Comparison of Conditional and Marginal Models in Assessing a Child Nutrition Intervention in Armenia.

INTRODUCTION: Child malnutrition is a major issue in conflict zones. Evidence-based interventions and their thorough evaluation could help to eliminate malnutrition. We aimed to assess the causal effect of a community-based multidisciplinary nutrition program for children in a chronic conflict zone near the northeastern border of Armenia on two main outcomes: stunting and anemia. We further compared the interpretations and public health relevance of the obtained effect estimates. METHODS: In 2016, the study measured hemoglobin and anthropometric measures and collected data from the children's caregivers. We used propensity score matching analyses, inverse probability weighting, and overlap weighting methods to examine the average treatment effects among treated population (ATT), and among population with overlapping weights (ATO). RESULTS: The ATT for stunting among children who participated in the intervention program estimated by propensity score matching analyses (PSM-ATT) was (1.95; 95%CI 1.15-3.28). Nevertheless, children who took part in the program had a lower risk of anemia (0.28; 95%CI 0.19-0.42). The ATT, estimated by inverse probability weighting (IPTW-ATT), was slightly lower for stunting (1.82; 95%CI 1.16-2.86) while similar for anemia (0.33; 95%CI 0.23-0.46) compared to PSM-ATT. Compared to the IPTW-ATT and PSM-ATT the ATO was lower for stunting (1.75; 95%CI 1.14-2.68) and similar for anemia (0.31; 95%CI 0.22-0.43). DISCUSSION: Marginal models could be used in similar quasi-experimental settings to identify the causal effect of interventions in specific populations of interest. Nonetheless, these methods do not eliminate threats to internal validity. Thorough study design and accurate data collection are necessary to improve the efficiency of marginal models.

A post-Soviet Republic in Transition: A Novel Amplification Programme to Address the Crisis of Continuing Medical Education and Challenges Facing Regional Physicians in the Republic of Armenia.

BACKGROUND: After the fall of the Soviet Union in 1991, the existing process of Continuing Medical Education (CME) was decimated. The Fund for Armenian Relief (FAR) was able to leverage competitive educational fellowship programmes in existence, and harness new knowledge gained by returning fellows thus amplifying the impact on education and patient care in the regions of the republic of Armenia. AIMS: This manuscript describes a replicable novel amplification programme using a "train the trainer" model for CME in the republic of Armenia. We sought to identify challenges specific to physicians from the regions, and to examine the strengths of the CME programme that can serve as a model for programme development and improvement in countries facing similar challenges. METHODS: The manuscript details a descriptive and mixed method study that includes in-depth interviews and focus group discussions from 2015-2016. Conceptual content analysis was used to identify major themes from the transcripts. RESULTS: Challenges facing regional physicians in post-Soviet counties in transition, exemplified by Armenia, are profound. Exploration of themes related to perceived barriers to care in the regions included, physicians' personal financial constraints, lack of up-to-date knowledge and equipment, lack of confidence, fear of criticism and of making incorrect diagnoses. CONCLUSIONS: The FAR/CME programme presents an innovative way to amplify the knowledge of Armenian physicians upon their return from educational programme participation abroad in order to address challenges facing regional physicians.

The prevalence of pelvic floor disorders and degree of bother among women attending primary care clinics in Armenia.

OBJECTIVE: To explore the prevalence of various Pelvic Floor Disorders (PFD) and the degree of symptom bother in a convenience sample of Armenian women in the Republic of Armenia. METHODS: Fifty women ages 20-85 years from each Armenian region (Marz) were included in the study. The survey included the validated Armenian version of the Global Pelvic Floor Bother Questionnaire (PFBQ) and general questions on demographics and comorbidities related to these disorders. RESULTS: A total of 540 women (90%) attending primary care clinics completed the validated PFBQ questionnaire. Initial analysis showed that the PFBQ score was significantly higher in older women, and those with higher vaginal parity and BMI. Women with prior hysterectomy (37.1+22.4) and prior pelvic prolapse or anti-incontinence surgeries (40.6+21.6) had significantly higher PFBQ scores than women without prior surgeries (18.8+20,0 and 19.4+19.7) and were associated with an increased odds of developing pelvic prolapse symptoms and obstructed defecation. CONCLUSIONS: PFD symptoms were observed to be common and significantly correlated with demographic characteristics and self-reported comorbidities in Armenian women. We need to start promoting proper training of physicians in Female Pelvic Medicine and Reconstructive Surgery.

Short-term nutrition and growth indicators in 6-month- to 6-year-old children are improved following implementation of a multidisciplinary community-based programme in a chronic conflict setting.

OBJECTIVE: We investigated short- and long-term indicators of malnutrition and diet before and after the community-based 'Breaking the Cycle of Poverty' multidisciplinary intervention. DESIGN: A historically and geographically controlled study using data collected in 2013 and 2016. We compared the prevalence of short-term indicators (anaemia, breast-feeding duration and minimum dietary diversity) and long-term indicators (stunting and wasting) in exposed communities at two time points. We then compared these factors in geographic areas exposed or not exposed to intervention. We conducted logistic regression analyses on the 2016 sample to measure associations between living in intervention communities and child growth indicators. SETTING: Berd region, a chronic conflict zone near the north-eastern border of Armenia and Azerbaijan. PARTICIPANTS: Children aged 6 months to 6 years. RESULTS: Analyses included data from 2013 comprising 382 children, and data from 2016 comprising 348 children living in communities where the programme was implemented, and 635 children from unexposed communities. Anaemia prevalence in exposed communities was significantly lower in 2016 v. 2013 (10·9 v. 19·1 %, P < 0·01). Minimum dietary diversity (79·0 v. 68·1 %, P < 0·001) and breast-feeding duration (13·0 v. 11·5 months, P < 0·002) were significantly improved in exposed communities. Prevalences of stunting (11·5 v. 10·2 %, P = 0·57) and wasting (4·8 v. 2·0 %, P = 0·07) were not significantly different. Odds of anaemia were significantly lower (OR = 0·24, 95 % CI 0·16, 0·36) in intervention communities. CONCLUSIONS: Exposure to a community-based multidisciplinary intervention reduced the rate of anaemia and improved dietary indicators.

Prevalence and determinants of stunting in a conflict-ridden border region in Armenia - a cross-sectional study.

BACKGROUND: Despite global efforts, stunting remains a public health problem in several developing countries. The prevalence of stunting among 0- to 5-year-old children in Armenia has increased from 17% in 2000 to 19% in 2010. A baseline study was conducted among preschool children in Berd, a region near the northeastern border of Armenia that has experienced intermittent military tension for over 20 years. METHODS: We conducted a cross-sectional study including 594 children aged 6-month- 6 years old and their caregivers in our analysis, to assess the prevalence and determinants of stunting. We calculated the anthropometric measurements and hemoglobin levels of children; analyzed children's stool and conducted a survey with children's caregivers. We employed the hierarchical logistic regression model to explore the predictors of stunting among 25-72 months old children and multivariable logistic regression models to investigate the predictors of stunting among 6-24 months old children. Individual and residence level variables were included in the models including anemia, minimum dietary diversity, mothers' height, the overall duration of breastfeeding, birthweight, child's history of diarrhea and mean socio-economic score. RESULTS: The prevalence of stunting was significantly higher among the 6-24 months old children (13.3%) compared to the children aged 25-72 months old (7.8%). We did not find any differences in the prevalence of stunting by place of residence in either age group. The 6-24 months old children who consumed at least four food groups during the previous day (minimum dietary diversity) had 72% lower odds of being stunted (p < 0.05). Each kilogram increase in birthweight was associated with 76% lower odds of being stunted (OR = 0.24, p < 0.01). Mother's height significantly decreased the odds of stunting among the children 25-72- months old (OR = 0.86, p < 0.001). BMI was also a significant predictor of stunting among both age-groups. CONCLUSIONS: The study results highlight the significance of mother's height, birthweight, and adequate complementary feeding to reduce stunting. Further studies are needed to determine the possible association of anemia and stunting with the ongoing conflict in the region, as well as socioeconomic conditions and food insecurity in the region.

Adapting continuing medical education for post-conflict areas: assessment in Nagorno Karabagh - a qualitative study.

BACKGROUND: One of the major challenges in the current century is the increasing number of post-conflict states where infrastructures are debilitated. The dysfunctional health care systems in post-conflict settings are putting the lives of the populations in these zones at increased risk. One of the approaches to improve such situations is to strengthen human resources by organizing training programmes to meet the special needs in post-conflict zones. Evaluations of these training programmes are essential to assure effectiveness and adaptation to the health service needs in these conditions. METHODS: A specialized qualitative evaluation was conducted to assess and improve a post-conflict continuing medical education (CME) programme that was conducted in Nagorno Karabagh. Qualitative research guides were designed for this post-conflict zone that included focus group discussions with physician programme participants and semi-structured in-depth interviews with directors of hospitals and training supervisors. RESULTS: Saturation was achieved among the three participating groups in the themes of impact of participation in the CME and obstacles to application of obtained skills. All respondents indicated that the continuing medical education programme created important physician networks absent in this post-conflict zone, updated professional skills, and improved professional confidence among participants. However, all respondents indicated that some skills gained were inapplicable in Nagorno Karabagh hospitals and clinics due to lack of appropriate medical equipment, qualified supporting human resources and facilities. CONCLUSION: The qualitative research methods evaluation highlighted the fact that the health care human resources training should be closely linked to appropriate technologies, supplies, facilities and human resources available in post-conflict zones and identified the central importance of creating health professional networks and professional confidence among physicians in these zones. The qualitative research approach most effectively identifies these limitations and strengths and can directly inform the optimal adjustments for effective CME planning in these difficult areas of greatest need.