Pharmacopoeial quality of drugs supplied by Nigerian pharmacies.

BACKGROUND: The quality of medicines available in some less-developed countries is inadequate in terms of content of active ingredient. Reasons for the poor quality of drugs include widespread counterfeiting of medicines in less-developed countries, excessive decomposition of active ingredient as a result of high temperature and humidity, and poor quality assurance during the manufacture of medicinal products. Our aim was to investigate the quality of different drugs obtained from retail pharmacies in two urban areas of Nigeria, and, in instances of poor quality, to ascertain the reason why. METHODS: We randomly collected 581 samples of 27 different drugs from 35 pharmacies in Lagos and Abuja in Nigeria. We analysed the medicines for drug content by validated chromatographic methods, and compared our results with pharmacopoeial requirements. FINDINGS: 279 (48%) samples did not comply with set pharmacopoeial limits, and this proportion was uniform for the various types of drugs tested. Although some preparations contained no active ingredient, most had amounts just outside the pharmacopoeial limits. We identified samples with both too much and too little active drug content. INTERPRETATION: The most probable cause of the poor quality of drugs is absence of adequate quality assurance during manufacture. Substandard drugs sold in the pharmacies of less-developed countries could contribute to global microbial resistance and therapeutic failure of infectious diseases.

Assessment of the incidence of substandard drugs in developing countries.

In a number of developing countries there is reportedly a high incidence of the availability of substandard drugs. The majority of these reports do not contain quantitative data to support these claims, nor do they describe the methodology employed for the quality assessment. Many assume counterfeiting as the reason for the poor quality and in some cases this is not justified. We collected 96 samples of chloroquine and selected antibacterials from Nigeria and Thailand in a controlled and methodical manner and analysed them using appropriately validated methods based on high-performance liquid chromatography capable of detecting drug-related impurities and quantifying active drug(s). The results indicate that 36.5% of the samples were substandard with respect to pharmacopoeial limits. Decomposition was the cause of poor quality in a number of the samples but overall, poor manufacturing appeared to be prevalent. The analyses generated little evidence to indicate fraudulent manufacturing. Treatment failure and drug-resistance are possible consequences of the use of substandard drugs.