Prospective comparative evaluation of quantitative-elastosonography (Q-elastography) and contrast-enhanced ultrasound for the evaluation of thyroid nodules: preliminary experience.

PURPOSE: To assess the effectiveness of semiquantitative elastosonography (Q-elastography) compared with contrast-enhanced ultrasound (CEUS) in differentiating the nature of thyroid nodules. METHODS AND MATERIALS: Forty-eight consecutive patients (35 males, 13 females, range: 34-69 years, mean: 49.4 years), candidate to surgery, previously detected at color-Doppler ultrasound (CDUS), were prospectively examined with elastosonography with dedicated semiquantitative software (Q-Elastography, Toshiba XG) and CEUS (Technos Mylab 70 Gold X, and Toshiba XG) before surgery. CEUS and elastosonography were evaluated by two investigators in consensus. Comparison between the CEUS pattern and elastonographic strain ratio observed and expected frequencies for the diagnoses was evaluated with χ(2) test or with Fisher exact test. RESULTS: Fifty-three nodules (19 papillary carcinoma, 32 hyperplasia, and 2 follicular adenoma) in 48 patients were available for analysis. Regarding echogenicity score, sensitivity, specificity, PPV and NPV of conventional US were 81%, 50%, 56%, 77%; according to Q-elastography, sensitivity, specificity, PPV and NPV were 95%, 88%, 97% and 91% respectively; whereas concerning CEUS, sensitivity specificity PPV and NPV were 79%, 91%, 83% and 89% respectively. Both CEUS and Q-elastography were more specific than US (p<0.01), with not statistical significant difference with regard to sensitivity. CONCLUSIONS: The results of the present study suggest that Q-elastography is a valuable tool in the characterization of thyroid nodules and it seems to be more sensitive than CEUS.

Increasing diagnostic accuracy for thyroid nodules by an integrated multivariate approach: a methodological study.

OBJECTIVES: Current guidelines for diagnostic management of thyroid nodules are based on a linear approach, using categorial classifications to cluster diagnostic findings and they still lead to unnecessary surgery. A diagnostic scoring system, based on clinical, cytological and ultrasound findings is described. MATERIALS AND METHODS: Two groups of patients (168 and 55 pts) were used to compute a multivariate model and the discriminating threshold by ROC curves. The performance of the derived scoring system was assessed by a simulation on a third group of 60 patients, who had undergone surgery according to current guidelines. RESULTS: The scoring system displayed a sensitivity of 100%, specificity 53.3%, positive and negative predictive values of 68.1% and 100%. According to the scoring system, 16 out of 60 operations would have been saved. CONCLUSIONS: A scoring system can take into account in a more accurate way the full informative content of the fine-grained description of diagnostic and clinical features.

Microcarcinoma and incidental carcinoma of the thyroid in a clinical series: clinical behaviour and surgical management.

OBJECTIVES: Papillary thyroid microcarcinomas (PTM) have not yet an agreed clinical management. The Authors compared PTMs with papillary thyroid carcinoma of larger size (LPTC) and incidental and not-incidental carcinomas. MATERIALS AND METHODS: Review of clinical data of 67 patients (54 women, 13 men) prospectively stored in a standardised way in an electronic patient record system. RESULTS: There were 36 cases of microcarcinoma (53.7%). Differences were not significant between PTM and LPTC groups as to patients personal data, TNM and MACIS staging, nodal involvement (8.3% vs 19.3%) and multifocality (25% vs 38.7%) while capsular invasion was significantly higher in LPTC (25% vs 54.8%). Nineteen incidental tumors were detected at pathological examination and they were all microcarcinomas. They were smaller than the remaining 17 not-incidental microcarcinomas but showed a similar clinical behaviour. There were not cancer related deaths nor recurrences in the follow up period in any group. CONCLUSIONS: Despite the excellent prognosis of PTM, a subset of these tumours shows aggressive biological and clinical features, like nodal or capsular invasion and multifocality. Actually, with the exclusion of size, they do not show any relevant difference from differentiated thyroid carcinoma of larger size. Since predictive cytogenetic markers are still missing, their treatment should then be the same as for conventional thyroid cancers.

[Clinical significance of thyroid nodule calcification]. / Significato clinico delle calcificazioni nei noduli tiroidei.

To confirm the predictive value of calcifications in thyroid nodules as a risk factor for malignancy and to detect specific aspects for tumours, in a set of 175 patients--30 papillary carcinoma (PC) and 145 multinodular goiters (MNG) with dominant nodule--calcifications were detected by ultrasound scan. Calcifications were significantly more frequent in PC than in MNG (40% vs 20.7% p < 0.05) but their considered characteristics (size, number, position, location in the gland, sonographic features of the nodule) did not show any particular difference between PC and MNG. The frequency of calcifications in our series was higher in older patients (mean age 58.7 +/- 13.3 vs 51.1 +/- 12.7 in patients without calcifications, p < 0.001) and this could imply that their onset is time-dependent. Calcifications can be a useful indicator of enhanced risk, to be considered in the overall process of surgical decision making.

Fine needle aspiration biopsy in the preoperative management of patients with thyroid nodules.

The aim of this study was to evaluate the role of Fine Needle Aspiration Biopsy (FNAB) in the preoperative diagnostic management of patients with solitary or dominant thyroid nodules. This study was performed on 1054 patients followed for various thyroid disorders during a three year period (1992-1995). One hundred thirty eight patients were surgically treated, 61 after cytological indication and 77 after clinical indication, of these, 67 were cytologically negative and 10 were not conclusive. The cytological diagnosis was compared to the final histological result. Among the 138 cases, 27 were malignant, 39 were adenomas and 72 were benign lesions. Of the 67 cytologically negative cases, 63 (94%) were histologically benign, three were papillary carcinomas and one was an oxyphilic adenoma. Of the 45 cytologically suspicious aspirates, four were malignant neoplasias, 38 were follicular adenomas, two were hyperplastic goiters and one was an Hashimoto thyroiditis. All the 16 cytologically positive cases, were confirmed histologically. The limits of FNAB, which emerge from our and other studies, were based mainly in the difficulty of discriminating follicular adenomas from well differentiated follicular carcinomas. Nevertheless, FNAB with ultrasonographic support, has been unanimously accepted as a guide test in the selection of patients with thyroidal pathology who need surgery.

[Echo-guided percutaneous celiac plexus block with alcohol with an anterior approach]. / Alcolizzazione percutanea ecoguidata del plesso celiaco con approccio per via anteriore.

The authors report the use of ultrasound as a guide to the execution of celiac plexus alcoholization with the anterior approach. Five patients with severe pain resistant to pharmacologic treatment with NSAID, cortisone and morphine have been treated. Once found out the celiac trunk and the best direction, using ultrasound, the needle is advanced slowly beyond the anterior lateral wall of the aorta, in order to recognize the tip with the same ultrasound response of the retroperitoneal tissue. After calculating the distance between the celiac trunk and the needle tip, this is withdrawn in order to be set in the alcoholization point of injection. No complication directly related to the technique has been observed in the five patients. Pain relief was optimal in four out of five patients and was kept until the exitus.