Extensive non-redundancy in a recently duplicated developmental gene family.

BACKGROUND: It has been proposed that recently duplicated genes are more likely to be redundant with one another compared to ancient paralogues. The evolutionary logic underpinning this idea is simple, as the assumption is that recently derived paralogous genes are more similar in sequence compared to members of ancient gene families. We set out to test this idea by using molecular phylogenetics and exploiting the genetic tractability of the model nematode, Caenorhabditis elegans, in studying the nematode-specific family of Hedgehog-related genes, the Warthogs. Hedgehog is one of a handful of signal transduction pathways that underpins the development of bilaterian animals. While having lost a bona fide Hedgehog gene, most nematodes have evolved an expanded repertoire of Hedgehog-related genes, ten of which reside within the Warthog family. RESULTS: We have characterised their evolutionary origin and their roles in C. elegans and found that these genes have adopted new functions in aspects of post-embryonic development, including left-right asymmetry and cell fate determination, akin to the functions of their vertebrate counterparts. Analysis of various double and triple mutants of the Warthog family reveals that more recently derived paralogues are not redundant with one another, while a pair of divergent Warthogs do display redundancy with respect to their function in cuticle biosynthesis. CONCLUSIONS: We have shown that newer members of taxon-restricted gene families are not always functionally redundant despite their recent inception, whereas much older paralogues can be, which is considered paradoxical according to the current framework in gene evolution.

Insect transformation with piggyBac: getting the number of injections just right.

The insertion of exogenous genetic cargo into insects using transposable elements is a powerful research tool with potential applications in meeting food security and public health challenges facing humanity. piggyBac is the transposable element most commonly utilized for insect germline transformation. The described efficiency of this process is variable in the published literature, and a comprehensive review of transformation efficiency in insects is lacking. This study compared and contrasted all available published data with a comprehensive data set provided by a biotechnology group specializing in insect transformation. Based on analysis of these data, with particular focus on the more complete observational data from the biotechnology group, we designed a decision tool to aid researchers' decision-making when using piggyBac to transform insects by microinjection. A combination of statistical techniques was used to define appropriate summary statistics of piggyBac transformation efficiency by species and insect order. Publication bias was assessed by comparing the data sets. The bias was assessed using strategies co-opted from the medical literature. The work culminated in building the Goldilocks decision tool, a Markov-Chain Monte-Carlo simulation operated via a graphical interface and providing guidance on best practice for those seeking to transform insects using piggyBac.

[Peter Holland, homeobox genes, and the developmental basis of animal diversity].

In 1867 Alexander Kowalevsky published an account of the development of the cephalochordate Amphioxus lanceolatus (now known as Branchiostoma lanceolatum) (Kowalevsky, 1867). Together with his study of the development of urochordates (Kowalevsky, 1866; 1871), this introduced a new way of thinking about the relationship between the evolution and development of animals, and established the basis for longstanding theories of the evolutionary origin of vertebrates. Some one hundred and fifty years later, cephalochordates and urochordates are again in the spotlight, as molecular biology and genome sequencing promise further revelations about the origin of vertebrates. The work of the 2006 Kowalevsky Medal winner, Peter Holland (Fig. 1), has played a central role in their reinstatement (see Mikhailov and Gilbert (2002) for more details of the history of the Kowalevsky Medal). Here, I profile Peter Holland's contribution to the rebirth of Evolutionary Developmental Biology in general and the study of homeobox genes and vertebrate origins in particular.

Identification of conserved C2H2 zinc-finger gene families in the Bilateria.

BACKGROUND: Identification of orthologous relationships between genes from widely divergent taxa allows partial reconstruction of the gene complement of ancestral genomes. C2H2 zinc-finger genes are one of the largest and most complex gene superfamilies in metazoan genomes, with hundreds of members in the human genome. Here we analyze C2H2 zinc-finger genes from three taxa - Drosophila, Caenorhabditis elegans and human - from which near-complete genome sequence data are available. RESULTS: Our analyses conclusively identify 39 families of genes, of which 38 can be defined as orthology groups in that they are descended from single ancestral genes in the common ancestor of Drosophila, C. elegans and humans. CONCLUSIONS: On the basis of current metazoan phylogeny, these 39 groups represent the minimum complement of C2H2 zinc-finger genes present in the genome of the bilaterian common ancestor.

Vertebrate innovations.

Vertebrate innovations include neural crest cells and their derivatives, neurogenic placodes, an elaborate segmented brain, endoskeleton, and an increase in the number of genes in the genome. Comparative molecular and developmental data give new insights into the evolutionary origins of these characteristics and the complexity of the vertebrate body.

An amphioxus Krox gene: insights into vertebrate hindbrain evolution.

The transcription factor Krox-20 has roles in the maintenance of segmentation and specification of segment identity in the vertebrate hindbrain. Overt hindbrain segmentation is a vertebrate novelty, and is not seen in invertebrate chordates such as amphioxus and tunicates. To test if the roles of Krox-20 are also derived, we cloned a Krox-20 related gene, AmphiKrox, from amphioxus. AmphiKrox is related to a small family of vertebrate Krox genes and is expressed in the most anterior region of the amphioxus brain and in the club shaped gland, a secretory organ that develops in the anterior pharynx. Neither expression domain overlaps with the expression of AmphiHox-1, -2, -3 or -4, suggesting that the roles of Krox-20 in hindbrain segmentation and in Hox gene regulation were acquired concomitant with the duplication of Krox genes in vertebrate evolution.

Gene function, gene networks and the fate of duplicated genes.

For both copies of a duplicated gene to become fixed in a population and subsequently maintained, selection must favour individuals with both genes over individuals with one. Here I review and assess some of the proposed ways that gene structure and function might affect the likelihood of both copies acquiring distinct functions and therefore positive selection. In particular I focus on the interacting pathways of genes that make up gene networks, and how these may affect genes duplicated both singly and en masse. Using the Wnt and hedgehog pathways as examples and data from developmental and genome analyses, I show that, while some of these theories may genuinely reflect what has occurred in animal evolution, there are still insufficient data to rigorously assess their relative importance. This, however, is likely to change in the near future.

The amphioxus rab GDP-dissociation inhibitor (GDI) gene is neural-specific: implications for the evolution of chordate rab GDI genes.

The rab GDP-dissociation inhibitor (rab GDI) proteins are involved in the regulation of vesicle-mediated cellular transport. We isolated the amphioxus rab GDI gene, analyzed its expression during amphioxus development, and performed a phylogenetic analysis of the rab GDI family. In contrast to the two major rab GDI forms in mammals, the alpha and beta forms, there is only one rab GDI isoform in amphioxus. Our analysis indicates that the occurrence of the alpha and beta forms of rab GDI preceded the divergence of lineages leading to birds and mammals, and that the amphioxus rab GDI may have evolved directly from the common ancestor of both forms. While the mammalian rab GDI beta-genes are ubiquitously expressed, the rab GDI alpha genes are predominantly expressed in neural tissues. The expression analysis of the amphioxus rab GDI gene shows predominantly neural expression similar to that of the mammalian rab GDI alpha form, suggesting that the ancestral expression pattern of chordate rab GDI was neural. In addition, the chicken rab GDI beta-like gene also shows neural-specific expression, which indicates that the neural expression was retained in both early postduplication alpha and beta isoforms and that a novel function associated with ubiquitous expression may have evolved uniquely in mammals. These results reveal a likely scenario of functional divergence of the rab GDI genes after duplication of the ancestral gene. A similar pattern of evolution, in which one of the duplicated genes retained a role similar to that of the ancestral one while other genes were recruited into novel roles, was also observed in the analysis of chordate Otx and hedgehog genes. In the rab GDI, hedgehog, and Otx gene families, the gene retaining the ancestral role shows a lower rate of sequence evolution than its counterpart, which was recruited for a novel function.

An amphioxus Msx gene expressed predominantly in the dorsal neural tube.

Genomic and cDNA clones of an Msx class homeobox gene were isolated from amphioxus (Branchiostoma floridae). The gene, AmphiMsx, is expressed in the neural plate from late gastrulation; in later embryos it is expressed in dorsal cells of the neural tube, excluding anterior and posterior regions, in an irregular reiterated pattern. There is transient expression in dorsal cells within somites, reminiscent of migrating neural crest cells of vertebrates. In larvae, mRNA is detected in two patches of anterior ectoderm proposed to be placodes. Evolutionary analyses show there is little phylogenetic information in Msx protein sequences; however, it is likely that duplication of Msx genes occurred in the vertebrate lineage.

The evolution of the hedgehog gene family in chordates: insights from amphioxus hedgehog.

The hedgehog family of intercellular signalling molecules have essential functions in patterning both Drosophila and vertebrate embryos. Drosophila has a single hedgehog gene, while vertebrates have evolved at least three types of hedgehog genes (the Sonic, Desert and Indian types) by duplication and divergence of a single ancestral gene. Vertebrate Sonic-type genes typically show conserved expression in the notochord and floor plate, while Desert- and Indian-type genes have different patterns of expression in vertebrates from different classes. To determine the ancestral role of hedgehog in vertebrates, I have characterised the hedgehog gene family in amphioxus. Amphioxus is the closest living relative of the vertebrates and develops a similar body plan, including a dorsal neural tube and notochord. A single amphioxus hedgehog gene, AmphiHh, was identified and is probably the only hedgehog family member in amphioxus, showing the duplication of hedgehog genes to be specific to the vertebrate lineage. AmphiHh expression was detected in the notochord and ventral neural tube, tissues that express Sonic-type genes in vertebrates. This shows that amphioxus probably patterns its ventral neural tube using a molecular pathway conserved with vertebrates. AmphiHh was also expressed on the left side of the pharyngeal endoderm, reminiscent of the left-sided expression of Sonic hedgehog in chick embryos which forms part of a pathway controlling left/right asymmetric development. These data show that notochord, floor plate and possibly left/right asymmetric expression are ancestral sites of hedgehog expression in vertebrates and amphioxus. In vertebrates, all these features have been retained by Sonic-type genes. This may have freed Desert-type and Indian-type hedgehog genes from selective constraint, allowing them to diverge and take on new roles in different vertebrate taxa.

Characterization of AmphiF-spondin reveals the modular evolution of chordate F-spondin genes.

The F-spondin genes are a family of extracellular matrix molecules united by two conserved domains, FS1 and FS2, at the amino terminus plus a variable number of thrombospondin repeats at the carboxy terminus. Currently, characterized members include a single gene in Drosophila and multiple genes in vertebrates. The vertebrate genes are expressed in the midline of the developing embryo, primarily in the floor plate of the neural tube. To investigate the evolution of chordate F-spondin genes, I have used the basal position in chordate phylogeny of the acraniate amphioxus. A single F-spondin-related gene, named AmphiF-spondin, was isolated from amphioxus. Based on molecular phylogenetics, AmphiF-spondin is closely related to a particular subgroup of vertebrate F-spondin genes that encode six thrombospondin repeats. However, unlike these genes, expression of AmphiF-spondin is not confined to the midline but is found through most of the central nervous system. Additionally, AmphiF-spondin has lost three thrombospondin repeats and gained two fibronectin type III repeats, one of which has strong identity to a fibronectin type III repeat from Deleted in Colorectal Cancer (DCC). Taken together, these results suggest a complex evolutionary history for chordate F-spondin genes that includes (1) domain loss, (2) domain gain by tandem duplication and divergence of existing domains, and (3) gain of heterologous domains by exon shuffling.

Molecular evolution of the ZFY and ZNF6 gene families.

Members of the ZFY and ZNF6 gene families have been cloned from species representing different taxa and different modes of sex determination. Comparisons of these genes show the ZFY-like and ZNF6 sequences to be strongly conserved across marsupials, birds, and lepidosaurians. Sequence analyzed by neighbor-joining indicated that both gene families are monophyletic with a high bootstrap value. Pairing of sequences from males and females of nonmammalian species showed there to be no significant difference between male and female sequences from a single species, consistent with autosomal locations. The molecular distances between murine Zfy-1, Zfy-2, and other ZFY-like sequences suggested that Zfy genes have undergone a period of rapid evolutionary change not seen in human ZFY.

A transcriptional modification motif encoded by homeobox and fork head genes.

Homeodomain and fork head domain proteins are thought to act as transcription factors by binding to specific DNA target sequences and interacting with other proteins. Here I describe a motif which is present in members of both groups of transcription factor and which has been shown to modulate their ability to activate transcription. The presence of this motif in both homeodomain and fork head proteins indicates they may control transcription by a similar molecular mechanism, perhaps by interacting with the same cofactors.

Characterisation of amphioxus HNF-3 genes: conserved expression in the notochord and floor plate.

The fork head/HNF-3 genes form a subclass of a family of transcription factors united by the possession of a conserved DNA binding domain known as the fork head domain. Most vertebrate HNF-3 class genes show several conserved sites of expression during development, including the dorsal lip/Hensen's node, notochord and floor plate, all structures known to organise adjacent tissues. In this paper I report the characterisation of HNF-3 class genes from the cephalochordate amphioxus. I show that amphioxus has two HNF-3 class genes, named AmHNF-3-1 and AmHNF-3-2; molecular phylogenetic analysis reveals that these derive from an independent duplication in the cephalochordate lineage. The expression of both genes in early development appears identical and shows striking similarities to that of vertebrates. In neurulae, transcripts of both genes were detected in the presumed organiser, endoderm, and notochord, supporting morphological and embryological evidence that these are homologous between vertebrates and amphioxus. This expression pattern overlaps considerably with that of amphioxus brachyury, suggesting that the functional relationship between these genes in vertebrates is conserved with amphioxus. Expression of both genes was maintained in the endoderm and notochord up to the 6 somite stage. After the 6 somite stage no expression of AmHNF-3-2 was detected and expression of AmHNF-3-1 began to decrease in the notochord, such that by the 10 somite stage transcripts were only detected in the terminal regions. At this stage, however, a column of AmHNF-3-1-expressing cells was detected at the ventral midline of the neural tube, a position occupied by the floor plate in vertebrates. This is the first evidence that amphioxus has a floor plate which is specified by a mechanism conserved with vertebrates. Taken together these data support two conclusions: Firstly, that the role of the dorsal lip/Hensen's node, notochord, and floor plate as organisers of the vertebrate body plan evolved prior to the separation of the vertebrate and cephalochordate lineages, at least 520 million years ago. Secondly, that the role of HNF-3 genes in these structures predates the origin of the multiple HNF-3 genes found in vertebrates.

The murine homeobox gene Msx-3 shows highly restricted expression in the developing neural tube.

The mouse homeobox-genes Msx-1 and Msx-2 are expressed in several areas of the developing embryo, including the neural tube, neural crest, facial processes and limb buds. Here we report the characterisation of a third mouse Msx gene, which we designate Msx-3. The embryonic expression of Msx-3 was found to differ from that of Msx-1 and -2 in that it was confined to the dorsal neural tube. In embryos with 5-8 somites a segmental pattern of expression was observed in the hindbrain, with rhombomeres 3 and 5 lacking Msx-3 while other rhombomeres expressed Msx-3. This pattern was transient, however, such that in embryos with 18 or more somites expression was continuous throughout the dorsal hindbrain and anterior dorsal spinal cord. Differentiation of dorsal cell types in the neural tube can be induced by addition of members of the Tgf-beta family. Additionally, Msx-1 and -2 have been shown to be activated by addition of the Tgf-beta family member Bmp-4. To determine if Bmp-4 could activate Msx-3, we incubated embryonic hindbrain explants with exogenous Bmp-4. The dorsal expression of Msx-3 was seen to expand into more ventral regions of the neurectoderm in Bmp-4-treated cultures, implying that Bmp-4 may be able to mimic an in vivo signal that induces Msx-3.

Spatial localisation of transcripts of the Hox-C6 gene.

The Hox-C6 gene, in common with its Xenopus and human homologues, is organised as 3 exons with 2 distinct promoters (PRI and PRII) producing 2 different transcripts. The PRII promoter produces a 'typical' Hox transcript by splicing 2 exons separated by a 700 bp intron. The PRI promoter initiates transcription from a 3rd exon, 9 kbp 5' of PRII. This exon is spliced into the 1st exon of the PRII transcript at a point 3' of the translation start codon. This means that the predicted protein product of the PRI protein contains the Hox-C6 homeodomain but is truncated by 82 amino acids compared with the PRII product. In situ hybridisation using probes specific for PRI or PRII showed them to have essentially the same distribution in the developing nervous system and prevertebrae of 12.5 d embryos. However, the distribution of transcripts in the CNS was distinctly different from that reported previously for a probe containing the Hox-C6 homeobox.

Sequence and embryonic expression of the murine Hox-3.5 gene.

The murine Hox-3.5 gene has been mapped and linked genomically to a position 18 kb 3' of its most 5' locus neighbour, Hox-3.4, on chromosome 15. The sequence of the Hox-3.5 cDNA, together with the position of the gene within the locus, show it to be a paralogue of Hox-2.6, Hox-1.4 and Hox-4.2. The patterns of embryonic expression for the Hox-3.5 gene are examined in terms of three rules, proposed to relate a Hox gene's expression pattern to its position within the locus. The anterior boundaries of Hox-3.5 expression in the hindbrain and prevertebral column lie anterior to those of Hox-3.4 and all other, more 5'-located Hox-3 genes. Within the hindbrain, the Hox-3.5 boundary is seen to lie posterior to that of its paralogue, Hox-2.6, by a distance equal to about the length of one rhombomere. Patterns of Hox-3.5 expression within the oesophagus and spinal cord, but not the testis, are similar to those of other Hox-3 genes, Hox-3.3 and Hox-3.4.

Cell-surface changes induced by ectopic expression of the murine homeobox gene Hox-3.3.

Murine homeobox-containing genes (Hox genes) are postulated as playing key roles in the establishment of the anterior-posterior embryonic body axis, possibly providing cells with positional cues. Little is known, however, concerning how cells might respond to homeobox gene expression to interpret these cues. Since changes in the cell-surface are central to many processes in early development we reasoned that cells expressing different complements of Hox genes might have different surface properties. In order to investigate this we have used the sensitive, non-disruptive technique of multiple two-phase aqueous partition, which is able to detect small differences on the surface of intact cells. Using this technique we have found that ectopic expression of the murine Hox-3.3 gene in cultured cells induces reproducible changes in the cell surface. Changes only occurred above a threshold level of gene expression, but above this level a correlation between surface change and gene expression was seen. The implications for the establishment of a 'Hox' code of homeobox genes acting to specifically change cell-surface properties are discussed.