Avoiding "Needless" nephrectomy: What is the role of small renal mass biopsy in 2024?

Current guidelines do not mandate routine preoperative renal mass biopsy (RMB) for small renal masses (SRMs), which results in a considerable rate (18%-26%) of needless nephrectomy/partial nephrectomy for benign renal tumors. In light of this ongoing practice, a narrative review was conducted to examine the role of routine RMB for SRM. First, arguments justifying the current non-biopsy approach to SRM are critically reviewed and contested. Second, as a standalone procedure, RMB is critically assessed; RMB was found to have higher sensitivity, specificity, and an equal or lower complication rate when compared with other commonly preoperatively biopsied solid organ tumors (e.g., breast, prostate, lung, pancreas, thyroid, and liver). Based on the foregoing information, we propose a paradigm shift in SRM management, advocating for an updated policy in which partial nephrectomy or nephrectomy for SRM invariably occurs only after a preoperative biopsy confirms that a SRM is indeed malignant.

Surgical Force: Initial Study and Clinical Implications in the Assessment of Ureteral Access Sheath Induced Injury.

Purpose: Ureteral access sheaths (UAS) pose the risk of severe ureteral injury. Our prior studies revealed forces ≤6 Newtons (N) prevent ureteral injury. Accordingly, we sought to define the force urologists and residents in training typically use when placing a UAS. Materials and Methods: Among urologists and urology residents attending two annual urological conferences in 2022, 121 individuals were recruited for the study. Participants inserted 12F, 14F, and 16F UAS into a male genitourinary model containing a concealed force sensor; they also provided demographic information. Analysis was completed using t-tests and Chi-square tests to identify group differences when passing a 16F sheath UAS. Participant traits associated with surpassing or remaining below a minimal force threshold were also explored through polychotomous logistic regression. Results: Participant force distributions were as follows: ≤4N (29%), >6N (45%), and >8N (32%). More years of practice were significantly associated with exerting >6N relative to forces between 4N and 6N; results for >8N relative to 4N and 8N were similar. Compared to high-volume ureteroscopists (those performing >20 ureteroscopies/month), physicians performing ≤20 ureteroscopies/month were significantly less likely to exert forces ≤4N (p = 0.017 and p = 0.041). Of those surpassing 6N and 8N, 15% and 18%, respectively, were high-volume ureteroscopists. Conclusions: Despite years of practice or volume of monthly ureteroscopic cases performed, most urologists failed to pass 16F access sheaths within the ideal range of 4N to 6N (74% of participants) or within a predefined safe range of 4N to 8N (61% of participants).

Alkaline Water: Help or Hype for Uric Acid and Cystine Urolithiasis?

PURPOSE: The consumption of alkaline water, water with an average pH of 8 to 10, has been steadily increasing globally as proponents claim it to be a healthier alternative to regular water. Urinary alkalinization therapy is frequently prescribed in patients with uric acid and cystine urolithiasis, and as such we analyzed commercially available alkaline waters to assess their potential to increase urinary pH. MATERIALS AND METHODS: Five commercially available alkaline water brands (Essentia, Smart Water Alkaline, Great Value Hydrate Alkaline Water, Body Armor SportWater, and Perfect Hydration) underwent anion chromatography and direct chemical measurements to determine the mineral contents of each product. The alkaline content of each bottle of water was then compared to that of potassium citrate (the gold standard for urinary alkalinization) as well as to other beverages and supplements used to augment urinary citrate and/or the urine pH. RESULTS: The pH levels of the bottled alkaline water ranged from 9.69 to 10.15. Electrolyte content was minimal, and the physiologic alkali content was below 1 mEq/L for all brands of alkaline water. The alkali content of alkaline water is minimal when compared to common stone treatment alternatives such as potassium citrate. In addition, several organic beverages, synthetic beverages, and other supplements contain more alkali content than alkaline water, and can achieve the AUA and European Association of Urology alkali recommendation of 30 to 60 mEq per day with ≤ 3 servings/d. CONCLUSIONS: Commercially available alkaline water has negligible alkali content and thus provides no added benefit over tap water for patients with uric acid and cystine urolithiasis.

Efficient and Accurate Computed Tomography-Based Stone Volume Determination: Development of an Automated Artificial Intelligence Algorithm.

PURPOSE: Given the shortcomings of current stone burden characterization (maximum diameter or ellipsoid formulas), we sought to investigate the diagnostic accuracy and precision of a University of California, Irvine-developed artificial intelligence (AI) algorithm for determining stone volume determination. MATERIALS AND METHODS: A total of 322 noncontrast CT scans were retrospectively obtained from patients with a diagnosis of urolithiasis. The largest stone in each noncontrast CT scan was designated the "index stone." The 3D volume of the index stone using 3D Slicer technology was determined by a validated reviewer; this was considered the "ground truth" volume. The AI-calculated index stone volume was subsequently compared with ground truth volume as well with the scalene, prolate, and oblate ellipsoid formulas estimated volumes. RESULTS: There was a nearly perfect correlation between the AI-determined volume and the ground truth (R=0.98). While the AI algorithm was efficient for determining the stone volume for all sizes, its accuracy improved with larger stone size. Moreover, the AI stone volume produced an excellent 3D pixel overlap with the ground truth (Dice score=0.90). In comparison, the ellipsoid formula-based volumes performed less well (R range: 0.79-0.82) than the AI algorithm; for the ellipsoid formulas, the accuracy decreased as the stone size increased (mean overestimation: 27%-89%). Lastly, for all stone sizes, the maximum linear stone measurement had the poorest correlation with the ground truth (R range: 0.41-0.82). CONCLUSIONS: The University of California, Irvine AI algorithm is an accurate, precise, and time-efficient tool for determining stone volume. Expanding the clinical availability of this program could enable urologists to establish better guidelines for both the metabolic and surgical management of their urolithiasis patients.

Electromotive Drug Administration in the Porcine Renal Pelvis: First Report.

Introduction: Electromotive Drug Administration (EMDA) amplifies drug delivery deep into targeted tissues. We tested, for the first time, the ability of EMDA to deliver methylene blue into the urothelium of the renal pelvis. Materials and Methods: In an anesthetized female pig, both proximal ureters were transected two inches distal to the ureteropelvic junction. An 8F dual lumen catheter and a 5F fenestrated catheter with an indwelling silver wire were inserted into both renal pelvises following which methylene blue (0.1%) was infused at a rate of 5 mL/min for 20 minutes. In one pelvis, a 4 mA positive pulsed electrical current was applied to the silver wire. Results: In contrast to the control pelvis, the EMDA side macroscopically exhibited dense homogeneous staining; microscopy revealed penetration of methylene blue into the urothelium/lamina propria. Conclusion: In the porcine renal pelvis, application of EMDA increased the penetration of a charged molecule into the urothelium/lamina propria.

Comparison of Ureteral Stent Biomaterials: Encrustation Profile in Lithogenic Artificial Urine Models.

Ureteral stent encrustation significantly limits indwelling time and can lead to downstream urological problems. However, no ideal polymeric biomaterials have been shown to completely resist encrustation in long-term urine exposure. Recently, 2-hydroxyethyl methacrylate (HEMA)-coated Pellethane was reported as a promising biomaterial resistant to encrustation. This study compared HEMA-coated Pellethane to commercially available stents under two different artificial urine environments. To evaluate the degree and composition of encrustation on HEMA-coated Pellethane, Boston Scientific Tria, Bard InLay Optima, Cook Universa Hydrogel, and Cook Black Silicone stents were used at various dwelling times in two different artificial urine environments. In a batch-flow model, samples of stents were suspended in an artificial urine solution (AUS) at 37 °C. Every 24 h for 11 weeks, 50% of the AUS would be replaced with fresh components using a programmable peristaltic pump system. The stent materials were removed at suitable time intervals and air-dried for 24 h under sterile conditions before follow-up analysis. SEM was used to assess the degree of encrustation, and inductively coupled plasma mass spectrometry (ICP-MS) was employed to quantify the encrusted compositions, specifically for calcium, magnesium, and phosphorus. We measured the weight gain over time due to encrusted deposits on the stents and quantified the amount of Ca, Mg, and P deposited on each encrusted stent. After the 11 week trial, HEMA-coated Pellethane showed the most average mass change. SEM showed that HEMA-coated Pellethane was fully encrusted in just 2 weeks in the AUS environments, and ICP-MS showed that Ca is the most abundant deposit. Among all the tested stents, Black Silicone performed the best. The two AUSs were formulated to encrust more rapidly than physiological conditions. HEMA-coated Pellethane is not an ideal stent material, while silicone is a promising material for advancing ureteral stents.

Evaluation of Renal Function and Stent Durability Following Resonance Stent Placement for Benign Disease.

Introduction: The metal-based Resonance stent (RS) has traditionally been placed in patients with malignant ureteral obstruction; as such, the long-term utility of RS among patients with benign ureteral obstruction (BUO) remains underinvestigated. Methods: We retrospectively reviewed our database for patients with BUO who underwent RS placement between 2010 and 2020. The impact of chronic RS placement on renal function was evaluated by estimated serum creatinine-based glomerular filtration rate (eGFR), furosemide renal scan, and CT-based renal parenchymal volume measurement. The number of and reason for RS stent exchanges during the follow-up period, incidence of encrustation, and the average indwell time were recorded. A cost analysis of placing the RS vs a polymeric stent was performed. Results: Among 43 RS patients with BUO, at a mean follow-up of 26 months, there was no change in eGFR (p = 0.99), parenchymal volume (p = 0.44), or split renal function of the stent-bearing side on renal scan (p = 0.48). The mean RS indwell time was 9.7 months. Eleven patients (26%) underwent premature stent replacement (6 cases) or removal (5 cases). Stents in 9 patients (32%) were encrusted, of which 4 (44%) required laser lithotripsy. Overall, 25 patients (58%) and 12 patients (28%) had a mean stent indwell time of ≥6 months and ≥12 months, respectively. Placing an RS resulted in a 52%, 37%, and 5.6% cost reduction compared with a regular polymeric stent placement, where it was exchanged every 6, 4, or 3 months, respectively. Conclusions: RS deployment in the patient with a BUO results in cost-effective maintenance of renal function and of renal parenchymal volume at a mean follow-up of 2 years; however, only 28% of patients fulfilled the 1-year criterion for RS indwell time.

Electromotive Drug Administration in the Ureter in an In Vivo Animal Model: Initial Report.

Introduction: Electromotive drug administration (EMDA) delivers a drug deeply into targeted tissues, such as the bladder. EMDA has never been applied to the ureter. Methods: In four in vivo porcine ureters, a unique EMDA catheter containing a silver conducting wire was advanced for the infusion of methylene blue. In two ureters, a pulsed current was delivered through an EMDA machine, whereas the other two ureters served as a control. After 20 minutes of infusion, the ureters were harvested. Results: In the EMDA ureter, there was diffuse staining of the urothelium; penetration of methylene blue occurred in the lamina propria and muscularis propria. In the control ureter, there was only patchy staining of the urothelium. Conclusion: In this first report of ureteral EMDA, a charged molecule penetrated beyond the urothelium into the lamina propria and muscularis propria of the porcine ureter.

Comparison of Superpulse Thulium Fiber Laser vs Holmium Laser for Ablation of Renal Calculi in an In Vivo Porcine Model.

Introduction and Objectives: We sought to compare the effectiveness and efficiency of the superpulse thulium fiber laser (sTFL to the holmium: yttrium-aluminum-garnet [Ho:YAG] laser for ureteroscopic "dusting" of implanted renal stones in an in vivo porcine model. Methods: Twenty-four porcine kidneys (12 juvenile female Yorkshire pigs) were randomized to Ho:YAG or sTFL treatment groups. Canine calcium oxalate stones were scanned with computed tomography to calculate stone volume and stone density; the stones were randomized and implanted into each renal pelvis via an open pyelotomy. In all trials, a 14F, 35 cm ureteral access sheath was placed. With a 9.9F dual lumen flexible ureteroscope, laser lithotripsy was performed using dusting settings: Ho:YAG 200 µm laser fiber at 16 W (0.4 J, 40 Hz) or sTFL 200 µm laser fiber at 16 W (0.2 J, 80 Hz). Lithotripsy continued until no fragments over 1 mm were observed. No stone basketing was performed. Throughout the procedures, intrarenal and renal pelvis temperatures were measured using two percutaneously positioned K-type thermocouples, one in the upper pole calyx and one in the renal pelvis. After the lithotripsy, the ureteropelvic junction was occluded, the kidneys were bivalved, and all residual fragments were collected, dried, weighed, and then measured with an optical laser particle sizer. Results: Implanted stones were similar in volume and density in both groups. Intraoperative collecting system temperatures were similar for both groups (all <44°C). Compared to Ho:YAG, sTFL ablated stones faster (9 vs 27 minutes, p < 0.001) with less energy expenditure (8 vs 26 kJ, p < 0.001), and a greater stone clearance rate (73% vs 45%, p = 0.001). After sTFL lithotripsy, 77% of the remaining fragments were ≤1 mm vs 17% of fragments ≤1 mm after Ho:YAG treatment (p < 0.001). Conclusions: In an in vivo porcine kidney, using dusting settings, sTFL lithotripsy resulted in shorter ablation times, higher stone clearance rates, and markedly smaller stone fragments than Ho:YAG lithotripsy.

Porcine Bladder Replacement with a Bilayer Silk Fibroin Enhanced Prosthetic Reservoir: A Feasibility Study.

Introduction: The creation of synthetic reservoirs for bladder replacement has been limited by challenges of interfacing synthetic materials and native tissue. We sought to overcome this challenge by utilizing a novel bilayer silk fibroin scaffold (BLSF) as an intermediary toward the development of an acellular prosthetic reservoir. Methods: Under institutionally approved protocols, 3D-printed reservoirs were implanted in six juvenile female pigs after cystectomy. BLSF was attached to the in situ prosthetic reservoir serving as an intermediary to native ureteral and urethral tissue anastomoses. Our first protocol allowed four pigs to be survived up to 7 days, and the second protocol allowed two pigs to be survived for up to 1 year. At the first sign of functional decline or the end of the study period, the animals were euthanized, and kidneys, ureters, prosthetic bladder, and urethra were harvested en bloc for histopathology analysis. Results: The first two pigs had anastomotic urine leaks because of design flaws resulting in early termination. The third pig had acute renal failure resulting in early termination. The artificial bladder design was modified in subsequent iterations. The fourth pig survived for 7 days and, upon autopsy, had intact urethral and ureteral anastomoses. The fifth and sixth pigs survived for 11 and 12 weeks, respectively, before they were sacrificed because of failure to thrive. One animal developed an enteric fistula. The other animal had an intact anastomosis, and the BLFS was identified at the ureteral and urethral anastomoses on histopathologic analysis. Conclusions: Replacing the porcine bladder with a prosthetic bladder was achieved for up to 3 months, the second longest survival period for a nonbiologic bladder alternative. BLSF was used for the first time to create an interface between synthetic material and biologic tissue by allowing ingrowth of urothelium onto the acellular alloplastic bladder.

Heterogeneity in stone culture protocols and endourologist practice patterns: a multi-institutional survey.

Kidney stone cultures can be beneficial in identifying bacteria not detected in urine, yet how stone cultures are performed among endourologists, under what conditions, and by what laboratory methods remain largely unknown. Stone cultures are not addressed by current clinical guidelines. A comprehensive REDCap electronic survey sought responses from directed (n = 20) and listserv elicited (n = 108) endourologists specializing in kidney stone disease. Questions included which clinical scenarios prompt a stone culture order, how results influence post-operative antibiotics, and what microbiology lab protocols exist at each institution with respect to processing and resulting stone cultures. Logistic regression statistical analysis determined what factors were associated with performing stone cultures. Of 128 unique responses, 11% identified as female and the mean years of practicing was 16 (range 1-46). A specific 'stone culture' order was available to only 50% (64/128) of those surveyed, while 32% (41/128) reported culturing stone by placing a urine culture order. The duration of antibiotics given for a positive stone culture varied, with 4-7 days (46%) and 8-14 days (21%) the most reported. More years in practice was associated with fewer stone cultures ordered, while higher annual volume of percutaneous nephrolithotomy was associated with ordering more stone cultures (p < 0.01). Endourologists have differing practice patterns with respect to ordering stone cultures and utilizing the results to guide post-operative antibiotics. With inconsistent microbiology lab stone culture protocols across multiple institutions, more uniform processing is needed for future studies to assess the clinical benefit of stone cultures and direct future guidelines.

Prospective, Randomized Comparison of Dual-Lumen vs Single-Lumen Flexible Ureteroscopes in Proximal Ureteral and Renal Stone Management.

Introduction: We sought to compare the safety, efficacy, efficiency, and surgeon experience during upper urinary tract stone management with single-lumen (SLFU) vs dual-lumen flexible ureteroscopes (DLFU). Materials and Methods: Seventy-nine patients with proximal ureteral or renal stone burden <2 cm were randomized to a SLFU or DLFU. We recorded times for ureteroscopy (URS), laser lithotripsy, stone basketing, as well as intraoperative and postoperative complications. The rate of stone clearance and stone free status were calculated using CT imaging. Surgeons completed a survey after each procedure rating various metrics regarding ureteroscope performance. Results: Thirty-five patients from the single-lumen group and 44 patients from the dual-lumen group had comparable median URS time (37 vs 35 minutes, p = 0.984) and basketing time (12 vs 19 minutes; p = 0.584). Median lithotripsy time was decreased in the dual-lumen group (single: 6 vs dual: 2 minutes, p = 0.017). The stone clearance rate was superior in the dual-lumen group (single: 3.7 vs dual: 7.1 mm3/min, p = 0.025). The absolute stone-free rate (SFR) was superior for the dual-lumen group (single: 26% vs dual: 48%, p = 0.045). No differences in intraoperative (single: 0% vs dual: 2%; p = 0.375) and postoperative complications (single: 7% vs dual: 11%, p = 0.474) were observed. Surgeons' ratings of the dual-lumen ureteroscope was superior for visibility, comfort, ease of use, and overall performance. Conclusions: The use of the dual-lumen ureteroscope in patients with renal and proximal ureteral stones <2 cm provided shorter lithotripsy time, higher stone clearance rates, improved SFR, and superior surgeon ratings when compared with SLFUs.

Retrograde Cystonephroscopy for Complex Renal Calculi Using Novel Dual-Action Aspiration, Irrigation Cystoscope: Initial Case Series.

Introduction: Percutaneous nephrolithotomy is the gold standard treatment for kidney stones ≥2 cm; however, it remains an invasive procedure with significant risks especially in individuals with severe medical comorbidities. In contrast, while ureteroscopy is far less morbid, a major impediment to its use for larger calculi is the inability to evacuate the many fragments created during laser lithotripsy. Herein, we describe two patients with large-volume calculi and a third high-risk patient with a smaller stone who were treated with cystonephroscopy using a recently released, 16F flexible cystoscope equipped with dual aspiration and irrigation capabilities. Materials and Methods: Three consecutive female patients underwent retrograde cystonephroscopy from June 2021 to July 2021 with a novel 16F aspiration-enabled flexible cystoscope. Demographic data were collected. Preoperative and postoperative CT scan images were reviewed to determine linear stone dimensions and scalene ellipsoid volume. Results: The three female patients had an average age of 72.3 years and an American Society of Anesthesiologists (ASA) physical status score of 3. The mean preoperative stone volume was 4950 mm3. The average postcystonephroscopy stone volume was 217 mm3, resulting in a total stone clearance rate of 97%. No major complications occurred. The average procedure time was 176 minutes. Conclusions: Among the three high-risk female patients, two with large-volume calculi, retrograde cystonephroscopy with a novel aspiration-enabled cystoscope allowed for the procedure to be effectively completed solely via a retrograde approach.

The Impact of One Week of Pre-Stenting on Porcine Ureteral Luminal Circumference.

Objectives: Larger ureteral access sheaths (UASs) have the potential to improve ureteroscopic stone removal outcomes but are often avoided by surgeons because of concerns of ureteral injury. Using our novel UAS force sensor and previously defined force thresholds for ureteral injury, we sought to evaluate the impact of 1 week of stenting on the maximum safe dilation of ureteral luminal circumference. Methods: Twelve juvenile female Yorkshire pigs (24 ureters) were evaluated. The inner (i.e., luminal) circumference of each ureter was determined using Cook urethral dilators ranging from 8F to 24F in 2F increments, 37 cm in length. Each dilator was sequentially passed while applying the UAS force sensor to measure insertion force before and after 1 week of stent placement. Each ureter was randomized to receive either a 4.7F or 7.0F stent (20 cm). Maximum ureteral luminal circumference was defined as effective passage of the dilator to the ureteropelvic junction with ≤6 newtons (N) of force (the force threshold previously defined by porcine and clinical studies to avoid ureteral damage). After passage of the largest dilator at 6 N, flexible ureteroscopy was performed and a post-ureteroscopic lesion scale (PULS) was recorded. Results: After 1 week of stent placement, the median ureteral luminal circumference increased to 15F representing a mean increase of 3.8F ± 2.8F (p < 0.001). Twenty-one (88%) of the pre-stented ureters had an increase in luminal circumference, with 12 ureters (50%) dilated to ≥16F (p = 0.032), 6 ureters (25%) dilated to ≥18F, and in 2 cases a maximum size of 24F was recorded. The PULS grade was ≤2 in all cases, indicating no high-grade ureteral injuries. Laterality and stent size did not impact ureteral luminal circumference after pre-stenting (p = 0.232 and p = 0.337, respectively). Conclusions: One week of ureteral stenting resulted in nearly a 4F increase in the luminal circumference of porcine ureters.

Ex Vivo Renal Stone Dusting: Impact of Laser Modality, Ureteral Access Sheath, and Suction on Total Stone Clearance.

Introduction and Objectives: Conventional renal stone dusting is challenging; the holmium (Ho:YAG) laser and holmium with MOSES effect (Ho:YAG-MOSES) fail to uniformly produce fragments ≤100 µm (i.e., dust). The superpulse thulium fiber laser (sTFL) may more effectively render uroliths into "dust," and may thus improve stone-free rates. Accordingly, we performed ex vivo evaluations with all three laser modalities, assessing stone fragments and stone clearance. Methods: Seventy-two ex vivo porcine kidney-ureter models were divided into 12 groups of 6: laser type (Ho:YAG, Ho:YAG-MOSES, sTFL), ureteroscope with and without applied suction, and the presence or absence of a 14F ureteral access sheath (UAS). Calcium oxalate stones were preweighed and implanted into each kidney via a pyelotomy. Stones were treated at 16W using dusting settings of 0.4J × 40Hz (Ho:YAG), 0.2J × 80Hz (Ho:YAG-MOSES), and 0.2J × 80Hz (sTFL) for up to 20 minutes. No stone basketing was performed. Kidneys were bivalved and residual fragments were collected, dried, weighed, and sieved to determine fragment size and stone clearance. Results: Initial stone mass (mg), procedure time (seconds), and laser energy expenditure (kJ) were similar in all 12 groups. The greatest stone clearance was seen with sTFL + suction + UAS (94%) compared with a conventional technique (Ho:YAG + no suction + no UAS) (65%, p < 0.01). The use of sTFL provided greater stone clearance than Ho:YAG or Ho:YAG-MOSES. Aspiration improved stone clearance for sTFL (p = 0.01), but not for Ho:YAG or Ho:YAG-MOSES, consistent with the creation of smaller fragments with sTFL. Presence of a 14F UAS improved stone clearance in all scenarios (p < 0.01). Conclusions: In this ex vivo study, stone clearance was optimized under the following conditions: sTFL, 14F UAS, and aspiration. This combination resulted in 94% of stone fragments being cleared; the 6% remaining fragments were all <2 mm. In all scenarios, deployment of a 14F UAS improved stone clearance.

Can preoperative renal mass biopsy change clinical practice and reduce surgical intervention for small renal masses?

INTRODUCTION: The role of renal biopsy prior to surgical intervention for a renal mass remains controversial despite the fact that for all other urological organs except the testicle, biopsy inevitably precedes treatment as is true for all other specialties dealing with solid masses (e.g. thyroid, breast, colon, liver, etc.). Accordingly, we sought to determine the impact of a routine biopsy regimen on the course of patients with cT1a lesions in comparison with a contemporary series of cT1a individuals who went directly to treatment without a preoperative biopsy. METHODS: We analyzed a multi-institutional, prospectively maintained database of patients who underwent an office-based, ultrasound-guided, renal mass biopsy (RMB) for a cT1a renal mass (i.e. ≤4cm in largest dimension). Controls were selected from all patients in the database who had a cT1a renal lesion but did not undergo RMB. Both groups were analyzed for differences in treatment modality and surgical pathology results. RESULTS: A total of 72 RMB and 73 control patients were analyzed. The groups were similar in regards to their baseline characteristics. Overall RMB diagnostic rate was 75%. Surgical pathology revealed that excision of benign tumors was eight-fold less in the RMB cohort compared to the control group (3% vs. 23%; P < 0.001). Additionally, the rate of active surveillance in the RMB cohort was nearly three times higher at 35% vs. 14% for the controls (P < 0.001). Biopsy was concordant with surgical pathology in 97% of cases for primary histology (i.e. benign vs. malignant), 97% for histologic subtype, and 46% for low (I or II) vs. high (III or IV) grade. On multivariate analysis patients who underwent surgical intervention without preoperative RMB were 6.7 times more likely to have benign histopathology compared to patients who underwent preoperative RMB (OR 6.7, 95% CI = 0.714 - 63.626, P = 0.096). There were no procedural or post-procedural RMB complications. CONCLUSIONS: For patients with cT1a lesions, the implementation of routine office-based RMB led to a significant decrease in the rate of surgical intervention for benign tumors. This practice also resulted in a higher rate of active surveillance for the management of renal cortical neoplasms with benign histopathology compared to a control group.

Office-Based Renal Tumor Biopsy: a Paradigm Change in the Management of a Small Renal Mass?

PURPOSE OF REVIEW: The goal of this paper is to evaluate the use of an office-based renal mass biopsy (RMB), whose feasibility could represent a paradigm shift in clinical practice. RECENT FINDINGS: Despite the earlier diagnosis of patients with renal masses, the lack of evidence showing a reduction in cancer-specific mortality warrants an examination in treatment practices. RMB is underutilized when compared to biopsy practice for all other neoplasms in every other solid organ (except testis), and the majority of RMB performed are outsourced to interventional radiologists. Performing an ultrasound-guided, office-based RMB is safe, reproducible, and has a meaningful impact on management decisions. The use of percutaneous RMB in clinical practice is growing, and the use of RMB has meaningful impact on management decisions for renal masses. Incorporating ultrasound-guided biopsy of a renal mass into clinical practice is feasible, and in contemporary practice, the urologist has the skill set to perform the procedure reliably, with low morbidity, and with minimal patient discomfort.

Crowd-Sourced Assessment of Surgical Skills of Urology Resident Applicants: Four-Year Experience.

OBJECTIVE: To determine a) if surgical skills among urology resident applicants could be reliably assessed via crowdsourcing and b) to what extent surgical skills testing impacts resident selection. DESIGN: Interviewees completed the following surgical skills tasks during their interview day: open knot tying (OKT), laparoscopic peg transfer (LPT), and robotic suturing (RS). Urology faculty and crowd-workers evaluated each applicant's video-recorded performance using validated scoring and were assessed for agreement using Cronbach's alpha. Applicants' USMLE scores, interview scores, and Jefferson Scale of Physician Empathy (JSPE-S) scores were assessed for correlation with skills testing scores and match rank. Additionally, a survey was distributed to interviewees assessing match outcomes. SETTING: University of California Irvine Department of Urology, Surgical Skills Laboratory PARTICIPANTS: All 94 urology residency interviewees at the University of California Irvine Department of Urology from 2015-2018 were invited to complete the three surgical skills tasks on their interview day. RESULTS: Survey responses were received from all 94 interviewees (100%). Crowd and expert agreement was good (α=0.88), fair (α=0.67), and poor (α=0.32) for LPT, RS, and OKT scores, respectively. The skills testing scores did not correlate with match rank, USMLE score, or JSPE-S score. On multivariate analysis, only interview score (r= -0.723; p<0.001) and faculty LPT score (r=-0.262; p=0.001) were significant predictors of match rank. Interviewees who reported matching into a top 3 residency choice had significantly higher faculty LPT scores than those who did not (11.9 vs. 9.7, p=0.03). CONCLUSIONS: Surgical skills overall did not significantly impact match rank. Expert assessment of laparoscopic peg transfer skills and interview performance among urology resident applicants correlated with match rank.