Super-Resolution Surface-Enhanced Raman Scattering: Perspectives on the Past, Present, and Future.

Super-resolution surface-enhanced Raman scattering (SERS) allows researchers to overcome the resolution limit of far field optical microscopy and peer into electromagnetic hot spots with nanoscale resolution. By localizing the signal from single (or few) molecules on the surface of plasmonic nanoparticle aggregates, relationships between the spatial origin of the SERS signal, local electromagnetic field enhancements, and SERS intensity can be determined. This Perspective describes the successes and challenges of super-resolution SERS, from the earliest mapping of single-molecule SERS hot spots to the current state-of-the-art, while highlighting open questions and future opportunities to advance the field. Comparisons with fluorescence-based super-resolution imaging are discussed to help frame the unique challenges associated with performing SERS in the super-resolution regime.

High-Throughput All-Optical Determination of Nanorod Size and Orientation.

As a single-particle characterization technique, optical microscopy has transformed our understanding of structure-function relationships of plasmonic nanoparticles, but the need for ex-situ-correlated electron microscopy to obtain structural information handicaps an otherwise exceptional high-throughput technique. Here, we present an all-optical alternative to electron microscopy to accurately and quickly extract structural information about single gold nanorods (Au NRs) using calcite-assisted localization and kinetics (CLocK) microscopy. Color CLocK images of single Au NRs allow scattering from the longitudinal and transverse plasmon modes to be imaged simultaneously, encoding spectral data in CLocK images that can then be extracted to obtain Au NR size and orientation. Moreover, through the use of convolutional neural networks, Au NR length, width, and aspect ratio can be predicted directly from color CLocK images within ∼10% of the true value measured by electron microscopy.

Nonlinear effects in single-particle photothermal imaging.

Although photothermal imaging was originally designed to detect individual molecules that do not emit or small nanoparticles that do not scatter, the technique is now being applied to image and spectroscopically characterize larger and more sophisticated nanoparticle structures that scatter light strongly. Extending photothermal measurements into this regime, however, requires revisiting fundamental assumptions made in the interpretation of the signal. Herein, we present a theoretical analysis of the wavelength-resolved photothermal image and its extension to the large particle scattering regime, where we find the photothermal signal to inherit a nonlinear dependence upon pump intensity, together with a contraction of the full-width-at-half-maximum of its point spread function. We further analyze theoretically the extent to which photothermal spectra can be interpreted as an absorption spectrum measure, with deviations between the two becoming more prominent with increasing pump intensities. Companion experiments on individual 10, 20, and 100 nm radius gold nanoparticles evidence the predicted nonlinear pump power dependence and image contraction, verifying the theory and demonstrating new aspects of photothermal imaging relevant to a broader class of targets.

Potential Dependent Spectroelectrochemistry of Electrofluorogenic Dyes on Indium-Tin Oxide.

Indium-tin oxide (ITO) is used in a variety of applications due to its electrical conductivity and optical transparency. Moreover, ITO coated glass is a common working electrode for spectroelectrochemistry. Thus, the ITO substrates should exhibit well-understood spectroscopic characteristics. Here, we report anomalous potential-dependent luminescence emission from three structurally-dissimilar electrofluorogenic probe on ITO coated glass. The three probes, flavin mononucleotide, resorufin, and Nile blue, show the expected fluorescence modulation between their oxidized, emissive forms and their reduced, non-fluorescent forms at low laser irradiance and/or high concentrations. However, at high irradiance and/or low concentration, the emission intensity increases at reducing potentials, contrary to expectations. In addition, a strong interplay between probe molecule concentration and laser irradiance is observed. We attribute the anomalous behavior to a combination of (1) irradiance-dependent ITO carrier dynamics, and (2) interaction of the fluorescent probe with ITO at reducing potentials resulting in a charge transfer state with altered emission behavior. Thus, the potential- and irradiance-dependent behavior of ITO and the resulting charge transfer state may not only interfere with the observation of potential-dependent fluorescence from redox probes but can completely reverse the polarity of the potential-dependent luminescence, especially at high irradiance and low concentration.

Calcite-Assisted Localization and Kinetics (CLocK) Microscopy.

Localization-based super-resolution imaging techniques have improved the spatial resolution of optical microscopy well below the diffraction limit, yet encoding additional information into super-resolved images, such as anisotropy and orientation, remains a challenge. Here we introduce calcite-assisted localization and kinetics (CLocK) microscopy, a multiparameter super-resolution imaging technique easily integrated into any existing optical microscope setup at low cost and with straightforward analysis. By placing a rotating calcite crystal in the infinity space of an optical microscope, CLocK microscopy provides immediate polarization and orientation information while maintaining the ability to localize an emitter/scatterer with <10 nm resolution. Further, kinetic information an order of magnitude shorter than the integration time of the camera is encoded in the unique point spread function of a CLocK image, allowing for new mechanistic insight into dynamic processes such as single-nanoparticle dissolution and single-molecule surface-enhanced Raman scattering.

Toward Quantitative Nanothermometry Using Single-Molecule Counting.

Photothermal heating of nanoparticles has applications in nanomedicine, photocatalysis, photoelectrochemistry, and data storage, but accurate measurements of temperature at the nanoparticle surface are lacking. Here we demonstrate progress toward a super-resolution DNA nanothermometry technique capable of reporting the surface temperature on single plasmonic nanoparticles. Gold nanoparticles are functionalized with double-stranded DNA, and the extent of DNA denaturation under heating conditions serves as a reporter of temperature. Fluorescently labeled DNA oligomers are used to probe the denatured DNA through transient binding interactions. By counting the number of fluorescent binding events as a function of temperature, we reconstruct DNA melting curves that reproduce trends seen for solution-phase DNA. In addition, we demonstrate our ability to control the temperature of denaturation by changing the Na+ concentration and the base pair length of the double-stranded DNA on the nanoparticle surface. This degree of control allows us to select narrow temperature windows to probe, providing quantitative measurements of temperature at nanoscale surfaces.

Wavelength-Dependent Photothermal Imaging Probes Nanoscale Temperature Differences among Subdiffraction Coupled Plasmonic Nanorods.

Plasmonic structures confine electromagnetic energy at the nanoscale, resulting in local, inhomogeneous, controllable heating, but reading out the temperature using optical techniques poses a difficult challenge. Here, we report on the optical thermometry of individual gold nanorod trimers that exhibit multiple wavelength-dependent plasmon modes resulting in measurably different local temperature distributions. Specifically, we demonstrate how photothermal microscopy encodes different wavelength-dependent temperature profiles in the asymmetry of the photothermal image point spread function. These asymmetries are interpreted through companion numerical simulations to reveal how thermal gradients within the trimer can be controlled by exciting its hybridized plasmon modes. We also find that plasmon modes that are optically dark can be excited by focused laser beam illumination, providing another route to modify thermal profiles beyond wide-field illumination. Taken together these findings demonstrate an all-optical thermometry technique to actively create and measure nanoscale thermal gradients below the diffraction limit.

Special topic on emerging directions in plasmonics.

Plasmonics enables a wealth of applications, including photocatalysis, photoelectrochemistry, photothermal heating, optoelectronic devices, and biological and chemical sensing, while encompassing a broad range of materials, including coinage metals, doped semiconductors, metamaterials, 2D materials, bioconjugates, and chiral assemblies. Applications in plasmonics benefit from the large local electromagnetic field enhancements generated by plasmon excitation, as well as the products of plasmon decay, including photons, hot charge carriers, and heat. This special topic highlights recent work in both theory and experiment that advance our fundamental understanding of plasmon excitation and decay mechanisms, showcase new applications enabled by plasmon excitation, and highlight emerging classes of materials that support plasmon excitation.

Active Far-Field Control of the Thermal Near-Field via Plasmon Hybridization.

The ability to control and manipulate temperature at nanoscale dimensions has the potential to impact applications including heat-assisted magnetic recording, photothermal therapies, and temperature-driven reactivity. One challenge with controlling temperature at nanometer dimensions is the need to mitigate heat diffusion, such that the temperature only changes in well-defined nanoscopic regions of the sample. Here we demonstrate the ability to use far-field laser excitation to actively shape the thermal near-field in individual gold nanorod heterodimers by resonantly pumping either the in-phase or out-of-phase hybridized dipole plasmon modes. Using single-particle photothermal heterodyne imaging, we demonstrate localization bias in the photothermal intensity due to preferential heating of one of the nanorods within the pair. Theoretical modeling and numerical simulation make explicit how the resulting photothermal images encode wavelength-dependent temperature biases between each nanorod within a heterodimer, demonstrating the ability to actively manage the thermal near-field by simply tuning the color of incident light.

Supercharging Superlocalization Microscopy: How Electrochemical Charging of Plasmonic Nanostructures Uncovers Hidden Heterogeneity.

Superlocalization microscopy enables the position of single plasmonic nanoparticles to be determined with <25 nm precision, enabling single-nanoparticle tracking and super-resolution imaging experiments to be conducted with sub-diffraction-limited spatial resolution. In many of these applications, the superlocalized position of the nanoparticle is assumed to correspond to the geometric center of the nanoparticle. However, work reported by Wang and co-workers in this issue of ACS Nano suggests that this assumption can be incorrect, based on studies in which electrochemically charging a nanoparticle leads to reproducible shifts in its scattering center. The shift is believed to originate from nonuniform charge accumulation in the nanoparticle, due to the inherent heterogeneity in nanoparticle surface properties. This Perspective explores the implications of this result, both for using this shift to probe dynamic changes in nanoparticle surface chemistry as well as for exploiting nonuniform charge accumulation to promote site-specific chemical reactions.

Plasmon Heating Promotes Ligand Reorganization on Single Gold Nanorods.

Single-molecule fluorescence microscopy is used to follow dynamic ligand reorganization on the surface of single plasmonic gold nanorods. Fluorescently labeled DNA is attached to gold nanorods via a gold-thiol bond using a low-pH loading method. No fluorescence activity is initially observed from the fluorescent labels on the nanorod surface, which we attribute to a collapsed geometry of DNA on the metal. Upon several minutes of laser illumination, a marked increase in fluorescence activity is observed, suggesting that the ligand shell reorganizes from a collapsed, quenched geometry to an upright, ordered geometry. The ligand reorganization is facilitated by plasmon-mediated photothermal heating, as verified by controls using an external heat source and simulated by coupled optical and heat diffusion modeling. Using super-resolution image reconstruction, we observe spatial variations in which ligand reorganization occurs at the single-particle level. The results suggest the possibility of nonuniform plasmonic heating, which would be hidden with traditional ensemble-averaged measurements.

Quantifying Wavelength-Dependent Plasmonic Hot Carrier Energy Distributions at Metal/Semiconductor Interfaces.

Hot carriers generated from the nonradiative decay of localized surface plasmons are capable of driving charge-transfer reactions at the surfaces of metal nanostructures. Photocatalytic devices utilizing plasmonic hot carriers are often based on metal nanoparticle/semiconductor heterostructures owing to their efficient electron-hole separation ability. The rapid thermalization of hot carriers generated at the metal nanoparticles yields a distribution of carrier energies that determines the capability of the photocatalytic device to drive redox reactions. Here, we quantify the thermalized hot carrier energy distribution generated at Au/TiO2 nanostructures using wavelength-dependent scanning electrochemical microscopy and a series of molecular probes with different redox potentials. We determine the quantum efficiencies and oxidizing power of the hot carriers from wavelength-dependent reaction rates and photocurrent across the metal/semiconductor interface. The wavelength-dependent reaction efficiency tracks the surface plasmon resonance spectrum of the Au nanoparticles, showing that the reaction is facilitated by plasmon excitation, while the responses from molecules with different redox potentials shed light on the energy distribution of the hot holes generated at metal nanoparticle/semiconductor heterostructures. The results provide important insight into the energies of the plasmon-generated hot carriers and quantum efficiencies of plasmonic photocatalytic devices.

Quantifying photothermal heating at plasmonic nanoparticles by scanning electrochemical microscopy.

Photothermal heating at metal nanoparticles results from the non-radiative decay of localized surface plasmons. The local heat generation enhances the mass transport rate of redox molecules and causes a shift in their formal potential, both of which can impact an electrochemical process at the nanoparticle interface. Here we present a methodology for probing the surface temperature at a plasmonic nanoparticle substrate using scanning electrochemical microscopy (SECM). Light is used to excite a plasmonic substrate electrode, while an ultramicroelectrode tip is positioned close to the substrate to read out both the mass transfer rate and concentration profile of the redox molecules. The measured mass transfer rate and the shift in the equilibrium potential provide a quantitative value of the temperature increase at the substrate surface, which is verified by simulations using a mass transfer model coupled with heat dissipation. The developed SECM approach is suitable for probing heat generation at a variety of both plasmonic and non-plasmonic nanostructures.

Three-Dimensional Super-resolution Imaging of Single Nanoparticles Delivered by Pipettes.

Controlled three-dimensional positioning of nanoparticles is achieved by delivering single fluorescent nanoparticles from a nanopipette and capturing them at well-defined regions of an electrified substrate. To control the position of single nanoparticles, the force of the pressure-driven flow from the pipette is balanced by the attractive electrostatic force at the substrate, providing a strategy by which nanoparticle trajectories can be manipulated in real time. To visualize nanoparticle motion, a resistive-pulse electrochemical setup is coupled with an optical microscope, and nanoparticle trajectories are tracked in three dimensions using super-resolution fluorescence imaging to obtain positional information with precision in the tens of nanometers. As the particles approach the substrate, the diffusion kinetics are analyzed and reveal either subdiffusive (hindered) or superdiffusive (directed) motion depending on the electric field at the substrate and the pressure-driven flow from the pipette. By balancing the effects of the forces exerted on the particle by the pressure and electric fields, controlled, real-time manipulation of single nanoparticle trajectories is achieved. The developed approach has implications for a variety of applications such as surface patterning and drug delivery using colloidal nanoparticles.

Super-Resolution Imaging and Plasmonics.

This review describes the growing partnership between super-resolution imaging and plasmonics, by describing the various ways in which the two topics mutually benefit one another to enhance our understanding of the nanoscale world. First, localization-based super-resolution imaging strategies, where molecules are modulated between emissive and nonemissive states and their emission localized, are applied to plasmonic nanoparticle substrates, revealing the hidden shape of the nanoparticles while also mapping local electromagnetic field enhancements and reactivity patterns on their surface. However, these results must be interpreted carefully due to localization errors induced by the interaction between metallic substrates and single fluorophores. Second, plasmonic nanoparticles are explored as image contrast agents for both superlocalization and super-resolution imaging, offering benefits such as high photostability, large signal-to-noise, and distance-dependent spectral features but presenting challenges for localizing individual nanoparticles within a diffraction-limited spot. Finally, the use of plasmon-tailored excitation fields to achieve subdiffraction-limited spatial resolution is discussed, using localized surface plasmons and surface plasmon polaritons to create confined excitation volumes or image magnification to enhance spatial resolution.

Visualizing and Calculating Tip-Substrate Distance in Nanoscale Scanning Electrochemical Microscopy Using 3-Dimensional Super-Resolution Optical Imaging.

We report a strategy for the optical determination of tip-substrate distance in nanoscale scanning electrochemical microscopy (SECM) using three-dimensional super-resolution fluorescence imaging. A phase mask is placed in the emission path of our dual SECM/optical microscope, generating a double helix point spread function at the image plane, which allows us to measure the height of emitting objects relative to the focus of the microscope. By exciting both a fluorogenic reaction at the nanoscale electrode tip as well as fluorescent nanoparticles at the substrate, we are able to calculate the tip-substrate distance as the tip approaches the surface with precision better than 25 nm. Attachment of a fluorescent particle to the insulating sheath of the SECM tip extends this technique to nonfluorogenic electrochemical reactions. Correlated electrochemical and optical determination of tip-substrate distance yielded excellent agreement between the two techniques. Not only does super-resolution imaging offer a secondary feedback mechanism for measuring the tip-sample gap during SECM experiments, it also enables facile tip alignment and a strategy for accounting for electrode tilt relative to the substrate.