Prevalence of ESR1 E380Q mutation in tumor tissue and plasma from Japanese breast cancer patients.

BACKGROUND: ESR1 mutations have attracted attention as a potentially important marker and treatment target in endocrine therapy-resistant breast cancer patients. The E380Q mutation, which is one of the ESR1 mutations, is associated with estradiol (E2) hypersensitivity, increased DNA binding to the estrogen response element, and E2-independent constitutive trans-activation activity, but its frequency in ESR1 mutations remains unknown. The present study aimed to investigate the E380Q mutation in comparison with the other representative ESR1 mutations. METHODS: We screened a total of 62 patients (66 tumor tissues and 69 plasma cell-free DNA (cfDNA)) to detect ESR1 mutations (E380Q, Y537S, Y537N, Y537C, and D538G) using droplet-digital polymerase chain reaction. Plasma was collected at more than two points of the clinical course, in whom changes of ESR1 mutations under treatment were investigated. RESULTS: We detected ESR1 mutations in 21% (12/57) of MBCs. The E380Q ESR1 mutation was found in 16% (2/12) and the other ESR1 LBD mutations were five (41.6%) of Y537S, and four each (33.3%) of D538G, Y537N, and Y537C, in 12 ESR1 mutant breast cancer patients. Five tumors had multiple ESR1 mutations: three had double ESR1 mutations; Y537S/E380Q, Y37S/Y537C, and Y537S/D538G, and two had triple ESR1 mutations; Y537S/Y537N/D538G. In plasma cfDNA analysis, the E380Q mutation was not detected, but increases in other ESR1 mutations were detected in 46.2% (6/13) of MBC patients under treatment. CONCLUSIONS: We have shown that there are distinct populations of ESR1 mutations in metastatic tissue and plasma. Each ESR1 mutation may have different clinical significance, and it will be necessary to investigate them all.

Analysis of ESR1 and PIK3CA mutations in plasma cell-free DNA from ER-positive breast cancer patients.

BACKGROUND: The measurement of ESR1 and PIK3CA mutations in plasma cell-free DNA (cfDNA) has been studied as a non-invasive method to quickly assess and monitor endocrine therapy (ET) resistant metastatic breast cancer (MBC) patients. METHODS: The subjects of this retrospective study were a total of 185 plasma samples from 86 estrogen receptor-positive BC patients, of which 151 plasma samples were from 69 MBC patients and 34 plasma samples were from 17 primary BC (PBC) patients. We developed multiplex droplet digital PCR assays to verify the clinical significance of ESR1 and PIK3CA mutations both in a snapshot and serially in these patients. RESULTS: cfDNA ESR1 and PIK3CA mutations were found in 28.9% and 24.6 % of MBC patients, respectively. The relation between ESR1 or PIK3CA mutations and clinical features showed that ESR1 mutations occurred mostly in patients previously treated by ET, which was not the case for PIK3CA mutations. The analysis of the clinical impact of those mutations on subsequent lines of treatment for the 69 MBC patients revealed that both ESR1 and PIK3CA mutations detection were related to a shorter duration of ET effectiveness in univariate analysis but only for ESR1 mutations in multivariate analysis. The monitoring of cfDNA in a subset of 52 patients showed that loss of ESR1 mutations was related to a longer duration of response, which was not the case for PIK3CA mutations. CONCLUSIONS: We have demonstrated the clinical significance of on-treatment ESR1 mutations both in a snapshot and serially in comparison with PIK3CA mutations.

Clinical significance of monitoring ESR1 mutations in circulating cell-free DNA in estrogen receptor positive breast cancer patients.

BACKGROUND: The measurement of circulating cell-free DNA (cfDNA) may transform the management of breast cancer patients. We aimed to investigate the clinical significance of sequential measurements of ESR1 mutations in primary breast cancer (PBC) and metastatic breast cancer (MBC) patients. RESULTS: ESR1 mutations ratio in the PBC groups was used as the minimum cutoff for determining increases in cfDNA ESR1 mutation ratio. An increase in cfDNA ESR1 mutations was found in 13 samples of cfDNA from 12 (28.6%) out of 42 MBC patients. A total of 10 (83.3%) out of 12 MBC patients with increase cfDNA ESR1 mutations showed a poor response to treatment. In survival analysis, increase cfDNA ESR1 mutations may predict a shorter duration of post-endocrine-therapy effectiveness (P = 0.0033). METHODS: A total of 119 patients (253 plasma samples) with breast carcinoma were enrolled in this study. Cases were selected if archival plasma samples were available from PBC before and after treatment and from MBC gathered more than twice at the time of progression. cfDNA was isolated from the 77 PBC patients (154 plasma samples) and from the 42 MBC patients (99 plasma samples). To investigate any changes in each cfDNA ESR1 mutation before and after treatment, we analyzed the difference with cfDNA ESR1 mutations ratio in the first blood sample using droplet digital polymerase chain reaction (ddPCR). CONCLUSIONS: We demonstrate that ddPCR monitoring of the recurrent ESR1 mutation in cfDNA of MBC patients is a feasible and useful method of providing relevant predictive information.