RESUMO
BACKGROUND: The pathogenesis of alloimmunization is not well understood, and initiatives that aim to reduce the incidence of alloimmunization are generally expensive and either ineffective or unproven. In this review, we summarize the current medical literature regarding alloimmunization in the sickle cell disease (SCD) population, with a special focus on the financial implications of different approaches to prevent alloimmunization. STUDY DESIGN AND METHODS: A review of EMBASE and MEDLINE data from January 2006 through January 2016 was conducted to identify articles relating to complications of SCD. The search was specifically designed to capture articles that evaluated the costs of various strategies to prevent alloimmunization and its sequelae. RESULTS: Currently, there is no proven, inexpensive way to prevent alloimmunization among individuals with SCD. Serologic matching programs are not uniformly successful in preventing alloimmunization, particularly to Rh antigens, because of the high frequency of variant Rh alleles in the SCD population. A genotypic matching program could offer some cost savings compared to a serologic matching program, but the efficacy of gene matching for the prevention of alloimmunization is largely unproven, and large-scale implementation could be expensive. CONCLUSIONS: Future reductions in the costs associated with genotype matching could make a large-scale program economically feasible. Novel techniques to identify patients at highest risk for alloimmunization could improve the cost effectiveness of antigen matching programs. A clinical trial comparing the efficacy of serologic matching to genotype matching would be informative.
Assuntos
Anemia Falciforme/terapia , Incompatibilidade de Grupos Sanguíneos/prevenção & controle , Tipagem e Reações Cruzadas Sanguíneas/métodos , Transfusão de Sangue/métodos , Anemia Falciforme/imunologia , Incompatibilidade de Grupos Sanguíneos/economia , Tipagem e Reações Cruzadas Sanguíneas/economia , Transfusão de Sangue/economia , Análise Custo-Benefício , Genótipo , Humanos , Reação TransfusionalRESUMO
Incompatible living donor kidney transplantation (ILDKT) has been established as an effective option for end-stage renal disease patients with willing but HLA-incompatible living donors, reducing mortality and improving quality of life. Depending on antibody titer, ILDKT can require highly resource-intensive procedures, including intravenous immunoglobulin, plasma exchange, and/or cell-depleting antibody treatment, as well as protocol biopsies and donor-specific antibody testing. This study sought to compare the cost and Medicare reimbursement, exclusive of organ acquisition payment, for ILDKT (n = 926) with varying antibody titers to matched compatible transplants (n = 2762) performed between 2002 and 2011. Data were assembled from a national cohort study of ILDKT and a unique data set linking hospital cost accounting data and Medicare claims. ILDKT was more expensive than matched compatible transplantation, ranging from 20% higher adjusted costs for positive on Luminex assay but negative flow cytometric crossmatch, 26% higher for positive flow cytometric crossmatch but negative cytotoxic crossmatch, and 39% higher for positive cytotoxic crossmatch (p < 0.0001 for all). ILDKT was associated with longer median length of stay (12.9 vs. 7.8 days), higher Medicare payments ($91 330 vs. $63 782 p < 0.0001), and greater outlier payments. In conclusion, ILDKT increases the cost of and payments for kidney transplantation.
Assuntos
Incompatibilidade de Grupos Sanguíneos/economia , Rejeição de Enxerto/economia , Teste de Histocompatibilidade/economia , Falência Renal Crônica/cirurgia , Transplante de Rim/economia , Doadores Vivos , Complicações Pós-Operatórias/economia , Estudos de Casos e Controles , Feminino , Seguimentos , Taxa de Filtração Glomerular , Rejeição de Enxerto/epidemiologia , Sobrevivência de Enxerto , Humanos , Testes de Função Renal , Masculino , Pessoa de Meia-Idade , Prognóstico , Qualidade de Vida , Estudos Retrospectivos , Fatores de RiscoRESUMO
The infrequent use of ABO-incompatible (ABOi) kidney transplantation in the United States may reflect concern about the costs of necessary preconditioning and posttransplant care. Medicare data for 26 500 live donor kidney transplant recipients (2000 to March 2011), including 271 ABOi and 62 A2-incompatible (A2i) recipients, were analyzed to assess the impact of pretransplant, transplant episode and 3-year posttransplant costs. The marginal costs of ABOi and A2i versus ABO-compatible (ABOc) transplants were quantified by multivariate linear regression including adjustment for recipient, donor and transplant factors. Compared with ABOc transplantation, patient survival (93.2% vs. 88.15%, p = 0.0009) and death-censored graft survival (85.4% vs. 76.1%, p < 0.05) at 3 years were lower after ABOi transplant. The average overall cost of the transplant episode was significantly higher for ABOi ($65 080) compared with A2i ($36 752) and ABOc ($32 039) transplantation (p < 0.001), excluding organ acquisition. ABOi transplant was associated with high adjusted posttransplant spending (marginal costs compared to ABOc - year 1: $25 044; year 2: $10 496; year 3: $7307; p < 0.01). ABOi transplantation provides a clinically effective method to expand access to transplantation. Although more expensive, the modest increases in total spending are easily justified by avoiding long-term dialysis and its associated morbidity and cost.
Assuntos
Sistema ABO de Grupos Sanguíneos/imunologia , Incompatibilidade de Grupos Sanguíneos/economia , Rejeição de Enxerto/economia , Falência Renal Crônica/economia , Transplante de Rim/economia , Doadores Vivos , Adolescente , Adulto , Bases de Dados Factuais , Feminino , Seguimentos , Taxa de Filtração Glomerular , Rejeição de Enxerto/etiologia , Humanos , Falência Renal Crônica/cirurgia , Testes de Função Renal , Transplante de Rim/efeitos adversos , Masculino , Medicare , Pessoa de Meia-Idade , Prognóstico , Estudos Retrospectivos , Fatores de Risco , Estados Unidos , Adulto JovemRESUMO
BACKGROUND: Prophylactic antigen-matching can reduce alloimmunization rates among chronically transfused patients with sickle cell disease (SCD), but this matching increases costs and may only benefit 30% of patients. We assessed the clinical and financial value of a potential assay for alloimmunization risk that would allow for targeted antigen-matching. STUDY DESIGN AND METHODS: A Markov-based model evaluated direct medical costs and alloimmunization events over 10 to 20 years among transfused (simple or exchange) patients with SCD. Four matching strategies were evaluated: prospective matching (for all patients), history-based matching (only for patients with prior alloimmunization), perfectly informed matching (assay with 100% sensitivity, 100% specificity), and imperfectly informed matching (reduced accuracy). Under all matching protocols, matching included C, E, K, and any additional alloantibodies present. A hospital perspective was adopted, with costs (2012US$) and events discounted (3%). RESULTS: Perfectly informed antigen-matching using a $1000 assay is expected to save $82,334 per patient over 10 years, compared to prospective matching. Perfectly informed antigen-matching is more costly than history-based matching, but reduces alloimmunization events by 45.6% over 10 years. Averting each alloimmunization event using this strategy would cost an additional $10,934 per patient. Imperfectly informed antigen-matching using an assay with 75% specificity and 75% sensitivity is less costly than prospective matching, but increases alloimmunization events. Compared to history-based matching, imperfectly informed matching would decrease alloimmunization events by 32.61%, at an additional cost of $147,915 per patient over 10 years. Cost-effectiveness of informed antigen-matching is largely driven by assay specificity. CONCLUSIONS: A sufficiently specific assay to inform antigen-matching may be cost-effective in reducing alloimmunization among transfused patients with SCD.
Assuntos
Anemia Falciforme/terapia , Doadores de Sangue , Antígenos de Grupos Sanguíneos/imunologia , Incompatibilidade de Grupos Sanguíneos/epidemiologia , Tipagem e Reações Cruzadas Sanguíneas/economia , Seleção do Doador/economia , Isoanticorpos/sangue , Reação Transfusional , Anemia Falciforme/economia , Anemia Falciforme/imunologia , Incompatibilidade de Grupos Sanguíneos/economia , Incompatibilidade de Grupos Sanguíneos/etiologia , Incompatibilidade de Grupos Sanguíneos/prevenção & controle , Transfusão de Sangue/economia , Análise Custo-Benefício , Custos e Análise de Custo , Técnicas de Apoio para a Decisão , Gastos em Saúde , Humanos , Cadeias de Markov , Prontuários Médicos/economia , Modelos Econômicos , Risco , Sensibilidade e Especificidade , Estados UnidosRESUMO
BACKGROUND: Sickle cell disease is associated with extensive health care utilization; estimated lifetime costs exceed $460,000 per patient. Approximately 30% of chronically transfused sickle cell patients become alloimmunized to red blood cell antigens, but these patients cannot be identified a priori. Prospective antigen matching can prevent alloimmunization, but is costly and may not benefit most patients. STUDY DESIGN AND METHODS: A Markov-based model was constructed to compare the health and financial implications of four alternative antigen-matching strategies for chronically transfused sickle cell patients. The strategies varied by the group of patients receiving matched blood (all patients prophylactically or only patients with a history of alloimmunization [history-based]), and by the extent of antigen matching (limited to C, E, and K, or extended to 11 antigens). Direct medical costs and alloimmunization events were assessed over 10- and 20-year periods, for a hypothetical cohort of initially transfusion-naive patients and for a dynamic population. RESULTS: Within a hypothetical cohort of initially transfusion-naive patients, implementing prophylactic limited matching for all chronically transfused patients instead of history-based limited matching is expected to cost an additional $765.56 million over 10 years, but result in 2072 fewer alloimmunization events. Within the same cohort, implementing prospective extensive matching is expected to cost $1.86 billion more than history-based extensive matching, but result in 2424 fewer alloimmunization events. Averting a single alloimmunization event using prospective matching would cost $369,482 to $769,284. Among a dynamic population over 10 years, prospective limited matching is expected to cost $358.34 million more than history-based limited matching. CONCLUSIONS: While prospective matching for all transfused patients would reduce alloimmunization, this strategy requires considerable expenditure.
Assuntos
Anemia Falciforme/imunologia , Anemia Falciforme/terapia , Incompatibilidade de Grupos Sanguíneos/prevenção & controle , Tipagem e Reações Cruzadas Sanguíneas/economia , Transfusão de Eritrócitos/efeitos adversos , Eritrócitos/imunologia , Anemia Hemolítica/economia , Anemia Hemolítica/etiologia , Anemia Hemolítica/imunologia , Anemia Hemolítica/prevenção & controle , Anemia Falciforme/economia , Incompatibilidade de Grupos Sanguíneos/economia , Tipagem e Reações Cruzadas Sanguíneas/métodos , Análise Custo-Benefício , Árvores de Decisões , Transfusão de Eritrócitos/economia , Transfusão de Eritrócitos/métodos , Custos de Cuidados de Saúde , Humanos , Cadeias de MarkovRESUMO
This final rule will implement section 2702 of the Patient Protection and Affordable Care Act which directs the Secretary of Health and Human Services to issue Medicaid regulations effective as of July 1, 2011 prohibiting Federal payments to States under section 1903 of the Social Security Act for any amounts expended for providing medical assistance for health care-acquired conditions specified in the regulation. It will also authorize States to identify other provider-preventable conditions for which Medicaid payment will be prohibited.
Assuntos
Reembolso de Seguro de Saúde/legislação & jurisprudência , Medicaid/legislação & jurisprudência , Patient Protection and Affordable Care Act/economia , Sistema de Pagamento Prospectivo/legislação & jurisprudência , Acidentes por Quedas/economia , Acidentes por Quedas/prevenção & controle , Incompatibilidade de Grupos Sanguíneos/economia , Incompatibilidade de Grupos Sanguíneos/prevenção & controle , Infecções Relacionadas a Cateter/economia , Infecções Relacionadas a Cateter/prevenção & controle , Cetoacidose Diabética/economia , Cetoacidose Diabética/prevenção & controle , Economia Hospitalar/legislação & jurisprudência , Embolia Aérea/economia , Embolia Aérea/prevenção & controle , Corpos Estranhos/economia , Corpos Estranhos/prevenção & controle , Reforma dos Serviços de Saúde/economia , Reforma dos Serviços de Saúde/legislação & jurisprudência , Humanos , Reembolso de Seguro de Saúde/economia , Legislação Hospitalar/economia , Medicaid/economia , Erros Médicos/economia , Erros Médicos/prevenção & controle , Medicare/economia , Medicare/legislação & jurisprudência , Úlcera por Pressão/economia , Úlcera por Pressão/prevenção & controle , Sistema de Pagamento Prospectivo/economia , Garantia da Qualidade dos Cuidados de Saúde/economia , Garantia da Qualidade dos Cuidados de Saúde/legislação & jurisprudência , Infecção da Ferida Cirúrgica/economia , Infecção da Ferida Cirúrgica/prevenção & controle , Estados Unidos , Trombose Venosa/economia , Trombose Venosa/prevenção & controleAssuntos
Transfusão de Eritrócitos/efeitos adversos , Hipersensibilidade/prevenção & controle , Procedimentos de Redução de Leucócitos , Transfusão de Plaquetas/efeitos adversos , Pré-Medicação , Incompatibilidade de Grupos Sanguíneos/complicações , Incompatibilidade de Grupos Sanguíneos/economia , Incompatibilidade de Grupos Sanguíneos/história , Transfusão de Eritrócitos/economia , Transfusão de Eritrócitos/história , Medicina Baseada em Evidências , História do Século XX , Humanos , Hipersensibilidade/economia , Hipersensibilidade/etiologia , Hipersensibilidade/história , Incidência , Prática Institucional/economia , Prática Institucional/história , Prática Institucional/tendências , Procedimentos de Redução de Leucócitos/economia , Procedimentos de Redução de Leucócitos/história , Transfusão de Plaquetas/economia , Transfusão de Plaquetas/história , Pré-Medicação/história , Síndrome do Desconforto Respiratório/economia , Síndrome do Desconforto Respiratório/etiologia , Síndrome do Desconforto Respiratório/história , Síndrome do Desconforto Respiratório/prevenção & controle , Sepse/economia , Sepse/etiologia , Sepse/história , Sepse/prevenção & controleRESUMO
BACKGROUND: The transplantation of living donor renal allografts across blood group barriers requires protocols to reduce and maintain anti-blood group antibody at safe levels. These protocols lead to an increase in resource utilization and cost of transplantation and may result in increased complications. METHODS: In this retrospective study, we compared 40 ABO-incompatible to 77 matching ABO-compatible living donor renal allografts with respect to complications, resource utilization, and cost from day -14 to 90 days after transplantation. RESULTS: Overall, surgery-related complications and resource utilization were increased in the ABO-incompatible group, primarily due to the desensitization protocol and antibody-mediated rejection. In the absence of rejection, the mean number of complications was similar for both groups. ABO-incompatible kidney transplantation was approximately 38,000 US dollars more expensive than ABO-compatible transplants, but was cost effective when compared to maintaining the patient on dialysis while waiting for a blood group compatible deceased donor kidney. Actuarial graft and patient survival was similar in the two groups. CONCLUSIONS: We conclude that ABO-incompatible living donor kidney transplantation is a viable option for patients whose only donor is blood group incompatible despite the additional resource utilization and cost of therapy.