quality of implementation, 4) utilization, 5) impact, 6) coverage, and 7) sustainability. We highlight one type of program per platform to illustrate strengths and weaknesses for delivering MMN interventions, identify critical knowledge gaps, and highlight what is needed to increase effectiveness for delivering MMN interventions. We found that all four platforms have the potential to effectively deliver MMN interventions if the following key program elements are addressed: 1) strong behavior change communication strategies to increase demand and proper utilization of services/products; 2) supply side interventions to ensure consistent availability of high quality interventions, products, and well-trained staff; 3) rigorous evaluations of effectiveness, quality of delivery, and impact pathways to generate best practices for replication and scale-up; and 4) timely dissemination of evaluation results to ensure use by program implementers and policy makers. The diversification of delivery platforms, which simultaneously addresses multiple determinants of MMN deficiencies and expands coverage, is needed to accelerate progress in reducing MMN deficiencies.