Specific Targeting of Multiple Myeloma by Dual Split-signaling Chimeric Antigen Receptor T cells Directed against CD38 and CD138.

PURPOSE: The success of B-cell maturation antigen (BCMA)-specific chimeric antigen receptor (CAR) T cells illustrates the potential of this novel therapy for multiple myeloma. Nonetheless, broadening CAR T-cell therapy beyond BCMA requires inventive strategies as there are only a few multiple myeloma- or plasma cell-specific target antigens. We investigated the feasibility of achieving multiple myeloma specificity by dual-split CD38/CD138 CAR targeting, whereby the stimulatory and costimulatory signals for T-cell activation are split into two separate stimulatory (sCAR) and costimulatory CARs (cCAR). EXPERIMENTAL DESIGN: Using various combinations of CD38 and CD138 sCARs and cCARs with different affinities, we generated several dual-split CAR T cells and analyzed them for multiple myeloma-specific effector functions in vitro. The best-functioning CAR T cells were tested in vivo in a murine xenograft model. RESULTS: We found optimal designs of both CD38sCAR/CD138cCAR and CD138sCAR/CD38cCAR combinations, that effectively lysed multiple myeloma cells but spared single CD38- or CD138-positive healthy hematopoietic cells. While the CD38sCAR/CD138cCAR T cells achieved multiple myeloma-specific activity solely due to the low affinity of the CD38sCARs, the multiple myeloma-specific cytotoxicity, cytokine release, and proliferation of CD138sCAR/CD38cCAR T cells were established through a true combinatorial stimulatory and costimulatory effect. The most optimal combination comprised a low-affinity CD138sCAR combined with a high-affinity CD38cCAR. These CD138sCAR/CD38cCAR T cells also showed dual-antigen specific anti-multiple myeloma effects in vivo. Importantly, they were also effective against multiple myeloma cells from daratumumab pretreated patients with decreased CD38 expression levels. CONCLUSIONS: We demonstrate the possibility to specifically target multiple myeloma cells, even after CD38 targeted therapy, with carefully-designed dual-split CARs directed against CD38 and CD138.

Current State of the Art and Prospects of T Cell-Redirecting Bispecific Antibodies in Multiple Myeloma.

Multiple myeloma (MM) patients eventually develop multi-drug-resistant disease with poor survival. Hence, the development of novel treatment strategies is of great importance. Recently, different classes of immunotherapeutic agents have shown great promise in heavily pre-treated MM, including T cell-redirecting bispecific antibodies (BsAbs). These BsAbs simultaneously interact with CD3 on effector T cells and a tumor-associated antigen on MM cells, resulting in redirection of T cells to MM cells. This leads to the formation of an immunologic synapse, the release of granzymes/perforins, and subsequent tumor cell lysis. Several ongoing phase 1 studies show substantial activity and a favorable toxicity profile with BCMA-, GPRC5D-, or FcRH5-targeting BsAbs in heavily pre-treated MM patients. Resistance mechanisms against BsAbs include tumor-related features, T cell characteristics, and impact of components of the immunosuppressive tumor microenvironment. Various clinical trials are currently evaluating combination therapy with a BsAb and another agent, such as a CD38-targeting antibody or an immunomodulatory drug (e.g., pomalidomide), to further improve response depth and duration. Additionally, the combination of two BsAbs, simultaneously targeting two different antigens to prevent antigen escape, is being explored in clinical studies. The evaluation of BsAbs in earlier lines of therapy, including newly diagnosed MM, is warranted, based on the efficacy of BsAbs in advanced MM.

CD38-specific Chimeric Antigen Receptor Expressing Natural Killer KHYG-1 Cells: A Proof of Concept for an "Off the Shelf" Therapy for Multiple Myeloma.

Chimeric antigen receptor (CAR) T cells are highly successful in the treatment of hematologic malignancies. We recently generated affinity-optimized CD38CAR T cells, which effectively eliminate multiple myeloma (MM) cells with little or no toxicities against nonmalignant hematopoietic cells. The lack of universal donors and long manufacturing times however limit the broad application of CAR T cell therapies. Natural killer (NK) cells generated from third party individuals may represent a viable source of "off the shelf" CAR-based products, as they are not associated with graft-versus-host disease unlike allogeneic T cells. We therefore explored the preclinical anti-MM efficacy and potential toxicity of the CD38CAR NK concept by expressing affinity-optimized CD38CARs in KHYG-1 cells, an immortal NK cell line with excellent expansion properties. KHYG-1 cells retrovirally transduced with the affinity-optimized CD38CARs expanded vigorously and mediated effective CD38-dependent cytotoxicity towards CD38high MM cell lines as well as primary MM cells ex vivo. Importantly, the intermediate affinity CD38CAR transduced KHYG-1 cells spared CD38neg or CD38int nonmalignant hematopoietic cells, indicating an optimal tumor nontumor discrimination. Irradiated, short living CD38CAR KHYG-1 cells also showed significant anti-MM effects in a xenograft model with a humanized bone marrow-like niche. Finally, CD38CAR KHYG-1 cells effectively eliminated primary MM cells derived from patients who are refractory to CD38 antibody daratumumab. Taken together, the results of this proof-of-principle study demonstrate the potential value of engineering affinity-optimized CD38CARs in NK cells to establish effective anti-MM effects, with an excellent safety profile, even in patients who failed to response to most advanced registered myeloma therapies, such as daratumumab.

Bone Marrow Mesenchymal Stromal Cells Can Render Multiple Myeloma Cells Resistant to Cytotoxic Machinery of CAR T Cells through Inhibition of Apoptosis.

PURPOSE: The microenvironment of multiple myeloma (MM) can critically impair therapy outcome, including immunotherapies. In this context, we have earlier demonstrated that bone marrow mesenchymal stromal cells (BMMSC) protect MM cells against the lytic machinery of MM-reactive cytotoxic T cells (CTL) and daratumumab-redirected natural killer (NK) cells through the upregulation of antiapoptotic proteins Survivin and Mcl-1 in MM cells. Here, we investigated the significance of this mode of immune escape on T cells engineered to express chimeric antigen receptors (CAR T cells). EXPERIMENTAL DESIGN: We tested the cytolytic ability of a panel of 10 BCMA-, CD38-, and CD138-specific CAR T cells with different affinities against a model MM cell line and against patient-derived MM cells in the presence versus absence of BMMSCs. RESULTS: Although BMMSCs hardly protected MM cells from lysis by high-affinity, strongly lytic BCMA- and CD38-CAR T cells, they significantly protected against lower affinity, moderately lytic BCMA-, CD38-, and CD138-specific CAR T cells in a cell-cell contact-dependent manner. Overall, there was a remarkable inverse correlation between the protective ability of BMMSCs and the lytic activity of all CAR T cells, which was dependent on CAR affinity and type of costimulation. Furthermore, BMMSC-mediated resistance against CAR T cells was effectively modulated by FL118, an inhibitor of antiapoptotic proteins Survivin, Mcl-1, and XIAP. CONCLUSIONS: These results extend our findings on the negative impact of the microenvironment against immunotherapies and suggest that outcome of CAR T cell or conventional CTL therapies could benefit from inhibition of antiapoptotic proteins upregulated in MM cells through BMMSC interactions.

Dual Targeting to Overcome Current Challenges in Multiple Myeloma CAR T-Cell Treatment.

In the era of highly promising novel targeted-immunotherapy strategies for multiple myeloma (MM), the first series of clinical trials with CAR T-cells targeting the plasma cell-specific B-cell maturation antigen (BCMA) have shown excellent response rates. In the long-term, however, MM appears to escape the therapy likely due to initial low and heterogeneous expression or downregulation of BCMA expression. Several other molecules targeted by CAR T-cells in MM are expressed at high levels on MM cells, but many of these attractive targets are also expressed on various, sometimes vital non-malignant cells, posing major risks for on-target, off-tumor side effects. CAR T-cell therapy for MM therefore faces two urgent challenges: (i) improving the efficacy of BCMA CAR T-cells and (ii) establishing a MM-selectivity even when CAR T-cells are directed against not entirely MM-specific target antigens. In this review, we will outline the current attempts to tackle these challenges, with a specific focus on how dual CAR targeting might be applied to tackle both issues.