Magnetometers vs Gradiometers for Neural Speech Decoding.

Neural speech decoding aims at providing natural rate communication assistance to patients with locked-in state (e.g. due to amyotrophic lateral sclerosis, ALS) in contrast to the traditional brain-computer interface (BCI) spellers which are slow. Recent studies have shown that Magnetoencephalography (MEG) is a suitable neuroimaging modality to study neural speech decoding considering its excellent temporal resolution that can characterize the fast dynamics of speech. Gradiometers have been the preferred choice for sensor space analysis with MEG, due to their efficacy in noise suppression over magnetometers. However, recent development of optically pumped magnetometers (OPM) based wearable-MEG devices have shown great potential in future BCI applications, yet, no prior study has evaluated the performance of magnetometers in neural speech decoding. In this study, we decoded imagined and spoken speech from the MEG signals of seven healthy participants and compared the performance of magnetometers and gradiometers. Experimental results indicated that magnetometers also have the potential for neural speech decoding, although the performance was significantly lower than that obtained with gradiometers. Further, we implemented a wavelet based denoising strategy that improved the performance of both magnetometers and gradiometers significantly. These findings reconfirm that gradiometers are preferable in MEG based decoding analysis but also provide the possibility towards the use of magnetometers (or OPMs) for the development of the next-generation speech-BCIs.