Failure to investigate anaesthetic anaphylaxis resulting in a preventable second anaphylactic reaction.

We present a case of anaphylaxis to suxamethonium and/or vecuronium in a patient who had previously suffered an anaphylactic reaction, presumably to rocuronium. The patient had not been referred for formal allergy testing after the first anaphylactic reaction. Subsequent formal allergy testing revealed sensitivities to suxamethonium, rocuronium and vecuronium. Her next anaesthetic, using cisatracurium, was uneventful. It is recommended that all patients with suspected perioperative anaphylaxis are referred for testing. This is the responsibility of the anaesthetist. Particular caution should be used with suspected neuromuscular blocking drug allergy as cross-reactivity is common and not predictable by drug structure.

An anesthesiologist with an allergy to multiple neuromuscular blocking drugs: a new occupational hazard.

We report a case of a final-year anesthesiology trainee who developed a severe allergic reaction to cutaneous exposure of succinylcholine. Intradermal testing was strongly positive to succinylcholine and all the aminosteroid neuromuscular blocking drugs (NMBDs). Specific immunoglobulin E to succinylcholine was also strongly positive. This unusual case of an anesthesiologist acquiring an allergy to an NMBD through occupational exposure has a significant effect on his practice of anesthesia. However, by avoiding operating rooms with a high usage of NMBDs and by wearing personal protective equipment, the anesthesiologist has worked in clinical anesthesia without incident.

National pholcodine consumption and prevalence of IgE-sensitization: a multicentre study.

BACKGROUND: The aim of this study was to test, on a multinational level, the pholcodine (PHO) hypothesis, i.e. that the consumption of PHO-containing cough mixtures could cause higher prevalence of IgE antibodies to PHO, morphine (MOR) and suxamethonium (SUX). As a consequence the risk of anaphylaxis to neuromuscular blocking agents (NMBA) will be increased. METHODS: National PHO consumptions were derived from the United Nations International Narcotics Control Board (INCB) database. IgE and IgE antibodies to PHO, MOR, SUX and P-aminophenyl-phosphoryl choline (PAPPC) were measured in sera from atopic individuals, defined by a positive Phadiatop test (>0.35 kU(A)/l), collected in nine countries representing high and low PHO-consuming nations. RESULTS: There was a significant positive association between PHO consumption and prevalences of IgE-sensitization to PHO and MOR, but not to SUX and PAPPC, as calculated both by exposure group comparisons and linear regression analysis. The Netherlands and the USA, did not have PHO-containing drugs on the markets, although the former had a considerable PHO consumption. Both countries had high figures of IgE-sensitization. CONCLUSION: This international prevalence study lends additional support to the PHO hypothesis and, consequently, that continued use of drugs containing this substance should be seriously questioned. The results also indicate that other, yet unknown, substances may lead to IgE-sensitization towards NMBAs.

[Anaphylactic shock from succinylcholine, complicated by a rhabdomyolysis]. / Choc anaphylactique dû à la succinylcholine compliqué de rhabdomyolyse.

A young woman, with a contact dermatitis to nickel, experienced a life threatening anaphylaxis after induction of general anaesthesia for an emergency curettage. Hypersensitivity reaction involving IgE antibodies against succinylcholine was proven by positive skin test and radioimmunoassay detection of antibodies against succinylcholine and quaternary ammonium. After restoration of haemodynamics in a few hours, the patient had rhabdomyolysis predominant at lower left leg, which required a fasciotomy. An haemodialysis session was necessary, renal function being normalized thereafter. Several months later, the patient suffers from dysesthesia on the leg and foot. Muscular ischaemia was the consequence of the shock, the external compression due to the compression stockings probably being an additional factor.

Pholcodine exposure raises serum IgE in patients with previous anaphylaxis to neuromuscular blocking agents.

BACKGROUND: Neuromuscular blocking agents (NMBAs) can cause anaphylaxis through immunoglobulin E (IgE) antibodies that bind quaternary ammonium ion epitopes. These epitopes are present in numerous common chemicals and drugs, exposure to which, theoretically, could be of importance in the development and maintenance of the IgE sensitization promoting allergic reactions. Pholcodine is one such drug, which in a recent pilot study was shown to induce a remarkable increase in serum IgE levels in two IgE-sensitized individuals. The present study explores the effect of pholcodine exposure on IgE in a population with previously diagnosed IgE-mediated anaphylaxis towards NMBAs. METHODS: Seventeen patients were randomized to 1 week's exposure with cough syrup containing either pholcodine or guaifenesin. The primary variables serum IgE and IgE antibodies towards pholcodine, morphine and suxamethonium were measured before and 4 and 8 weeks after start of exposure. RESULTS: Patients exposed to pholcodine had a sharp rise in levels of IgE antibodies towards pholcodine, morphine and suxamethonium, the median proportional increases 4 weeks after exposure reaching 39.0, 38.6 and 93.0 times that of the base levels respectively. Median proportional increase of IgE was 19.0. No changes were observed in the guaifenesin group. CONCLUSION: Serum levels of IgE antibodies associated with allergy towards NMBAs increase significantly in sensitized patients after exposure to cough syrup containing pholcodine. Availability of pholcodine should be restricted by medical authorities because of the potential risk of future allergic reactions to muscle relaxants.

Immunoglobulin E antibodies to rocuronium: a new diagnostic tool.

BACKGROUND: Diagnosis of allergy from neuromuscular blocking agents is not always straightforward. The objectives of the current study were to investigate the value of quantification of immunoglobulin E (IgE) by ImmunoCAP (Phadia AB, Uppsala, Sweden) in the diagnosis of rocuronium allergy and to study whether IgE inhibition tests can predict clinical cross-reactivity between neuromuscular blocking agents. METHODS: Twenty-five rocuronium-allergic patients and 30 control individuals exposed to rocuronium during uneventful anesthesia were included. Thirty-two sera (total IgE > 1,500 kU/l) were analyzed for potential interference of elevated total IgE titers. Results were compared with quantification of IgE for suxamethonium, morphine, and pholcodine. Cross-reactivity between drugs was assessed by IgE inhibition and skin tests. RESULTS: Sensitivity of IgE for rocuronium, suxamethonium, morphine, and pholcodine was 68, 60, 88, and 86%, respectively. Specificity was 100% for suxamethonium, morphine, and pholcodine IgE and 93% for rocuronium IgE. ROC analysis between patients and control individuals changed the threshold to 0.13 kUa/l for rocuronium, 0.11 kUa/l for suxamethonium, 0.36 kUa/l for morphine, and 0.43 kUa/l for pholcodine. Corresponding sensitivity was 92, 72, 88, and 86%, respectively. Specificity was unaltered. Interference of elevated total IgE with quantification of IgE was demonstrated by the analysis in sera with a total IgE greater than 1,500 kU/l. IgE inhibition did not predict clinical relevant cross-reactivity. CONCLUSIONS: The rocuronium ImmunoCAP constitutes a reliable technique to diagnose rocuronium allergy, provided an assay-specific decision threshold is applied. IgE assays based on compounds bearing ammonium epitopes are confirmed to represent reliable tools to diagnose rocuronium allergy. High total IgE titers were observed to affect specificity of the assays.

No consumption of IgE antibody in serum during allergic drug anaphylaxis.

BACKGROUND: The general understanding is that a blood sample for analysis of immunoglobulin (Ig) E antibodies to an allergen suspected to cause an anaphylaxis cannot be drawn until several weeks after the reaction. As this is most unpractical, the changes in IgE antibody levels during anaphylaxis were studied to evaluate the possibility of using samples drawn at the time of the reaction. METHODS: Immunoglobulin E antibodies to suxamethonium were quantitated with ImmunoCAP before, during and after an anaphylactic reaction occurring during anaesthesia using neuromuscular blocking agents. RESULTS: Serum IgE antibody concentrations against suxamethonium in blood samples collected up to 6 h after the reaction were not different from those in samples drawn before or days and weeks after the anaphylaxis. CONCLUSIONS: A serum sample intended to trace the drug involved in an IgE-mediated anaphylactic reaction can be drawn in direct relation to the reaction.

Delayed allergic reaction to suxamethonium driven by oligoclonal Th1-skewed CD4+CCR4+IFN-gamma+ memory T cells.

BACKGROUND: Muscle relaxants represent the drugs most frequently involved in intraoperative anaphylaxis during surgical procedures. Our aim was to report the case of a delayed reaction to suxamethonium and analyze specific T cell lines with regard to their specificity, phenotype and cytokine profile. METHODS: We generated a drug-specific T cell line from a biopsy at the site of positive intradermal reactions and analyzed the immunophenotype, T cell receptor Vbeta domain expression and cytokine profile. RESULTS: T cells isolated from positive intradermal test reactions to suxamethonium showed a strict dose-dependent proliferation in response to drug-pulsed autologous antigen-presenting cells. The drug-specific CD4+ T cells were oligoclonal memory CD3+CD4+ T cells and expressed the skin homing receptors cutaneous lymphocyte antigen (CLA) and CCR4. Furthermore CD4+ suxamethonium-reactive T cell lines were IFN-gamma-positive and synthesized high levels of IFN-gamma and TNF-alpha. CONCLUSION: The study describes a delayed hypersensitivity to suxamethonium, driven by an oligoclonal T helper cell 1-skewed CD4+ memory T cell population, expressing the skin homing receptors CLA and CCR4.

High prevalence of IgE antibodies among blood donors in Sweden and Norway.

BACKGROUND: Reactions after a blood transfusion could be allergic because of passive transfer of immunoglobulin E (IgE) antibodies from allergic donors. AIMS OF THE STUDY: To compare spectrum and prevalence of IgE antibodies in blood donors from Sweden and Norway. METHODS: Using the ImmunoCAP method, serum samples from 1002 blood donors from Sweden and 500 from Norway were analysed for IgE antibodies to common inhalant and food allergens and allergens common in a hospital environment, such as penicilloyl G and latex. RESULTS: As many as 23.6-27.3% of the donors had IgE antibodies to at least one of the 14 allergens tested. Of these 6.8-16.7% had extremely high concentrations, i.e. >35 kU(A)/l corresponding to 100 times the cut-off for a positive allergy test. Most donors were sensitized to pollens, dander and mite but several had very high levels of IgE antibodies to penicilloyl G, latex and peanut. The pattern of sensitizing allergens differed between Sweden and Norway. CONCLUSIONS: High serum levels of IgE antibodies to various allergens are common among blood donors and the degree of sensitization and spectrum of involved allergen varies between geographical regions. Present routines to identify IgE sensitized, potential risk, donors are not satisfactory; the sensitivity of selection procedures is about 25%.

Screening for mast cell tryptase and serum IgE antibodies in 18 patients with anaphylactic shock during general anaesthesia.

BACKGROUND: In the perioperative setting multiple agents can cause anaphylaxis. Often the reactions are dramatic, and due to their lifethreatening potential it is crucial that the responsible agent is identified in order to avoid future adverse reactions. The aim of the present study was to measure the concentration of serum mast cell tryptase (MCT), to investigate the prevalence of serum IgE antibodies against ammonium groups, choline, morphine, suxamethonium, thiopentone and latex and to perform skin prick tests (SPTs) in 18 patients experiencing an anaphylactic reaction during induction of general anaesthesia. METHODS: Serum samples from 18 patients with an anaphylactic reaction during general anaesthesia were analyzed for MCT and specific IgE against ammonium groups, choline, morphine, suxamethonium, thiopentone and latex. Skin prick tests were performed in 11 out of 18 patients. RESULTS: Ten patients had elevated MCT levels and specific IgE against ammonium ion, morphine and (with the exception of patient nos 3, 9 and 10) suxamethonium. Seven of these patients had positive SPTs to suxamethonium. One of the patients tested positive to latex in addition to suxamethonium. Two patients showed elevated MCT, while specific IgE against the drugs tested was not detected. Three patients tested positive to ammonium ion, morphine and suxamethonium, but negative to MCT. Three patients tested negative to both MCT and specific IgE. CONCLUSIONS: Fifteen out of 18 sera tested positive for MCT and/or specific IgE against neuromuscular blocking drugs (NMBDs). Ten of the 18 patients experienced an IgE-mediated anaphylactic reaction to NMBDs during anaesthesia, verified by detection of specific IgE and elevated levels of MCT.

Adverse effects of neuromuscular blockers and their antagonists.

Among all the drugs used for general anesthesia, neuromuscular blockers appear to play a prominent role in the incidence of severe adverse reactions. It now seems likely that most serious adverse drug reactions occurring during anesthesia are immunological in type. The frequency of life-threatening anaphylactic or anaphylactoid reactions occurring during anesthesia has been estimated to be between 1 in 1000 and 1 in 25,000 anesthetic procedures, with the neuromuscular blockers being involved in 80% of cases. The mortality from such serious reactions is reported to be in the range of 3.4 to 6%. The highly immunogenic drug, suxamethonium chloride (succinylcholine), was found to be the most hazardous agent. Drug-specific immunoglobulin E antibodies to suxamethonium chloride and other neuromuscular blockers have been demonstrated. This sensitivity to neuromuscular blockers seems to be a long-lasting phenomenon. During anesthesia, the clinical features of an allergic reaction are often masked. Tachycardia and circulatory collapse may be the only signs of an allergic reaction, and they are easily misdiagnosed. Bronchospasm is reported to be present in about 40% of cases. Successful management of these patients includes stabilisation during the acute reaction and avoidance of future reactions. The latter is based on the identification of the causative drug and potentially cross-reacting compounds. The use of suxamethonium chloride is associated with many other adverse effects, such as fasciculations, myalgia, potassium release, changes in the heart rate, increases in intragastric and intraocular pressures, and malignant hyperthermia. Because of the dangers of hyperkalemic cardiac arrest suxamethonium chloride administration in children with unrecognised muscular dystrophy, there have now been moves to limit the use of this drug in children. Although neuromuscular blockers are designed to specifically block nicotinic cholinergic receptors at the neuromuscular junction, many bind to muscarinic cholinergic receptors on ganglia and smooth muscle, and alter parasympathetically mediated heart rate and airway calibre. Most benzylisoquinolinium muscle relaxants can induce histamine release, especially when they are administered rapidly, which can lead to disturbances of cardiovascular function. In addition, nondepolarising neuromuscular blockers have been implicated in causing generalised weakness following their long term administration to patients on an intensive care unit. The problem with these adverse drug reactions is their upredictable nature. Therefore, prompt recognition with appropriate therapy can help to improve the outcome.

Evaluation of a new reactive solid phase for radioimmunoassay of serum specific IgE against muscle relaxant drugs.

Until now, immunoassays for detection of anti-muscle relaxant IgE in serum have been performed with the drug coupled to epoxy-activated Sepharose or to RAST papers dics. In the present work we have used a quaternary ammonium-Sepharose in which the quaternary ammonium reactive group (choline chloride) was directly coupled to Sepharose via an ether linkage. 50 microliters of the quaternary ammonium solid phase (QAS) was incubated with 50 microliters of serum for 3 h, washed, incubated 18 h with 125I-anti-IgE and washed again. The results were expressed as the percentage of 125I-anti-IgE absorbed onto the solid phase. The results were at 1.3 +/- 0.5% for 20 control sera, with an upper normal limit estimated to 2.3%. The within-run reproducibility ranged from 3.2% to 10.0%. The results were significantly correlated with those obtained with either alcuronium-epoxy-Sepharose, choline-epoxy-Sepharose, the RAST-alcuronium or with the RAST-succinyl choline (respectively, r = 0.66, r = 0.80, r = 0.81, r = 0.40 and r = 0.85). The values obtained with the sera of 83 patients ranged from 0.3 to 38.5%. The sensitivity was estimated at 87.9%, 66.7% and 40.7% with the QAS-RIA, the RAST-succinyl choline and the RAST-alcuronium, respectively. The inhibition of adsorption of specific IgE onto the gel ranged from 13.0 to 90.6% in presence of 130 nmol of soluble muscle relaxants. In 83.3% of 30 cases, the highest inhibition was obtained with the muscle relaxant which was clinically incriminated.(ABSTRACT TRUNCATED AT 250 WORDS)

Anaphylaxis to muscle-relaxant drugs: study of cross-reactivity by skin tests.

Intradermal skin tests (two dilutions) carried out systematically with 5 muscle-relaxant drugs were used to study the cross-reactivity between these drugs in 131 patients who had suffered from anaphylaxis. The skin tests were positive for at least 2 drugs in 65.6% of the cases. We observed a significant concordance (positive-positive or negative-negative skin tests) between pancuronium and vecuronium (p less than 0.01) and a significant correlation between the skin test diameters obtained with these 2 drugs (p less than 0.02 for wheals and p less than 0.01 for flares). Conversely, the lack of concordance between pancuronium and suxamethonium was significant (p less than 0.05). When comparing all the concordances obtained with each pair of drugs, it appeared that the concordance between pancuronium and vecuronium was significantly higher than all others. For other concordances, 2 main factors seemed to play a role: the N+ of the ammonium ions included in a ring as in pancuronium and the presence of a 'choline-like' side chain as in suxamethonium. But there was no significant correlation between skin test diameters. Altogether, these results suggest that in vivo there is no 'true' cross-reactivity between the drugs except frequently between pancuronium and vecuronium. In all other cases, the patients have probably specific IgE antibodies for each drug, all these antibodies being able to recognize the ammonium determinant; this common property may be insufficient to induce a clinical allergy.

Naturally occurring IgG-antibody-like substance reacting with quaternary ammonium group and neuromuscular blockers: a common finding in humans and other species?

IgG antibodies reacting with the quaternary ammonium group of choline and alcuronium appeared to be present in the sera of humans, guinea pigs, and rats. The antibodies, particularly those 'against' alcuronium, were detected in every serum by paper immunosorbent test(s). This finding, if substantiated, would be of fundamental importance in view of the wide distribution of choline derivatives within the body and in the environment. It may also be relevant to the histamine-releasing activity of neuromuscular blockers and compounds possessing the quaternary ammonium group.

Suxamethonium-induced histamine release from the heart of naïve and suxamethonium-sensitized guinea-pigs: evidence suggesting spontaneous sensitization in naïve animals, and relevance to anaphylactoid reactions in man.

A guinea-pig model for anaphylactic and anaphylactoid reactions to suxamethonium was evaluated. 'Sensitization' to that drug was demonstrated both by cardiac anaphylaxis in the Langendorff preparation, and by serum antibody studies. Spontaneous sensitization to cross-reacting chemicals in a proportion of control animals is strongly suggested, somewhat akin to spontaneous sensitization in patients with anaphylactoid reactions to neuromuscular blockers on first exposure, and in whom IgE antibodies are detected.

Anaphylaxis to muscle relaxants: cross-sensitivity studied by radioimmunoassays compared to intradermal tests in 34 cases.

Thirty-four patients (31 female and three male patients) with a previous anaphylactoid shock to muscle relaxants were investigated. The seric antimyorelaxant IgE was detected by radioimmunoassay (RIA), and the results were compared to intradermal test (IDR) reactions to dilutions of the commercial drugs. The RIA was carried out with a Sepharose-myorelaxant solid phase and anti-IgE 125I-labeled IgG. The results corresponded to the percentage of labeled anti-IgE bound on the solid phase. The RIA with Sepharose-alcuronium and Sepharose-choline was estimated positive from determination with normal sera (n = 12) when bound IgE was greater than 1.0% and 1.5%, respectively. The RIA and IDR were positive in 43.5% and 75%, respectively, of the cases, with a concordance of 66%. One test at least was positive in 79.4% of the cases. No correlation was found between IgE seric levels and the RIA nor between the cutaneous sensitivity and the RIA. Cross-reactivity with Sepharose-choline and Sepharose-alcuronium was observed in 50%, and it was demonstrated by IDR in only 34.2%. The RIA demonstrated the specificity of IgE to quaternary ammonium compounds as myorelaxant drugs. The positive IDR revealed the bridging of mast cell-bound specific IgE, depending on structural conditions, such as the flexibility of the molecules or the variable specificity of the antibodies, restricted to quaternary ammonium ions or enlarged to a broader part of the incriminated molecules.