Influence of Measurement Location on Reflectance Pulse Oximetry in Sleep Apnea Patients: Wrist vs. Upper Arm.

Peripheral oxygen saturation (SpO2) plays a key role in diagnosing sleep apnea. It is mainly measured via transmission pulse oximetry at the fingertip, an approach less suited for long-term monitoring over several nights.In this study we tested a more patient-friendly solution via a reflectance pulse oximetry device. Having previously observed issues with pulse oximetry at the wrist, we investigated in this study the influence of the location of our device (upper arm vs. wrist) to measure SpO2. Accuracy was compared against state-of-the-art fingertip SpO2 measurements during a full overnight polysomnography in nine patients with suspected sleep apnea.The upper arm location clearly showed a lower root mean square error ARMS = 1.8% than the wrist ARMS = 2.5% and a lower rate of automatic data rejection (19% vs 25%). Irrespective of the measurement location the accuracies obtained comply with the ISO standard and the FDA guidance for pulse oximeters. In contrast to the wrist, the upper arm location seemed to be more resilient to deteriorating influences such as venous blood.Reflectance pulse oximetry at the wrist remains challenging but the upper arm could provide remedy for more robust SpO2 estimates to reliably screen for sleep apnea and other diseases.Clinical Relevance- The performance of reflectance pulse oximetry measured at the upper arm during sleep is superior to measurements at the wrist which are perturbed by undesired large fluctuations suspected to be caused by venous blood. If confirmed, this could also apply to the optical measurement of other vital signs such as blood pressure.

Pulse Oximetry at the Wrist During Sleep: Performance, Challenges and Perspectives.

The state-of-the-art non-invasive measurement of peripheral oxygen saturation (SpO2) during sleep is mainly based on pulse oximetry at the fingertip. Although this approach is noninvasive, it can still be obtrusive and cumbersome to apply, in particular for ambulatory monitoring over several nights.We developed a wrist-worn reflectance pulse oximetry device which can be embedded in a watch, making it less obtrusive and easy to apply. This device was tested in an ongoing clinical study on 57 subjects (33 patients and 24 healthy volunteers) undergoing a full overnight polysomnography recording. The accuracy was evaluated against state-of-the-art fingertip SpO2 measurements.In the 54 subjects available for analysis we obtained an SpO2 accuracy (ARMS) of 3.4 % when automatically rejecting 17.7 % of signals due to low quality. When further excluding measurements suffering from insufficient contact of the watch with the skin an ARMS of 2.7 % was obtained while rejecting a total of 23.2 % measurements. These accuracies comply with the ISO standard and the FDA guidance for pulse oximeters.The present results are promising and pave the way for unobtrusive and continuous monitoring of SpO2 to screen for sleep disordered breathing. Nonetheless, contact pressure and venous blood have shown to adversely affect the SpO2 estimation and remain a challenge for wrist-based reflectance pulse oximetry.