Assessment of mechanisms driving non-linear dose-response relationships in genotoxicity testing.

In genetic toxicology, risk assessment has traditionally adopted linear dose-responses for any compound that causes genotoxic effects. Increasing evidence of non-linear dose-responses, however, suggests potential cellular tolerance to low levels of many genotoxicants with diverse modes of action. Such putative non-linear dose-responses need to be substantiated by strong mechanistic data that identifies the mechanisms responsible for the tolerance to low doses. This can be achieved by experimental demonstration of cytoprotective mechanisms and by providing experimental support for the existence of tolerance mechanisms against low dose effects. By highlighting key experiments into low dose mechanisms, this review aims to clarify which mechanistic data are required to support the use of non-linear dose-response models in risk assessment. Such key experiments are presented and discussed for alkylating agents, oxidants, particulate matter, nucleoside analogues, topoisomerase inhibitors and aneugens and exemplify the use of gene knockout models or transgenic models as well as chemical modulators of key effectors of relevant pathways and their impact on dose-response relationships. In vitro studies are particularly valuable to elucidate mechanisms of low-dose protection or lack thereof, while in vivo experiments are most appropriate for deriving a safe dose. In order to evaluate the existence of non-linear dose-response relationships for genotoxicants, we suggest that careful attention should be given to the mode of genotoxic action, relevant biomarkers of exposure, as well as to the existence and impact of potential cytoprotective mechanisms like detoxifying metabolism and DNA repair.

Automation and validation of micronucleus detection in the 3D EpiDerm™ human reconstructed skin assay and correlation with 2D dose responses.

Recent restrictions on the testing of cosmetic ingredients in animals have resulted in the need to test the genotoxic potential of chemicals exclusively in vitro prior to licensing. However, as current in vitro tests produce some misleading positive results, sole reliance on such tests could prevent some chemicals with safe or beneficial exposure levels from being marketed. The 3D human reconstructed skin micronucleus (RSMN) assay is a promising new in vitro approach designed to assess genotoxicity of dermally applied compounds. The assay utilises a highly differentiated in vitro model of the human epidermis. For the first time, we have applied automated micronucleus detection to this assay using MetaSystems Metafer Slide Scanning Platform (Metafer), demonstrating concordance with manual scoring. The RSMN assay's fixation protocol was found to be compatible with the Metafer, providing a considerably shorter alternative to the recommended Metafer protocol. Lowest observed genotoxic effect levels (LOGELs) were observed for mitomycin-C at 4.8 µg/ml and methyl methanesulfonate (MMS) at 1750 µg/ml when applied topically to the skin surface. In-medium dosing with MMS produced a LOGEL of 20 µg/ml, which was very similar to the topical LOGEL when considering the total mass of MMS added. Comparisons between 3D medium and 2D LOGELs resulted in a 7-fold difference in total mass of MMS applied to each system, suggesting a protective function of the 3D microarchitecture. Interestingly, hydrogen peroxide (H2O2), a positive clastogen in 2D systems, tested negative in this assay. A non-genotoxic carcinogen, methyl carbamate, produced negative results, as expected. We also demonstrated expression of the DNA repair protein N-methylpurine-DNA glycosylase in EpiDerm™. Our preliminary validation here demonstrates that the RSMN assay may be a valuable follow-up to the current in vitro test battery, and together with its automation, could contribute to minimising unnecessary in vivo tests by reducing in vitro misleading positives.

The Cosmetics Europe strategy for animal-free genotoxicity testing: project status up-date.

The Cosmetics Europe (formerly COLIPA) Genotoxicity Task Force has driven and funded three projects to help address the high rate of misleading positives in in vitro genotoxicity tests: The completed "False Positives" project optimized current mammalian cell assays and showed that the predictive capacity of the in vitro micronucleus assay was improved dramatically by selecting more relevant cells and more sensitive toxicity measures. The on-going "3D skin model" project has been developed and is now validating the use of human reconstructed skin (RS) models in combination with the micronucleus (MN) and Comet assays. These models better reflect the in use conditions of dermally applied products, such as cosmetics. Both assays have demonstrated good inter- and intra-laboratory reproducibility and are entering validation stages. The completed "Metabolism" project investigated enzyme capacities of human skin and RS models. The RS models were shown to have comparable metabolic capacity to native human skin, confirming their usefulness for testing of compounds with dermal exposure. The program has already helped to improve the initial test battery predictivity and the RS projects have provided sound support for their use as a follow-up test in the assessment of the genotoxic hazard of cosmetic ingredients in the absence of in vivo data.

In vitro approaches to develop weight of evidence (WoE) and mode of action (MoA) discussions with positive in vitro genotoxicity results.

A recent analysis by Kirkland et al. [Kirkland, D., Aardema, M., Henderson, L. and Müller, L. (2005) Evaluation of the ability of a battery of 3 in vitro genotoxicity tests to discriminate rodent carcinogens and non-carcinogens. I. Sensitivity, specificity and relative predictivity. Mutat. Res. 584, 1-256] demonstrated an extremely high false positive rate for in vitro genotoxicity tests when compared with carcinogenicity in rodents. In many industries, decisions have to be made on the safety of new substances, and health risk to humans, without rodent carcinogenicity data being available. In such cases, the usual way to determine whether a positive in vitro genotoxicity result is relevant (i.e. indicates a hazard) for humans is to develop weight of evidence (WoE) or mode of action (MoA) arguments. These are based partly on further in vitro investigations, but usually rely heavily on tests for genotoxicity in one or more in vivo assays. However, for certain product types in the European Union, the use of animals for genotoxicity testing (as well as for other endpoints) will be prohibited within the next few years. Many different examples have been described that indicate DNA damage and genotoxic responses in vitro can arise through non-relevant in vitro events that are a result of the test systems and conditions used. The majority of these non-relevant in vitro events can be grouped under a category of 'overload of normal physiology' that would not be expected to occur in exposed humans. However, obtaining evidence in support of such MoAs is not easy, particularly for those industries prohibited from carrying out in vivo testing. It will become necessary to focus on in vitro studies to provide evidence of non-DNA, threshold or in vitro-specific processes and to discuss the potential for such genotoxic effects to occur in exposed humans. Toward this end, we surveyed the published literature for in vitro approaches that may be followed to determine whether a genotoxic effect observed in vitro will occur in humans. Unfortunately, many of the approaches we found are based on only a few published examples and validated approaches with consensus recommendations often do not exist. This analysis highlights the urgent need for developing consensus approaches that do not rely on animal studies for dealing with in vitro genotoxins.

Exercise-induced DNA effects in human leukocytes are not accompanied by increased formation of 8-hydroxy-2'-deoxyguanosine or induction of micronuclei.

The present study examined the effects of a short-distance triathlon on the induction of DNA effects in peripheral leukocytes, urinary excretion of oxidized DNA bases, and frequency of micronuclei in lymphocytes of human volunteers. Induction of DNA effects was measured as increased DNA migration using the alkaline comet assay. Increased DNA migration was found in leukocytes of all individuals at different time points after exercise and revealed a biphasic pattern. Twenty-four hours postexercise, elevated DNA migration was found, whereas lower values were detected 48 h after exercise. Seventy-two hours postexercise, the maximum increase in DNA migration was found and baseline values were still elevated after 120 h. A modified protocol of the comet assay for the detection of oxidized DNA bases revealed no differences in leukocytes before and directly after the triathlon. Urinary excretion of 8-hydroxy-2'-deoxyguanosine remained unaltered during the 5 consecutive days sampled. No differences were found in the micronucleus-frequency in lymphocytes before or 48 and 96 h after exercise. Our data suggest that DNA effects detected with the comet assay in leukocytes of humans after exercise are secondary effects that do not originate from oxidized DNA bases and do not result in chromosome damage.

Detection of DNA-crosslinking agents with the alkaline comet assay.

The single cell gel electrophoresis, or comet assay, under alkaline conditions is a sensitive, simple and rapid method for the detection of DNA damage at the individual cell level. Its applicability as an indicator for the DNA crosslinking potency of a test substance was investigated in human white blood cells by combined treatment with the DNA damaging agent methyl methanesulphonate (MMS) for 2 hr at 37 degrees C. The known crosslinking agents cisplatinum, mitomycin C and formaldehyde, and the formaldehyde releasers diazolidinyl urea and dimethylol urea, were shown to reduce MMS-induced DNA migration in the comet assay in a concentration-dependent manner. Two other protocols, adding MMS to the cells before or after treatment with a crosslinking agent, were carried out and achieved similar results. The results of this study indicate that the comet assay is a useful tool for the detection of crosslinking agents. Advantages and limitations of this method compared to the alkaline elution technique are discussed.

Investigation of genotoxic effects of the anti-asthmatic and anti-inflammatory drugs Apocynin and Acetosyringenin in the Salmonella typhimurium mutagenicity assay and the SCE-test with human lymphocytes.

We examined the possible genotoxicity of the recently isolated or developed anti-asthmatic and anti-inflammatory substances Apocynin (CAS 498-02-2) and Acetosyringenin (CAS 2478-38-8) using short term test systems. Apocynin is a constituent of Picrorhiza kurroa, a plant from the Himalaya region. Acetosyringenin is its methoxylated synthetic derivative. The test systems used were the Salmonella typhimurium mutagenicity assay (Ames test) with the tester strains TA 97, TA 98, TA 100, and TA 102, and the sister chromatid exchange assay (SCE-Test) performed with human peripheral lymphocytes. The genetic endpoints covered by these test systems are the induction of gene mutations and the induction of SCEs, which is interpreted as an indicator for DNA-damaging properties of the test compound. The results obtained with Apocynin and Acetosyringenin do not demonstrate genotoxic activities of these compounds regarding the investigated endpoints.